3DNews85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1383Score 85.4737Score 85.4737Z 0.1383A gritty combat adventure with a tragic atmosphere.
Read original review
A Gaming Network90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4413Score 88.5038Score 88.5038Z 0.4413Gears of War: E-Day delivers a visually stunning and emotionally intense campaign that captures the chaos of Emergence Day. With brutal combat, organic exploration, strong side content, and some of the best visuals Xbox has delivered in years, it deserves serious Game of the Year consideration, even if the Marcus and Dom connection could have been stronger.
Read original review
AltChar90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5939Score 90.0298Score 90.0298Z 0.5939E-Day is the Gears game newcomers and hardcore fans have been waiting for, with a spectacular city-wide collapse and real heart.
Read original review
Alternative Reality88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4672Score 88.7627Score 88.7627Z 0.4672Gears of War: E-Day is the game fans have been waiting for for many years. A return to the dirty, mean origins of the franchise, which recovers its most visceral identity with far-sighted and absolutely spot-on changes. Marcus and Dom's first adventure is spectacular and adrenaline-fueled, thanks to fun gameplay that respects the legacy of a twenty-year-old series modernized by greater dynamism in movement, cover and shootouts. While we wait to test the multiplayer, an absolutely distinctive feature of the series, The Coalition takes home a clear and evident success. One that some may find a bit too faithful to a game design born of another gaming era. But for everyone else it will be a warm homecoming.
Read original review
Arakat Mag86/100 → 86 · Z 0.2613Score 86.7041Score 86.7041Z 0.2613Gears of War: E-Day tells the story of a legendary event that has been talked about for years. It does so without shying away from grand storytelling or graphic violence. Getting almost everything right in terms of presentation, E-Day also delivers rock-solid gameplay with its fast-paced, menacing action. After taking a few hits with its recent entries, the series is back with a game that recaptures the grandeur of its glory days.
Read original review
Atomix90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3516Score 87.607Score 87.607Z 0.3516Yes, Gears of War: E-Day is the best Gears of War game ever made so far. I fully understand that the nostalgia and affection people have for the first three entries is incredibly strong, but objectively speaking, The Coalition has far surpassed what Epic Games delivered back in the day. This applies to everything from the core gameplay and level design philosophy to the technical aspects and storytelling. Xbox desperately needed an achievement of this magnitude in the midst of the worst period the company has gone through in its entire history. The only major question I’m left with is where they will take the franchise in the future, because a big part of the success this new installment has achieved comes from its strong connection to its predecessors, while leaving behind the less successful sequels from a few years ago.
Read original review
Bastidores80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3653Score 80.4378Score 80.4378Z -0.3653Gears of War: E-Day is a bloody, confident return to the series’ roots, turning the city of Kalona itself into the real star while its human cast, caught in the shadow of a scene-stealing newcomer, never quite rises to the occasion.
Read original review
BaziCenter70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2678Score 71.4131Score 71.4131Z -1.2678While Gears of War: E-Day delivers a solid online multiplayer experience, its single-player campaign plays it safe, offering little new in the way of storytelling or level design, and despite a 20-year gap between the original Gears of War and E-Day, the gameplay shows no meaningful evolution, let alone two decades worth of progress.
Read original review
Bazimag85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0165Score 84.2566Score 84.2566Z 0.0165Gears of War: E-Day is precisely the turning point this storied franchise needed after years of trial and error—a glorious, dark, and visceral return to the authentic roots of a series defined by raw brutality and grueling combat. By reviving the heavy, terrifying weight of warfare, seamlessly blending modern movement with a dynamic, destructible cover system, and delivering one of this generation's most breathtaking visual showcases via Unreal Engine 5, The Coalition once again elevates the standard for third-person shooters. While underdeveloped chemistry between young Marcus and Dom, repetitive side quests, and a slight dip in late-game enemy variety hold it back from absolute perfection, the harrowing fall of Kalona alongside addictive gunplay, exceptional pacing, and a rich multiplayer suite make E-Day a gripping, bone-chilling triumph. It is a masterclass in gunpowder and gore that proves the Gears name still demands absolute reverence
Read original review
Bazinameh80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5063Score 79.0277Score 79.0277Z -0.5063Gears of War: E-Day delivers the franchise’s classic identity with hard-hitting gunplay, refined cover mechanics, diverse weapons and a dark atmosphere. Its prequel setting also makes for a friendly introduction for newcomers, while delivering the brutality that long-time fans expect.
Read original review
But Why Tho?95/100 → 95 · Z 0.825Score 92.341Score 92.341Z 0.825Gears of War: E-Day shines by showing off humanity's perseverance. Every new character stands out, never overshadowed by the legacy of Marcus or Dom. Even with the game taking place in one city over several days, the evolution of that city and its inhabitants has created fleshed-out characters that you're rooting for the success of every step of the way.
Read original review
Capsule Computers90/100 → 90 · Z 0.518Score 89.2709Score 89.2709Z 0.518Gears of War: E‑Day shows the franchise’s enduring strength, delivering a visceral look at Emergence Day with new threats and classic, weighty combat.
Read original review
CBR90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3817Score 87.9079Score 87.9079Z 0.3817Playing Gears of War: E-Day felt like playing the original trilogy on the Xbox 360, not in a technical sense, but in the feeling of being back in this world. Getting a new adventure with Marcus and Dom is a real treat, and the story surrounding them is incredible.
Read original review
CGMagazine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5173Score 89.264Score 89.264Z 0.5173Gears of War: E-Day is here, bringing with it what feels like a new push for Xbox and one of the best entries into the long-running third-person shooter franchise.
Read original review
Checkpoint Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7201Score 91.2922Score 91.2922Z 0.7201Gears of War: E-Day makes an incredibly positive impression with a package that offers tons of intense carnage. The campaign is a thrilling take on Emergence Day, and exploring the town of Kelona getting ravaged in real-time is entertaining, with side missions proving to be worthwhile distractions. Meanwhile, Horde Siege is a standout new cooperative mode that has eaten up lots of my spare time, while Versus is there for the die-hard competitive types. It’s all presented with visually stunning art direction and smart gameplay tweaks that improve on what Gears has always been, while maintaining what we love about it in the first place. This is a blood-soaked, adrenaline-filled adventure you simply can’t miss.
Read original review
COGconnected85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2372Score 86.463Score 86.463Z 0.2372Gears of War: E-Day is a brilliant addition to the Gears of War franchise. The story does an excellent job of bridging a gap between the Gears world before the locust invasion and after. The character development is excellent, and you can’t help but feel for the members of Bravo Squad and some of the supporting characters you encounter along the way. The gunplay is as solid as ever and the added weapon and armour mods help make us feel in more control of the outcomes. E-Day is not without it’s issues. There were drops to the dashboard, really stupid CPU-controlled Bravo Squad members, and some cheap deaths along the way. I also had a difficult time enjoying the versus mode as there wasn’t a deathmatch-only playlist. The objective modes just aren’t that fun. Overall, Gears of War: E-Day is an excellent shooter that will be an absolute blast to play alongside friends.
Read original review
Completexbox100/100 → 100 · Z 1.327Score 97.3612Score 97.3612Z 1.327Gears of War: E-Day is set during Emergence Day, fourteen years before the events of the original Gears of War, as Marcus and Dom, along with a host of other Gears, face off against the first wave of Locust. They’ll have to fight and survive against the unknown as they scramble to save civilians scattered throughout the city.
Gears of War: E-Day is a third person action shooter where players will be able to use a myriad of weapons to take the fight up to the Locust. Returning players will notice that The Coalition have made a few tweaks in terms of controls. Given that our protagonists are younger, their movement is a bit more nimble. Running has been delegated to pressing the left joystick instead of holding A. Marcus and company can now jump and climb up reasonably high surfaces. There’s also a useful slide mechanic to dodge enemy projectiles.
Read original review
Comunidad Xbox98/100 → 98 · Z 1.2926Score 97.017Score 97.017Z 1.2926In conclusion, I've had the privilege of playing one of the best installments in the series—if not the best—set in a very well-crafted world, with mission design that...
Read original review
Console Creatures90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7129Score 91.2204Score 91.2204Z 0.7129Gears of War: E-Day feels like the first true Coalition Gears of War game. It's a shift away from Gears 4 and Gears 5, and it feels like the game the studio genuinely wanted to make, capturing what made the original trilogy special while finally pushing the series forward in its own way. They've taken the horror, brutality, brotherhood, and incredible gunplay that defined those games and used them as the foundation for something more modern. Expanded movement gives combat more freedom, while perks and modifications add another layer of experimentation, and the larger environments make Emergence Day feel like a genuine catastrophe happening around you. Gears of War: E-Day is incredible. Despite a handful of frustrations keeping it from perfection, it's one of the best games I've played this year.
Read original review
CrazyGameCommunity.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8505Score 92.5958Score 92.5958Z 0.8505Gears of War: E-Day pulls off a feat that seemed impossible: looking back without missing a beat, delivering a prequel of the highest quality.
Read original review
Creative Bloq80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2981Score 81.1105Score 81.1105Z -0.2981Climbing, collapsing buildings, impressive new tech and build-your-own weapons breathe new life into Gears, though a slightly bloated campaign and sponge-like enemies hold it back.
Read original review
CriticLenz95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9178Score 93.2695Score 93.2695Z 0.9178E-Day is a major victory and a dream comeback for the studio, Microsoft, and most importantly, Gears fans. Smartly blending the dark, terrifying, and bloody atmosphere of the classic entries with a fully modern gameplay system, smooth animations, and graphics that push the boundaries of this generation, it delivers on every front. Whether you're a longtime fan of Marcus Fenix who misses the sound of a Lancer chainsaw, or a newcomer looking for pure, visceral, and flawless action, E-Day is a title you absolutely shouldn't miss.
Read original review
Daily Star90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2322Score 86.4133Score 86.4133Z 0.2322Overall, this is an excellent return to the Gears of War franchise, with well designed, detailed levels an an emotion-packed action storyline as good as a movie.
Read original review
DayOne100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3559Score 97.6499Score 97.6499Z 1.3559The Coalition has elevated the franchise to new heights, crafting an engaging, brutal, and surprisingly intimate campaign that’s full of smart gameplay mechanics and wonderful surprises. It’s the best Gears has ever felt to play, and the best it’s ever looked and sounded on the big screen. Gears of War: E-Day? It's a f.cking masterpiece.
Read original review
Destructoid90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5082Score 89.173Score 89.173Z 0.5082Gears of War: E-Day is a return to form for the 20-year-old franchise, offering up a great and beefy campaign, expanded Horde mode, and classic Gears multiplayer action in a really well-made package.
Read original review
Digitale Anime95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9101Score 93.1919Score 93.1919Z 0.9101"The series returns to its darkest day"
Gears of War: E-Day successfully returns the franchise to its roots, preserving its signature combat style while introducing more fluid movement and deeper weapon customization. The story and the bond between Marcus and Dom lend a powerful human element to the experience, while Kalona offers one of the best environments in the series' history. Despite some pacing issues and repetition, E-Day stands as a strong comeback, proving that the classic Gears formula can still deliver a modern, standout experience.
Read original review
Digitec Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3178Score 80.9134Score 80.9134Z -0.3178Kalona is the real star of «Gears of War: E-Day», transforming so dramatically throughout the campaign that it feels like the game's main character. The story and characters are less memorable, but the weighty, satisfying gunplay and improved movement make for a solid «Gears» experience. It gets repetitive, but fans of the series should feel right at home.
Read original review
DualShockers90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4932Score 89.023Score 89.023Z 0.4932There's a lot I love about Gears of War: E-Day, and I honestly feel like its best moments naturally fit along with the original trilogy. I also had to ignore a lot of the things I greatly disliked about the campaign and get straight to the good stuff. It's as if I was fast-forwarding through the parts of a movie I hated to get to the good stuff. PVP multiplayer has its moments, but ultimately, it'll still turn off those who haven't spent the past two decades perfecting their strategy. That said, Horde Siege more than makes up for those shortcomings. The result is an incredible experience that has me excited for the future of the franchise. I'm honestly quite happy with how E-Day's campaign turned out, even if I'd take the open world sections and leave them on the cutting room floor.
Read original review
Duuro Magazine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3702Score 87.7929Score 87.7929Z 0.3702Gears of War: E-Day is an extraordinary production and a powerful return to a world I have loved since that time when I finished the first Gears in that arcade place. Its characters, atmosphere, and collapsing city stayed with me, even when its combat outlasted my enthusiasm. Fans who still love that rhythm will find plenty to celebrate. I came away wishing it had pushed further, but also deeply impressed by how much care went into bringing this nightmare to life.
Read original review
Echo Boomer75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7733Score 76.3578Score 76.3578Z -0.7733Gears of War E-Day may have the best gameplay the series has ever delivered, but between bullet-sponge enemies, co-op-focused design and a story with little to say, this may well be the weakest Gears campaign to date.
Read original review
Edge Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1163Score 85.2543Score 85.2543Z 0.1163It's far from flawless, but after seven years away - and a full two decades since the Locust first smashed through the ground - The Coalition has succeeded in making this particular forever war feel fresh again. [Issue#430, p.96]
ElderPlayers95/100 → 95 · Z 1.1514Score 95.6056Score 95.6056Z 1.1514Gears of War: E-Day is the best game The Coalition made! As it was an exceptional experience and one of the strongest (and the boldest) in the franchise's history, while staying true to its core identity. The game delivered a rich story filled with emotions, heartbreaking moments, and excellent environmental storytelling. Alongside interesting dynamic encounters, masterful weapon and gear handling, and refined movement and gameplay mechanics. All of this blends with top-tier visual effects, exceptional animation quality, stunning graphics, and an expressive, powerful soundtrack. It is truly the greatest third-person action game of all time and the undisputed ruler of the genre.
Read original review
ElDesmarque90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4681Score 88.7718Score 88.7718Z 0.4681Gears of War: E-Day has managed to bring back the feel of the first games in this legendary Xbox series—the ones that sprang from the mind of Cliff Bleszinski at Epic Games. But it does so under the guise of exploring the beginnings of Marcus and Dom’s friendship, the response of a city that becomes a witness to the invasion, and a combat system that introduces new features and tactical possibilities. This return to the series’ origins provides context for the characters and revives a threat that needed to feel unsettling once again.
Read original review
EmuGlx.org90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4199Score 88.2903Score 88.2903Z 0.4199Gears of War is back with a guns-blazing attitude. If you love the good old mechanics from previous games, now further improved, this package has everything you need. The solid multiplayer and a campaign that strives to deliver an epic experience may still be overshadowed by narrative issues that should have been handled differently.
Read original review
Enternity.gr80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0786Score 83.3047Score 83.3047Z -0.0786Gears of War: E-Day is, as expected, a real treat, both in single-player and in co-op mode for 2 to 4 players.
Read original review
EntreMandos95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0477Score 94.5677Score 94.5677Z 1.0477Gears of War: E-Day not only revives one of Xbox's greatest franchises, but also manages to restore much of the identity that seemed to have been lost in its last two installments. The Coalition understands what made the original trilogy special: the brutality of war, the depth of its characters, an oppressive atmosphere, and spectacular action that doesn't have to sacrifice emotion
Read original review
Eternal Games90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3844Score 87.9353Score 87.9353Z 0.3844In the end, I believe that Gears of War: E-Day has largely succeeded in recapturing an important part of the series' spirit that we loved in the original trilogy, whether in terms of atmosphere, the feeling of combat, or that distinct character that defined the series in its early days. Although it is not the best game in the series, its true value lies not in merely being a return of the Gears of War franchise after an absence, but in its ability to bring back that feeling that made us love the series in the first place, and reminding us of what made Gears games special and beloved by players from the very beginning.
Read original review
Eurogamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1753Score 82.3383Score 82.3383Z -0.1753Though there's still plenty of waist-high cover, ebb-and-flow firefighting, and braindead machismo, Gears E-Day proves that looking back can, indeed, help you look forward, too.
Read original review
Eurogamer Germany100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2032Score 96.1235Score 96.1235Z 1.2032A campaign executed to perfection in terms of both technical aspects and gameplay. A brutal and intense war spectacle featuring the best Gears story to date.
Read original review
Eurogamer.pt60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7059Score 67.0317Score 67.0317Z -1.7059Following Marcus and Dom on Emergence Day is an action-packed rollercoaster ride. Gears of War: E-Day shines on the PC with stunning graphics and addictive combat, with the weapon customisation adding an extra touch. Unfortunately, the pace drops off in the final third of the campaign, let down by a dull ending and an uninspired boss.
Read original review
Everyeye.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7496Score 91.5876Score 91.5876Z 0.7496Ultimately, in addition to the already widely praised campaign, Gears of War E-Day also offers a robust multiplayer mode capable of satisfying both competitive and Horde enthusiasts, with a substantial, consistent and satisfying content plan that helps to outline the contours of what is, without a shadow of a doubt, one of the best productions of the year.
Read original review
Everyeye.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7486Score 91.5772Score 91.5772Z 0.7486Ultimately, complementing its already widely acclaimed campaign, Gears of War E-Day also offers a robust multiplayer mode capable of satisfying both competitive players and Horde enthusiasts; it features a substantial, solid, and rewarding content plan that helps define what is, without a shadow of a doubt, one of the year's best titles.
Read original review
Final Weapon90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6133Score 90.2237Score 90.2237Z 0.6133Gears of War: E-Day is a fantastic experience from beginning to end, regardless of whether you are a fan of the series or not. The storytelling is deeply compelling thanks to the great cast of characters and aptly bleak tone. The gameplay is brought together by satisfying combat and gorgeous visuals. Despite the frame drops, if this is the quality that fans and newcomers can expect from Gears of War going forward, then the future of the franchise is bright.
Read original review
Fun Factor60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7865Score 66.2265Score 66.2265Z -1.7865Gears of War E-Day feels like an unnecessary prequel, and a bit of a cop-out to avoid addressing Gears 5's cliffhanger ending. It's a competent but forgettable campaign that's too long for its own good that wastes its new gameplay and mechanics on uninspired level design. That said, I'm sure playing this with 3 other friends can still be a blast.
Read original review
Game Informer95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8052Score 92.1432Score 92.1432Z 0.8052Gears of War: E-Day is as close to a complete package as it gets, effectively rivaling the series’ heyday. Minor quibbles with the story or matchmaking pale in comparison to the frightening tale of humanity’s darkest hours and the intense fallout of the all-out invasion. Seeing Marcus and Dom back in action and in their prime is an exciting prospect for a longtime fan like me, but it would be meaningless if it were just a nostalgia play; instead, Gears of War: E-Day innovates in all the right ways while keeping the core and heart of the franchise intact, stamping the series’ return with one of, if not its best, entries to date.
Read original review
Game Rant90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5373Score 89.464Score 89.464Z 0.5373Between PvP, Horde Siege, and the campaign, Gears of War: E-Day gives players significant bang for their buck. Narrative shortcomings hold it back from reaching the level as some other games in the series, but it's still a blood-soaked thrill ride with nonstop action no matter what mode players choose to dive into. It's a no-brainer for Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass subscribers, but E-Day is also an easy recommendation even if you have to pay full price.
Read original review
Game880/100 → 80 · Z -0.3044Score 81.047Score 81.047Z -0.3044I had a great time with Gears of War: E-Day, even when the campaign started showing its unpolished edges. The combat is still incredibly satisfying, and the free-roam sections gave me some of my favorite moments; it gave me more time with characters I ended up caring about more than I expected to. That made the campaign's weaker points stand out more, though, with the repetition and occasional technical issues becoming egregious at times. Neither was enough to sour the experience fully. I finished it satisfied, thinking I probably could have used a little less Locust shooting, which is about as Gears of War a problem as you can have.
Read original review
GameBlast85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2775Score 86.8665Score 86.8665Z 0.2775Gears of War: E-Day returns to the series' roots with an intense, well-executed campaign and refined combat. It plays it safe rather than innovating, but it's an easy recommendation for veterans and newcomers alike.
Read original review
GameFM85/100 → 85 · Z 0.051Score 84.6014Score 84.6014Z 0.051Gears of War: E-Day was a pleasant surprise for me, for XBOX, and for 2026 as a whole. While no Gears game has ever been a disaster, there's no denying that the franchise has been on a downward trajectory since Gears of War 4, struggling to recapture the appeal of the original trilogy. With E-Day, The Coalition has managed to restore the feeling that Gears is once again a flagship XBOX franchise, delivering a high-quality product packed with action from start to finish, meaningful gameplay innovations, breathtaking visuals, and a traditional multiplayer experience, even if there's still room for improvement in some areas.
Read original review
Gamekult60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4268Score 69.8231Score 69.8231Z -1.4268There's no point pretending otherwise: we're living in a post-Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2 world. Up against the brutal generosity of its direct heir, Gears of War: E-Day simply doesn't measure up. And it would be a lie to say my feelings didn't turn from disappointment to anger over these 14 hours of play. Watching the series that once dictated terms to an entire industry turn into a sluggish follower—bloated with loot and filler—is heartbreaking. The worst part is that Act 3 and the sound design serve as a reminder of what Gears of War could still be. The rest just highlights what it has become: a franchise on autopilot with little left to say, except to cling to memories of its former glory. We tried everything to love it. It did precious little to make us.
Read original review
Gameliner90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7067Score 91.1578Score 91.1578Z 0.7067Gears of War: E-Day has a blockbuster campaign that sets a new benchmark for Unreal Engine 5 games, with great audiovisuals, strong performance, and new peaks for the franchise, especially in the gameplay department. Its rock-solid combat, evolved mobility options, and deeper mechanics make for an experience that is difficult to put down. However, the open levels undermine some of what makes E-Day so good while introducing technical issues, and despite strengthening its emotional themes, environmental repetition and some weaker story beats do tire at a certain point. Thankfully, the excellent Horde Siege and Versus multiplayer give it enough reasons to keep playing.
Read original review
GameMAG60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5368Score 68.7233Score 68.7233Z -1.5368Gears of War: E-Day has become a clear embodiment of the modern problems of American game development and of Microsoft in particular. An inadequately large production budget forced the developers not to take risks, and as a result we got a rather boring story and gameplay that in certain aspects has even degraded. Sorry, but rewriting the origin story of the chainsaw gun for the third time doesn't amount to a breakthrough.
Read original review
Gamemeca76/100 → 76 · Z -0.8051Score 76.04Score 76.04Z -0.8051With enhanced graphics, 'Gears of War: E-Day' successfully implements the heavy and metalic combat characteristic of the series and effectively portrays the horrors of Emergence Day. However, the monotonous game structure and repetitive combat patterns leave a tedious impression in the second half, and the boss fights also become drawn-out battles in later chapters. While it is a welcome title for fans, it is difficult to strongly recommend to newcomers.
Read original review
GameOnly75/100 → 75 · Z -0.4732Score 79.3588Score 79.3588Z -0.4732Gears of War: E-Day’s campaign is a real emotional rollercoaster when it comes to gameplay, but a major disappointment in terms of its story. No wonder Marcus Fenix wasn’t the focus of the game’s marketing.
Read original review
GameOver.gr95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9152Score 93.2432Score 93.2432Z 0.9152Gears of War: E-Day proves, once again, that The Coalition was a top choice to handle this emblematic IP. This prequel expands the gameplay thanks to the clever addition of a dedicated jump button, elevating the moveset and tactical possibilities of the cover-based gameplay. The biggest triumph of E-Day, apart from its gorgeous visuals, is its meticulously crafted and numerous action set-pieces, each one offering thrilling battles. All in all, this new chapter proves that the franchise may be 20 years old, but it remains the pinnacle of third-person cover shooters.
Read original review
GamePro Germany87/100 → 87 · Z 0.2741Score 86.8325Score 86.8325Z 0.2741Gears of War: E-Day thrills with gripping battles and spectacular staging, but it does drag a bit here and there.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8293Score 92.3844Score 92.3844Z 0.8293E-Day succeeds in telling the story of Emergence Day in a gripping, desperate, and most importantly, fun way. The culmination of 20 years as a franchise, refining everything the series is into a must-play XBOX title that takes you on a gloriously brutal, emotionally-satisfying, and epic, cinematic adventure.
Read original review
Gamer.no70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8166Score 75.9256Score 75.9256Z -0.8166Gears of War: E-Day delivers some of the most spectacular large-scale action sequences in recent memory, but is held back by an irritating cast of characters and unnecessary padding between the firefights.
Read original review
GameRant90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5489Score 89.5799Score 89.5799Z 0.5489Gears of War: E-Day features an action-packed co-op campaign, intense PvP multiplayer, and an endlessly replayable Horde Siege mode.
Read original review
GamerFocus88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4329Score 88.4203Score 88.4203Z 0.4329Gears of War: E-Day is a highly solid entry in the Xbox franchise that successfully recaptures the series' core gameplay identity, horror, and visual grittiness. Although it stumbles in terms of narrative pacing, enemy variety, and certain artificial intelligence issues, its graphical performance and the evolution of its combat system more than make up for these shortcomings.
Read original review
Gamerheadquarters75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8374Score 75.7169Score 75.7169Z -0.8374Gears of War E-Day brings the series back its dark visceral roots with elevated levels of horror but everything outside of the campaign suffers.
Read original review
Gamers &a; Games90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4804Score 88.8948Score 88.8948Z 0.4804An atmospheric, beautifully optimized return to the series’ roots, E-Day pairs a memorable Emergence Day story with satisfying co-op, detailed environments, and excellent PC performance. Its familiar cover-based combat still hits hard, but bullet-sponge enemies, an underwhelming arsenal, and unreliable squad AI hold the campaign back. Even so, it’s a strong prequel and an easy recommendation for Gears fans—especially through Game Pass.
Read original review
GamersGlobal80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2996Score 81.0954Score 81.0954Z -0.2996I love the linear segments of E-Day, they deliver on rioting action and awesome set-pieces. This gets derailed by the dull open zones in the map and some to spongy enemies. But the highs outweigh the lows for sure.
Read original review
Gamersky82/100 → 82 · Z -0.342Score 80.6708Score 80.6708Z -0.342Gears of War: E-Day feels like an old series deliberately recreated with modern technology while preserving its aged character. Fans of Gears of War are unlikely to mind going through another adventure that feels familiar from start to finish.
Read original review
GamersRD87/100 → 87 · Z 0.3852Score 87.9434Score 87.9434Z 0.3852Gears of War: E-Day is one of the most brutal, fun, and visually stunning entries in the series, breathing fresh air into a formula that clearly needed a shake-up. It isn't completely flawless due to a few minor hiccups, but at its core, it is pure, unadulterated Gears of War.
Read original review
GAMES.CH90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7751Score 91.842Score 91.842Z 0.7751The story mode of "Gears of War: E-Day" is a challenging yet exhilarating experience and undoubtedly ranks among the highlights of the series.
Read original review
GAMES.CH90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7232Score 91.3227Score 91.3227Z 0.7232Gears of War: E-Day delivers a spectacular and intense campaign that stays true to the series while feeling slightly faster and more dynamic. Excellent gunplay, strong presentation and varied missions make it one of the most impressive entries in the franchise, despite a few minor control and melee issues.
Read original review
Games.cz80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2062Score 82.0295Score 82.0295Z -0.2062The legendary cover-based shooter returns with what might be its swan song; while it exhibits all the genre's flaws, it nonetheless delivers a solid, visually stunning military sci-fi experience—one that is perhaps longer than it should be, yet somehow you end up forgiving it. However, if you are expecting a major evolution or simply don't enjoy shooting from behind cover, steer clear.
Read original review
GamesCreed90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4443Score 88.5341Score 88.5341Z 0.4443Gears of War: E-Day feels less like another attempt to modernize Gears and more like a reminder of why the series became important in the first place. It keeps the heart of Marcus and Dom's relationship, brings back the fear of the Locust, and adds enough new ideas to make another trip through Sera worthwhile.
Read original review
GameSpot70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0678Score 73.4129Score 73.4129Z -1.0678For better or worse, E-Day is distinctly Gears, and I had a good time with it, even if the story is disappointing and the open areas are fairly dull.
Read original review
Gamesurf90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8243Score 92.3342Score 92.3342Z 0.8243Gears of War: E-Day is simply phenomenal. A campaign that stands as the best ever made for the series, distinguished by a narrative that is finally deeper, outstanding character development, and level design that manages to intelligently evolve the original formula. The gameplay is a sure thing, but this time it manages to offer something more thanks to a structure that perfectly alternates exploration and linear missions, always keeping the pace of the action extremely high. The multiplayer is packed with content, Horde Siege is addictive, and the Versus component continues to deliver everything fans could want. And then there’s the technical and artistic presentation, which is simply off the charts. On Xbox Series X, we’re looking at an impressive visual spectacle, accompanied by a fantastic soundtrack and top-tier sound design. The Coalition has created a work that doesn’t merely celebrate the past, but manages to breathe new life into one of Xbox’s most important franchises. A production that is polished in virtually every respect, capable of moving players, entertaining them, and above all demonstrating just how much this series still has to offer. For me, the best Microsoft Xbox exclusive at the moment and one of the most successful Gears of War games ever made. A triumphant return, simply unmissable.
Read original review
Gaming Age90/100 → 90 · Z 0.1337Score 85.4282Score 85.4282Z 0.1337Gears of War: E-Day is a bold new step forward for the franchise, while looking backward to the core of what made this franchise so great.
Read original review
Gaming Boulevard95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8128Score 92.2192Score 92.2192Z 0.8128After all these years, I didn’t expect a Gears prequel to hit me this hard. E-Day takes characters and enemies I know inside out and somehow makes them feel important again, especially because I already know where all of this is heading. By the time I finished the campaign, it felt like I had finally seen a missing part of a story I’ve been following for years. I thought I’d be done after the credits, but Horde Siege quickly proved otherwise. For me, this sits right up there with the best games in the series.
Read original review
Gaming Instincts80/100 → 80 · Z -0.453Score 79.5609Score 79.5609Z -0.453Ultimately, Gears of War: E-Day is an enjoyable campaign wrapped inside an exceptionally impressive technical package. It is a pleasure to look at, the combat remains satisfying, and the return of Marcus Fenix and Dom Santiago is exactly what many longtime fans wanted. Unfortunately, the forced DEI character writing, unnecessary social commentary, excessive dialogue, questionable level-design decisions, technical stuttering, and underwhelming ending prevent E-Day from becoming the definitive Gears experience I was hoping for after such a long wait when it comes to it's single player campaign portion.
Read original review
Gaming Professors100/100 → 100 · Z 1.8533Score 100Score 100Z 1.8533Gears of War: E-Day is a phenomenal action triumph of the highest calibre that doesn’t let players catch their breath for a single second. It captivates with both its melancholic, raw and deeply tragic story campaign and its devilishly addictive yet exceptionally fair multiplayer. For me personally, it’s currently a shoo-in for Game of the Year, and I already know that I’ll be happily spending hundreds more hours in the ruined streets of Kalona. Look past the occasional technical glitches and join the front lines without hesitation, because the Locusts are breaking through to the surface and the relentless battle for humanity’s very survival has just begun.
Read original review
GAMINGbible80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2909Score 81.1816Score 81.1816Z -0.2909Gears of War: E-Day is a solid prequel that gets a lot of things right. The characters, the combat, and the visuals all mesh together into a must-play adventure for any Gears of War fan, but it’s also an excellent starting point for those new to the series.
Read original review
GamingBolt90/100 → 90 · Z 0.717Score 91.2607Score 91.2607Z 0.717Gears of War: E-Day delivers thrilling combat, varied multiplayer offerings, and impressive level design.
Read original review
GamingTrend95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7691Score 91.7817Score 91.7817Z 0.7691Gears of War: E-Day is now XBOX’s flagship franchise. The campaign’s brutal and stunning recount of Kalona’s fall is immaculate storytelling, featuring revived gameplay via reworked movement systems and the visceral combat we know and love. Although Versus is well-made, it’s lacking depth to promote engaging with the high learning curve. Horde Siege is the best iteration of the mode we’ve ever seen, with a gameplay loop you want to play again and again. E-Day might be one of the easiest recommendations we'll make all year, for purchase and awards season.
Read original review
Geek Culture82/100 → 82 · Z -0.404Score 80.0511Score 80.0511Z -0.404Gears of War: E-Day takes players back to Emergence Day, the pivotal Locust invasion that defined the franchise, and while this prequel modernises its gameplay for some of the most fluid action seen from the series to date, it loses the spark that makes it a Gears experience in the process.
Read original review
Geekinout.pt90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4447Score 88.5378Score 88.5378Z 0.4447Gears of War: E-Day doesn’t try to be anything else. It’s the same old formula, but executed with confidence and solidity. The campaign is intense from start to finish, finds room for moments of terror that remind us just how frightening the Locust can be, and provides more context for the relationship between Marcus and Dom. New features, such as the open-world sections and the customisation of weapons, armour and abilities, add to the experience without detracting from its essence. And with Horde, Multiplayer and co-op campaign with open lobbies, the package guarantees hours of gameplay long after the final credits roll. Those looking for a revolution in the genre won’t find it here. But for those seeking Gears of War at its best, look no further.
Read original review
Geeks &a; Com90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6433Score 90.5241Score 90.5241Z 0.6433Gears of War: E-Day delivers a powerful return to the franchise’s roots, combining intense combat with a darker, horror-inspired atmosphere and an emotional story about Marcus and Dom. The campaign offers satisfying gameplay, well-designed semi-open environments, and impressive visuals, while its expanded movement mechanics modernize the classic formula. Although enemy variety is limited and some exploration elements become repetitive, The Coalition delivers a memorable adventure that captures what makes Gears of War so compelling.
Read original review
Generación Xbox100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3057Score 97.1486Score 97.1486Z 1.3057Gears of War: E-Day is, for me, the best game in the series and The Coalition's finest work to date. Its campaign brings Marcus and Dom back without relying solely on nostalgia, delivering a darker and more brutal take on the origins of the Locust threat.
Read original review
Gfinity100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2663Score 96.7545Score 96.7545Z 1.2663Gears of War: E-Day delivers arguably the franchise's finest, most atmospheric campaign, brilliantly balancing pulse-pounding action with genuine horror roots. By pairing breathtaking Series X visuals and refined combat with a deeply emotional return to Marcus and Dom, The Coalition has delivered a masterclass prequel that restores complete faith in Xbox's future. A triumph from start to finish.
Read original review
GRYOnline.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3389Score 80.7024Score 80.7024Z -0.3389Gears of War: E-Day successfully fulfils its mission of returning to the roots of the series, whilst offering noticeable improvements over all previous instalments and reminding us once again of the horror of the Locusts. Unfortunately, it also suffers from issues with pacing and enemy AI, while pushing Marcus into the background in favour of a new character. Nevertheless, this dynamic, emotional and extremely brutal shooter should appeal to fans of the series – and many others as well.
Read original review
Guardian60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5154Score 68.9375Score 68.9375Z -1.5154E-Day boasts the best combat in 20 years of Gears games – but everything surrounding it is disappointing
Read original review
Hardcore Gamer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1225Score 72.866Score 72.866Z -1.1225Gears of War: E-Day can be placed on two sides of a coin. On one side, the campaign is lackluster and fails to create a meaningful, lasting impression. On the other side of the coin, the multiplayer, both PvP and PvE, are some of the best you can get within the third-person shooter space. Horde mode feels perfectly refined for what The Coalition built, and PvP remains highly satisfying, especially with the addition of all the new weapons. In the end, it’s a matter of what the player is coming for. The campaign is the weakest link, while its multiplayer helps propel it into a lasting experience. In the end, Gears of War: E-Day is something that could have been so much more.
Read original review
HCL.hr88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5997Score 90.0882Score 90.0882Z 0.5997E‑Day is the good old Gears we know, but pushed to its peak. With the best gameplay in the series, an atmospheric story, and an excellent Horde Siege mode, this is the return to form the franchise has been waiting for.
Read original review
ID95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9725Score 93.816Score 93.816Z 0.9725Gears of War: E-Day gets it right from start to finish. In the campaign, The Coalition keeps the pure DNA of the series, with brutal action that puts Michael Bay movies to shame. It also successfully works in quieter moments that let the story and atmosphere breathe. The result is not only the most gripping Gears of War game to date, but also a confronting war epic with few equals. On the multiplayer side, E-Day surpasses its predecessors mainly by going bigger.
Read original review
IGN90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4564Score 88.6553Score 88.6553Z 0.4564Gears of War: E-Day is a powerful package of campaign and multiplayer. The single-player (and co-op-enabled!) story stands up to the best in the series with heavy doses of both heart and horror, a delightfully vicious complement of modifiable weapons, and a whole bunch of gorgeous setpieces to battle through. A razor-sharp – if shotgun-tastic – Versus mode and an evolved Horde Siege mode are also fully equipped to keep you and your friends having a ton of PvE fun deep into the night. Together, the latest in this long-running cover shooter series is one of my favorite games of the year, and dare I say one of the best as well.
Read original review
IGN Brasil95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8987Score 93.0785Score 93.0785Z 0.8987I hope the game comes out with fewer bugs and runs more smoothly, because other than that, I had a simply phenomenal experience with Gears of War: E-Day and I wholeheartedly recommend it. This is definitely the best game in the franchise.
Read original review
IGN Deutschland70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9922Score 74.1693Score 74.1693Z -0.9922While the campaign in Gears of War: E-Day doesn’t quite win me over due to its structural weaknesses, the game demonstrates the potential of its new mechanics in its solid multiplayer mode. Personally, I see this as the main reason to buy the game—especially if you play with a regular group so you can coordinate your tactics more effectively. The new Horde mode will certainly take some getting used to for fans. But especially given the larger map, I see a lot of interesting possibilities here for future expansions, provided Xbox gives the game the support it needs. Ultimately, while I’m somewhat torn about the overall package, I’m optimistic about the future of the series.
Read original review
IGN France90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7612Score 91.7036Score 91.7036Z 0.7612Brutal and inspired, despite some repetition and technical issues. With its masterful presentation, visceral combat and excellent soundtrack, it brings the essence of the series back to life. One thing’s for sure: the Gears are back.
Read original review
IGN Italy90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7791Score 91.8819Score 91.8819Z 0.7791With E-Day, the Gears of War saga delivers a dramatic and profound story centered on Marcus, Dom, and their traumas-but above all, on a humanity that was ready for peace and suddenly finds itself, overnight, in the midst of a war against a ruthless and brutal enemy. The gameplay has returned to the exceptionally high standards of the original trilogy, retaining its foundational elements while expanding every aspect to further enhance the experience-including weapons, enemies, and maps.
Read original review
IGN Spain100/100 → 100 · Z 1.6661Score 100Score 100Z 1.6661Weapons of all kinds, gadgets, and locations brimming with possibilities form the foundation of a story that excels in every aspect. Marcus and Dom return alongside old and new acquaintances in a prequel that feels fresh and invigorating. The story of Kalona’s downfall on E-Day serves as the starting point for a war-torn odyssey filled with unique situations, memorable scenes, and the feeling of experiencing an iconic moment in a saga that, for many, is a must-play. Gears of War: E-Day marks a turning point for the Xbox catalog with a console and PC exclusive that’s determined to raise the bar for Microsoft.
Read original review
Indie Games Devel78/100 → 78 · Z -0.577Score 78.3215Score 78.3215Z -0.577Ultimately, Gears of War: E-Day is a compelling reminder of what makes the franchise endure, even if it falls short of fully realising the potential of its return to the past. The Coalition has recaptured much of the series’ defining identity, from its uncompromising brutality and visceral combat to the emotional bond at the heart of its story. What it has not quite achieved is turning those strengths into a consistently memorable campaign.
The most successful aspect of the prequel is undoubtedly the relationship between Marcus Fenix and Dom Santiago. Their friendship gives the narrative its emotional heart, bringing back the humour, camaraderie, and underlying vulnerability that helped define the original trilogy. Tai further strengthens the connection to the series’ history, while Carlos and the references to established events give the story a broader sense of continuity. Crucially, E-Day does more than invite players to revisit familiar ground: at its best, it reminds us why these characters and their world mattered in the first place.
That same understanding extends to the gameplay. The return to the franchise’s brutal origins restores some of the menace that made the Locust such formidable adversaries, while the familiar arsenal and cover-based shooting remain as satisfying as ever. The combat has weight, the weapons retain their distinctive character, and well-executed encounters demonstrate that the foundations of Gears of War remain remarkably resilient. There is no inherent need to reinvent a formula that still works this well. The challenge is to keep it engaging over the course of an entire campaign, and this is where E-Day proves less convincing.
Its shortcomings become increasingly apparent as the hours accumulate. An overextended campaign, larger environments that too rarely translate into meaningful gameplay variety, and supporting characters who struggle to leave a lasting impression all dilute the experience. Boss encounters frequently favour endurance over ingenuity, while an intrusive interface and severe performance drops in demanding areas further compromise the action. Individually, these issues vary in significance; collectively, they prevent the game from achieving the consistency its strongest moments suggest is within reach.
For all its merits, E-Day is not the triumphant return that could have reasserted Gears of War at the very forefront of the genre. Nor does it recapture the impact of the original trilogy in its entirety. Yet judging the prequel solely against the legacy it seeks to revisit would mean overlooking a more encouraging truth: The Coalition understands the foundations on which that legacy was built. The problem is not a loss of identity, but an uneven ability to translate that identity into an experience that remains compelling from beginning to end.
The distinction matters most when the game returns to Marcus and Dom. Their relationship gives the campaign something that spectacle alone cannot provide: a personal stake in the unfolding catastrophe. Through them, Emergence Day becomes more than the beginning of a war; it becomes the defining experience of two soldiers whose friendship will shape the future of the series. It is in these moments that E-Day comes closest to recapturing the spirit of the original games, reminding us that beneath the armour, the chainsaw bayonets, and the relentless violence, Gears of War has always been a story about survival, friendship, and sacrifice.
That is ultimately what makes this prequel worth experiencing, despite its shortcomings. It does not deliver a uniformly successful return to the series’ origins, but it does reaffirm the value of the characters, the world, and the combat that have sustained the franchise for so long. Its strongest elements provide a solid foundation; its weaker ones make clear how much further that foundation could have taken it.
For The Coalition, the next challenge is not to rediscover what makes Gears of War distinctive, but to build on it with greater ambition and discipline. E-Day proves that the series still has a compelling story to tell and that Marcus and Dom remain at its heart. Whether that promise can be transformed into something truly exceptional will depend on what comes next. For now, this is a worthwhile return to the battlefield: one that honours the past, reclaims much of the franchise’s identity, and leaves room for a more assured future.
Read original review
Indigo GEEK90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5165Score 89.2563Score 89.2563Z 0.5165Gears of War: E-Day is The Coalition’s best entry in the series to date. It recaptures the brutality and identity of the original trilogy while evolving its formula through greater mobility, customization, and a more ambitious campaign. Its emotional story gives new weight to an event we have known for decades, while an excellent multiplayer offering and the ambitious Horde Siege provide an equally compelling reason to keep playing. Technical issues prevented it from reaching perfection, but ironically, after years of searching for a way forward, Gears found its best version by returning to the day it all began.
Read original review
INVEN87/100 → 87 · Z 0.2354Score 86.4447Score 86.4447Z 0.2354'Gears of War: E-Day' returns to the series' starting point, Emergence Day, bringing back its darkest atmosphere yet and the core appeal of Gears. If you've been missing the explosive, hard-hitting battlefields of the original trilogy, 'Gears of War: E-Day' is sure to be a satisfying choice.
Read original review
Jeuxvideo.com85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3774Score 87.8656Score 87.8656Z 0.3774Is Gears of War: E-Day the Xbox Series X/S exclusive that PS5 players will envy? Perhaps. The Coalition’s ultra-violent blockbuster delivers a stunning visual punch in 4K/60fps—the most impressive seen on console to date. Classic yet fresh, the gameplay focuses on the essentials rather than spreading itself too thin. With environments that crumble apart, visceral impacts, and fluid enemy movement, the game directs its efforts exactly where a Gears of War title needs them. Had the characters been less one-dimensional and the side quests more varied, the *E-Day* campaign could easily have stood as the series' best—surpassing even the original trilogy. Whether played solo or with others via a highly entertaining multiplayer mode, this Gears of War makes a massive impact.
Read original review
JsemGamer82/100 → 82 · Z 0.1249Score 85.3402Score 85.3402Z 0.1249Gears of War: E-Day is a brutal and visually spectacular return to the series, combining incredibly satisfying gunplay, excellent audiovisual feedback, oppressive atmosphere, and strong environmental storytelling with some genuinely effective horror elements. Its larger areas occasionally dilute the campaign’s pacing, enemy AI can be inconsistent, and a few encounters frustrate more than they challenge, but the relentless action and polished presentation make this one of the year’s biggest surprises. Jsem Gamer
Read original review
Julien Chièze90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4681Score 88.7724Score 88.7724Z 0.4681Gears of War E-Day stands out as the best entry in a very long time and one of Xbox’s most accomplished games in recent years in terms of pacing and production values. Its more open design and improved mobility make up for a somewhat traditional formula. Still, The Coalition delivers its best Gears yet, recapturing the series’ brutality, fury and spectacle while expanding its universe. I really enjoyed this return to its roots. It just lacks that extra emotional impact that could have made it truly incredible.
Read original review
Just Play it85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0652Score 83.4388Score 83.4388Z -0.0652Gears of War: E-Day is more than just an attempt to revive past glories or recreate previous successes; it is a heartfelt tribute to the fans that lives up to their expectations. A cinematic and tactical experience that brings together all the right elements, cementing the franchise’s place among the best shooters of this generation and successfully marking the rebirth of a legendary combat saga.
Read original review
Kakuchopurei80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1677Score 82.4144Score 82.4144Z -0.1677Gears of War: E-Day is just fun comfort food to go back to shooter-wise; like a village hometown dish you grew up with back again in your mouth after years of abstaining. The best kind of beef rendang and hearty rice combo if we're talking literal Malaysian comfort food.
Read original review
KonsoliFIN70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7734Score 76.3573Score 76.3573Z -0.7734Gears of War: E-Day is a prequel, which doesn't feel like the next big chapter in GoW universe. Still, nimbler movement, weapon mods and excellent Horde Siege mode freshen up the familiar formula a bit.
Read original review
LevelUp85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0892Score 83.1996Score 83.1996Z -0.0892Gears of War: E-Day is The Coalition's best campaign to date; an intense, spectacular experience that remains faithful to the franchise's roots. Its gripping story, dark atmosphere, industry-leading visuals, and satisfying arsenal make the return to Emergence Day an unforgettable roller coaster that honors the legacy of Gears.
Read original review
Loot Level Chill90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3786Score 87.8772Score 87.8772Z 0.3786Gears of War: E-Day is an excellent return to form for the series, with a fun and engaging campaign, improved movement, and a strong range of multiplayer modes.
Read original review
Lords Of Gaming93/100 → 93 · Z 0.6846Score 90.9376Score 90.9376Z 0.6846Gears of War: E-Day does not disappoint; the story starts strong and only gets better. For players who have experienced the previous entries in the franchise, there are plenty of easter eggs scattered throughout. Any graphic and audio-related glitches I ran into were very minor and did not detract from the experience overall. For me, this game is in the running for my Game of the Year.
Read original review
Meristation90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4624Score 88.7156Score 88.7156Z 0.4624Xbox couldn't have chosen a better title for its return to exclusives. Gears of War: E-Day is an enviable, outstanding game. It features one of the best campaigns in the series and breathes new life into the formula.
Read original review
Metacritic Users84/100 → 84 · Z 0.1189Score 85.2805Score 85.2805Z 0.1189Metacritic user score 8.4/10 (2235 ratings).
Metro GameCentral70/100 → 70 · Z -0.5053Score 79.0377Score 79.0377Z -0.5053A prequel that looks and feels far too similar to the 20-year-old original and while it’s a vastly more entertaining experience in co-op, it still feels worryingly old-fashioned and overfamiliar.
Read original review
Minimap90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4575Score 88.6666Score 88.6666Z 0.4575Gears of War: E-Day is a shot in the arm for the franchise. It pushes the franchise while returning to its roots and finding what is core to the heart of the series.
Read original review
MKAU Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5548Score 89.6391Score 89.6391Z 0.5548Gears of War: E-Day feels like the return to Gears that we’ve all been waiting for, bringing back the brutal cover-based combat, dark atmosphere and Locust while still adding enough new ideas to move the series forward. The story of younger Marcus and Dom hit harder than I expected.
Read original review
MondoXbox95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9899Score 93.9899Score 93.9899Z 0.9899Gears of War: E-Day delivers arguably the series’ strongest campaign, combining mature, restrained storytelling with the return of Marcus Fenix’s charismatic presence. Already among the franchise’s finest entries, it could become a serious Game of the Year contender if its content-rich multiplayer matches the campaign’s quality. Regardless, Xbox players should not miss this outstanding return to form.
Read original review
MonsterVine70/100 → 70 · Z -0.883Score 75.2608Score 75.2608Z -0.883Gears of War: E-Day is an excellent-feeling third-person shooter. It’s gorgeous, runs well (even in split-screen), and is a ton of fun when it focuses on firefights. It lacks an interesting take on being both a prequel and an invasion day story mechanically, slipping back into classic Gears a little too quickly. The open zone levels are dull, checklist-filled areas that create unnecessary downtime. Multiplayer is sharp and well executed, but also doesn’t rise above being more Gears. Horde Siege takes on the faults of the open campaign levels and becomes too focused on meta upgrades, losing sight of having fun in the current match, not the next one. It’s well-crafted, but ultimately feels at its best when it’s trying the least.
Read original review
Neutral Game90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4478Score 88.5693Score 88.5693Z 0.4478Gears of War: E-Day understands perfectly that going back to the past doesn't mean living on nostalgia alone. The Coalition uses characters, enemies and elements that any fan recognizes right away, but places them in a completely different moment. One where the Locust are still terrifying and where Marcus Fenix is not yet the practically indestructible soldier we all know.
Read original review
Nexus Hub90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5258Score 89.3488Score 89.3488Z 0.5258Gears of War: E-Day is firing on almost every cylinder - a fantastic back to basics prequel that makes the Locust Horde scary again while delivering weighty, brutal gameplay that keeps you hooked.
Read original review
NoobFeed92/100 → 92 · Z 0.7877Score 91.9681Score 91.9681Z 0.7877Gears of War: E-Day doesn't completely reinvent the series, and it doesn't need to. Its biggest changes come from movement, encounter design, customization, and the decision to focus the campaign around a single city and a short period of time. Those changes work because they strengthen the parts of Gears that already mattered.
Read original review
One More Game90/100 → 90 · Z 0.1722Score 85.8134Score 85.8134Z 0.1722Gears of War: E-Day is arguably one of the best Gears games in the decorated franchise, portraying Emergence Day as both terrifying and spectacular, capturing humanity's darkest moment through unforgettable set pieces, emotional stakes, and a renewed focus on Marcus and Dom's brotherhood. While the narrative occasionally treads predictable ground, the game's exceptional presentation, stunning visuals, and atmospheric depiction make for a compelling campaign from start to finish.
Read original review
Oyungezer Online85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2102Score 86.1936Score 86.1936Z 0.2102It's definitely a step in the right direction for the franchise. With its story, the way it's presented, and the gameplay, a solid GoW game is waiting for us. They've kindly reminded us once again why we love this series. We can easily overlook a few minor flaws.
Read original review
PC Gamer77/100 → 77 · Z -0.3967Score 80.1243Score 80.1243Z -0.3967Great cover-based shooting with terrific multiplayer. Shame the main campaign is an exhausting, endless firefight that outstays its welcome.
Read original review
PC Games85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1373Score 85.4638Score 85.4638Z 0.1373E-Day carefully modernizes the Gears formula, but never looses sight of what made the series great in the first place. Amazing visuals, high-octane action and a surprisingly decent story all come together in one of the best Gears of War games to date. Some pacing issues aside, you are getting a really strong package here, with a satisfying campaign, co-op, pvp and the new Horde Siege which should keep you busy for quite some time.
Read original review
PCMag Middle East80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3521Score 80.5705Score 80.5705Z -0.3521Gears of War: E-Day is a brutal, atmospheric return to form that reminds us why this franchise became legendary in the first place. It may not reinvent the formula, but its terrifying take on this war’s bitter beginning makes for one hell of a comeback.
Read original review
PCMGAMES100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4567Score 98.6579Score 98.6579Z 1.4567Gears of War: E-Day is a must-play title because it recaptures the essence of the series while introducing significant improvements to its formula. Its campaign is the perfect way to experience E-Day firsthand and gain a deeper understanding of how the relationship between Marcus and Dom began to take shape, all set in a world brimming with detail and in constant flux. It may feel a bit repetitive at times, but beyond that, this is a game that proves that going back to the roots doesn’t have to mean getting stuck in nostalgia.
Read original review
Pizza Fria85/100 → 85 · Z 0.082Score 84.9108Score 84.9108Z 0.082Gears of War: E-Day is a good shooter and an excellent introduction to this universe for those who, like me, have spent years following the franchise only from the outside. There's a long, very well-produced campaign, visually impressive, and one that probably gains another dynamic when shared with friends.
Read original review
PowerUp!85/100 → 85 · Z 0.154Score 85.631Score 85.631Z 0.154Gears of War: E-Day feels like a confident reminder of what made this series Xbox royalty in the first place. It’s nasty, ridiculous, surprisingly funny and occasionally horrifying, all while giving Marcus and Dom another jaunt to share that feels worthwhile rather than merely nostalgic.
Read original review
PPE.pl90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4258Score 88.3489Score 88.3489Z 0.4258Gears of War: E-Day marks a brilliant return for one of Xbox’s most iconic franchises, allowing players to experience E-Day and witness the beginning of Marcus and Dom’s story from a completely new perspective. The Coalition isn’t revolutionising the familiar formula, but in a way it’s building on it – improving mobility, shooting and exploration, offering a varied campaign, and in the process showcasing the immense capabilities of Unreal Engine 5. It’s a modern Gears game that never forgets its roots.
Read original review
Pragalicious90/100 → 90 · Z 0.664Score 90.7307Score 90.7307Z 0.664Gears of War: E-Day is exactly the prequel the franchise needed. The Coalition harks back to the horror, the tension and the brutal action of the first games. But they’ve tweaked the gameplay with smarter enemies and more verticality. The story surrounding Emergence Day also delivers a wealth of emotion, whilst Kalona emerges as one of the most impressive locations the franchise has ever seen. At its core, it remains good old Gears, but this E-Day is undoubtedly one of the strongest and most impressive Gears games ever. Full stop.
Read original review
Press Start90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5403Score 89.4938Score 89.4938Z 0.5403Though fault can be found with its meaningless side quests and examples of knuckleheaded dialogue, Gears of War: E-Day gets so much of its core loop right. It's hard to recall a game nailing the desperate, helpless feeling of invasion quite like this, and E-Day sets a new benchmark for Gears' iconic gunplay. More than anything, E-Day is a technical crown jewel that delivers an audiovisual experience that, on Xbox, is unrivalled.
Read original review
Pure Xbox100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2496Score 96.5875Score 96.5875Z 1.2496Gears of War: E-Day is a monumental triumph from a developer that irrefutably understands what’s important to fans: Gears isn’t just about tearing through Locust with a chainsaw, it’s about brotherhood, sacrifice, and grief. The Coalition has delivered an unforgettable campaign packed full of fresh ideas whilst staying true to what makes Gears so special. The Locust are back and more terrifying than ever, and blasting them to bits is incredibly satisfying. This is the best the combat has felt in twenty years, and fighting to survive the fall of Kalona will leave you speechless. Through its stunning locations, characters, and cinematics, E-Day is a visual powerhouse and one of the best-looking games I’ve ever seen on Xbox.
Read original review
Radio Times80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4085Score 80.0065Score 80.0065Z -0.4085I’ve really enjoyed my time with E-Day. Series S players have got the raw end of the deal, but everyone else should buckle up for a properly epic showcase of enemy brutality, impressive world-building and jaw-dropping spectacle.
Read original review
RageQuit.GR85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0772Score 83.3194Score 83.3194Z -0.0772Gears of War: E-Day marks a return to the series’ roots, without, however, feeling like a typical “reimagining” of the past. The Coalition took the core elements that made Gears of War special and rebuilt them masterfully, into a satisfying game that isn’t groundbreaking or the best shooter you’ve ever played, but is certainly capable of entertaining fans of the genre.
Read original review
Rectify Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.47Score 88.791Score 88.791Z 0.47The longest Gears of War Campaign succeeds in entertaining gameplay, intriguing open world chapters with side objectives, and plenty of content to enjoy. The Campaign embraces co-op like no other game does these days and you could argue it's one of the best games that we have witnessed in the series.
E-Day understands that Gears of War has always been about more than shooting monsters. It is about the people standing beside you while you do it. Whether that person is sitting beside you on the couch in split screen, joining you online from across the country, or simply standing beside Marcus as an AI companion, E-Day constantly comes back to the idea that surviving this world is easier when you never fight alone.
Read original review
ReGame It95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8814Score 92.9049Score 92.9049Z 0.8814A fantastic revival of the series, revisiting Emergence Day through Marcus, Dom, and the rest of the squad’s eyes. With evolved gameplay and epic visuals, it delivers an excellent experience for fans of the series.
Read original review
Region Free80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2104Score 81.9875Score 81.9875Z -0.2104Epic to a fault, Gears of War: E-Day packs in everything but the kitchen sink, almost as if saying goodbye to the franchise, which, considering everything, it just might be. But if this is it, what a way to close up shop. E-Day combines everything Gears fans love about the series into an overwhelming and immensely earnest celebration that stands proudly alongside the original trilogy.
Read original review
República DG92/100 → 92 · Z 0.7599Score 91.6902Score 91.6902Z 0.7599Gears of War: E-Day marks the return of Marcus and Dom in an excellent campaign, with renewed gameplay, impressive graphics, and a few issues that don’t overshadow the game’s major achievements. One of the best Xbox titles of this generation, worthy of all the attention.
Read original review
Rocket Chainsaw80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3263Score 80.828Score 80.828Z -0.3263Fans that played the original games on launch will appreciate just how dark and gritty Gears of War E-Day is, and the way the campaign develops with the Locust Horde gradually becoming more of a problem, the environmental destruction and level of detail around every bend definitely cements this game as one of the best looking exclusive Xbox titles
Read original review
RogerEbert.com85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0698Score 84.7896Score 84.7896Z 0.0698Gears of War: E-Day is the best the series has been in a long, long time. While its campaign is fairly by-the-numbers standard for a third-person shooter, the game’s cast is engaging enough to elevate it. The pacing can be a bit of a slog sometimes, but the fantastic movement, gunplay, and visuals make all-out firefights an experience to behold.
Read original review
Saudi Gamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2364Score 81.7269Score 81.7269Z -0.2364While it could be seen as the developer losing faith in what they accomplished with the 4th and 5th entries, it can’t be denied that it makes for a fun & bloody good time.
Read original review
SavePoint80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3987Score 80.1038Score 80.1038Z -0.3987If you're a Gears fan, you'll turn your nose up at the annoying new character early on, but you'll enjoy taking part in Emergence Day and learning how it all began.
Read original review
SavePoint Gaming85/100 → 85 · Z -0.1092Score 82.9995Score 82.9995Z -0.1092Gears of War: E-Day modernises the series without losing its trademark weight, pairing brutal combat and meaningful weapon customisation with strong character work, smart exploration and only a handful of frustrating solo-play shortcomings.
Read original review
Saving Content80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2329Score 81.7626Score 81.7626Z -0.2329Even in a silo, Gears of War: E-Day delivers a rollercoaster of action and emotion that ranks alongside the series’ best campaigns. The Coalition grounds the global devastation of Emergence Day in a deeply human story, letting players watch Marcus and Dom’s friendship forge into an unbreakable brotherhood. It retains the franchise’s signature brutality while completely reinvigorating the moment-to-moment combat. While the narrative plays it safe compared to the tragic finality of Halo: Reach, it sticks the landing and beautifully sets the stage for a new trilogy. Gears of War: E-Day serves as the perfect entry point for newcomers, and explores the devastating, series-haunting history veterans have waited twenty years to experience.
Read original review
screenactu88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3208Score 87.2991Score 87.2991Z 0.3208Gears of War E-Day is exactly the return to basics the series needed. After Gears 5 got a little lost in its semi-open areas, The Coalition goes back to the franchise’s strengths: a focused campaign, visceral combat, satisfying cover mechanics and spectacular set pieces. New moves and low cover add some freshness without compromising the series’ DNA. It’s not perfect, though. Some environments and situations are reused too often, while the lack of enemy variety makes their patterns predictable. The biggest disappointment is Marcus and Dom, who should have been at the heart of the story. The game had a great opportunity to explore the beginning of their friendship, but their relationship never gets the attention it deserves. Still, E-Day delivers an excellent solo campaign and a strong reminder of what Gears does best.
Read original review
Seasoned Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4398Score 88.4894Score 88.4894Z 0.4398With two decades of expectations on its shoulders, The Coalition succeeded in crafting another classic Gears game with E-Day. Its technical brilliance is matched by strong character development and modernized gameplay, resulting in one of my favorite experiences of the year.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5762Score 89.853Score 89.853Z 0.5762Gears of War: E-Day takes the series back to Emergence Day and the beginning of the Locust War through the eyes of Marcus and Dom. The campaign shows a peaceful city gradually turning into a devastated war zone while revealing the origins of several iconic elements of the series. Familiar cover-based combat has been refined with smoother movement and faster encounters, while multiplayer remains close to the classic formula and adds the more dynamic Horde Siege mode. Combined with impressive UE5 visuals, E-Day is a very good return to the roots of Gears.
Read original review
Shacknews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6898Score 90.9892Score 90.9892Z 0.6898Gears of War excels when it leans into humanity versus monsters, is painted with a brush drenched in blood, and offers vicious, savage gameplay that belies surprisingly rich stories and heartfelt characters.
Read original review
Sirus Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.392Score 88.0111Score 88.0111Z 0.392Gears of War: E-Day is more than I could have hoped for: a focused, tightly contained, action-packed story filled with memorable characters and moments that deliver an emotional rollercoaster for those brave enough to witness the horrors of the first days of Emergence Day. E-Day is what a Gears of War game should be: relentlessly fun, engaging from all angles, and best experienced with friends.
Read original review
Slant Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1957Score 86.0482Score 86.0482Z 0.1957While E-Day’s cover-based third-person shooter gameplay doesn’t break the mold, it’s a finely tuned experience that builds on the mechanics established across the long-running series.
Read original review
SmashPad90/100 → 90 · Z 0.627Score 90.3613Score 90.3613Z 0.627Gears of War: E-Day injects new life into the franchise and sets a new tone moving forward. It captured the spirit of the original Gears of War with putting just enough of a new spin on things. It’s definitely a highlight of the series. A perfect reload, indeed.
Read original review
SomGeek90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6635Score 90.7258Score 90.7258Z 0.6635The Coalition delivers a visually breathtaking and atmospherically uncompromising action epic that takes the series back to its brutal roots through the raw story of a young Marcus and Dom. Despite occasional recycling of urban environments and minor pacing hiccups, it is an absolute triumph of the cover-shooter genre and an unforgettable ride that no gamer should miss.
Read original review
SpazioGames90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8161Score 92.2525Score 92.2525Z 0.8161Gears of War: E-Day is a stunning AAA production and the triumphant return the series deserves. The Coalition blends two decades of experience with meaningful experimentation, delivering a polished campaign that works equally well for newcomers and longtime fans. Gorgeous visuals, impeccable technical execution, and refined gameplay make E-Day a standout release and one of 2026’s essential games.
Read original review
Spilstrøm90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5934Score 90.0248Score 90.0248Z 0.5934While some small, confusing shortfalls persist throughout, Gears of War: E-Day thoroughly demonstrates, that The Coalition are the right stewards for the franchise, showcasing fantastic gameplay tweaks and additions, and a strong structural foundation on which to build for the future.
Read original review
STWGames Italia90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5971Score 90.062Score 90.062Z 0.5971With Gears of War: E-Day, Microsoft has unequivocally demonstrated its desire to restore the series to its former glory, and that The Coalition is the perfect studio to do so. From the campaign to the multiplayer modes, from the gameplay to the graphics and aesthetics, everything reflects the creative and developmental richness of a major production done right—not just thanks to a massive budget and many years of work, but also to good intentions, excellent ideas, and exceptional execution. At the same time, there’s no denying that there are a few minor issues here and there: the campaign suffers from some slight narrative, structural, and audio mixing shortcomings (including lip sync), while Versus and Horde Siege lack content volume—evidently in anticipation of substantial post-launch support.
Read original review
TechRaptor95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0486Score 94.5771Score 94.5771Z 1.0486Gears of War: E-Day is the best game in the series. The story gives us an up-close and personal look at the events of E-Day, providing a horror-filled and harrowing experience. Meanwhile, the enhancements to movement are very welcome, and gunplay feels more varied with a great roster of weapons and the inclusion of mods.
Read original review
TechStomper100/100 → 100 · Z 0.9974Score 94.0656Score 94.0656Z 0.9974Gears of War: E-Day takes the things that made the original games so good, throws in some modern bells and whistles, and reminds us why this series became such a big deal in the first place.
Read original review
TestingBuddies90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4936Score 89.0267Score 89.0267Z 0.4936Gears of War: E-Day is a stunning comeback with fun, fast-paced cover shooting, smart enemies and the best visuals in the series, held back only slightly by stiff NPC animations and some ragdoll glitches.
Read original review
The AU Review90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5785Score 89.876Score 89.876Z 0.5785An engaging story, tied together with some nifty new features that make for smoother gameplay, and more robust PvE and PvP multiplayer modes make this an absolutely irresistible package.
Read original review
The Games Machine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6749Score 90.8403Score 90.8403Z 0.6749The Coalition modernizes movement and cover mechanics without sacrificing the series' hallmarks-such as its sense of weight and brutality-delivering a spectacular campaign, a Versus mode that intelligently revives old-school multiplayer, and Horde Siege, an ambitious and compelling evolution of the classic Horde mode. Add a top-tier technical presentation to the mix, and the score speaks for itself.
Read original review
The Nerd Stash95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6824Score 90.9151Score 90.9151Z 0.6824This prequel once again raised the bar for the series and the genre, delivering one of the year's most brutal, jaw-dropping shooters.
Read original review
The Outerhaven Productions100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2181Score 96.2726Score 96.2726Z 1.2181Gears of War: E-Day is everything I wanted from a prequel and more. It finally delivers the Emergence Day story fans have waited two decades to experience, while deepening the relationship between Marcus and Dom and returning the series to the darker, horror-inspired tone of the original trilogy. With the best gameplay the franchise has ever had, incredible visuals, excellent pacing and memorable characters, E-Day isn’t just the best Gears game yet; it’s one of Xbox’s strongest exclusives in years.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0041Score 84.1317Score 84.1317Z 0.0041Gears of War: E-Day is a reminder of just how bloody good this series can be. After twenty years, perhaps Gears didn't need another revolution, it just needed another Emergence Day.
Read original review
TheXboxHub100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0898Score 94.989Score 94.989Z 1.0898I have to say that Gears of War: E-Day is an absolute triumph of a game. The maps in the multiplayer and the campaign are big, with things to find in unlikely corners. From there, exploration in the story mode should be seen as its own reward. This is a game full of content, and you’ll spend hours upon hours taking in everything it has to offer. Whether you’re here for the campaign, or prefer to get invested in the multiplayer, if you have the slightest interest in Gears, you have to play Gears of War: E-Day. It really is that simple.
Read original review
TierraGamer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5807Score 89.8984Score 89.8984Z 0.5807Gears of War: E-Day marks an excellent return for the beloved shooter franchise, introducing enough new ideas to keep the experience fresh without sacrificing its identity. Its story thrusts players into a desperate struggle against an invading force, while its varied and consistently satisfying firefights and stunning visuals make Marcus Fenix’s latest adventure a highly recommended experience for both longtime Gears of War fans and shooter enthusiasts.
Read original review
TodoJuegos95/100 → 95 · Z 1.135Score 95.4415Score 95.4415Z 1.135Gears of War: E-Day brings back the series’ brutality from a more human perspective, placing Marcus and Dom at the heart of Emergence Day. The Coalition returns to the beginning while expanding the formula through exploration, upgrades and less restrictive areas, without losing the core identity that defines Gears of War.
Read original review
Tom's Guide90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6616Score 90.7071Score 90.7071Z 0.6616Gears of War: E-Day brings the series back to its literal roots, delivering all the blood-soaked action and characters that made it a hit. Filled with expansive maps, tons of thrilling enemy encounters, a slew of weapon modifications, and a truly gripping action-movie narrative, it's the must-own Xbox exclusive of 2026.
Read original review
Tom's Hardware Italia90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5529Score 89.6202Score 89.6202Z 0.5529Gears of War: E-Day is not simply the return of a historic franchise, but its definitive consecration in the modern gaming era. The Coalition has pulled off a courageous and surgical feat, stripping away the unnecessary bloat accumulated over the years to return the series to its purest, most ruthless, and visceral essence. The single-player campaign, clocking in at nearly twenty hours, stands as one of the finest narrative achievements in the action genre. It flawlessly blends intimate human drama with a cinematic spectacle of enormous proportions, all supported by an Unreal Engine 5 technical showcase that sets new standards for the entire industry.
Coupling this majestic adventure with an incredibly fluid and entertaining multiplayer suite (despite the natural need for fresh content in the short term) and a Horde mode that is deeper and more customizable than ever, the result is an absolute masterpiece. In a 2026 already packed with outstanding releases, E-Day stands tall as one of the best games of the year, rightfully claiming the title of the best shooter of 2026 and finally giving fans back the true Gears of War they have been dreaming of for far too long. The war for survival on Sera has only just begun.
Read original review
TrueAchievements90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4741Score 88.8321Score 88.8321Z 0.4741Gears of War: E-Day hits all the right notes for veteran Gears and newcomers alike. Witnessing the fall of Kalona is terrifying, but it's filled with the level of action you'd want from a Gears title.
Read original review
TwoHitGames85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3622Score 87.7131Score 87.7131Z 0.3622Gears of War: E-Day takes the franchise back to its roots with a brutal, emotional and spectacular experience that reminds us why the Locust War remains one of gaming’s most memorable conflicts.
Read original review
Uagna90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6963Score 91.0537Score 91.0537Z 0.6963Gears of War E-Day achieves exactly what it set out to do: breathe new life into a legendary franchise without betraying its essence, while giving it something new to say. It does so with an opening act that hits like a punch, technical prowess that sets new standards for the generation, and gameplay that’s finally more in-depth, blending verticality with loadout customization. The only real drawbacks lie in an open world that’s still a work in progress and exploration that’s too guided, which dampen the sense of discovery but don’t undermine the beating heart of the experience. The result is an exceptionally solid game that will satisfy the hardcore community and throw open the door to newcomers; by the time the credits roll, you’re left with the feeling that The Coalition and People Can Fly have rebuilt an excellent foundation from which to move forward. It remains to be seen where the series will go from here, and to find out, it will likely take another two or three years.
Read original review
Uagna.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6265Score 90.3565Score 90.3565Z 0.6265Gears of War E-Day revitalizes a storied franchise without betraying its soul, yet gives it something new to say. It achieves this with a hard-hitting opening act, technical execution that sets new standards for the generation, and gameplay that finally offers greater depth through verticality and loadout customization. Minor flaws—such as a still-nascent open-world design and overly guided exploration—dampen the sense of discovery but do not undermine the experience's beating heart. The result is a rock-solid game that will satisfy the hardcore community while opening the door to newcomers; by the time the credits roll, the feeling is that The Coalition and People Can Fly have laid an excellent foundation for the future. It remains to be seen where the series will go from here—and finding that out will, in all likelihood, take another two or three years.
VGC80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3665Score 80.4262Score 80.4262Z -0.3665Gears of War E-Day's campaign offers balls-to-the-wall action and rarely lets up, but that means the story takes more of a back seat than I'd like. It's good that time is given to the backstories of new protagonists Mags and Lucas, but given that the game is literally the playable Marcus and Dom backstory fans have been waiting decades to see, more time could have been spent on their relationship. In terms of pure gunplay, however, very little beats it this year.
Read original review
Videogiocare.it85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1033Score 85.124Score 85.124Z 0.1033Gears of War: E-Day is a brutal and confident return to the series' roots, with satisfying combat, strong atmosphere and welcome weapon customization. Its story plays things too safely and the open areas lack focus, but this is still Gears at its most enjoyable.
Read original review
Virtualni Kutak95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9349Score 93.4398Score 93.4398Z 0.9349Gears of War: E-Day is an absolute masterpiece and the perfect return to form for the franchise. Xbox and The Coalition made the brilliant decision to plug a massive narrative hole that fans have been wondering about for nearly two decades: how did Emergence Day actually happen? E-Day answers that question flawlessly. Thanks to smart mechanical tweaks and new traversal options, the gameplay is never dull; it is constantly engaging, always pushing you to see what horrific set-piece comes next. Because of all this, I firmly believe this is yet another massive win for the Xbox exclusive lineup.
Read original review
Voxel90/100 → 90 · Z 0.406Score 88.1514Score 88.1514Z 0.406Gears of War: E-Day hits the mark by getting the basics right: embracing its identity as a Gears of War game and elevating the strengths inherent to the series. The game doesn't revolutionize the genre, but it delivers a fun gameplay experience featuring a cinematic narrative and local multiplayer support.
Read original review
WayTooManyGames95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9921Score 94.0121Score 94.0121Z 0.9921The way it masterfully tells the story of Emergence Day with its devastation and destruction, watching as the city of Kalona gradually becomes more war-torn was amazing. It was also amazing to have Marcus and Dom back in action again without it feeling like nostalgia bait, and the character development of Mags and Lucas was well paced and meaningful. While I do have a few nitpicks here and there, and I would have liked to see more Versus launch content, there aren’t many AAA games giving this much content with this much quality.
Read original review
Wccftech74/100 → 74 · Z -0.9506Score 74.5847Score 74.5847Z -0.9506Gears of War: E-Day has been promoted as the most ambitious game ever made by The Coalition, but to be honest, it feels like a step back from Gears 5 in several ways. The narrative is a lot less memorable, and the side content is forgettable. Its saving grace is that the third-person shooter gameplay is better than ever, thanks to improved movement and fluidity, making combat encounters generally a lot of fun. Still, it's not the kind of masterpiece that sells a console like the original did.
Read original review
Windows Central90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4089Score 88.18Score 88.18Z 0.4089Gears of War: E-Day is a monstrously large package boasting multiple gameplay modes, a meaty campaign, an infectious Siege PvE mode, and classic versus PvP modes. Boasting some of the most impressive Unreal Engine visuals ever committed to the medium, Gears of War: E-Day is another impressive victory for one of the industry's most consistent dev teams. That "consistency" perhaps holds E-Day back in some ways, with a campaign that could've used more innovation and iteration, but the overall package is undeniably fantastic, fun, and ripe for future success.
Read original review
Worth Playing80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4881Score 79.2097Score 79.2097Z -0.4881As a complete package, Gears of War: E-Day is very good. The campaign may not be all that exciting, but it works fine and is elevated by the solid gunplay, especially if you play with real people rather than AI teammates. The adversarial multiplayer is fine if you can adapt to sticking with the one accepted play style. It is the PvE that really breathes life into the game and makes it a solid multiplier contender for a good while. While the game can be brutal for newcomers, it fits fan expectations well enough that they'd be happy to see this title in their libraries.
Read original review
Xbox Achievements90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6458Score 90.5494Score 90.5494Z 0.6458Gears of War: E-Day's campaign is an explosive ride, and being boots on the ground on day zero, as the invasion kicks off, is a wild experience. It's dark, it's brutal, and at times, it's shocking. Multiplayer is pretty great too, especially the new Horde Siege mode, but Versus needs more maps.
Read original review
Xbox Tavern95/100 → 95 · Z 0.739Score 91.4811Score 91.4811Z 0.739All in all, Gears of War: EDay is the best thing Gears since Gears of War 2, and we say that having very much enjoyed the majority of the franchise. The Coalition have done a superb job making the Locust feel fresh – and frightening – all over again, the combat is easily the best in the series, and despite knowing how the general gist turns out for Marcus and Dom, they’ve crafted a genuinely completing story to follow along with. Excellent stuff all round, and if this is the marker of a new beginning for XBOX’s first party titles – exclusive or otherwise – then we’re in for once hell of a renaissance.
Read original review
XGN85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1713Score 85.8042Score 85.8042Z 0.1713Gears of War: E-Day takes us back to the beginning of the Locust War with an intense and epic campaign. Not everything hits the mark, but spectacular moments, relentless action, and new additions make E-Day a strong evolution of Gears.
Read original review
ZdobywcyGier.eu70/100 → 70 · Z -1.427Score 69.821Score 69.821Z -1.427Gears of War: E-Day was my first encounter with this popular series, and to be honest, it didn’t encourage me to check out the other games in the series. Don’t get me wrong—it’s not a bad game. Not at all. It’s just incredibly uneven. It’s a game full of extremes, where great, well-thought-out solutions are interspersed with ideas that are outright bad or suffer from poor execution. The latest Gears game offers a spectacular, almost cinematic adventure, accompanied by superb graphics and an incredible, dark atmosphere. Unfortunately, behind all of this lies, well, a terrible story and poorly written characters. Moving on, on the one hand, we have beautiful, detailed locations; on the other, however, we have tedious exploration and places that, despite their polished appearance, are completely forgettable. The same goes for the gameplay, which can be a lot of fun but at the same time grows tiresome due to its repetitiveness and, at times, is downright frustrating because of its uneven difficulty.
Read original review
Zoomg85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2059Score 82.0325Score 82.0325Z -0.2059Gears of War: E-Day may have a few shortcomings in its story, character development, and the overall depth of its Versus mode, but these issues don't take away from what is otherwise a fantastic experience. When it comes to gameplay, E-Day stands as one of the best entries in the franchise. Its 15-hour campaign delivers an exceptional level of excitement, backed by brilliantly designed levels. Meanwhile, Siege Horde offers hours of entertainment and has the potential to keep players engaged for the long run with the right content updates. Combined with stunning visuals and high-quality sound design, these elements make E-Day a worthwhile experience for Gears fans and a triumphant return for the franchise. It's a comeback that lives up to the series' legacy and one you shouldn't miss.
Read original review