Alternative Reality60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0513Score 63.5778Score 63.5778Z -2.0513Evaluating a work like The Relic: First Guardian always presents an ethical and critical dilemma. Behind the flaws of this project you can glimpse the enormous heart of a small team that tried to bite off more than it could chew, putting together a content package beyond its real means. But passion alone cannot justify a product that reaches the market in a truly too approximate technical state. Focusing on quantity instead of quality was the final blow to a project that, in different conditions, could have made its mark among soulslike games. In its current state, the adventure is a problematic journey with the taste of a wasted opportunity. One that, despite all its rough edges, shows the seeds of intriguing and quite stimulating ideas. Therefore, while waiting for massive corrective patches (which we hope will arrive soon), it is a dark fantasy odyssey meant only for the most devoted fans of the genre.
Read original review
Bazinameh50/100 → 50 · Z -3.1865Score 52.226Score 52.226Z -3.1865The Relic: First Guardian is hardly a bad action RPG, which makes its failures all the more aggravating. Its fierce fighting, exciting parries, occasional exploration surprises and tougher boss encounters hint at the potential of a far greater game.
Read original review
CGMagazine30/100 → 30 · Z -4.3737Score 40.354Score 40.354Z -4.3737Between rough gameplay feel and mechanics, The Relic: First Guardian doesn’t present itself with a bang, but with a wimper.
Read original review
COGconnected60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2116Score 61.9751Score 61.9751Z -2.2116Relic: The First Guardian is not so messy as to be unplayable. In fact, the game’s combat can be excellent at times, and the use of Korean folklore twisted into a dark narrative is an interesting idea.
Read original review
Completexbox65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3545Score 70.5457Score 70.5457Z -1.3545The Relic: First Guardian has been available on PC and PlayStation for a while. Accordingly, I’ve been waiting patiently to give this a go on Xbox. With Souls-like elements, unusual mechanics, and a rich and dark lore-filled story, this appealed to me. However, there are plenty of performance issues and bugs that hold it back.
Project Cloud Games has developed this action-adventure, Souls-like title. It is a semi-open world game that encourages you to investigate every building, ruin, and cave you encounter. However, you must stay frosty throughout as monsters roam everywhere and danger is around every corner.
This single-player affair focuses on bitty lore, impressive passive abilities, and seamlessly never-ending boss battles. The huge and often hideous bosses test your skills as you dodge, weave, block, and slice your way to victory.
Read original review
Comunidad Xbox50/100 → 50 · Z -2.3036Score 61.0548Score 61.0548Z -2.3036The Relic: First Guardian is one of my personal disappointments of the year. And perhaps the worst part is that I don't think it's a game completely devoid of good ideas—it does have some.
Read original review
Console-Tribe65/100 → 65 · Z -1.521Score 68.8816Score 68.8816Z -1.521The Relic: First Guardian lives in a constant tension between ambition and reality. Its intense world‑building, melancholic Korean‑folklore micro‑stories, and surprisingly layered combat show Project Cloud Games’ clear vision and uncommon talent. But an overload of bosses, abrupt difficulty shifts, technical problems, and some awkward design choices keep it from reaching its full potential. What remains is an imperfect yet heartfelt action game, capable of striking moments for those willing to accept its roughness and sink into its ruined world. If the team can refine this first effort—cutting excess and aiming for greater cohesion—the future could hold something truly exciting. For now, it’s a dark, troubled journey, still worth taking for anyone seeking something different in today’s action landscape.
Read original review
CriticLenz50/100 → 50 · Z -2.0798Score 63.293Score 63.293Z -2.0798"A game that perhaps could have shown considerable potential, but ultimately ended up buried under the weight of its own shortcomings."
Read original review
DualShockers50/100 → 50 · Z -2.7128Score 56.9635Score 56.9635Z -2.7128The Relic: First Guardian is a game with good ideas, but it ultimately fails to execute them. Performance issues, recurring bugs, and the lack of essential navigation features make the experience feel unfinished, leaving the impression that it needed more time in development.
Read original review
Final Weapon70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7127Score 76.9643Score 76.9643Z -0.7127The Relic: First Guardian is an engaging new action game that takes cues from the Soulslike genre while incorporating medieval and Korean folklore into the mix. With its enjoyable combat mechanics and difficult but fair boss fights, The Relic: First Guardian offers many systems that will make Souls fans happy. However, its technical issues take away from the beautiful vision that the game sets out to achieve.
Read original review
Game864/100 → 64 · Z -1.7949Score 66.1426Score 66.1426Z -1.7949The Relic: First Guardian is a game that dared to be different and suffered for it. In the pursuit of challenging what has been tried and tested, it put forth a plethora of great ideas: equipment-based tactical combat, non-respawning enemies as progression, and genuinely great boss battles. Unfortunately, it also revealed why those ideas weren’t the norm. Poor animation implementation, questionable camerawork, and forgettable narratives all end up making this a much lesser product than the sum of its parts. In fixing what wasn’t broken, it only revealed the cracks within itself.
Read original review
GameBlast60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8068Score 66.0235Score 66.0235Z -1.8068The Relic: First Guardian* is certainly an ambitious debut project from the studio Project Cloud Games, promising a vast open world, eighty unique elite enemies, and a simple yet conceptually strong story. However, that ambition ultimately hindered development, resulting in a product that fails to deliver on any of its initial promises in a polished state. This forces those who have already purchased the game to wait for numerous fixes before it reaches the level of quality promised by the trailers and promotional material.
Read original review
Gamefa45/100 → 45 · Z -3.5858Score 48.2329Score 48.2329Z -3.5858Relic: The First Guardian has the foundations of a solid action RPG, with an impressive roster of over 70 unique bosses and a respectable variety of Relic-based abilities that keep major encounters engaging. Unfortunately, those strengths are constantly undermined by shallow combat mechanics, clunky animations, inconsistent voice acting, poor audio design, technical issues, and surprisingly amateur translation errors. Rather than a true Soulslike, this is a straightforward action game weighed down by an overwhelming number of avoidable flaws. With more polish, it could have been a pleasant surprise. Instead, it ends up as a frustrating experience that rarely allows its best ideas to shine.
Read original review
Gameliner40/100 → 40 · Z -2.505Score 59.0416Score 59.0416Z -2.505The Relic: First Guardian has plenty of promising ideas on paper, from its Korean mythology setting to its fast-paced combat and variety of Brutals, but few of them truly stand out in practice. The fragmented storytelling, uninspired voice acting and lack of meaningful combat depth make both the lore and the battles feel less engaging than the trailers suggest. Despite being marketed as a soulslike, its challenge comes more from clunky controls than memorable encounters, leaving the overall experience feeling underwhelming.
Read original review
GameOver.gr40/100 → 40 · Z -3.284Score 51.2508Score 51.2508Z -3.284The Relic can be summarily described as disappointing and a chore to play. It's one of the weaker AA soulslike games from a developer that is clearly trying to punch above their weight. There was no reason to include an open-world environment where assets are repeated ad nauseam and enemy variety is virtually non-existent. Technically, the game is all over the place, with a camera that often proves to be the worst enemy and a highly inconsistent frame rate. Lastly, the advertised 80+ boss fights are, for the most part, humanoid enemies that are frustrating to fight rather than exciting encounters.
Read original review
Gamesurf70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0169Score 73.9223Score 73.9223Z -1.0169The Relic: First Guardian is an undeniably ambitious title, but it heavily suffers under the weight of expectations, ultimately trying to do too much and doing it poorly. There are certainly positive aspects: excellent environmental design, dynamic and intuitive gameplay, and an equipment management system that integrates seamlessly with the lore. However, these qualities are not enough to offset a series of poor game design choices. Enemies prove to be ultra-aggressive, while the 80 bosses—supposedly the flagship feature of the game—turn out to be flaw-ridden "damage sponges" that are often mere copies of one another. The game world is vast, varied, and boring—immersed in a cosmic void, with design decisions that destroy any sense of discovery. A visually well-crafted technical presentation is undercut by frustrating camera management and visibly dated NPCs. So many times in my reviews I find myself writing that "more could have been done," but The Relic: First Guardian is the first game that made me think that, perhaps, less should have been done.
Read original review
GamingBolt70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0206Score 73.8856Score 73.8856Z -1.0206The Relic: First Guardian may never escape its technical shortcomings, but its melancholy world is well worth saving.
Read original review
GamingTrend30/100 → 30 · Z -5.4539Score 29.5517Score 29.5517Z -5.4539The Relic: First Guardian is one of the worst games to come out in 2026. With so many other titles worth your time and money, this one is an easy skip.
Read original review
IGN40/100 → 40 · Z -3.5236Score 48.8552Score 48.8552Z -3.5236The true dark fantasy of The Relic: First Guardian is all of the potential it squanders; an energetic action game marred by its own shambolic state and broken in too many inexcusable ways.
Read original review
IGN Italia60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3637Score 60.4542Score 60.4542Z -2.3637The Relic: First Guardian is a game of stark contrasts, where immense developer passion clashes with severe technical shortcomings. While the anachronistic PS3-era graphics and early framerate drops make for a frustrating start, the game redeems itself through a magnetic exploration loop, a surprisingly deep RPG progression without inventory clutter, and a staggering roster of over ninety unique bosses. Once the technical performance miraculously stabilizes in the latter half of the adventure, a genuinely solid and rewarding action-RPG emerges from the rubble. It’s a heavily flawed journey, but one crafted with enough heart and solid mechanics to earn a passing grade.
Read original review
IGN Italy60/100 → 60 · Z -2.1977Score 62.1145Score 62.1145Z -2.1977The Relic: First Guardian is a work of violent contrasts, a crossroads where an almost moving authorial passion collides head-on with undeniable production and technical limitations.
Read original review
INVEN76/100 → 76 · Z -1.0272Score 73.8193Score 73.8193Z -1.0272The Relic: First Guardian is best described as an action RPG that blossoms despite its clear limitations. It is far from a perfectly well-rounded game, with awkward animations, imprecise controls, and underwhelming character models standing out as obvious flaws. Even so, its stylish combat, built around carefully timed attacks and defenses, delivers a thrilling sense of catharsis that keeps you coming back.
Read original review
Just Play it70/100 → 70 · Z -1.547Score 68.6214Score 68.6214Z -1.547The Relic: First Guardian is a solid addition for Soulslike fans, offering fast combat, engaging lore, deep weapon skill trees, and great boss design. However, weak visuals, unstable PS5 performance, and a generic art style drag the experience down significantly, preventing it from reaching greater heights.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %14.705882352941178/100 → 14.7059 · Z -1.6785Score 67.3063Score 67.3063Z -1.678514.7% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (34 reviews).
PlayStation Universe65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5917Score 68.1737Score 68.1737Z -1.5917There are things about The Relic: First Guardian that I absolutely loved. The game's exploration also leaves something for you to find, and the game's combat is satisfying and rewarding. It's just a shame I had to suffer through major bugs that kept me from progressing or finishing quests.
Read original review
PS4Blog.net60/100 → 60 · Z -2.395Score 60.1412Score 60.1412Z -2.395Soulslike adventure through the apocalyptic wasteland of the once-prosperous realm of Arsilthus that could benefit from a patch or two
Read original review
República DG54/100 → 54 · Z -2.6605Score 57.4866Score 57.4866Z -2.6605either a soulslike nor an action RPG, The Relic: First Guardian is a huge wasted potential due to its lack of technical polish and severe stability issues.
Read original review
RPG Fan45/100 → 45 · Z -3.7146Score 46.9454Score 46.9454Z -3.7146I think I could write about 4000 more words of complaining about The Relic: First Guardian, but I’m eager to simply wash my hands clean of this game and forget it ever existed. If you love Souls-likes or action RPGs, there are dozens of other experiences you’re better off playing. This one’s not even worth your curiosity.
Read original review
SomGeek70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8125Score 75.966Score 75.966Z -0.8125The Relic: First Guardian may not reach the heights of the genre’s best titles, but it can still appeal to action RPG fans looking for challenging combat. Its strengths lie in its dark fantasy setting, combat system, and attempt to offer its own take on the Soulslike genre. If you can overlook some of its weaker aspects, The Relic: First Guardian can still provide a decent amount of fun.
Read original review
STWGames Italia45/100 → 45 · Z -2.998Score 54.1111Score 54.1111Z -2.998Unfortunately, The Relic: First Guardian disappointed us. It has plenty of ideas, quests, and bosses, but everything feels a bit slapdash and poorly polished. You can sense the passion and dedication, but productions of this scale require more structured teams and a significantly larger budget. It would have been better to lower the bar a bit, reducing the quantity of content in favor of higher quality—both in terms of the combat system (the game’s core) and the technical aspects. We hope this first project will serve as a learning experience for the developer to understand where they went wrong, because there’s no shortage of ideas, passion, and love for the genre.
Read original review
TestingBuddies35/100 → 35 · Z -4.2895Score 41.1962Score 41.1962Z -4.2895The Relic: First Guardian shows clear ambition, but repetitive enemies, weak technical presentation, an awkward camera and inconsistent framerates run too deep for patches alone to fix.
Read original review
The Games Machine70/100 → 70 · Z -1.5537Score 68.554Score 68.554Z -1.5537The Korean studio doesn't quite hit its stride. Despite this, and provided the technical aspects are quickly fixed, The Relic: First Guardian is a dark ARPG that rewards initiative without ever becoming too frustrating or punishing; it's not a mere imitation of FromSoftware's work.
Read original review
The GameSlayer40/100 → 40 · Z -3.1728Score 52.3629Score 52.3629Z -3.1728The Relic: First Guardian is not only one of the worst Soulslikes I have ever played, but a prime candidate for the worst game of 2026. It's a game that crumbles under the weight of its own ambition, aiming to be the next Elden Ring and missing the target wildly. Not one aspect of this game warrants praise, and in its current state, it is an affront to the Souls genre as a whole. It's time I will never get back, but hopefully through my suffering, you won't suffer the same fate.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis40/100 → 40 · Z -2.9853Score 54.2384Score 54.2384Z -2.9853The Relic: First Guardian feels like a case of a smaller developer overextending itself. It brings an aggressive twist to combat and features a host of bosses to battle, but that's not enough to overcome the game's flaws and weaknesses. A flurry of patches have arrived since launch, but you're currently still better off waiting to see if they can address more of the core issues.
Read original review
Thumb Culture40/100 → 40 · Z -2.4669Score 59.4219Score 59.4219Z -2.4669After trying to give The Relic a fair shot I just could not continue. The bosses are unbalanced, and combat is just too janky to really enjoy it. Statues effect are very punishing with some of the first few bosses you will encounter. I’m not sure why the game decided to riddle the world with notes, and make them right next to each other at that. With me even counting 11 notes exactly one after another, that just led to a boss fight. An empty, lifeless world with side-quest that end up feeling like just filler. But honestly from the 8 hours I spent with The Relic, the whole time has felt like useless padding.
A very large amount of my frustration comes from just how bad the hit boxes are. Tie that with the severe dropping in frame rate over nothing going on in the world. And even worse when you actually fight one enemy let alone a group or boss.
Everything is just a chore, and I just couldn’t push through. I really don’t have any praise for The Relic: First Guardian. It’s definitely the Thumb Culture Bronze Award.
Read original review
Thumb Wars80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808Score 78.6808Z -0.541The Relic: First Guardian is Project Cloud Games debut title. It has some issues, like performance issues and a lack of some basic mechanics like jumping, but the world-building, the skill tree, the combat, the bosses and the feeling of wonder we all need and love from Soulslike is present. It has jank sure, but it has heart, and it’s one of my favourite experiences of the year, and something that I will continually be heading back to for the next few months.
Read original review
TwoHitGames68/100 → 68 · Z -0.9518Score 74.5734Score 74.5734Z -0.9518The Relic: First Guardian delivers an accessible mix of RPG and soulslike elements, backed by more than 80 bosses, dynamic combat and beautifully crafted environments. However, chaotic group encounters, a clumsy camera and repetitive mission design hold back an ambitious adventure that still needs further refinement.
Read original review
Worth Playing45/100 → 45 · Z -3.9483Score 44.6084Score 44.6084Z -3.9483Despite the time that has elapsed and the patches applied on other platforms, The Relic: First Guardian remains a mess that can't address some of its shortcomings on the technically weaker platform it is running on. The combat seems decent until you reach one of the game's numerous boss fights, where the fighting suddenly feels messy. The story isn't that engaging, and it's actually made worse by the side stories, whose endings and constant repetition of facts overshadow some of the fairly intriguing narratives you would've found along the way. The presentation is also quite terrible in parts, especially the voice acting, which makes the game's long length all the more agonizing. There is still a kernel of a good game, and there is a chance that enough patching can make this a decent title, but with so many Souls-like games already on the system, even if you discount the ones created for the original Switch, there's not much reason to give this title a look.
Read original review
Xbox Tavern15/100 → 15 · Z -4.4001Score 40.0902Score 40.0902Z -4.4001The Relic: First Guardian is messy, buggy, with a bad story, bad voice acting, it should be the kind of plucky Z-tier game I fall in love with. Instead it is marred by a lot of (presumed) clanker nonsense. There are better bad games to spend your time with.
Read original review