4News.it89/100 → 89 · Z 0.4629Score 88.7196Score 88.7196Z 0.4629Crimson Desert is a colossal, rough-edged, and at times chaotic game, yet one that is also incredibly captivating. Its controls demand patience, its narrative falls short of the potential of its world, and some of its design choices remain overly cumbersome. But it also boasts exceptional exploration, deep combat, an impressive array of mechanics, and a sense of adventure that few open-world games today can still convey with such power. Pearl Abyss has created a work that doesn’t aim for formal perfection, but for grandeur. And, despite stumbling several times along the way, it still manages to leave its mark. If you can get past the initial hurdle of the controls and accept a few inevitable rough edges, and overcome that ‘déjà vu’ feeling you’ll often experience when encountering a mechanic from that particular game, you’ll find yourself with a title capable of absorbing you for hundreds of hours, full of surprising moments and, above all, incredibly fun to play. It isn’t the most polished game in its category, but it is certainly one of the most vibrant, generous and ambitious of recent times.
Read original review
4P.de60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3132Score 60.9587Score 60.9587Z -2.3132Crimson Desert is massive and visually stunning, but to truly enjoy its game world, you’ll have to be willing to make some compromises. The controls take more than a little getting used to and can be a real pain at times, whether you’re using a gamepad or a mouse and keyboard. The quest design and gameplay guidance are among the worst I’ve experienced in a long time. The story leaves me completely cold, the characters spark zero interest, and while Crimson Desert strives for immersion with its detailed, vibrant world, high-quality animations, and many features, it repeatedly undermines that immersion itself.
Read original review
ACG75/100 → 75 · Z -1.0034Score 74.0567Score 74.0567Z -1.0034"Fantastic exploration, amazing systems, but ultimately bugs and lots of idiosyncrasies bring this one down a peg or two. ":
Read original review
Adrenaline80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3902Score 80.1896Score 80.1896Z -0.3902Crimson Desert is an ambitious open-world adventure with a slow pace that won't appeal to everyone. While the narrative is a weak point, often lacking urgency and cohesion, the game excels in its vast world and abundance of interwoven mechanics. Players will discover a wealth of activities, from crafting to complex combat, rewarding exploration and experimentation. Boss battles are challenging and engaging, contrasting with repetitive encounters against common enemies. Despite some visual inconsistencies, the game is well-optimized on PC and offers a unique personality, making it a compelling choice for those seeking a deep, self-guided experience.
Read original review
AltChar80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3027Score 81.0639Score 81.0639Z -0.3027Pearl Abyss's long-awaited RPG, Crimson Desert, had sort of a rough landing but eventually delivers one of the most absorbing open worlds in recent memory.
Read original review
Analog Stick Gaming85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1341Score 85.4325Score 85.4325Z 0.1341Crimson Desert is the next-gen game we were promised a decade ago by AAA publishers. The scale here is beyond massive, with hundreds of hours offered here if you can get past the game’s criminal control setup and sluggish opening few hours. With some bizarre design choices, Crimson Desert is a game that I can see both sides of the argument on, given the current state of the game. Still, Pearl Abyss has created what is effectively the next Skyrim, a game that offers an unparalleled amount of freedom, that rewards you the more you put into it.
Read original review
Arakat Mag85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1717Score 85.8083Score 85.8083Z 0.1717Of course, it has its flaws and shortcomings, and I already tried to address them above. But the massive vision it presents, along with its pure sense of adventure and freedom, is so powerful that it deserves to go down in history as one of the boldest and most spectacular games the industry has seen in recent years. Every player who wants to experience limitless freedom, chaos, and exploration should step into the continent of Pywel and experience this game for themselves.
Read original review
Areajugones90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3829Score 87.9204Score 87.9204Z 0.3829Crimson Desert demands patience and isn't afraid to challenge you, but when everything clicks, few games come close. Pywel is one of the most alive and detailed open worlds I've seen in years, the combat becomes deeply rewarding once you master it, boss fights are a genuine spectacle, and the sheer amount of things to discover and do is almost ridiculous. Pearl Abyss took its time with this one, and it shows.
Read original review
Atarita84/100 → 84 · Z -0.0215Score 83.8763Score 83.8763Z -0.0215Although Crimson Desert falls short in terms of its story and narrative, its vast world, gameplay mechanics and brilliant execution have introduced the term ‘single-player MMORPG’ into our vocabulary, and we’re likely to be hearing it more often.
Read original review
Atomix65/100 → 65 · Z -2.2895Score 61.1957Score 61.1957Z -2.2895Crimson Desert tries to offer something for everyone. While it presents itself as an open-world game, the reality is that there's much more to it. Although the foundations are solid, Pearl Abyss didn't stop there, adding multiple superfluous systems and mechanics that only cause the game to constantly stumble. While there are some quality elements, everything surrounding the good ideas is marred by a terrible interface, unresponsive controls, and a structure that lacks a clear direction. Like a buffet, Crimson Desert throws too much at us, but each bite is, in most cases, a disappointment.
Read original review
Bastidores70/100 → 70 · Z -1.3583Score 70.5083Score 70.5083Z -1.3583Crimson Desert is an undeniably ambitious open-world RPG, but its impressive scale and technical spectacle are constantly undermined by fragmented systems, uneven pacing, and a lack of identity.
Read original review
Bazimag100/100 → 100 · Z 1.353Score 97.621Score 97.621Z 1.353Crimson Desert isn't just one of the best games of the year; in my opinion, it's one of the greatest games ever made and deserves to be counted among the legendary works in the history of the industry. This game sets a new standard for action RPGs and open-world sandbox games, and I can't wait to see what else the developers will add to this seemingly endless world in future DLCs.
Read original review
Bazinameh86/100 → 86 · Z 0.0297Score 84.3881Score 84.3881Z 0.0297You’ve probably seen those small, quiet restaurants before; places that are out of the way and not too fancy or expensive. They don’t seem very interesting at first glance. But the taste of what they serve stays with you long after, and you can’t get it back.
Some video games make you feel the same way. You don’t expect much from them when you first step inside; maybe something routine or even boring. But if you give it some time, like that meal you’ll never forget, their true charm will start to show. In this review, we’ll look more closely at how Crimson Desert puts a new spin on what modern Zelda-inspired games can be
Read original review
BuffGaming.rs80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4893Score 79.198Score 79.198Z -0.4893Crimson Desert is far more than just another open-world title. Despite some gameplay-related flaws, the game has the potential to leave a lasting impression on players and set new standards within the genre. It’s definitely a game that rewards patience, and one that’s best enjoyed by taking your time with its world and systems.
Read original review
But Why Tho?90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4236Score 88.327Score 88.327Z 0.4236This is a massive undertaking for any development team. It's ambitious to a point that it becomes curious that it was attempted. But unlike Captain Ahab, this is a level of investment and ambition that ultimately pays off in the highest order. The level of detail in Crimson Desert is unlike anything we have seen in this console generation.
Read original review
Capsule Computers90/100 → 90 · Z 0.518Score 89.2709Score 89.2709Z 0.518Crimson Desert offers a sprawling world full of challenges and discovery, even if its rough intro and flat story dampen the journey.
Read original review
CBR90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3817Score 87.9079Score 87.9079Z 0.3817Crimson Desert is everything I hoped it would be, and it has the potential to be one of the biggest titles of this generation of gaming.
Read original review
CGMagazine70/100 → 70 · Z -1.113Score 72.9607Score 72.9607Z -1.113Crimson Desert is an ambitious open-world game that buckles under its own weight, making it a fun but flawed experience that will leave the player base divided.
Read original review
Checkpoint Gaming75/100 → 75 · Z -0.4006Score 80.0854Score 80.0854Z -0.4006Crimson Desert is clearly a labour of love whose developers filled it to the brim. While many central mechanical systems work well, they are accompanied by numerous side systems that never quite earn their place in the wider world of Pywel. There is plenty to enjoy here, but you can’t help shake the feeling that if Pearl Abyss had focused on fewer systems and a more grounded narrative, Crimson Desert could have been truly special.
Read original review
Chicas Gamers80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3671Score 80.4203Score 80.4203Z -0.3671Crimson Desert is a visual titan that borders on Platonic perfection on its surface, but stumbles over its coarse substance and a soulless narrative. With addictive combat and breathtaking photorealism, it invites us to get lost in Pywel despite its clear technical rough edges and the weight of overwhelming hype—accepting that the purest beauty can also be imperfect.
Read original review
Cloud Dosage76/100 → 76 · Z -0.6401Score 77.6906Score 77.6906Z -0.6401Pearl Abyss built something massive with Crimson Desert, and the cracks show alongside the ambition. The visuals are the best I’ve seen in an open world, the combat is one-of-a-kind, and I never ran out of reasons to keep exploring. But the story lets the whole thing down, Kliff is too blank to carry a game this long, and a lot of the side content just doesn’t hold up. It’s worth playing, but go in with your eyes open.
Read original review
COGconnected84/100 → 84 · Z 0.1392Score 85.4835Score 85.4835Z 0.1392Crimson Desert is a remarkable achievement in open world design, with an inexhaustible number of things to see, do, and fight. It's a miracle that it never collapses under its own weight. It isn't perfect. By both accident and design, there are times when clarity and user-friendliness temporarily disappear, and the game's rough edges and opaque mechanics overshadow the fun. A lot of games over-promise and under-deliver. Crimson Desert is not one of them.
Read original review
Combo Infinito80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4601Score 79.4905Score 79.4905Z -0.4601Crimson Desert delivers an ambitious open-world experience with impressive scale, strong visual impact and a combat system that becomes more engaging as it evolves. Exploration is one of its biggest strengths, offering verticality, variety and a sense of discovery that keeps the journey compelling. However, the game struggles with narrative execution, a lack of charismatic characters and several design issues, including inventory management, inconsistent boss fights and performance drops in intense moments. It’s a solid and often impressive adventure, but one that falls short of fully realizing its own potential.
Read original review
ComicBook90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5106Score 89.1971Score 89.1971Z 0.5106Crimson Desert is a game built on impossible ambition, meticulously realized. Its UI frustrations and annoying inventory management are most certainly setbacks from true perfection, but they cannot and do not obscure the brilliance beneath. Even with these flaws, it undoubtedly stands atop the peaks of open-world games, looking down on nearly everything else alongside legends like Elden Ring. It is a triumph of scale and vision; a world that lingers long after the play session ends.
Read original review
Completexbox80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2053Score 82.0381Score 82.0381Z -0.2053Crimson Desert is an ambitious, expansive RPG that rewards curiosity, exploration, and patience.
It doesn’t always hold your hand. It doesn’t lay out every objective in neon signs. Instead, it invites you to think, to explore, and to become truly immersed in a world that feels alive and unpredictable.
Whether you’re uncovering a hidden quest in an abandoned outpost, negotiating with wary factions, or watching the sun set over a candlelit desert city, there’s a constant sense of discovery that keeps you invested.
For players who love deep worlds, layered storytelling, and the freedom to carve their own path, Crimson Desert offers a rewarding experience — rough edges and all.
Crimson Desert is an ambitious journey worth taking — a living world with endless stories to uncover, even if it doesn’t always hold your hand.
Read original review
Console Creatures90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7129Score 91.2204Score 91.2204Z 0.7129Summary
Crimson Desert is one of the most rewarding experiences I've had in years, each moment of frustration giving way to excitement the next. It'll give you as much as you put in, even if that won't be for everyone.
Read original review
Console-Tribe70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0274Score 73.8167Score 73.8167Z -1.0274Crimson Desert is a game of contradictions. It captivates and frustrates, offering a vast world that invites exploration even as its ideas feel held back. It’s “a giant playground,” yes, but one where every attraction seems restrained, never fully realized. Yet something keeps calling you back — above all, its world, “the beautiful frame of a painting,” urging you toward one more path, one more horizon. It has that peculiar charm of imperfect but sincere games: not entirely successful, yet strangely unforgettable. Crimson Desert doesn’t deliver on all its promises, but it leaves a mark. It could have been much more, yet it still manages to hold onto something — not everything, but enough to stay with you. In a landscape full of flawless but forgettable titles, that’s no small thing.
Read original review
Critical Hits45/100 → 45 · Z -3.2076Score 52.0148Score 52.0148Z -3.2076Crimson Desert draws attention for its ambitious open-world adventure proposal, but the experience ultimately falls short of expectations. The game features a confusing narrative, with uninteresting characters and missions that feel like generic MMO tasks. The combat has many mechanics but little depth, with artificial difficulty spikes and unresponsive controls. Even with impressive graphics and a high degree of exploration freedom, issues with art direction, bugs, and design decisions make the game feel vast in content but shallow in quality.
Read original review
CriticLenz85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2517Score 86.608Score 86.608Z 0.2517"Crimson Desert offers a unique world with extensive interactivity, where you can lose yourself in exploration and experience impressive, multi-layered combat. However, even numerous updates haven't brought its weak puzzle design and narrative depth up to a satisfying level.
Read original review
Cubed350/100 → 50 · Z -1.7414Score 66.6775Score 66.6775Z -1.7414The expectations were so high, but fundamentally, Crimson Desert is a beautifully boring mess. If there is no other intention than exploration and looking at the pretty rocks, this will satisfy in spades. However, for anybody easily frustrated by frankly ridiculous controls, busywork, and a main character giving less conversation than a mute Hylian, it is probably worth a miss.
Read original review
Cultura Geek70/100 → 70 · Z -1.3085Score 71.0061Score 71.0061Z -1.3085An ambitious yet uneven open-world action RPG. Crimson Desert stands out for its polished visuals and an exploration system built around discovery and learning. Even so, its slow pacing, steep learning curve, and generic protagonist hold it back. It won’t be for everyone, but it still knows how to reward patience.
Read original review
Daily Mirror60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8321Score 65.7705Score 65.7705Z -1.8321If you hadn’t already guessed, Crimson Desert is a behemoth of an RPG that threatens to eat up all your time. If only it wasn’t primed to frustrate and test your patience as much while doing so.
Read original review
DayOne85/100 → 85 · Z 0.246Score 86.5513Score 86.5513Z 0.246Crimson Desert is an amazing game full of wonder and frustration. I spent 110 hours completing its story and did not see half of the map, including the titular sandy-red expanse. It is an incredible achievement, living up to the promises and hype, while still needing a lot of love to get it into tip-top shape.
Read original review
Destructoid85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1064Score 85.1551Score 85.1551Z 0.1064Crimson Desert features a fantastic, content-rich open world where player freedom is the number one priority. There's so much to do and so many places to go to that it's easy to get lost among its ancient ruins, mystical forests, and snowy mountains. A lack of polish breeds frustration, but nothing can shake up the firm foundations of this incredible title.
Read original review
Dexerto60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9156Score 64.935Score 64.935Z -1.9156Crimson Desert is a good game that could have been great, with an absolutely incredible open-world adventure undercut by poor pacing, a boring story, annoying boss fights, frustrating puzzles, and awkward controls.
Read original review
Digital Chumps90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2834Score 86.9249Score 86.9249Z 0.2834Crimson Desert is a dense, daunting game that rewards players who invest with dedication. It is also a game that has immensely changed at launch and will continue to evolve through the efforts of Pearl Abyss and its community. While certainly flawed, it is a thing of awe.
Read original review
Digital Spy80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5715Score 78.3762Score 78.3762Z -0.5715Crimson Desert's sandbox playground and beautifully crafted world do a lot of the heavy lifting to just about overshadow its confusing elements, generic story, and boring characters. What's here is an overwhelming amount of content and the bones of an amazing game that has to be respected for its ambitions.
Read original review
Digitale Anime90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3382Score 87.4732Score 87.4732Z 0.3382"Game of the Year"
Crimson Desert offers an immersive and ambitious experience for open-world game enthusiasts, combining a complex combat system, free exploration, and interconnected life systems that provide depth and interactivity. Realistic graphics and advanced lighting enhance immersion, while the technical performance is relatively stable. However, the game requires patience and investment to grasp its complexity and overcome its technical and design challenges, making it an excellent experience for dedicated gamers but potentially overwhelming for beginners.
Read original review
Digitec Magazine100/100 → 100 · Z 1.1183Score 95.2741Score 95.2741Z 1.1183If you look up the term ‘open world’ ‘Crimson Desert’ is bound to be listed right next to it. Because you can’t get much more open-world than that. It offers a world in which you can completely lose yourself. What could be better?
Read original review
DualShockers95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8939Score 93.0304Score 93.0304Z 0.8939Crimson Desert combines all the phenomenal aspects of some of the most notable titles of the past decades. It has the sense of discovery like Elden Ring, a deeply engaging and dense world like Skyrim, unpredictable moment-to-moment gameplay like Red Dead Redemption 2, and the exciting exploration and overall feel of the latest Zelda games.
Read original review
Edge Magazine50/100 → 50 · Z -1.9601Score 64.4899Score 64.4899Z -1.9601For players to get more out of this world, Crimson Desert requires a greater sense of purpose - a reason to remain invested in persevering through its most testing moments, to press on for hours in the faith that it will attain some kind of shape. [Issue#423, p.98]
ElDesmarque84/100 → 84 · Z -0.131Score 82.7808Score 82.7808Z -0.131Crimson Desert is a vast and ambitious sandbox that stands out for its living world, deep systems and sense of freedom. At its best, it delivers memorable combat, strong boss encounters and cleverly designed puzzles. However, its MMO-like structure and abundance of routine tasks can disrupt pacing and overwhelm some players. It’s an excellent game overall, but one that demands time, patience and the right mindset to fully appreciate.
Read original review
EmuGlx.org90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4199Score 88.2903Score 88.2903Z 0.4199Crimson Desert is a massive game that pushes the boundaries of open world RPGs a little further, giving players a completely different level of freedom than competing titles. If you find yourself liking its unique style that won't suit everyone, its heavy focus on action and unrestricted adventuring will give you a great place to find hundreds of hours of entertainment.
Read original review
Enternity.gr70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0269Score 73.8225Score 73.8225Z -1.0269What’s most troubling about Crimson Desert is that Pearl Abyss has something truly good at its core, but has gone out of its way to “overload” it with as many features as possible.
Read original review
Entertainment Geekly60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8011Score 66.0798Score 66.0798Z -1.8011Crimson Desert is best for explorers, screenshot hunters, and system tinkerers who can live with rough edges. If you crave a tight story and carefully tuned combat, you will bounce off its excesses.
Read original review
Eurogamer60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5491Score 68.6003Score 68.6003Z -1.5491A vast world and even vaster array of MMO-like activities mix with glittering fidelity in Crimson Desert, but what good is it without much character, texture or charm?
Read original review
Eurogamer Germany100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2032Score 96.1235Score 96.1235Z 1.2032A monumental masterpiece: Despite the bugs, clunky menus, and awkward controls, its magnetic pull is simply impossible to resist.
Read original review
Eurogamer Poland70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9912Score 74.179Score 74.179Z -0.9912Crimson Desert is undoubtedly an original and ambitious game, but at the same time it feels a bit like a soup with too many ingredients thrown in. On one hand, it offers an intriguing world where almost every hour of play can bring something new; on the other, it overwhelms with an excess of mechanics you constantly have to learn, often without much guidance. When you take a closer look at its gameplay systems, you’ll notice plenty of missteps, yet despite them it’s hard to remain indifferent to this game. If you can accept its flaws and invest a good amount of time and attention, you’ll likely get hooked just like I did - discovering an adventure on a scale beyond anything we’ve seen in video games so far.
Read original review
Eurogamer Portugal60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9367Score 64.7246Score 64.7246Z -1.9367Chaotic, frustrating, but undeniably ambitious. Crimson Desert constantly tests our patience with technical problems and a confusing narrative, before letting us enjoy its ambitious combat system, exploration and stunning visuals. A game that demands time and a lot of patience for those who manage to overcome the barrier of its lack of polish.
Read original review
Eurogamer.pt60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7059Score 67.0317Score 67.0317Z -1.7059Chaotic, frustrating, but undeniably ambitious. Crimson Desert constantly tests our patience with technical problems and a confusing narrative, before letting us enjoy its ambitious combat system, exploration and stunning visuals. A game that demands time and a lot of patience for those who manage to overcome the barrier of its lack of polish.
Read original review
EvelonGames79/100 → 79 · Z -0.4248Score 79.8434Score 79.8434Z -0.4248Crimson Desert is a game that knows how to make you feel small and wonder-struck, then immediately trips over itself trying to be everything at once. Pearl Abyss has built a technically impressive open world packed with systems, secrets, and genuine moments of discovery — but buries them under a incoherent story, frustrating boss design, padding that stretches 60 hours of content into 100, and visuals that rely heavily on post-processing to mask surprisingly modest character models and geometry up close.
This is not a misunderstood gem waiting to find its audience. It's a competent, occasionally brilliant, fundamentally overdesigned action RPG from a studio making its first single-player game. The foundation is there. The execution isn't quite.
Read original review
Everyeye.it78/100 → 78 · Z -0.4821Score 79.2697Score 79.2697Z -0.4821We have concluded our adventure on the continent of Pywel: Crimson Desert is a gigantic and unique experience, for better or worse.
Read original review
Everyeye.it78/100 → 78 · Z -0.4688Score 79.4028Score 79.4028Z -0.4688Crimson Desert is certainly neither a masterpiece nor a total disaster; rather, it is the outcome of an evolutionary trajectory with excellent potential—albeit one undermined by a creative direction that compromised part of its final execution. It is a product evidently diminished by the creative metamorphosis it underwent during development, yet one whose immense scope remains palpable thanks to one of the finest implementations of the open-world structure in recent memory, a generous wealth of content, and technical execution of the highest caliber. As it currently stands, we cannot give it top marks; however, there is a concrete possibility that the project's stewards—who have proven surprisingly swift in responding to community feedback—will succeed in resolving many of its most glaring flaws. Should that happen, we could well be looking at a result of an entirely different caliber.
Read original review
Fextralife81/100 → 81 · Z -0.2919Score 81.1718Score 81.1718Z -0.2919Crimson Desert is an 8 out of 10 that could have been a 9 or even a 10 with better controls and less clutter. It's a "wait for sale" or "wait for a 2.0 patch" for a lot of players. If you want to deep dive into a new world and you can ignore some of these flaws, you'll definitely have a fun time. But don't expect it to be a title that reinvents the wheel when it comes to an immersive single-player experience.
Read original review
Forbes95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7381Score 91.4722Score 91.4722Z 0.7381But if the question was if Crimson Desert could really be that big and really play that well and really keep you entertained the whole time, the answer, for me, is unequivocally yes.
Read original review
Game Informer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.7016Score 67.0756Score 67.0756Z -1.7016[Crimson Desert is] a beautiful, exploration-rich open-world game that’s a clear technological achievement, hampered by a cornucopia of little frustrations and a stark lack of narrative depth.
Read original review
Game Rant80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1666Score 82.4256Score 82.4256Z -0.1666Crimson Desert will likely appeal most to players who enjoy getting lost in an incredibly detailed and realistic open world and figuring things out for themselves, even when the game isn't always clear about how everything works. Those who value exploration and long-form progression will find plenty to dig into, especially if they don't mind learning it all through a fair amount of trial and error. On the other hand, players who prefer a more streamlined experience, a stronger narrative focus, or systems that clearly communicate their rules may find the journey more frustrating than rewarding. Even though Crimson Desert initially seemed like a game for everyone, it's not, but it is one that everyone should at least try.
Read original review
Game888/100 → 88 · Z 0.4408Score 88.4992Score 88.4992Z 0.4408Crimson Desert is a sprawling adventure across a vast and living world that rewards every hour you put into it. The core gameplay evolves with your progress, introducing upgradable skills and increasingly demanding boss fights, with plenty of content to discover. While the narrative initially lacks direction and its threads can feel disconnected, this never outweighs the game’s many strengths. Crimson Desert is a slow burn that rewards time, patience, and curiosity.
Read original review
GameBlast75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5562Score 78.5293Score 78.5293Z -0.5562Crimson Desert lives up to its promise, delivering a rich open world with plenty of activities and fun combat. However, the title doesn't reach its peak because it lacks a particularly compelling protagonist and wastes the potential of other playable characters. Furthermore, the project still needs some polishing.
Read original review
Gameblog.fr80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1534Score 82.5573Score 82.5573Z -0.1534Despite its rather delicate first hours, its shortcomings, and the frustrations that the experience can bring, Crimson Desert is undeniably a unique adventure in the video game landscape. Rarely has a game so convincingly blended epic combat, exploration open to experimentation, and life simulation within such a massive yet coherent and addictive medieval fantasy open world. Pearl Abyss's title isn't for everyone and is likely to be divisive, but it will captivate the most dedicated players for hundreds of hours of pure enjoyment as they lose themselves in its breathtaking abundance. It however needs a little polish to truly shine and take its rightful place among the greatest open-world sandbox games of all time.
Read original review
Gamefa60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2115Score 61.9763Score 61.9763Z -2.2115Crimson Desert is arguably one of the most ambitious RPGs of recent years, one that attempts to reach the pinnacle of action RPGs and deliver a massive, diverse, and deep experience.
Read original review
gamefinity80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5032Score 79.0588Score 79.0588Z -0.5032Crimson Desert is a sprawling open-world action RPG that impresses
with its world-building and combat — even if its ambitions
occasionally outpace its execution.
Read original review
GameGrin80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3428Score 80.6634Score 80.6634Z -0.3428Crimson Desert is a game with a lot to offer players, but it gets held back slightly by some odd design choices that can create more of a challenge than they really need to.
Read original review
Gamekult50/100 → 50 · Z -2.221Score 61.8808Score 61.8808Z -2.221Crimson Desert is the absolute definition of a massive disappointment. It’s a Ferrari body with a lawnmower engine under the hood. Pearl Abyss tried to please everyone and ended up pleasing no one: Elden Ring fans will be driven mad by the clunky combat, Witcher fans will be bored to tears by the lack of depth, those looking for a world as organic as Breath of the Wild are in for a rude awakening, and the general public will struggle with the abysmal UI and unwarranted difficulty spikes. Riddled with technical issues unacceptable for a blockbuster of this scale, and weighed down by dated writing, Crimson Desert is on the verge of a total systemic failure. The hype train has well and truly derailed. See you in a year, after 150 patches and a mountain of DLC, which, of course, are already in the works.
Read original review
Gameliner100/100 → 100 · Z 1.349Score 97.5811Score 97.5811Z 1.349Pearl Abyss delivers a dynamic and visually stunning open world that feels alive and full of discovery. There’s plenty to do, and the game expects you to explore on your own, with challenging puzzles, memorable bosses and little handholding. The many systems and mechanics can take time to master, but are very rewarding. While the story takes a backseat and is told through lore, it is still a tale you don't want to miss. Strong performance and a great soundtrack round out this must-play experience.
Read original review
GameMAG80/100 → 80 · Z 0.066Score 84.7512Score 84.7512Z 0.066Crimson Desert is unlikely to become a revolution that will redefine the genre. But it will certainly attract crowds of people and spark more than a few heated debates. It's funny that the very desert featured in the title is just one of many corners of the vast world created by Pearl Abyss — one that, presumably, far from everyone will reach.
Read original review
GameOver.gr80/100 → 80 · Z -0.23Score 81.7907Score 81.7907Z -0.23Crimson Desert is an enormously ambitious game, both figuratively and in scope. We’ve rarely seen a single-player experience this large, in terms of content and mechanical variety. Even 100 hours in, we’re still discovering new areas, traversal methods, and bosses. However, it also proves that no matter how high the quality of the content (at least in a single-player game) diminishing returns eventually set in. In the end, a mediocre story does little to support the experience, and the initial excitement gradually gives way to a dull sense of routine.
Read original review
GamePro89/100 → 89 · Z 0.0132Score 84.2229Score 84.2229Z 0.0132Even in its current state, Crimson Desert has the potential to become my game of the year. If the console performance is still good and the day-one patch perhaps even fixes a few annoying issues, the action-adventure could even climb a small step higher in my ranking.
Read original review
Gamer Guides50/100 → 50 · Z -2.9657Score 54.4338Score 54.4338Z -2.9657Combat is flashy, but unresponsive. The open world is vast, but soulless. The NPCs are legion, but uninspired. The puzzles are complex, but frustrating. Systems are convoluted, but not deep. And the patches keep making the game more and more generic. The bottom line is that Crimson Desert demands at least 100 hours of your life, and it cannot justify that ask with a rewarding experience.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club80/100 → 80 · Z -0.309Score 81.0007Score 81.0007Z -0.309Often feeling like a game chasing greatness, Crimson Desert is in every sense of the word ambitious. Sure, Kliff’s story of revenge is one that been told a thousand times, but it’s seemingly endless open world begs you to chase the adventures beyond the horizon. When you tie this beautifully crafted playground together with a combat system that encourages the player to experiment and think outside the box, you get a game that feels impossibly complex while feeling eerily familiar in the same breath. Crimson Desert is many things – dangerously ambitious, clunky, beautiful, messy, and most importantly: mind-numbingly addictive.
Read original review
Gamer.no80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0599Score 83.4923Score 83.4923Z -0.0599Crimson Desert is a highly ambitious open-world game. It is absolutely beautiful, packed with discovery, puzzles and combat. It doesn't always deliver on all its potential, and bugs are to be found, but in the end it is unique, mesmerizing and addicting.
Read original review
GameRant80/100 → 80 · Z -0.122Score 82.8713Score 82.8713Z -0.122Crimson Desert offers one of the most impressive worlds in gaming, but the deeper you go, the more it asks you to meet it on its own terms.
Read original review
Gamereactor UK80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0297Score 84.3878Score 84.3878Z 0.0297Crimson Desert can be a place where you can lose yourself for months as a player, but don't expect all those hours to be spent on an enriching adventure in a world that, I repeat, is wonderful. I can overlook certain technical issues given the scale of the project and because they may be fixed with a patch, but there are simply too many design conflicts across all the systems operating simultaneously for me to call it a 'masterpiece'. If you can simply live with that and enjoy the journey, even without necessarily understanding where it leads, then this open world is worth a try.
Read original review
GamerFocus88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4329Score 88.4203Score 88.4203Z 0.4329Crimson Desert doesn't always know exactly what it wants to be, but it's very clear about what it wants to offer. Between accumulating systems, intersecting stories, and a world that constantly beckons exploration, the story feels more like a journey through Pywell. Its greatest strength may lie not in what it tells, but in everything that happens along the way.
Read original review
Gamers Heroes100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3342Score 97.4328Score 97.4328Z 1.3342Dark Souls has often been used to measure one's gaming prowess, but that measuring stick has changed with Crimson Desert. Not only does it boast some of the most challenging boss battles ever seen in the industry, its required levels of patience, determination, and ability have set a new gold standard.
Read original review
GamersGlobal60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0668Score 63.4227Score 63.4227Z -2.0668If you can ignore a bad story and lacking quests with a "the more the better" approach, but enjoy turning every stone in a world in search of loot, you will have fun with Crimson Desert. But while a really like good games with friction in the design, even after 20 hours this game manges to grind my gears all too often and of all the many, many things I could potentially do in Pywell, there are too few worthwhile to make me stick around for much longer.
Read original review
Gamersky86/100 → 86 · Z 0.0993Score 85.0839Score 85.0839Z 0.0993Crimson Desert feels like a single player version of an MMORPG that has been live for years. Its sheer scale alone is enough to guarantee hundreds of hours of playtime. But with its weak guidance, cumbersome interactions, and many design choices that show little regard for user experience, whether that time feels enjoyable or exhausting will likely vary from player to player.
Read original review
GAMES.CH80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4999Score 79.0922Score 79.0922Z -0.4999Crimson Desert is a beautiful and technologically impressive collection of various gameplay and simulation ideas that struggle to find together into a cohesive whole. Over dozens of hours the game meanders, only to hit you with a moment where every obtuse element suddenly clicks together, offering a truly groundbreaking experience. Though immediately after you're tasked with something so odd, such as cleaning chimneys that you can't help but wonder if this is all an elaborate social experiment.
Read original review
Games.cz70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0267Score 73.8246Score 73.8246Z -1.0267A massive game with a beautiful, engaging, and highly interactive world that is a joy to explore. It impresses with sheer content, compelling puzzles, numerous systems, and dynamic combat. However, weak boss fights, a bland story, uninspired quests, and clunky controls and UI leave noticeable blemishes on the overall experience.
Read original review
GamesCreed80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3126Score 80.9647Score 80.9647Z -0.3126Crimson Desert has some of the most stacked and immersive content you will see in a video game – in the modern era, anyway. Despite the updates, the game still has many glaring positives; however, it has just as many glaring negatives. Having said that, this game is a highly enjoyable sandbox experience, and, as mentioned earlier, I will continue playing because it has countless things to offer.
Read original review
GamesNight90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7627Score 91.7181Score 91.7181Z 0.7627Crimson Desert is a once-in-a-generation video game. Its expansive open world is breathtaking and one I can get lost in for days thanks to its beautiful visuals, enchanting music and in-depth, meaningful gameplay systems. It’s not perfect, with some obtuse design choices, an underwhelming story and a very slow opening. But the more you peel back each layer of Crimson Desert, it all begins to click, and you realize this is truly a fantastic achievement in video game design.
Read original review
GameSpot70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0678Score 73.4129Score 73.4129Z -1.0678Crimson Desert is a frequently thrilling game, elevated by an open world well worth exploring and hard-hitting combat that delights with its depth and emphasis on player expression. It might not always be the most cohesive game, mixing high fantasy with steampunk and sci-fi elements, but there's nothing else quite like it, and I can't help but be impressed by how little restraint Pearl Abyss has shown in its commitment to delightful absurdity. In some respects, Crimson Desert might not be too good to be true, but it's a world worth getting lost in.
Read original review
GamesRadar+80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3691Score 80.4005Score 80.4005Z -0.3691Crimson Desert is messy, but as you untangle its mechanics and compensate for its flaws, elements of genius and wonder make the experience worthwhile. Take time to leave the beaten path and find out which of its many facets appeals to you, and you'll discover a game that's far better as a sandbox than as a story.
Read original review
GameStar82/100 → 82 · Z -0.0622Score 83.4692Score 83.4692Z -0.0622Gigantic open-world game with spectacular battles that is held back by a lack of player guidance and accessibility.
Read original review
Gamesurf90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8243Score 92.3342Score 92.3342Z 0.8243If your concern is that the game wasn't final yet, that's correct — there's a mountain of things still to be polished; but if you think it doesn't work or that it isn't fun, then no, I can assure you that you could spend your whole life in it listening to stories, admiring landscapes, discovering secrets, riding, saving... and even greeting people (yes, that matters too), because everyday life has never been so enjoyable, even in the small things, and the adventures that await you are truly memorable.
Read original review
Gaming Boulevard80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3043Score 81.0477Score 81.0477Z -0.3043Crimson Desert is an ambitious and visually impressive
sandbox that excels in delivering exciting combat, player freedom, and a
richly interactive, immersive world. Its bold vision and emphasis on
exploration and player choice stand out as its greatest strengths,
offering a unique and experimental experience with countless ways to
approach the world. However, clunky mechanics, sometimes overwhelming
systems, and a weaker narrative hold it back from greatness. While it
may not satisfy those seeking a deep RPG or story-driven experience, it
remains a rewarding adventure for players who highly value freedom and
immersion, even if it won’t appeal to everyone.
Read original review
GAMINGbible80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2909Score 81.1816Score 81.1816Z -0.2909Crimson Desert is by no means a perfect game. It’s an amalgamation of perhaps slightly too many ideas, and that makes for a weirdly paced experience that demands a lot of the player without offering much in the way of help. And yet, it left me in awe more times than anything else I’ve played in recent memory with its dazzling open-world. Crimson Desert may not be the best game you'll ever play, but it’ll certainly be up there as perhaps the most memorable.
Read original review
GamingBolt80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1518Score 82.5732Score 82.5732Z -0.1518Crimson Desert is as expansive as promised, dwarfing pretty much every other open world currently with its scale. Its content doesn't always stick the landing, but the combat shines, and the sense of discovery is hard to deny, even with the lackluster story.
Read original review
GamingTrend95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7691Score 91.7817Score 91.7817Z 0.7691This is a once-in-a-generation action RPG that redefines the genre, providing hundreds of hours of incredibly varied gameplay that never stops giving you new things to do. There are a handful of bugs to hammer out, but don't let that dissuade you — you're looking at your likely RPG of the year.
Read original review
Geeks &a; Com80/100 → 80 · Z -0.373Score 80.3608Score 80.3608Z -0.373This game has been polarizing from the very beginning. Some will love it for specific reasons: its length (easily around 120 hours), the numerous and varied quests, and the engaging and fun combat. Others, however, will find the game sorely lacking in inspiration when it comes to its story. The truth lies somewhere in between. Crimson Desert offers plenty of enjoyment for those who like to engage in various activities at their own pace. But if you’re looking for a deep story where you’ll grow attached to the characters and people you meet along the way, you couldn’t be further from it. So you have to take the game for what it is: an adventure RPG that stands out without being the blockbuster everyone was expecting. And that’s perfectly fine.
Read original review
Generación Xbox94/100 → 94 · Z 0.9918Score 94.0088Score 94.0088Z 0.9918Crimson Desert is an RPG that rewards the patient player. The more time you spend in its world, the more you understand its systems and the more you enjoy what it has to offer. And when that happens, it becomes very easy to get swept away by the adventure and immerse yourself in the work that Pearl Abyss has created for us over so many years.
Read original review
Generación Xbox94/100 → 94 · Z 0.7976Score 92.0675Score 92.0675Z 0.7976Crimson Desert delivers an ambitious open-world RPG with stunning visuals and a deep combat system that becomes increasingly rewarding over time. Played on PC with high-end hardware, the game showcases impressive environments and a highly customizable graphics setup.
Read original review
Gfinity80/100 → 80 · Z -0.365Score 80.4412Score 80.4412Z -0.365Crimson Desert is an ambitious open-world epic that succeeds through its dense, rewarding exploration and weighted combat, even while stumbling over a generic story and a flat protagonist. While unintuitive controls and momentum-killing puzzles can cause occasional frustration, the sheer scale of Pywel and its deep progression systems offer a level of discovery unlike anything seen before it. Ultimately, the game’s narrative shortcomings are overshadowed by its immense depth and breathtaking world, making it a flawed but deeply memorable adventure.
Read original review
GRYOnline.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3389Score 80.7024Score 80.7024Z -0.3389After all these hours in Crimson Desert, it feels like the charm of this world is so powerful that, despite everything, it’s hard not to be drawn in. Poorly designed quests, a shallow storyline and various shortcomings don’t really bother you that much when weighed against the sheer ocean of possibilities the game offers. Crimson Desert is a game that is difficult to judge conclusively – it has plenty of strengths, many flaws, yet it is definitely not a game you can simply ignore.
Read original review
GRYOnline.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3101Score 80.9898Score 80.9898Z -0.3101After all these hours in Crimson Desert, it feels like the charm of this world is so powerful that, despite everything, it’s hard not to be drawn in. Poorly designed quests, a shallow storyline and various shortcomings don’t really bother you that much when weighed against the sheer ocean of possibilities the game offers. Crimson Desert is a game that is difficult to judge conclusively – it has plenty of strengths, many flaws, yet it is definitely not a game you can simply ignore.
Read original review
Hardcore Gamer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.678Score 90.8714Score 90.8714Z 0.678Crimson Desert is one of a kind. It’s a spectacular adventure that has a phenomenally crafted open world to explore and an immense number of systems at play.
Read original review
HardZone93/100 → 93 · Z 0.7577Score 91.6677Score 91.6677Z 0.7577Crimson Desert is an ambitious open-world RPG that successfully blends fast-paced combat, deep gameplay systems, and a vast, living world into one cohesive experience. Despite a sometimes confusing narrative and a few frustrating encounters, its depth, technical performance, and sheer amount of content make it one of the most impressive releases of the year, and a strong contender for Game of the Year.
Read original review
HCL.hr80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1664Score 82.4273Score 82.4273Z -0.1664Crimson Desert offers one of the most impressive open worlds of this generation and stunning combat that rewards creativity. However, a bland protagonist and shallow story reveal that Pearl Abyss is still learning to walk outside MMO territory.
Read original review
Het Nieuwsblad60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6258Score 67.8327Score 67.8327Z -1.6258The balance, in particular, isn’t quite right yet. We certainly applaud the fact that the game doesn’t hold your hand, but the contrast is quite stark. In some missions, everything is so broken down and spoon-fed to you that the game guides you through every step like a toddler. And at other times, you have absolutely no idea—and absolutely no explanation—of what you’re supposed to do. The lack of narrative and coherence is clearly a shortcoming. Despite all its flaws, there’s definitely the potential for a fantastic game here. It never becomes as emotionally compelling as Arthur Morgan’s story in Red Dead Redemption 2, and it lacks that childlike wonder of Breath of the Wild, but it all looks great and the massive amount of content makes up for a lot. Crimson Desert is a rough diamond that still needs a good polish. In its current form, it’s an okay game with obvious limitations. With enough post-launch support, it might still achieve what it sets out to do: become one of the better games of the year.
Read original review
Hey Poor Player50/100 → 50 · Z -2.9839Score 54.2526Score 54.2526Z -2.9839I admire Pearl Abyss’ quick response to some of Crimson Desert’s issues, and I think there’s a real chance that it will eventually feel decent to play. At the moment, though, it simply doesn’t, and even with updates, I have my doubts that it will ever give me a world that’s engaging for anything more than its impressive visuals. There’s a lot to do in Crimson Desert, but so little that I actually wanted to do.
Read original review
Hobby Consolas80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6599Score 77.4924Score 77.4924Z -0.6599Crimson Desert is a great game hampered by a series of frustrating design choices and MMO-style gameplay. With time and numerous updates, it might just reach the top of the genre; it certainly has the potential and ambition to do so. But right now, it takes immense patience to uncover the hidden gem buried beneath the desert sands.
Read original review
Hooked Gamers84/100 → 84 · Z -0.0096Score 83.9955Score 83.9955Z -0.0096In all Crimson Desert is a fun experience, with engaging combat, a gigantic world to explore, and a ton of side activities that can keep a player playing for hours and hours on end. There are some issues like long loading times, janky camera angles, and a story that struggles to get its footing. If a gamer enjoys Action RPGs, then Crimson Desert very well might be on the list of games to check out, ready to pour ages into exploring, fighting, and finding things to do.
Read original review
IGN60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9316Score 64.7753Score 64.7753Z -1.9316Crimson Desert is an extremely ambitious open-world adventure, and that ambition is what makes it both incredibly cool and gobsmackingly infuriating in almost equal measure. I had some memorable times exploring this gorgeous world, discovering weird minigames and killing bandits along the way. But those memories were also marred by moments I’d rather forget, like the tedious combat encounters, unintuitive puzzles, awful story, and substantial bugs. There’s lots to love about this quirky, kitchen sink design, and I admire that it’s managed to pack a metric ton of unique mechanics and interesting areas into one package. But it takes work to dig your way through the thick layer of gunk that covers it all, and the mostly competent action-adventure game that’s buried beneath is only sometimes worth that effort.
Read original review
IGN Adria80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3363Score 80.7285Score 80.7285Z -0.3363Crimson Desert is a visually impressive and highly ambitious open-world RPG with thrilling, adrenaline-fueled combat. While its complexity can occasionally feel more like a drawback than a strength, for fans of RPGs and open-world games, this is a title that always has something more to offer.
Read original review
IGN Benelux85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1285Score 85.376Score 85.376Z 0.1285Crimson Desert is an excellent game with an engaging open world, highly challenging boss fights, and mind-bending puzzles. The game is certainly not perfect, but Pearl Abyss' willingness to listen to feedback gives me hope that Crimson Desert will only continue to improve in the future on what is already a strong foundation.
Read original review
IGN Brasil85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0775Score 83.3159Score 83.3159Z -0.0775Crimson Desert offers a well-rounded experience, even if it has a few stumbles along the way. Its campaign leaves something to be desired, but the game more than makes up for it with a vibrant, detail-rich world. Its excellent combat, combined with stunning visuals and a powerful soundtrack, makes the battles fun and epic, but it was in its open world that I found the game’s greatest appeal and standout feature.
Read original review
IGN Deutschland60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8418Score 65.6732Score 65.6732Z -1.8418Crimson Desert is an entertaining open-world action RPG that offers a unique gameplay experience and, thanks to its vast scale, keeps you occupied for a long time, but fails to truly impress in almost every respect. In this case, less would have been more.
Read original review
IGN France80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1869Score 82.2223Score 82.2223Z -0.1869Although there are still a few areas that could use some tweaking —particularly in terms of ergonomics— Crimson Desert manages to live up to the hype. It’s not perfect, but the authenticity of its world, the richness of its content, and its engaging gameplay make it a standout title for the start of 2026. Pearl Abyss has a diamond that’s still a bit rough around the edges, but with a little polish, it’ll be nothing short of divine.
Read original review
IGN India80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3948Score 80.1433Score 80.1433Z -0.3948The world design and combat of Crimson Desert are a resounding win for fans of free-form exploration, but the bland story and the tedious flow of Crimson Desert stop it from becoming the true masterpiece it could have been.
Read original review
IGN Italia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2392Score 86.4836Score 86.4836Z 0.2392An ambitious adventure set in a visually stunning world that tries to do a bit too much, ultimately feeling underdeveloped in some respects.
Read original review
IGN Italy85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2829Score 86.9206Score 86.9206Z 0.2829An ambitious adventure set in a visually stunning world that tries to do a bit too much, ultimately feeling underdeveloped in some respects.
Read original review
IGN Japan80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4837Score 79.2542Score 79.2542Z -0.4837Crimson Desert is an open-world adventure game that boasts stunning visuals and an enormous amount of content. From challenging combat and puzzles to slower-paced activities such as trading and animal husbandry, it offers a wide variety of ways to play. That said, the game falls short in its storytelling, and some inconvenient systems leave it missing the mark in many respects, making it hard to call it universally accessible. Still, for those looking to embark on a complex, anything-but-straightforward ambitious journey, it’s a game well worth experiencing.
Read original review
IGN Portugal80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5678Score 78.4136Score 78.4136Z -0.5678Crimson Desert is an ambitious game that tries to be (almost) everything at once, only to ultimately buckle under the weight of its own complexity. Although its story is disjointed and uninteresting, the game is ultimately saved by a complex and almost always entertaining combat system, which rewards us as we master it better. Added to this is an overwhelming and visually stunning world, which only needed a bit more narrative coherence to become memorable.
Read original review
IGN Spain70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2719Score 71.3726Score 71.3726Z -1.2719Crimson Desert offers a vast and visually stunning open world, full of freedom and exploration, but its simplistic story and unclear objectives may frustrate many players.
Read original review
IGN Turkey80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1419Score 82.6724Score 82.6724Z -0.1419Crimson Desert is a technically impressive game with a stunning world; it’s a joy to play and offers a content-rich experience. However, the effort to bring so many systems together has, at times, led to confusion and control issues.
Read original review
Impulsegamer82/100 → 82 · Z -0.272Score 81.371Score 81.371Z -0.272Though the devs aimed for quantity and size rather than quality and coherence, exploring the hidden corners of Pywel to engage in different side-quests and activities is a thirst that will keep any fan of fantasy action games entertained for tens if not hundreds of hours.
Read original review
INDIANTVCZ60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6535Score 67.5566Score 67.5566Z -1.6535Crimson Desert is an incredible showcase of technological triumph, but also a cautionary tale of how ambition without experience leads to a painful fall. Pearl Abyss bit off more than they could chew. The result teeters on the line between a hollow MMORPG and an amazing world that's a joy to explore but difficult to live in. Every ingenious mechanic is followed by a frustrating and illogical decision that brings the experience crashing down. The result is a massive, entertaining, and technically brilliant title that lacks the legendary soul needed to become a legend that will survive for decades.
Read original review
INFINITY AREA45/100 → 45 · Z -2.9273Score 54.8186Score 54.8186Z -2.9273Crimson Desert is exactly the kind of game that will divide players. Some will see it as a massive, ambitious adventure, while others will view it as an enormous patchwork of ideas borrowed from better franchises, without ever truly understanding what made them work in the first place. Unfortunately, the formula doesn’t come together here. The exploration feels reminiscent of Zelda without delivering the same sense of enjoyment, the protagonist tries to emulate Geralt without the charisma or strong writing, the combat aims for epic scale without ever reaching the heights of Horizon, and the story constantly chases the emotional depth of God of War without ever coming close.
Read original review
Insider Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9695Score 74.3962Score 74.3962Z -0.9695Crimson Desert is a game of extremes. At its best, it offers a breathtaking world filled with meaningful exploration, impressive scale, and genuinely thrilling battles. However, that brilliance is occasionally weighed down by an overabundance of unfocused systems, a weak narrative, and combat that struggles to maintain consistency.
Read original review
INVEN83/100 → 83 · Z -0.2238Score 81.8536Score 81.8536Z -0.2238Crimson Desert unfolds in a vast open world filled with an enormous amount of content, but there are simply too many gameplay elements scattered without order, clashing with one another. There is room for improvement, but as it stands now, it falls somewhat short of being a truly great game.
Read original review
Invision Community80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1926Score 82.1655Score 82.1655Z -0.1926Crimson Desert isn’t a tidy, ultra-focused RPG. It’s rough around the edges, chaotic by design, and absolutely full of ambition.
That ambition can feel overwhelming at times, and some systems like camera control or story pacing could use refinement.
But when everything clicks — traversal, combat, world exploration, base building, and character play — Crimson Desert delivers moments that feel genuinely next gen rather than just big.
Read original review
JeuxActu95/100 → 95 · Z 1.2287Score 96.3783Score 96.3783Z 1.2287After spending over 110 hours in Pywel, there’s really no debate: Crimson Desert absolutely delivers on its promise of a massive open world. Pearl Abyss has built something huge and alive, with a real sense of freedom. You’re not constantly being guided, you have to observe, experiment, get lost and that’s honestly where the game shines. Content-wise, it’s massive. You’re looking at around 120 to 140 hours just for the main story, and easily up to 400 if you want to see everything. The combat system is also a big highlight, it’s deep, fast-paced, and pretty demanding, with tons of options. Every fight requires focus, but that’s exactly what makes it so satisfying. Visually, the game looks incredible, with a world that feels immersive and believable. That said, it’s not perfect: the difficulty can be pretty unforgiving, it takes time to really get comfortable with the controls, and the story doesn’t always hit as hard as it should. In the end, Crimson Desert is a huge game. Ambitious, sometimes tough, definitely not for everyone, but if you’re willing to fully invest yourself in it, it’s a pretty amazing experience.
Read original review
Jeuxvideo.com75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6342Score 77.7494Score 77.7494Z -0.6342It is impossible to fault Crimson Desert for the sheer generosity it displays. Yet, by pushing this dial too far, Pearl Abyss finds itself ensnared by its own ambitions. The result is a stark disconnect between the technical and immersive qualities of its world and the actual content within it. The storyline leaves one feeling almost entirely indifferent; quests follow one another, largely indistinguishable in their structure; and boss battles—at times approachable, at others absurdly difficult—often force us to repeat the same routine ad nauseam. Fortunately, the gameplay—despite its minor flaws—constantly evolves, infusing the adventure with a cathartic, stress-relieving energy—something absolutely essential to help digest the puzzles devised by the development team. Inconsistent—much like the rest of the game—these puzzles nevertheless have the merit of bringing players together and fostering a genuine sense of community engagement. Add to this an astronomical amount of content—enough to make any completionist’s eyes light up—and you end up with a title that will keep your mind occupied for hundreds of hours. Yes, the journey is enjoyable, exotic, and even stimulating from time to time; yet, Crimson Desert ultimately lacked the structural fortitude to support the lofty pedestal upon which it was placed.
Read original review
Jump Dash Roll50/100 → 50 · Z -2.4061Score 60.0304Score 60.0304Z -2.4061A technical achievement that proves you can build everything - and still have nothing to say.
Read original review
Just Play it70/100 → 70 · Z -1.547Score 68.6214Score 68.6214Z -1.547Crimson Desert delivered an ambitious experience that attempts to combine multiple genres into a single package, but it doesn’t fully succeed in mastering any of them as it should. While it does offer enjoyable moments in combat and exploration, issues with controls, a weak narrative, and an overall lack of cohesive design make the experience feel like it lacks a distinct identity. Therefore, if you’re looking for a polished and well-rounded experience, Crimson Desert may not be the best choice at the moment.
Read original review
Kakuchopurei70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9242Score 74.8496Score 74.8496Z -0.9242I think of Crimson Desert as an unrefined-but-still-promising The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild successor, but with a lot more Rockstar-design-level shenanigans in play. You have to give Pearl Abyss huge credit for somewhat succeeding in that action-adventure role-playing game design front, as well as listening to the community while implementing important changes for its long-term health. Crimson Desert's going places, but for now it's in quite a half-baked-but-still-entertaining state.
Read original review
KeenGamer95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9403Score 93.494Score 93.494Z 0.9403Crimson Desert is one of the most expansive RPGs I have played. It is a bold open-world experience with rich lore, atmospheric immersion, and dynamic gameplay. Despite the vastness of the world that overshadows the whole story and narrative, it still grips you and keeps you engaged with pursuing new mysteries. It is an addictive game, especially due to its scale. I am still finding new things to this date, and every time I feel amazed. One of the great reasons that I recommend this game to every RPG enjoyer is the care from the Devs. The devs are still hard at work pushing out patches and working on further improvements and features requested by the players.
Read original review
KonsoliFIN60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4387Score 69.7038Score 69.7038Z -1.4387As an open world game Crimson Desert feels like next gen, but lame story telling makes it feel quite hollow.
Read original review
LevelUp90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4357Score 88.4478Score 88.4478Z 0.4357Crimson Desert is one of the most ambitious games in a long time. It’s an expansive, and deeply detailed fantasy world that constantly invites exploration and rewards curiosity. Its fluid, skill-based combat and sheer scale are genuinely impressive, but that same ambition often works against it. A lack of focus, overly complex systems, and a slow, demanding progression can make the experience feel overwhelming and, at times, exhausting. It’s a game of extremes: deeply immersive and rewarding for those willing to invest the time, but far from accessible for everyone.
Read original review
Life is Xbox65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3722Score 70.3692Score 70.3692Z -1.3722A gorgeous, punishing adventure weighed down by bugs, lighting woes, and a story that never quite keeps up.
Crimson Desert, despite its issues, proves to be a very capable RPG/soulslike game that offers a ton of interactivity in what appears to be a compelling, living and breathing world. Those who are veterans of the souls-like genre will likely feel overwhelmed here with its staggering 168 missions just inside the main story alone. It may feel like a copy-paste of Game of Thrones at times, but for the most part, its diverse portfolio of characters delivers a somewhat fun and engaging gameplay experience, enriched by its epic boss fights and jaw-dropping daylight scenery. Crimson Desert offers a lot of content that will keep you busy for weeks long after the main story has drawn to a close.
Read original review
Loot Level Chill90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3786Score 87.8772Score 87.8772Z 0.3786Crimson Desert is frustrating and buggy and can be very player-unfriendly, but it's also beautiful, deep, seemingly endless and monumentally, perhaps detrimentally, ambitious.
Read original review
Malditos Nerds80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5348Score 78.7436Score 78.7436Z -0.5348Crimson Desert isn't a game for everyone. Despite its flaws and complex systems, it's a fascinating game that has a lot to offer—though it does test your patience.
Read original review
Manual dos Games73/100 → 73 · Z -1.3875Score 70.2158Score 70.2158Z -1.3875Crimson Desert is a rough diamond of colossal ambition. Pearl Abyss stumbles in its delivery of a convoluted story, graphical optimization issues, and an excess of unexplained systems, but at the same time, the title makes up for its shortcomings by delivering one of the densest, most alive, and most rewarding open worlds of the current generation. For those with the patience to master its punishing learning curve, the reward is an absolutely unforgettable journey.
Read original review
Meristation75/100 → 75 · Z -1.0885Score 73.2058Score 73.2058Z -1.0885Crimson Desert could be an amazing game in a hypothetical sequel, but right now fails in its own ambition despite its amazing sense of adventure.
Read original review
Merlin'in Kazanı85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0042Score 84.1336Score 84.1336Z 0.0042Crimson Desert, while offering a truly exceptional offline MMORPG experience, falls slightly short of expectations due to some minor shortcomings.
Read original review
Merlin'in Kazanı (Turkey)85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1288Score 85.3787Score 85.3787Z 0.1288Crimson Desert, while offering a truly exceptional offline MMORPG experience, falls slightly short of expectations due to some minor shortcomings.
Read original review
Metacritic Users87/100 → 87 · Z 0.4563Score 88.6546Score 88.6546Z 0.4563Metacritic user score 8.7/10 (14172 ratings).
Metro GameCentral60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2051Score 72.0404Score 72.0404Z -1.2051A bizarre mishmash of disparate gameplay elements, with absolutely no sense of coherent design or narrative… and yet its stunning game world is still a fascinating mess to explore.
Read original review
MeuPlayStation85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0212Score 83.8788Score 83.8788Z -0.0212An ambitious and content-rich open-world adventure, Crimson Desert stands out for its freedom, deep exploration, and dozens of hours of gameplay, but suffers from a weak narrative, underdeveloped characters, and inconsistencies in some mechanics and technical aspects.
Read original review
MGG65/100 → 65 · Z -1.8314Score 65.7769Score 65.7769Z -1.8314Crimson Desert’s best moments come when you think about the game it could have been, were it not for its overabundance of clunky mechanics and its painfully sluggish controls. Riddled with glitches and systems that don’t work, Pearl Abyss’s first single-player game can rely on its sublime open world, or its core management system borrowed from BDO, to occasionally lift us out of our frustration.
Read original review
MMORPG.com90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5874Score 89.9647Score 89.9647Z 0.5874I can confidently say that Crimson Desert is a modern masterpiece, despite its shortcomings.
Read original review
MMORPG.com90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5786Score 89.8768Score 89.8768Z 0.5786Yet, as I sit here writing this review, I can’t help but be awed by what Pearl Abyss has built. It is a game that will push forward open-world design much like the games it was inspired by did in their day. Its combat will be the benchmark for many players moving forward, and its visuals are among the best on PC to date, full stop. I can confidently say that Crimson Desert is a modern masterpiece, despite its shortcomings.
Read original review
MondoXbox80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4863Score 79.2282Score 79.2282Z -0.4863Crimson Desert is a massive and ambitious project defined by its extremes: it presents itself as a vast open-world game that incorporates the greatest modern gaming achievements, yet it suffers from a fragmented identity, shoddy storytelling, and an overwhelming abundance of content that stifles its original spirit. Nevertheless, it’s an adventure that’s well worth your attention, poised to improve steadily through dedicated post-launch support.
Read original review
Multiplayer.it70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1404Score 72.6875Score 72.6875Z -1.1404Crimson Desert is not a game that leaves you indifferent. It’s certainly not a masterpiece of the genre, nor is it a complete disaster. It shows as much potential as it does flaws. The game doesn’t set any new standards, but those who were expecting a grand, long-lasting adventure can set off for Pywel confident they’ll find what they’re looking for.
Read original review
Nexus Hub80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5077Score 79.0145Score 79.0145Z -0.5077Crimson Desert backseats the quality of its story and writing, yet it succeeds on its engaging exploration, outstanding technical prowess and an overabundance of content and activities.
Read original review
NME60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2789Score 71.3025Score 71.3025Z -1.2789There’s no denying that Crimson Desert is a massively ambitious game. Bringing together the most inventive parts of Breath Of The Wild, The Witcher, Elden Ring and a dozen more fantasy games means you can still be surprised after sinking hundreds of hours into exploring the beautiful, varied land of Pailune. However, trying to cram so many different mechanics into a game that also offers players total freedom means it often feels a bit hollow.
Read original review
NoobFeed55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2215Score 61.876Score 61.876Z -2.2215Crimson Desert is one of the most interestingly different games one would have played in a long time. There are times when it's grand without always being graceful, kind without always being thoughtful, and so full that respect and tiredness start to go together. The game sometimes feels like an exciting next step for fantasy action games.
Read original review
One More Game75/100 → 75 · Z -1.3887Score 70.2046Score 70.2046Z -1.3887At this point in time, especially when Pearl Abyss is deeply dedicated to patching the game, Crimson Desert might be the perfect definition for a “Wait for it…” title. Given the developers’ update pace, it’s only a matter of time before the game realizes its potential.
That said, it isn’t for everybody, but those who can power through the opening segments will be rewarded with an experience chock-full of systems and activities, far more than what others can normally offer. Crimson Desert is packed to the brim, and that may even be an understatement, and it simply will not respect your time (in a good way) because you’ll find yourself wanting to explore every nook and cranny in a world full of possibilities.
Read original review
Oyungezer85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2412Score 86.5028Score 86.5028Z 0.2412Unable to decide what it wants to be and trying to cram everything together, Crimson Desert may not be a game that appeals to everyone, but it’s an adventure absolutely worth trying. Its story isn’t deep, but it offers a world where you can fully indulge your desire to explore different places across its massive map.
Read original review
Oyungezer Online85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2102Score 86.1936Score 86.1936Z 0.2102Unable to decide what it wants to be and trying to cram everything together, Crimson Desert may not be a game that appeals to everyone, but it’s an adventure absolutely worth trying. Its story isn’t deep, but it offers a world where you can fully indulge your desire to explore different places across its massive map.
Read original review
PC Gamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1274Score 82.817Score 82.817Z -0.1274Vast and obtuse in a way that is going to frustrate some and exhilarate others, Crimson Desert is a fascinating journey, even when the destination isn't all that.
Read original review
PC Games75/100 → 75 · Z -0.9457Score 74.6346Score 74.6346Z -0.9457Crimson Desert juggles an insane number of game elements—and some of them inevitably hit the floor. Yet the game is confident enough to keep going regardless, smiling all the while and pretending it’s all just part of the show.
Read original review
PCGamesN60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5907Score 68.1843Score 68.1843Z -1.5907Crimson Desert is huge, and it's beautiful, but it can't pull itself out of the bog standard narrative trenches. Combat feels clunky, especially when facing off against one of the many frustrating bosses, and there feels like there is little reward for exploration. I wanted to like this, but it left me feeling empty.
Read original review
PCMGAMES80/100 → 80 · Z -0.49Score 79.1912Score 79.1912Z -0.49Crimson Desert comes highly recommended because it’s a game that combines ambition, scale, and detail in an exceptional way. At first, it can be frustrating due to its dense systems, cryptic puzzles, and some questionable design choices, but when everything clicks, it offers a unique experience. It’s a game designed for those who enjoy in-depth exploration paired with a complex combat system, rewarding patience and curiosity.
Read original review
Pizza Fria89/100 → 89 · Z 0.4337Score 88.4277Score 88.4277Z 0.4337Crimson Desert is one of the most ambitious games in the genre in many years. Its open world is immense, but not empty, with the continent of Pywel rich in detail, inhabitants, secrets, and memorable landscapes. Exploring it is therefore a rewarding experience.
Read original review
Play Watch Read80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0604Score 83.4874Score 83.4874Z -0.0604Crimson Desert is an RPG from the makers of Black Desert. The game started off a bit unstable, but Pearl Abyss has done everything they can to improve it. Now the game is a real top title.
Read original review
PLAY! Zine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.518Score 89.271Score 89.271Z 0.518Crimson Desert is a game you must get used to for it to get amazing. In the first few hours I wanted to give up. However, I persevered and I would regret it if I hadn’t. The sense of wonder, exploration and combat is top notch and scratches that Skyrim itch I’ve been having for years. The story is weaker and starts super “MMOish”, but it picks up the pace later and immerses you into a political and supernatural war between… well, everybody! By the 100th hour I still have not discovered everything nor did I finish the story, but there is not a minute of free time that I don’t spend playing this game. It pulled me in, and won’t let me go, and at this point, I don’t want it to.
Read original review
Player 275/100 → 75 · Z -1.0146Score 73.945Score 73.945Z -1.0146Whilst it doesn’t quite reach the heights of the greats, this is still a compelling experience that’s more than worth your time. Come for the visuals, stay for the gripping combat.
Read original review
PlayStation Universe90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4717Score 88.8079Score 88.8079Z 0.4717Crimson Desert is an incredibly ambitious project. If you are willing to commit, you will find appreciation in this deeply immersive medieval RPG that is almost stuffed with too many features, but somehow makes it all hang together in a beautiful and ambitious package.
Read original review
PNN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2129Score 81.9617Score 81.9617Z -0.2129Crimson Desert feels like a completely different game now. At launch, its story was difficult to follow, and it lacked the narrative hooks needed to make players truly want to immerse themselves in its vast open world. As a result, it was hard to become emotionally invested in the journey.
That has changed dramatically with the Enhanced update. Kliff now feels like a character with real emotions, and the bond between the members of the mercenary group comes across much more clearly to the player. Because of that, the strengths Crimson Desert already had are able to shine even brighter.
That said, the limited enemy variety is still disappointing.
Read original review
PowerUp!85/100 → 85 · Z 0.154Score 85.631Score 85.631Z 0.154It might not be the cleanest contender in the open-world arena, but it’s easily one of the most interesting. A sprawling, slightly chaotic, thoroughly entertaining swing that connects far more often than it misses.
Read original review
PPE.pl65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5866Score 68.2247Score 68.2247Z -1.5866I had high hopes for Crimson Desert, but... I was more disappointed than thrilled. A single-player MMO based on things we love from other great games—it just couldn't work out as well as we thought.
Read original review
Pragalicious80/100 → 80 · Z -0.152Score 82.5714Score 82.5714Z -0.152Crimson Desert is a typical game that doesn't have a golden middle ground. Either the game is fantastic or you don't like it. It is clear that I am a fan of Crimson Desert and of course there are several reasons for that. Especially since it's been a while since I played a game of this caliber. You will be treated to a wonderful world of Pywell, where the atmosphere makes you gasp for breath. There is also a lot to do in Crimson Desert, and that will also provoke different reactions here. However, if you can get used to the here and there some downsides of the game and you take your time for Crimson Desert, then you will experience an adventure that will undoubtedly be engraved in the memory for a long time.
Read original review
Press Start85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0662Score 84.7535Score 84.7535Z 0.0662Though I’ll call it imperfect but patchable, Crimson Desert is still impressive enough to be within striking distance of the juggernauts of this genre. At the very least, this represents one of the first few must-plays of the year. Perhaps contradictorily, Crimson Desert is a lush and generously-sized oasis of awesome that needs to be seen to be believed on PC. Here's hoping the console versions are up to snuff as well.
Read original review
Press Start Australia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0375Score 84.466Score 84.466Z 0.0375Though I’ll call it imperfect but patchable, Crimson Desert is still impressive enough to be within striking distance of the juggernauts of this genre. At the very least, this represents one of the first few must-plays of the year. Perhaps contradictorily, Crimson Desert is a lush and generously-sized oasis of awesome that needs to be seen to be believed on PC. Here's hoping the console versions are up to snuff as well.
Read original review
PSX Brasil90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4984Score 89.0754Score 89.0754Z 0.4984Excellent in many aspects, with great atmosphere, fun combat, a constant sense of discovery and novelty on an absurd scale, Crimson Desert is one of the best open-world experiences of this generation. Some problems don't detract from the brilliance of a title that always rewards the time invested and makes the player want to play more whenever possible.
Read original review
Push Square80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1239Score 85.3303Score 85.3303Z 0.1239Not everyone will have the time and patience required to truly appreciate Crimson Desert. It's a monumental achievement in open world design, but it's constantly struggling with the details.The campaign is a frustratingly disjointed journey, and quests range from downright epic to mind-blowingly bad. Mechanically, it's a game that tries to do everything, but would have been better off just focusing on what it gets right.Still, it's an all-consuming open world adventure that hits some truly incredible highs, and it's already come a long, long way since launch. If you can stomach its more obtuse moments - of which there are many - then Crimson Desert borders on being brilliant.
Read original review
Radio Times80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4085Score 80.0065Score 80.0065Z -0.4085Vast, ambitious, overwhelming, beautiful, thrilling, blood-pumping, flawed. There is almost no end to the words I could use to describe Crimson Desert. Boring is not one of them.
Read original review
RageQuit.GR85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0772Score 83.3194Score 83.3194Z -0.0772An exceptional and stunningly beautiful open-world action game, with incredibly rich gameplay and a pleasantly old-fashioned level of difficulty, regardless of its potentially frustrating flaws.
Read original review
Ragequit.gr85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0733Score 83.3579Score 83.3579Z -0.0733An exceptional and stunningly beautiful open-world action game, with incredibly rich gameplay and a pleasantly old-fashioned level of difficulty, regardless of its potentially frustrating flaws.
Read original review
ReGame It80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4632Score 79.459Score 79.459Z -0.4632Crimson Desert changed my view of open-world games, delivering a strong exploration experience with a rich world, massive content, and excellent gameplay systems. However, its weak story and modest voice acting hold it back from reaching all-time great status, though it still remains a hard-to-ignore experience.
Read original review
Region Free50/100 → 50 · Z -2.217Score 61.9212Score 61.9212Z -2.217Crimson Desert is a gorgeous audiovisual experience with obtuse mechanics, poor mission design, and a nonexistent story. It plays like an MMO trapped in the frame of a single-player adventure game with too many cooks in the kitchen.
Read original review
República DG83/100 → 83 · Z -0.0502Score 83.5893Score 83.5893Z -0.0502Crimson Desert delivers one of the richest and most expansive open-world experiences of 2026, standing out as a landmark title for players. Even amidst hits and misses, the game surprises with dynamic combat and a large amount of secondary content to explore.
Read original review
RPG Fan80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4492Score 79.5993Score 79.5993Z -0.4492It’s such a dense game that there’s way more than I can realistically fit into a review, but I want anyone reading this to come away knowing that Crimson Desert is a massive game with loads of handcrafted content and systems that will allow you to organically craft a narrative truly unique to you. The subgenre that gave me some of my favorite RPG experiences has quietly been losing the studios that built it. Just in the last two years, we’ve lost Piranha Bytes and Spiders. The kind of game they made, patient, systemic, built for a specific kind of player willing to meet it on its own terms, has felt increasingly endangered. Crimson Desert, even if it isn’t perfect, carries that torch. And it carries it with a budget that finally matches the ambition. Just please, for the love of god Pearl Abyss, add the option to skip dialog.
Read original review
RPG Site70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0915Score 73.1758Score 73.1758Z -1.0915Crimson Desert is a flawed but breathtaking, annoying yet fantastic, game of excess that has managed to infuriate and delight me in almost equal measure.
Read original review
Saudi Gamer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0594Score 73.4969Score 73.4969Z -1.0594Crimson Desert is not a bad game at all, but it really feels like this person who is trying everything and too hard to get you which will eventually get you tired of their attempts. Too many things, too little soul.
Read original review
Screen Rant70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9526Score 74.5649Score 74.5649Z -0.9526You have to admire its ambition, and there are high points, but there's also a lot of slogging around and meaningless fetch quests.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0945Score 73.1459Score 73.1459Z -1.0945Crimson Desert is a demanding, complex RPG that can feel punishing and occasionally unfair, especially without constant progression. Yet it offers a breathtaking open world with unmatched scale and depth. Its reception will vary widely'frustrating for some, but deeply rewarding for those willing to fully invest.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0248Score 73.8427Score 73.8427Z -1.0248Crimson Desert is a demanding, complex RPG that can feel punishing and occasionally unfair, especially without constant progression. Yet it offers a breathtaking open world with unmatched scale and depth. Its reception will vary widely—frustrating for some, but deeply rewarding for those willing to fully invest.
Read original review
Shacknews50/100 → 50 · Z -2.9849Score 54.2421Score 54.2421Z -2.9849Crimson Desert is an exercise in excess, and it is worse for it. If you believe more is always better and are so enraptured by “world big” that you are willing to overlook substantial, glaring flaws (and there are many), you’ll love Crimson Desert. Perhaps the most damning thing I can say about Crimson Desert is that it is an enormous game with a ton of content, and I spent most of my time with it wishing I was doing anything else.
Read original review
Softpedia90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6396Score 90.4872Score 90.4872Z 0.6396Crimson Desert is one of those games that manages to seamlessly combine elements from our favorite RPGs and open world games. While you can see some of its original MMO roots in the quest design and side activities, it’s clearly meant to be a wonderful, immersive and engaging action RPG focused on exploration and with a good, emotional story to boot. The game features satisfying combat that rewards mastery, but which can be very punishing, especially when it comes to bosses. And it has so many great activities and side content that, along with the main game, it will take you over 200 hours to complete everything, especially if you want 100% achievements. Crimson Desert makes the most out of its massive scope and even if a few of its parts are undercooked, it’s still one of the most impressive open world experiences released in recent years.
Read original review
SpazioGames77/100 → 77 · Z -0.5413Score 78.6785Score 78.6785Z -0.5413Crimson Desert is the kind of game that makes you want to use the word “impressive” every three minutes, and then makes you feel guilty for doing so. Because impressive, technically and quantitatively, it truly is, but the impression it leaves, once the dust of hype has settled, is that of a title that was afraid to choose. Pearl Abyss built a vast world and then filled it with everything, as if emptiness were an enemy to be defeated through sheer volume of content. The result is a game that almost never gets boring, but that only rarely moves you in the deep, lasting way that the titles it borrows from manage to do.
Read original review
SteamDeckHQ90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4375Score 88.4665Score 88.4665Z 0.4375I didn’t think it was possible for a game of this scale to exist yet, and I don’t recall the last time I ever played a game that wasn’t designed to be replayable that hooked me for such a long time. But here we are. The game lived up to its hype, and even though it isn’t perfect, Crimson Desert is one of the best RPGs I have ever played.
Read original review
STWGames Italia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1976Score 86.0674Score 86.0674Z 0.1976Pearl Abyss came very close: all it would have taken was a slightly more inspired story and some less complex gameplay mechanics, and we would have been looking at a true masterpiece. It’s an excellent game nonetheless—one we recommend even to those who aren’t fans of the genre—that immerses players in a vast open world and captivates them with a solid, dynamic combat system. You’ll be tempted to keep playing even after finishing the main quest to enjoy its world with hours of activities and pure fun. And watch out, because all the pieces are in place for the developer to expand and improve it even further.
Read original review
TechRadar Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3464Score 80.6269Score 80.6269Z -0.3464Crimson Desert manages to capture the essence of pure open-world exploration and delivers incredible combat that is unlike anything you've played previously, while offering an engaging story that keeps you engaged as you progress through its massive map. It's not perfect due to some of its quality of life issues and unfair boss encounters, but this is a game that deserves very high praise.
Read original review
TestingBuddies55/100 → 55 · Z -2.5502Score 58.5891Score 58.5891Z -2.5502Crimson Desert impresses with its ambitious world and presentation, but uneven gameplay, clunky controls, and technical issues prevent it from fully realizing its potential.
Read original review
The Games Machine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6749Score 90.8403Score 90.8403Z 0.6749The overall experience is one of the most impressive I've ever seen, even in terms of its robustness. The version we played on had some inevitable bugs and glitches, but nothing that had a severe impact on the gaming experience. The most significant technical limitation concerns the loading times , which are quite long even with high-end configurations, but are ultimately justifiable given the amount of data to load, especially since once in the game, noticeable loading times are practically non-existent. Then, looking closely, there are a few flaws: detail pop-up (well masked by the overabundance of stimuli) is noticeable while moving, the acting is a bit stiff, there are sporadic issues with lighting and reflections, and above all, a strange night whose darkness doesn't encompass the farthest visible portion of the world, while we are immersed in darkness. But, guys, it really does happen quite often that you're left speechless.
Read original review
The GameSlayer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6265Score 90.3565Score 90.3565Z 0.6265Crimson Desert isn't a perfect game. It's not a game for everyone, and it's got as many good ideas as it does poorly implemented ones. However, what cannot be denied is that this game is a generational game and an open-world experience like no other. It's visually outstanding, mechanically dense, and immersive beyond compare. Yet, it's also one of the most laborious games to get to grips with in recent memory, meaning a lot of players may bounce off this title. However, what I would say is 'stick with it'. As Crimson Desert is a game that doesn't respect your time, but certainly deserves it.
Read original review
The Nerd Stash95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6824Score 90.9151Score 90.9151Z 0.6824Crimson Desert is a breath of fresh air for those looking for true ambition and adventure, as it delivers one of the most experimental combat systems and an open world on par with anything Rockstar Games has ever made.
Read original review
The Outerhaven100/100 → 100 · Z 1.294Score 97.0311Score 97.0311Z 1.294Despite a few minor issues, Crimson Desert sets a new benchmark for this style of open-world experience, one that will be extremely difficult for future games to match.
Read original review
The Outerhaven Productions100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2181Score 96.2726Score 96.2726Z 1.2181Despite a few minor issues, Crimson Desert sets a new benchmark for this style of open-world experience, one that will be extremely difficult for future games to match.
Read original review
The Wand Report60/100 → 60 · Z -1.0335Score 73.7558Score 73.7558Z -1.0335There are so many moments of discovery and bizarre flourishes in this vast open world, but they’re obscured by obtuse design and an absence of narrative depth.
Read original review
TheGamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1461Score 82.6302Score 82.6302Z -0.1461It’s highly ambitious and one of the most intriguing triple-A games I’ve played in years, but I wish so many parts of the whole weren’t inherently flawed. Now my journey in Pywel has come to an end, I’ll be leaving this one on the shelf for a while.
Read original review
TheReviewGeek80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309Score 85.3309Z 0.124Crimson Desert is a messy, ambitious RPG that constantly battles against itself. It’s frustrating and uneven, but its sheer scale and ideas make it hard to walk away from. A bold and often brilliant experience, this is the kind of game that sticks with you long after you’ve put it down.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7433Score 76.6584Score 76.6584Z -0.7433Crimson Desert is unique in the gaming landscape. A vast single player game that's shaped by its original vision to be an MMO, it's gigantic and packed full of interesting places, but its story is incredibly rough and delivered awkwardly at best. Combat is excellent, but the bosses are mostly awful. There is always a negative side to the game's positives, but I feel those positives outshine them anyway. I wouldn't recommend it to just anyone, but the right person will lose themselves in Crimson Desert.
Read original review
This Is Game90/100 → 90 · Z 0.627Score 90.3608Score 90.3608Z 0.627Crimson Desert presents a steep barrier to entry with its flat narrative, demanding controls, and heavy pacing. However, the game's massive open world, forged by Pearl Abyss's uncompromising vision rather than safe trends, is a unique achievement that sets a new milestone in the Korean gaming market. If you have the patience to overcome its initial unfriendliness, this fascinating continent is well worth your time to explore.
Read original review
Thumb Culture80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1505Score 82.5858Score 82.5858Z -0.1505The biggest complaint I have for Crimson Desert is definitely the control scheme. It just feels awkward. Holding R1 to perform a full combo, instead of individual prompts really throws me off. And not being able to lock onto enemies besides when holding block doesn’t help. It ruins the whole flow of combat. Tie that with blocking not working as intended most of the time, then get ready to be mauled a lot. Overall the world is rich with life and vast, but the janky controls do ruin it. I did slowly get use to them but only enough to get by, but it still feels off to me.
Crimson Desert has a lot of fun ideas, but they come across as unfinished. Take the multiple characters for example. They don’t offer anything for the actual game-play besides a preference for the player. But even then you are forced to stick with Kilff mainly due to what seems the world being made for him. Such as puzzles and armour. Another big issue comes from the storage in Crimson Desert. And what I mean by that, is there really isn’t any for the player. Yes we can sell goods, or donate to the camp. But I feel as if we should be able to store produce for cooking, and ore for levelling gear. This should have been a bare minimum feature. I know I haven’t mentioned the story, this is because I honestly don’t have a clue beyond the fact the Graymanes, were slaughtered and that there is an imbalance of good and evil. Crimson Desert has so much I couldn’t fit it all in this review even if I wanted too. There is just that much depth to the game.
Update dropped, so Final Thoughts part 2.
While playing Crimson Desert, an update did drop fixing some issues, like the storage problem. And man does it help a lot. The combat hasn’t changed much, but I have got somewhat use to it more over time. I hope they allow us to switch it from holding down R1, to simple singular prompt. And that they fix the camera style while fighting bosses.
I will give credit, where it’s due, I have enjoyed the world of Pywel. But there is just so much that should have been checked before release. So if you can deal with the awkward jankyness, then you should love it. But personally, I flick between loving and hating it. But in the end, I am giving Crimson Desert the Thumb Culture Gold Award. However, I can see why some people might suggest a lower rating.
Read original review
TierraGamer85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0357Score 83.734Score 83.734Z -0.0357Crimson Desert is an ambitious action RPG that impresses on a technical level and through its open world design, yet it repeatedly stumbles in execution. Its early hours feel promising, and its boss encounters stand out as memorable, but excessive grinding, a narrative that loses momentum, and unclear design decisions gradually wear down the experience. Pearl Abyss demonstrates both talent and resources. However, the game attempts to cover too much without fully refining its core systems, ultimately falling short of its true potential.
Read original review
TodoJuegos77/100 → 77 · Z -0.4412Score 79.6789Score 79.6789Z -0.4412It is not for everyone, but Crimson Desert rewards patient players with vast exploration, tough combat, and a world that feels alive despite its many imperfections.
Read original review
Tom's Guide80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2722Score 81.3694Score 81.3694Z -0.2722The story is pretty average, and the beginning can be brutal, but if you're the kind of person who loves big, sandbox adventures, this one is worth the ride (and $69). $1.29 at Amazon $59.49 at Fanatical(PC) $69.99 at GamersGate $69.99 at Green Man Gaming
Read original review
Tom's Hardware Italia75/100 → 75 · Z -1.0198Score 73.8936Score 73.8936Z -1.0198Its hybrid identity between MMO and single-player is felt in every single progression mechanic. However, despite the frustration, despite the aesthetic trash, and despite some unbalanced bosses, Pywel is a world worth visiting. It's not the game many were hoping for, but it's a journey that, for better or worse, leaves its mark.
Read original review
TrueGaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3645Score 80.4464Score 80.4464Z -0.3645Crimson Desert may not be a completely focused game, meaning that it may not shine in certain aspect overwhelmingly, but its diverse set of systems and activities defies repetition and boredom and attempts to break technical and design boundaries. It is certainly a real technical achievement that takes open worlds in games to unprecedented levels, but storytelling is a bit weaker than we expected.
Read original review
Uagna85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2138Score 86.2288Score 86.2288Z 0.2138Crimson Desert represents an impressive milestone in the open-world genre, offering a virtually endless array of things to explore, activities to undertake and enemies to face. However, it is not a perfect game: there are moments when the clarity of the mechanics and the user-friendly nature of a title of this scale seem to disappear. Many games promise too much and then disappoint. Crimson Desert is not one of them.
Read original review
VG24760/100 → 60 · Z -1.5828Score 68.2632Score 68.2632Z -1.5828As it stands on release, the best parts of Crimson Desert are buried deep under layers of absurdity.
Read original review
Vgames90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3288Score 87.379Score 87.379Z 0.3288Crimson Desert is one of the most rewarding open-world games I’ve played in years, but it absolutely makes you work for that payoff. Its opening hours are rough, the story never fully comes together, and the UI, inventory management, and control scheme can be frustratingly clunky. Still, once the world opens up, the game becomes something special. Exploration feels meaningful, not like filler, and the best rewards often come from curiosity, detours, and preparation rather than simply following the main quest. Combat is flashy, deep, and incredibly satisfying against groups of enemies, even if some boss fights lean too hard into frustration. This is basically Pearl Abyss making a single-player Black Desert: mechanically rich, often messy, and far more interested in systems, movement, and discovery than in telling a compelling story. If you value exploration over narrative and can push through a bumpy start, Crimson Desert is an easy recommendation.
Read original review
Vice100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2266Score 96.3568Score 96.3568Z 1.2266If you are someone who wants a more linear or cinematic, story-driven campaign, Crimson Desert might not be for you. However, if you loved the sense of freedom and discovery that The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild had, then Crimson Desert is the next big game in that genre. Pearl Abyss has truly created something special here, that I suspect we’ll be talking about for years to come.
Read original review
Videogiocare.it65/100 → 65 · Z -1.8315Score 65.7766Score 65.7766Z -1.8315Crimson Desert could have been so much more. Pearl Abyss's ambition is real and occasionally tangible — exploring Pywel can still surprise even after dozens of hours. But that sense of wonder is constantly interrupted by a combat system that wears thin, an unconvincing narrative, disorienting controls, and bugs that can cost hours of progress. Recommended only to the most patient.
Read original review
Voxel78/100 → 78 · Z -0.5631Score 78.4597Score 78.4597Z -0.5631Crimson Desert is an experience that won’t appeal to everyone, but it can be unforgettable for those who embrace what others might see as flaws. Blending combat, survival, and exploration, the game offers over 100 hours of content that may feel superficial to some yet captivating to others. Despite issues like confusing menus and a clunky inventory system, it remains fun and worthy of attention in 2026. Ultimately, the key question is whether you have the time and willingness to dive into its expansive design, which could shine even brighter if it focused less on quantity and more on personality.
Read original review
Wccftech90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5719Score 89.8104Score 89.8104Z 0.5719After spending roughly 30 hours with the game, I would have scored the game in the 9.0 out of 10 range. Now that I have completed the story, I feel that score is completely warranted, and would have been even higher if the narrative had a bit more cohesion. Crimson Desert is very fun and gripping, and a game that is very easy to get lost into with an incredible world density, its sandbox mechanics allowing for tons of player expression in traversal, combat, and quest completion, so much so that I feel I will continue to play the game for a long time even after having completed the story. Now completely comfortable with the game's unique quirks, I firmly believe Crimson Desert has the chance of being this year's Baldur's Gate 3 and becoming a benchmark moving forward for all open-world games.
Read original review
WellPlayed55/100 → 55 · Z -2.0816Score 63.2749Score 63.2749Z -2.0816Proving that looks aren’t everything, Crimson Desert’s stunning visuals and strong performances aren’t enough to save it from being a disappointing experience. Jam-packed with content and systems that make it feel like a Jack of all features, master of none with an unenjoyable gameplay loop, Crimson Desert is really just a single-player MMORPG in all but name.
Read original review
Windows Central90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4089Score 88.18Score 88.18Z 0.4089Crimson Desert is the kind of game that usually only comes along once in a generation, so singular in its ambition that it will define the gaming conversation for weeks, if not months, to come. Despite granular misses, Pearl Abyss has showcased what gameplay freedom truly means.
Read original review
Xbox Achievements65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5193Score 68.8982Score 68.8982Z -1.5193For the first few hours of Crimson Desert, I spent much of my time as Kliff, a Greymane warrior rescued from an untimely death by supernatural forces...
Read original review
Xbox Tavern92/100 → 92 · Z 0.5463Score 89.5539Score 89.5539Z 0.5463Despite the AI controversy around the launch of Crimson Desert, I’ve found a lot to enjoy during my time with the game. There is a lot of content to explore, and freedom to do so at your own pace and style. So much so, that even with some annoying interface and controller decisions and an initially confusing storyline, I found myself compelled to keep coming back and enjoying the moment to moment experiences.
Read original review
ZTGD75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7031Score 77.0605Score 77.0605Z -0.7031Crimson Desert is an odd game for me to place, I enjoyed it for the freedom I had to make my own story and for all the combat and systems but I wasn’t a huge fan of the narrative; even though it did get better.
Read original review