SourceCritic

Xbox Tavern

38 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj83.0263
Raw spread σj18.0431
Shrunk mean μ′j83.4961
Shrunk spread σ′j15.567

Reviews from this outlet

Aphelion45/100 → 45 · Z -2.4729Score 59.3618

Aphelion has a heartfelt story that is well-acted and paced. It falls apart with unfinished gameplay and too many bugs to ignore.

Read original review

Battlefield 678/100 → 78 · Z -0.3531Score 80.5605

All in all, Battlefield 6 feels very much like a game of two parts; the campaign is an exhilarating spectacle that lacks any narrative interest whatsoever, while the multiplayer is just all out chaos is the best way. It will have its learning curve for new players, but DICE certainly has a very good online shooter contender this time around, and it’s something that will keep drawing me back for some time as I attempt to get even remotely passable at it. Hopefully before the next game…

Read original review

Black Desert85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0966Score 85.0572

Black Desert won’t be to everybody’s tastes, and does little to push the MMO genre forward. With that said, it does streamline the experience into a more familiar shell, its real-time combat and impeccable UI tweaks helping it fit onto a console with the minimal of fuss. Its quest structure is lacking in variation, and it doesn’t have the complex characters of The Witcher 3, but it’s a world that is great to explore with friends, with the promise of more to come.

Read original review

Cairn100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0602Score 94.693

Cairn is thoughtful in its mechanical exploration of being a climber and it also delivers a story that pushes back on the mythology of the sport and the people that reach the highest levels. This is an essential game.

Read original review

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0602Score 94.693

As you can hopefully tell, I absolutely adore Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. It’s the first game in some time that I’ve found myself utterly lost in, so much so that I genuinely did not want to put the controller down. Any minor gripes there might be to have (some areas can get a little confusing to navigate at times, though none are so big that it remains a problem for long) are easily outnumbered by the sheer brilliance of the full product from start to finish. Combat, presentation, exploration, story; it’s all so damn good that I cannot recommend highly enough that you go play this game. We’ve still got a long way to go this year, and a few big hitters to come, but man, it’ll take something special to give Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 a run for its money.

Read original review

Crimson Desert92/100 → 92 · Z 0.5463Score 89.5539

Despite the AI controversy around the launch of Crimson Desert, I’ve found a lot to enjoy during my time with the game. There is a lot of content to explore, and freedom to do so at your own pace and style. So much so, that even with some annoying interface and controller decisions and an initially confusing storyline, I found myself compelled to keep coming back and enjoying the moment to moment experiences.

Read original review

Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss70/100 → 70 · Z -0.867Score 75.4214

A game that isn’t afraid to let players muddle through it on their own is an idea to be lauded, and here there is a core mystery that will provide a compelling enough reason to continue if you can get into the rhythm of the puzzling.

Read original review

Dave the Diver: In the Jungle90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4178Score 88.2692

Perhaps one of the best DLCs (at least for a smaller "indie" game) I've played. Not only do you get more of an already great game, but they also give you multiple new gameplay elements. Honestly this could have been a good base for a sequel game with the amount of content you get. It's priced accordingly, give you more than a handful of missions like other smaller DLCs and it's fun. Highly recommend once you beat the base game.

Read original review

Denshattack!95/100 → 95 · Z 0.739Score 91.4811

Fun, bright, packed with challenges and with one of the year's best soundtracks, Denshattack! is a joy to behold at all times.

Read original review

Dispatch98/100 → 98 · Z 0.9317Score 93.4082

Dispatch is a refreshing piece of gaming. Bringing back the Telltale-style choose your own adventure is great, but doing so with such brilliant style, technical proficiency and excellent script and performances has won me over entirely. Engaging from start to finish, Dispatch is easily one of my favourite games of the year, and a new standard in the genre.

Read original review

Dynasty Warriors: Origins90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4178Score 88.2692

Dynasty Warriors: Origins is a very impressive addition to this franchise, and would even be a great entry point for anyone new to series as you don’t need to have played any of the previous series to understand or follow the story. With the variety of weapons, skills and many hours of gameplay I would say this is great value for money and a great game to relieve some stress with.

Read original review

Eternal Strands80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2246Score 81.8453

Eternal Strand is an immense start for Yellow Brick. There are so many perfect parts in this tapestry of ideas from other games, and its approach of letting players explore and figure out ways to use their powers is amazing. There are a few glaring flaws here, but I think it is a case of the rest of it being so good that those weaknesses are put into stark contrast.

Read original review

F1 2589/100 → 89 · Z 0.3536Score 87.6268

I’m encouraged by the work that has gone in to improve and launch My Team 2.0, but I can’t help but feel short-changed with too many customized options being locked behind a paywall. That being said, I can see myself putting a lot more hours into F1 25, exploring the different outcomes in Braking Point 3 and delving into a long-term save in My Team.

Read original review

Forza Horizon 498/100 → 98 · Z 0.9317Score 93.4082

Forza Horizon 4 is the most stunning, deepest and most engaging Forza Horizon game to date. The sheer volume of utterly diverse and wildly interesting content pushes the game’s longevity through the roof. There’s no shortage of activities to take to, set across a sprawling, vividly detailed representation of Britain. Safe to say that if you enjoy the series, you’re going to love this.

Read original review

Gears of War: E-Day95/100 → 95 · Z 0.739Score 91.4811

All in all, Gears of War: EDay is the best thing Gears since Gears of War 2, and we say that having very much enjoyed the majority of the franchise. The Coalition have done a superb job making the Locust feel fresh – and frightening – all over again, the combat is easily the best in the series, and despite knowing how the general gist turns out for Marcus and Dom, they’ve crafted a genuinely completing story to follow along with. Excellent stuff all round, and if this is the marker of a new beginning for XBOX’s first party titles – exclusive or otherwise – then we’re in for once hell of a renaissance.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto VI100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0602Score 94.693

This review can only hint at what has made GTAVI so wonderful to play over the last few weeks, but if there’s simple take away, let it be this; GTAVI is a masterclass in what can be achieved in gaming technically with all of the time and money, sure, but it’s also a masterclass in redefining a well-worn genre into something that feels genuinely fresh. The updates to the gameplay mechanics, the Wanted system, and bringing a still outlandish crime story down to earth with incredibly realistic and relatable characters all meld into what is simply the best game of the year, and something that will be the new standard bearer for what gaming can be.

Read original review

INDUSTRIA 245/100 → 45 · Z -2.4729Score 59.3618

There is still a spark of what made Industria intriguing in some of the settings and lore we can find, but the package as a whole just misses the mark for me. It is technically average at best, with slow, plodding, and uninteresting gunplay and a story that feels like a step backwards from the original in almost every regard.

Read original review

Kingdom Come: Deliverance II70/100 → 70 · Z -0.867Score 75.4214

It won’t be for everybody, and even the ones it will be for will no doubt find grievances within its systems, but there’s no denying KCD2 is an incredibly deep and dense game that will reward those willing to invest the time and energy into getting the most out of it. A strong story pulls us through parts that otherwise might have been too much to persevere with, but there have certainly been enough times that we have found ourselves enjoying the game that we’d offer a cautious recommendation.

Read original review

Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii91/100 → 91 · Z 0.482Score 88.9115

Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii is everything I thought this game was going to be and I enjoyed the ride immensely. It’s possible purists may not like the tone of the game too much but as a fan I can always get behind Majima being the main protagonist. His attitude and antics from previous games suit the farfetched nature here and you don’t even need to have played any of the previous game to dive in and enjoy this title.

Read original review

Mina the Hollower90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4178Score 88.2692

Mina the Hollower has been on many gamers lists for a long time coming and I'm happy to say, it's not bad. It lets you experience "old school hard" gameplay or new age accessible gameplay in hopes of reaching all players. It lets you experience the game in so many ways that fit you which is something I think most games don't allow. Easy recommendation for gamers looking for action adventure through an old school lens.

Read original review

MIO: Memories in Orbit85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0966Score 85.0572

MIO has a lot of features that other games in the genre introduced and found a way to incorporate and make them shine. The modifier system is similar to Hollow Knight or Ori and the Will of the Wisps. The accessibility option that makes each boss a tiny bit weaker after each failed attempt is similar to Hades. The extended platforming sections of the Ori games and Guacamelee are also present. MIO does a fantastic job of taking all these systems and making them their own while wrapping them up in a huge world to explore. This is Douze Dixièmes’ second game which follows their stunning debut, Shady Part of Me, and I can’t wait to see what they do next.

Read original review

Mixtape100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0602Score 94.693

Celebrating the 90’s, excellent music and how it impacts and marks our lives, and the joy of growing up with a few close friends, Mixtape is a stellar experience from start to finish.

Read original review

MOUSE: P.I. For Hire85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0966Score 85.0572

There’s a lot to like about Mouse P.I., from it’s excellent visuals and animation to the simply act of exploring and shooting. Cuphead is a clear inspiration in certain aspects, and though this is a different genre, it will likely still appeal if you enjoyed that game. It is a great game for console and handheld should you have one as well.

Read original review

Ori and the Will of the Wisps97/100 → 97 · Z 0.8675Score 92.7659

Ori and the Will of the Wisps had some lofty expectations coming into it, and it’s safe to say that it more than met them handsomely, Some difficulty spikes can frustrate, but overall it’s a charming, beautiful, brilliantly fun title. Gamepass subscriber or not, you absolutely need to experience this game.

Read original review

Pragmata90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4178Score 88.2692

I was pleasantly surprised by many aspects of Pragmata. First, the constantly evolving and engaging hacking mechanic, then, the creative level design and puzzles, and finally the emotional bond forming between Hugh and Diana. Hopefully we’ll see more from this new, innovative IP in years to come (hopefully with a much-improved map).

Read original review

Pro Jank Footy78/100 → 78 · Z -0.3531Score 80.5605

It might not be the Aussie Rules simulation that people want, but Pro Jank Footy is an accessible sports game, that ended up making me appreciate some of the finer points of the real sport. Perfect for beginners that have no idea about this sport, or any sports for that matter.

Read original review

Resident Evil Requiem100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0602Score 94.693

Easily the best Resident Evil game in many years, with inspirations from both RE2’s survival horror and RE4’s more action horror. Paced perfectly, and with plenty of surprises to discover, I can’t recommend Resident Evil Requiem highly enough.

Read original review

Rivage97/100 → 97 · Z 0.8675Score 92.7659

Rivage requires willing on the part of the player to really get invested in the world, but let it sink its hook in you and it’ll be an immersive adventure that you won’t soon forget. Excellent stuff all round, and another notch in the already impressive bow of Raw Fury’s output.

Read original review

Sea of Thieves73/100 → 73 · Z -0.6743Score 77.3486

Sea of Thieves offers a stunning world for players to explore and uncover its secrets. It’s fun, often hilarious, and unique. Though, the lack of meaningful structure and its simplistic gameplay really do hurt the experience. The game needs to offer more than cosmetic stature and acquisition if it wants a lengthy lifespan. Still, this is one of the few exclusives that Microsoft can, and should, be proud of.

Read original review

Space Engineers75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5458Score 78.6334

There’s a lot of potential with the groundwork Keen Software have set here in Space Engineers. However, it’s an incredibly obtuse game to get into, not helped by a lack of clear, legible information in game (relying on YouTube links instead). If you’ve the patience to get stuck in though, the scope of what can be done will likely surprise and amaze you.

Read original review

Split Fiction96/100 → 96 · Z 0.8032Score 92.1235

Split Fiction is a fantastic game, polished to perfection, I can’t imagine how the developers are going to top this.

Read original review

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Splintered Fate83/100 → 83 · Z -0.0319Score 83.7725

It happened, it finally happened! It's been too long since I've enjoyed a good TMNT game but I am so happy to say Splintered Fate delivered a good time. Roguelites have been hot for a while now and throwing the TMNT skin on top of one makes a lot of sense. I think more recognizable IP's should branch out and try new genres like Splintered Fate here. Easy recommend for Turtles fans and roguelite enthusiasts alike.

Read original review

Tell Me Why80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2246Score 81.8453

Tell Me Why is a great adventure that, although could be considered almost as a playable movie, still offers a nice amount of interaction and story hooks to be a worthwhile experience. Fans of this narrative and thought-provoking genre are likely to have an enjoyable experience with Tell Me Why and its interesting and relatable characters.

Read original review

The Blood of Dawnwalker80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2246Score 81.8453

In some ways, The Blood of Dawnwalker feels a bit old-school in its design, but once we settled into its rhythm, we found a satisfying, if slightly clunky RPG that is well worth a recommendation from us. The time limit means we can’t be the all-in-one hero, and there’s a story here that…ahem..sank it’s fangs into us early on.

Read original review

The Relic: First Guardian15/100 → 15 · Z -4.4001Score 40.0902

The Relic: First Guardian is messy, buggy, with a bad story, bad voice acting, it should be the kind of plucky Z-tier game I fall in love with. Instead it is marred by a lot of (presumed) clanker nonsense. There are better bad games to spend your time with.

Read original review

The Walking Dead: Streets of Survival50/100 → 50 · Z -2.1517Score 62.5737

Sadly, I feel The Walking Dead: Streets of Survival misses the mark in some key areas. While the combat is fine, and fans of the show will be glad to reunite with the core main characters, the lack of voice acting and general atmosphere I associate with The Walking Dead meant it didn't quite engage me as much as I'd hoped.

Read original review

Tides of Tomorrow80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2246Score 81.8453

Presenting a serious message in what is a fairly light-hearted game, Tides of Tomorrow is absolutely an entertaining time. The Story Link feature is a very cool concept, and the way it affects not just our world but those that come after gives us pause for thought every time we’re asked to make a choice.

Read original review

We Were Here Forever90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4178Score 88.2692

The We Were Here series is in a class of its own, and Forever is the best entry yet. Grab a buddy and get ready to test both your brains over about 15 hours of gameplay that constantly impresses and brings new things to the table.

Read original review