SourceCritic

Tell Me Why

80.4745SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 79.7477 · 111 reviews

2020 · Xbox One, PC, Xbox Series X/S

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

4P.de62/100 → 62 · Z -2.1089Score 63.0019

Tell Me Why brings you an intense story of a traumatic childhood, but the boring gameplay elements as well as the superficial emotional connection of the protagonists rather are a disappointment.

Read original review

Areajugones90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3829Score 87.9204

In conclusion I can be very clear about Tell me Why. This new title by Dontnod will undoubtedly delight all those who have enjoyed previous works of both the studio and the genre. It is a much more adult game that tackles complex topics of great interest in today's society, so it may personally be much easier to fit in with the audience for these works. It is even a great opportunity to introduce you to the genre, because Tell me Why is as accessible as it is spectacular.

Read original review

Atomix75/100 → 75 · Z -1.2331Score 71.7602

Tell Me Why tells a compelling story with some of the most memorable characters in videogames of recent years, but the narrative sometimes feels rushed and some of its best moments feel a little bit too short.

Read original review

Attack of the Fanboy80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3317Score 80.7739

There's no singular moment or element that stands out to make it an amazing experience, but looking back I'm quite happy that the game exists and that I got to play it. The story of Tyler and Alyson is worth experiencing and will live with you long after the credits roll.

Read original review

BaziCenter80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3892Score 80.1987

Tell Me Why picks up the story just when the player feels it has nothing more to offer, and carries it until the very end. There are some weird gameplay mechanics going on, and the overall experience is not that solid, but there is no denying that Dontnod knows how to tell a story, and hopefully things will get even more exciting in upcoming season 2.

Read original review

Capsule Computers85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0547Score 84.6377

Tell Me Why features a compelling mystery that loses its depth the longer the story progresses but its strong characters and solid puzzles prove that Dontnod hasn’t missed a step.

Read original review

Cerealkillerz67/100 → 67 · Z -2.0306Score 63.7853

Contrary to its predecessors Tell me Why can't really make an impact in the first episode. Not only due to it being very short but also the cryptic story build up with little to none decision options that can't be rescued by the uninteresting side characters that get introduced in it.

Read original review

CGMagazine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2979Score 81.1123

Tell Me Why’s exploration of the complexities of memory, the difficulties of knowing our loved ones, and a world that can be better for our transgender loved ones make it a game worth experiencing.

Read original review

Checkpoint Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7201Score 91.2922

Normally I would have to turn to the indie scene for any sort of good trans rep. But it seems the tide is turning, with Dontnod leading the charge. Whether other studios actually follow suit is unknown. But for now, Tell Me Why is a game way overdue; a captivating story, a huge win for diversity and a thoughtful, heartfelt experience.

Read original review

COGconnected80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2526Score 81.5654

You could say that Tell Me Why is about the journey and not the destination, and that journey is indeed a compelling one. And it’s complex; with violence, dysfunction and mental illness featuring prominently, it’s a dark tale in many ways. But it is also one full of hope as well – in the unlikely love that can bring two outsiders together, in the mental bond that literally connects two siblings, and in the liberating power of the truth. You’ll come away from playing Tell Me Why feeling a lot of things – sadness, optimism, confusion, disappointment. I can’t tell you which of these you’ll feel when you play it … but you should play it.

Read original review

Console Creatures80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1411Score 82.6805

Dontnod’s poignant story delivers what it set out to do, and through rekindling the sadness of a broken childhood, the twins discover much about themselves and also their mother.

Read original review

Console-Tribe65/100 → 65 · Z -1.521Score 68.8816

Tell Me Why leaves players disappointed despite its promising premise. The plot's roundabout approach and superficial treatment of diversity are letdowns. Interesting for fans of Dontnod, but it could have been more daring.

Read original review

Critical Hit75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8171Score 75.9197

Tell Me Why is a moody and mature-minded mystery focused on family secrets, while touching sensitively on themes like mental health, gender, and indigenous cultural practices. It's slow going but compelling. Less successful is a supernatural gameplay component that's never fully explored, and feels superficially integrated with the storyline.

Read original review

cublikefoot75/100 → 75 · Z -0.288Score 81.211

Tell Me Why is yet another example of proper storytelling in video game form. It boasts a compelling mystery, a cast of interesting and realistic characters, and also looks great on top of that while running well on modern hardware. As someone that plays a ton of story-driven games, I can definitely say it’s worth a look, even if the ending may have been unsatisfying.

Read original review

Daily Star80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5576Score 78.5156

Those who enjoyed Life is Strange will find quite a lot to love in Tell Me Why . It’s strange that this game isn’t a third entry into the series when it very well does feel like one. After several releases with very similar gameplay structure, you’d think there’d be some more improvements in regards to the slowness of picking of objects and cycling through dialogue. However, as you’d come to expect, the characters are great and the overall story is intriguing enough to keep going. Tell Me Why is another interesting and captivating episodic adventure, albeit a familiar one, from one of the studios that does it the best.

Read original review

DarkStation90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3431Score 87.5226

Tell Me Why might lack the excitement of time travel or superhuman abilities but its subdued tone works in its favor as a tightly paced and progressive character drama.

Read original review

DASHGAMER.com80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6353Score 77.7386

Tell Me Why is an astounding addition to an amazing line-up of DONTNOD’s lofty library of occultic tales, and most definitely a must play in 2020.

Read original review

DualShockers80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3083Score 81.0081

Tell Me Why doesn't stray far from Dontnod's style of episodic storytelling, but features rich characters and compelling representation.

Read original review

Echo Boomer100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0617Score 94.7084

DONTNOD giva us a more intimate, personal and familiar journey than the rest of its games, full of heart and emotion.

Read original review

EGM80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1915Score 82.1763

Tell Me Why might be smaller in scope and less mechanically complex than Dontnod’s Life is Strange series, but it’s just as emotionally impactful. It’s a compelling story with relatable, complex characters, and yet another example of Dontnod’s unbeaten ability to make players feel something, anything, in a medium that’s increasingly more mind-numbing.

Read original review

Eurogamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1753Score 82.3383

Another excellent narrative adventure that combines topical issues and emotional drama.

Read original review

Explosion Network85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0271Score 84.3624

It's a game about trauma and how it affects all of us in different ways. How we treat it. How we self medicate and how we can move past it with help.

Read original review

Filmweb70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1319Score 72.7719

"Tell My Why" is not a perfect game, but it is definitely very important because of what it shows and how it shows it. Great story, full of interesting and colorful characters, which it was a pity to part with.

Read original review

Fun Factor80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1285Score 82.8064

Tell Me Why is more down to earth than its Life is Strange predecessors, but that is in no way a flaw. Its charming characters, beautiful Alaskan setting and slow-burning storyline that rewards the attentive player make it a great slice-of-life adventure.

Read original review

Game Informer78/100 → 78 · Z -0.8994Score 75.0972

Tell Me Why doesn’t exactly answer the question it poses in its title, and maybe that’s the point. Even so, I came away with mixed feelings by the end. I really enjoyed getting to know Tyler and Alyson, and I felt the suspense and intrigue of figuring out this larger mystery, but it also disappointed me. This was only further illustrated in the ending choice, which is just absolutely awful in terms of how it’s presented and how the characters rationalize it in the scenes that follow. It doesn’t end on a strong note, and what’s in between is full of highs and lows. The highs make it worth playing, but just expect to be shaking your head when those low points hit.

Read original review

Game Rant50/100 → 50 · Z -2.2781Score 61.3104

Tell Me Why doesn't allow players to skip most of the dialogue in the game, meaning those going back through for collectibles or to see how different choices impact the story will experience a lot of deja vu. This inability to skip dialogue significantly brings down Tell Me Why's replay value, unfortunately.

Read original review

Game Revolution50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6781Score 57.3098

Tell Me Why and Dontnod deserve praise for the game’s carefully considered representation of trans protagonist Tyler, but unfortunately, the game struggles on all other fronts.

Read original review

GameBlast85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2775Score 86.8665

Tell Me Why is a beautiful and interesting narrative game with charismatic and complex characters. Its artistic characteristics are well crafted and it discuss sensitive topics in a very respectful and natural way. Despite some specific technical problems, Tell Me Why is recommended to those who like investigative games with intense stories and immersive experiences.

Read original review

Gameblog80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0621Score 83.4702

As its title suggests, Tell Me Why depicts the journey of two siblings trying to find the truth about their twisted past. Adressing in a mature way the transgender question, the game also delivers an interesting perspective on the flaws of human memory, with the confrontation of childhood recollections. The second episode sometimes moves at low pace and the game lacks of new environments, but the overall experience is memorable.

Read original review

GameCrate85/100 → 85 · Z 0.102Score 85.1112

It's a shame that the gameplay is so shoddy at times, because I truly believe that Tell Me Why is one of the most important games of our time, in terms of social impact. Hopefully later episodes won't feel as awkward to play.

Read original review

GameMAG70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7354Score 76.7373

Tell Me Why is more of a PR product that suffers from typical problems of Dontnod Entertainment' games, where's the key story bits is exaggerated and backed up by nothing interesting, while the game tries to resonate with players by cheap controversy. The first episode is powerful, but then game descends into a pit of monotony and despondency. And this is sad.

Read original review

GamePro82/100 → 82 · Z -0.6539Score 77.5521

An atmospherically dense adventure with a sensitively told story, which, however, suffers from the typical Dontnod weaknesses.

Read original review

Gamer.no70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8166Score 75.9256

A honorable attempt to breach multiple difficult and complex issues.

Read original review

Gamerheadquarters75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8374Score 75.7169

Tell Me Why is a solid experience that presents important modern social issues in a respectful and educational way, while also dealing with heavy emotional grief.

Read original review

Gamerweb.pl85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0221Score 83.8701

Tell Me Why tells one of the most mature stories in gaming. It touches on the topics of domestic violence and transgenderism in an incredibly tactful way, creating a world where no character is morally black or white. Unlike in most of Dontnod’s games, there’s almost no fantastical elements to the game, making the story and gameplay surprisingly grounded in reality. Don’t expect much action here, Tell Me Why focuses on its character. The most action-packed moments were a plushie fight and a fishing minigame.

Read original review

GamesBeat80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4415Score 79.6758

It doesn’t rely on stereotypes or tropes to find easy answers, and it could be a source of comfort to those who can empathize with these problems. That’s why I liked the tale. It treats all of its characters with a kindness and empathy that unsheathes their complexities.

Read original review

GameSpew100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4796Score 98.8874

I’ve no hesitation in saying that Tell Me Why is Dontnod Entertainment’s best game yet. Its narrative may be somewhat small in scope, but the subject matter it deals with packs a punch much greater than any tall tale of time manipulation ever could. Its characters are some of the most well-realised I’ve come across in a game yet, and their story is one that’s not going to leave me any time soon. Dontnod deals with difficult subject matter bravely and commendably, but that’s not why Tell Me Why is so special. It’s the combination of everything altogether – its characters, actors, visuals, story – that makes this an experience I’m not soon going to forget.

Read original review

GameSpot70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0678Score 73.4129

Mary-Ann reminds me a lot of Twin Peaks' Laura Palmer, a girl known primarily as a victim. It's only until the movie Fire Walk With Me that we know just how much was going on behind the eyes of that idyllic photograph we saw of her every episode. In Tell Me Why, our clearest, enduring image of Mary-Ann Ronan is the dead woman whose childrens' lives were destroyed after her death. Finding out everything beautiful, intelligent, and loving that was going on behind those eyes is the most powerful thing in Tell Me Why, and matched in how her life created two strong, empathetic children who knew her well and didn't even realize it. There's a lot of empty disengaging space to be filled in in this game, but with a little patience and sympathy, what it does provide you is worth the effort.

Read original review

GamesRadar+100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3842Score 97.9328

Tell Me Why offers a much-needed reshaping of the choose your own adventure games, moving away from cliffhangers and dramatic, distinct choices towards a more gentle and meaningful experience. The game features bouts of magic realism, but is most magic in its human moments. All the major choices shape your character's experience more than their actions, and while the first, introductory chapter occasionally feels shallow, later chapters are overflowing with depth.

Read original review

GamesRadar+80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3691Score 80.4005

It's a masterpiece, if not of technique, then of soul, story and heart.

Read original review

GAMINGbible80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2909Score 81.1816

A lot of families hide pasts that, well, those living in the present day would rather not talk about. The Ronan twins' past is one touched by darkness, by actions and individuals who they have, understandably, pushed to one side. Going through this journey of rediscovery with them is a sometimes shocking but often joyous experience, and if you're someone who loves a tender yet twisted narrative adventure, Tell Me Why absolutely deserves your attention.

Read original review

GamingBolt80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1518Score 82.5732

When all is said and done, though Tell Me Why doesn’t necessarily disturb the established Dontnod template too much, it executes it well enough that that doesn't ever seem like an issue. Excellent characters, strong writing, and a deeply personal plot help the player connect with the story. In the end, that most criticisms of the game can be boiled down to “I wish I had had more time to spend in its world and with its characters” should, ultimately, be all that really needs to be said about Tell Me Why.

Read original review

Geeks Under Grace90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4757Score 88.8486

Everyone should play Tell Me Why for what it says about how we often neglect or don't recognize the love of those around us and how that can effect everyone, not just ourselves.

Read original review

Generación Xbox72/100 → 72 · Z -1.4814Score 69.2767

Tell Me Why arrives to bring us a mature and sensitive story very well executed.

Read original review

Generación Xbox72/100 → 72 · Z -1.0654Score 73.4367

Tell Me Why arrives to bring us a mature and sensitive story that is very well executed.

Read original review

God is a Geek80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4338Score 79.7529

Tell Me Why deals with some sensitive subjects with respect and sensitivity, making the story both gripping and powerful in ways they've never done before.

Read original review

GotGame90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3292Score 87.3828

When it comes down to it, Tell Me Why is yet another solid story from Dontnod Entertainment. It's groundbreaking in its approach to representation, and yet it doesn't make that the focus of the story. Of course, this won't be a game for everyone, but those looking for fantastic writing, fun pop culture references and emotional storytelling will be in for a good time. The amazing performances and music also make it a stellar presentation.

Read original review

GRYOnline.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3389Score 80.7024

Tell Me Why is best experienced as an interactive move – discovering the unusual story of the Ronan siblings from this angle yields an extremely compelling experience. DONTNOD’s new game is worth your time and money not only because it has something important to say, but also because it does so in an extremely satisfying, and gracious way.

Read original review

Hardcore Gamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2222Score 81.8687

While still supernatural, Tell Me Why provides more of a mature tale overall than Life is Strange. It's surprisingly dark, but uplifting at times as well. This game takes chances with the cast of characters in ways that are mostly a resounding success. It's exciting to see a LGBTQ lead character and a storyline that doesn't plunge headfirst into tropes. Here's hoping that this is a sign of where Dontnod will go in the future, because Tell Me Why is a step in the right direction.

Read original review

Hobby Consolas83/100 → 83 · Z -0.306Score 81.0309

Quotation forthcoming.

Read original review

IGN70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1356Score 72.7353

Tell Me Why’s well-written dialogue, mundane yet charming exploration, and whimsical fairy tale angle makes digging into the town of Delos Crossing a good story with decent puzzles. It’s just that the low-stakes decisions and an underwhelming mystery plot left me searching for more depth and consequences in the search for the truth.

Read original review

IGN Italy75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7093Score 76.9982

Tell Me Why is a good game but some flaws in the plot make the story a little too confusing and uninvolving in the end.

Read original review

Impulsegamer98/100 → 98 · Z 1.1121Score 95.2125

As there are many decisions throughout the game that affect the dialogue, interactions and end scene, this game has quite a bit of playability, despite being able to complete all three chapters comfortably over the weekend. Despite some obvious ‘woke’ elements, this game simply delivers a really good story, breaking ground in the premise and delivery of the memories and the voice between the characters. Overwhelmingly this game is wonderful to play, captivating as a story and highly immersive.

Read original review

INDIANTVCZ70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8481Score 75.6098

Tell Me Why struggles on the edge of irregular nuances: the game overflows with beautiful ideas, but on the other hand the potential of most of these ideas goes nowhere. Adventure opens you the door to another world, yet it can be one you won't like much at first. But as you dig deeper through the story, you realize that behind another social problem and „controversy" stands much larger narration with detective subtext in its core. Even though you want to compare Tell Me Why to Life is Strange, Tell Me Why is not Life is Strange: not with its story and not with its quality. And that's a shame, because Tell Me Why took some steps that brought the game so close to the line, which Life is Strange back then drew us. Only the small details left it a few steps before the finish line.

Read original review

JeuxActu70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1708Score 72.3829

Tell me Why is clearly the heir of Life Is Strange, but it will only appeal to those who don't mind to hear the same story. Both games are extremely similar, and it feels like DontNod is getting low on inspiration. If you don't mind that deja vu feel, you'll enjoy a nice storyline and a very nice artistic touch.

Read original review

Jeuxvideo.com70/100 → 70 · Z -1.14Score 72.6913

Dontnod announced to us with Tell Me Why a realistic production devoid of minimalist stereotypes. Promise kept. For almost eight hours, it tells a harsh story, strong in its words, its authentic characters, and its thoughtful dialogues. These are the main strengths of the game. But the player's involvement is too little in this title, which nevertheless outlined attractive possibilities, often under-exploited. His participation will be limited mainly to emotional choices, often giving the impression of being passive in the face of the action. We will remember a benevolent story, whose rhythm and lack of freedom sometimes push us to drop out.

Read original review

KeenGamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4215Score 79.8759

Overall, Tell Me Why is a wonderful and thoughtful game that values both its characters and story. Every little detail that is scattered across the game works in harmony to create a believable and engaging world. It is a game that is constantly teaching us more about its interesting side characters and rarely gives the player a chance to want to put the controller down. Despite not having a wild and climactic ending, Tell Me Why is one of the best stories to come out of Dontnod studios and a must-play for any fans of the adventure genre.

Read original review

KonsoliFIN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.108Score 83.0107

Tell Me Why is a touching narrative adventure by Dontnod Entertainment that follows twins Alyson and Tyler—now a trans man—as they revisit their troubled past in a small Alaskan town. With familiar gameplay mechanics, telepathic connections, and a focus on progressive themes like trans identity and Indigenous rights, the game trades innovation for emotional depth and strong writing. Though the formula is becoming predictable, the story's sincerity and character development carry it through.

Read original review

Level Down Games70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2046Score 72.0452

But let’s be honest. You aren’t going to decide to pick up and play Tell Me Why based off of how it performs, how it looks, or even how it sounds. You’re going to pick this up and play it because Dontnod Entertainment has shown that they know how to make an engaging choose-your-own-adventure style of game. As usual for anything published by Xbox Game Studios, the game is available through Xbox Game Pass, and for that reason alone, it’s worth a handful of hours of your time.

Read original review

Lords Of Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4894Score 79.1975

Tell Me Why is a massive step forward in diverse and unique storytelling in the mainstream space.

Read original review

M380/100 → 80 · Z -0.2431Score 81.6606

Sometimes the course of events may be a little predictable, and sometimes a little too shallow. In a mystery-edged, dialogue-driven game, it is a difficult balancing act to decide how far to follow the various stories. The road to dissolution is also relatively short and we would have preferred a fourth chapter that allowed us to dig a little deeper in different places. We want more! Because under the three hundred note, you get an entertaining mystery to solve and put your own stamp on. The fact that Microsoft also allows the game to be included in Game Pass makes the acquisition issue an even bigger no-brainer. Tell Me Why is one of the most touching games of the year so far that will have your full attention from start to finish.

Read original review

Metro GameCentral70/100 → 70 · Z -0.5053Score 79.0377

Dontnod continues to lead the world in terms of character diversity and representation, and while Tell Me Why’s story can sometimes lack drama it’s still engagingly interactive.

Read original review

MondoXbox80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4863Score 79.2282

An intimate and compelling story, with great characterization and environments. It brilliantly manages to represent a transgender character without falling in clichés and stereotypes, normalizing him and making him part of a wider, intense drama. We would have liked more varied gameplay and interactivity though, as the experience is mainly limited to basic exploration, object interaction and dialogue.

Read original review

MSPoweruser75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8061Score 76.0297

Tell Me Why is a well-executed and heartfelt tale about the importance of growing up and moving on, whatever your circumstances might be. Not once did I fail to recognise either Alyson or Tyler as three-dimensional characters and it’s impossible not to be invested in their family’s story, even if some circumstances they’re placed in are overtly melodramatic. Most importantly, the trans experience is expertly handled here, as a stellar example of how video games can sensitively handle a complex character that few get right.

Read original review

New Game Network69/100 → 69 · Z -1.0408Score 73.6831

Tell Me Why tackles a difficult subject quite well thanks to interesting central characters who interact maturely and drive the story forward. But limited use of telepathy, immaterial player choice, and a generally boring delivery tarnish this morose tale.

Read original review

NoobFeed55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2215Score 61.876

Tell Me Why takes a more personal direction than previous Dontnod titles. Unlike the Life is Strange series which involved the lives of dozens, something hundreds, of people Tell Me Why has twin siblings simply looking for answers about their past. With a story that provides limited narrative diversity, simple branching paths, and an overall lukewarm ending. Tell Me Why is a checklist of everything a basic story needs to reach mediocrity.

Read original review

PC Gamer69/100 → 69 · Z -1.1147Score 72.9438

Despite the craft and heart, Tell Me Why feels like a game at odds with itself.

Read original review

Player 2100/100 → 100 · Z 1.1687Score 95.7779

Tell Me Why’s focus on authenticity in storytelling makes it an absolute narrative triumph. The perfect pace allows you to reflect on each element of the story as it unfolds, and clever use of gameplay mechanics makes each choice feel impactful yet organic. A must play for fans of the genre.

Read original review

Portal E780/100 → 80 · Z -0.4023Score 80.068

Tell Me Why upholds Dontnod's high standard of quality in crafting stellar narratives: the title offers a well-constructed story with great twists and memorable, charismatic characters. Providing representation for transgender people is certainly a point worth highlighting, but that isn't the only social issue addressed. The studio's greatest achievement was managing to build a plot that naturally encompasses a range of relevant themes, making for a rewarding gameplay experience that prompts players to reflect on the content they are engaging with.

Read original review

Post Arcade (National Post)90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4743Score 88.834

This is exactly the sort of game we, as a society, need right now: authentic, inclusive, edifying, engaging, and, in the end, hopeful. Tell Me Why is one of the best and most memorable games of the year, and it helps lay a foundation for the growth of minority presence in games with wider audiences.

Read original review

Power Unlimited71/100 → 71 · Z -1.503Score 69.0609

Tell Me Why keeps you invested and interested story-wise for the full nine hours, but is lacking in the gameplay department. It's clear that this genre in its current state is standing on its last legs.

Read original review

PowerUp!100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4688Score 98.779

Stellar writing and performances are paired with refined mechanics and an overall vibe that makes the whole thing seem effortless.

Read original review

PPE.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3792Score 80.2992

The first episode of Tell Me Why perfectly begins another groundbreaking story in the history of Dontnod. For lovers of genre, Life is Strange and serious themes, a must-have item!

Read original review

Press Start80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4078Score 80.0132

Tell Me Why is a Dontnod game throughout its every part, right down to its bones. Although those bones might be bare, it has a lot of soul. With care, Dontnod dive into discomfort and drag us with them throughout three concise episodes that explore the power that comes coupled with familial ties, both bound by blood and by the metaphysical, as well as memory and all of its heartbreaking deceptions.

Read original review

Press Start Australia80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4143Score 79.9478

Tell Me Why is a Dontnod game throughout its every part, right down to its bones. Although those bones might be bare, it has a lot of soul. With care, Dontnod dive into discomfort and drag us with them throughout three concise episodes that explore the power that comes coupled with familial ties, both bound by blood and by the metaphysical, as well as memory and all of its heartbreaking deceptions.

Read original review

Pure Xbox70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0687Score 73.4042

Tell Me Why is a thought-provoking narrative adventure that will stick long in the memory, and for the right reasons. It delivers an imaginative and emotional tale that isn't afraid to address mature topics along the way, and does a commendable job of making you care about its characters and remain invested in its conclusion. It won't suit everyone due to its slow pace and lack of action-packed gameplay, but it nevertheless tells a worthwhile story that deserves to be experienced, and we're grateful to have gone along for the ride.

Read original review

Rocket Chainsaw70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2405Score 71.6865

If you’re looking for a new narrative adventure, you’ll likely love Tell Me Why, but if it’s not your genre of choice, this won’t be the game to make you love them.

Read original review

RPG Fan79/100 → 79 · Z -0.5425Score 78.6663

Take a trip down memory lane, but be prepared for a bit of a bumpy ride.

Read original review

Screen Rant80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1822Score 82.2695

All in all, Tell Me Why is another strong effort from Dontnod. The care it takes with its characters is to be applauded, and although it doesn't always hit the perfect spot with its themes the fact that it is discussing them at all is commendable. Those who enjoyed Life is Strange will get a kick (and a cry) out of its cast and plot, and at least it's not afraid to talk about uncomfortable topics in an age where so many developers are trying so hard to be apolitical.

Read original review

Seasoned Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6276Score 77.8149

So, all in all, Tell Me Why is a fun, story-telling video game with memorable protagonists.

Read original review

SECTOR.sk85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1585Score 85.6762

Tell Me Why could be the best game from Dontnod, but their gameplay is not as charming as the first time. Fortunately, the game offers one of the best stories this year so far.

Read original review

Shacknews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6898Score 90.9892

Tell Me Why stands out as one of Dontnod Entertainment's best efforts to date, which is high praise given their output to this point. It's a brilliant story about twins coming to terms with childhood trauma while exploring the mysteries of how they came to be where they are. The characters are memorable and the dialogue is some of the best to come out of a Dontnod game yet. And at three chapters that average roughly two hours each, the game doesn't overstay its welcome. Dontnod knows just what it wants to say and it says it beautifully.

Read original review

Sirus Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4326Score 79.7653

Tell Me Why is quite amazing. It’s very heartwarming and heartbreaking at the same time. It pulls you in nicely and makes you care for these characters. It makes you one of them. And while this is in no way a perfect game, it’s a fun ride from start to finish, and the players will surely be enticed with this title for its characters and story.

Read original review

SomHráč.sk75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7622Score 76.4694

Tell Me Why is an exemplary narrative adventure game. However, it somewhat feels like a missed opportunity.

Read original review

SomosXbox90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3015Score 87.1066

Tell Me Why changes the Life is Strange formula and manages to bring something fresh. Although not as deep as previous Dontnod games, its gameplay is far more fluid and dynamic. Tell Me Why is a perfect choice for Xbox Game Pass portfolio and a great value for Xbox Game Studios. Meet the Ronan twins; you won't forget them.

Read original review

SpaceNerd.it76/100 → 76 · Z -0.7662Score 76.4293

Tell Me Why is an excellent narrative adventure that talks about childhood dramas and character diversity, but we would have preferred to play more and watch less.

Read original review

SpazioGames73/100 → 73 · Z -0.9589Score 74.5019

Tell Me Why lacks the emotion of Life is Strange and feels a little restraint in its three-episode structure, however it's a well written story-based game, with a complex and mature plot, and the ability to tell a tale about how extraordinary everyday life is.

Read original review

Stevivor100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3361Score 97.4518

That’s the real beauty here: stories don’t have to be full of doom, gloom, betrayal and murder to be effective or impactful. Queers don’t have to be dragged through the mud because of who they are. While Tell Me Why may draw people in because of a transgender character, it offers far more than just that. It presents a complex, psychological narrative that doesn’t use minorities as mere tools to shortcut emotional responses from its players. Take note.

Read original review

The Digital Fix80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2727Score 81.3642

Tell Me Why pushes the boundaries of video-game storytelling with its mature, open-minded approach to its themes and its pioneering representation. The inclusion of a trans lead character is vital but the story is a lot deeper than what's on the surface.

Read original review

The Games Machine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4394Score 79.6972

Tell Me Why is an intriguing narrative game, an intimate story capable of discussing complex themes using the power of a story that lives between reality and fiction, and that never sounds pretentious. If you like this kind of story-based games and have followed DONTNOD since Life is Strange, you will not be disappointed.

Read original review

TheGamer100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2503Score 96.5943

Ultimately, Tell Me Why taught me how to not be defined by my past, and gave me the tools to thrive in the future. In a time where I needed hope perhaps more than ever, Dontnod delivered it. For that, their masterpiece has firmly cemented itself as my absolute favorite video game I've had the pleasure of playing.

Read original review

TheSixthAxis80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0041Score 84.1317

Reining in on the supernatural, Tell Me Why is a more nuanced, intimate and mature story that explores family trauma that challenges our memories and relationships, while making another bold step in representation for video games.

Read original review

TheXboxHub90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3535Score 87.6259

Tell Me Why on Xbox One is DONTNOD's strongest game to date. It is quiet, introspect, mature and superbly written and performed, with visuals that are easy on the eyes - the novel release approach also helps things. There are still some factors holding it back from perfection, but I sincerely hope this is the start of a great partnership between Xbox and DONTNOD, as I feel this game is a perfect example of the type of content Game Pass is perfect for delivering.

Read original review

Tom's Hardware Italia83/100 → 83 · Z -0.181Score 82.2811

For the themes it deals with and above all for the way in which they are treated, Tell Me Why represents for Dontnod a test of maturity passed decisively successfully. Whether it is to represent a plot of family relationships, or a condition of marginality or a complex path like that of a transgender person, the game never takes shortcuts, carefully avoiding transforming their characters into two-dimensional figures defined only by their gender identity, their belonging to a rural community or their religious faith.

Read original review

TrueAchievements70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1972Score 72.1193

Tell Me Why has an engaging narrative that will keep you glued until the end. Although it's not as emotional an experience as the Life is Strange series, there's more than enough there for you to care about the character's outcomes and work towards a good ending. The memory mechanic provides for some tough decision making, and the light puzzles break up the heavy dialogue and exploration, which makes for a satisfying gameplay experience. It's just a shame that Tell Me Why is dragged down somewhat by poor facial animations and some shaky voice acting at times, but if you can get past that, there's an intense and enjoyable story here that's been crafted and handled well on several different fronts.

Read original review

Trusted Reviews80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1922Score 82.1687

Tell Me Why is an engrossing narrative adventure that pushes inclusivity to the forefront, setting a new benchmark for queer representation in the blockbuster space. As a transgender person, this is the level of research and respect that I anticipate from games going forward, and knowing it has the backing of Xbox Game Studios gives me that hope.

Read original review

TrustedReviews80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2272Score 81.8193

Tell Me Why is an engrossing narrative adventure that pushes inclusivity to the forefront, setting a new benchmark for queer representation in the blockbuster space. As a transgender person, this is the level of research and respect that I anticipate from games going forward, and knowing it has the backing of Xbox Game Studios gives me that hope.

Read original review

Twinfinite70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0653Score 73.4385

Tell Me Why is one of those games you're best experiencing for yourself. The narrative's engaging and mysterious, its characters are well-written and likable, and the varied gameplay keeps things fresh to help you push through to the end.

Read original review

Vandal85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0728Score 84.8195

Dontnod successfully brings back its narrative, dealing masterfully with complex topics and absorbing the player in its world.

Read original review

VDZE Media90/100 → 90 · Z 0.446Score 88.5516

I am a big fan of both narrative adventure and episodic games. Over the course of this generation, Dontnod has provided us with some great stories that stick with me to this day. So when I say that this is their best work to date I don't make that comment flippantly. There are themes tackled in this game that we don't see enough of and they are done so in a mature and natural way. It really is great to see boundaries being torn down. Tell Me Why is a must-play title.

Read original review

VGN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7087Score 77.0045

Tell Me Why diversifies from the usual narrative adventures, manages to strike deep thanks to a story based on hard and complicated themes.

Read original review

Video Chums77/100 → 77 · Z -0.4639Score 79.4521

Tell Me Why tells an engaging story of twins unraveling a mystery and forming a bond after being separated for most of their childhood. It's a more mature narrative set in a cozy Alaskan backdrop that could draw the attention of gamers who are interested in story-driven experiences yet may have been put off by all of the teen drama featured in previous Dontnod titles.

Read original review

Washington Post80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2473Score 81.618

By cleverly leaning on the conventions of YA fiction — supernatural elements, family conflicts and the like — the studio has hit emotional peaks rarely, if ever, seen before in gaming (both the first and the second Life is Strange games left me misty-eyed).

Read original review

Wccftech90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5719Score 89.8104

Tell Me Why uses everything it can to get you invested. The puzzles are creative and often use the game's systems in a way you might not expect, while the characters are incredibly interesting and the story is powerful.

Read original review

WellPlayed100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2157Score 96.2481

Backed by stellar writing, a gorgeous presentation and the culmination of years of innovation in the genre, DONTNOD's latest episodic narrative game is their best yet

Read original review

Windows Central70/100 → 70 · Z -1.185Score 72.2414

Tell Me Why respectfully deals with sensitive topics and tells a meaningful story about grief and trauma. The performance and dialogue can be janky at times, but that shouldn't deter you from this experience.

Read original review

Worth Playing90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5005Score 89.0958

Tell Me Why is a memorable experience that's done well. The adventure portions are a good reminder to adventure game fans that the classic experience of logical puzzle-solving is alive and well, but the narrative becomes the driving force for completing the title. From the natural reactions to the characters to the assurances that the subjects of culture and transgenderism aren't just there for show, everything is elevated to the level of some of the best television dramas. For those who want something that's still considered new in the gaming landscape, Tell Me Why is a title that's well worth checking out.

Read original review

Xbox Tavern80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2246Score 81.8453

Tell Me Why is a great adventure that, although could be considered almost as a playable movie, still offers a nice amount of interaction and story hooks to be a worthwhile experience. Fans of this narrative and thought-provoking genre are likely to have an enjoyable experience with Tell Me Why and its interesting and relatable characters.

Read original review

XboxAddict88/100 → 88 · Z -0.0491Score 83.6004

It’s abundantly obviously that Tell Me Why was made as a labor of love, and my time with Tyler and Alyson, while short, was very memorable. More importantly, it made me learn something new, ask questions and broadened my knowledge to other people’s plights that I’ve never had to personally experience. Not many other games have had the same lasting impact that Tell Me Why has.

Read original review

XboxEra78/100 → 78 · Z -0.55Score 78.5911

All in all Tell Me Why is a nice 9 hour journey with a great story in a new world that’s able to keep you entertained and engaged. And if you want, you can try out different story branches by making other choices. But if you don’t like DontNod games, you should think twice before jumping in this story in Delos Crossing.

Read original review

XGN.nl85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1208Score 85.2993

This first episode of the new Dontnod trilogy story is a bit of a slow starter but sets a beautiful scene of little-town Alaska where twins Tyler and Alyson grew up. The game brings everything we expect from a Dontnod game: exploration, tough decisions, and puzzles combined with the supernatural and more than one complex and difficult relationship.

Read original review