SourceCritic

The Punished Backlog

32 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj83.9375
Raw spread σj8.7676
Shrunk mean μ′j84.0118
Shrunk spread σ′j10.54

Reviews from this outlet

Backyard Baseball63/100 → 63 · Z -1.9935Score 64.1559

I could recommend Backyard Baseball to nostalgic super-fans of the franchise or sport, but I'd struggle to suggest it for new players, especially given the price point and the fact that the 1997 remaster is available for $9.99. I myself am going to put Backyard Baseball (2026) down and come back later if/when there have been some patches. Backyard Baseball (2026) still has a long way to go to be ready for the big leagues, but it's a new season for the franchise. I'm so happy it's making a return. These games taught me a lot about strategy, statistics, and teamwork; more young people deserve to get to play games like this. I wish the team all the luck in the world as they take the plate.

Read original review

Bionic Bay70/100 → 70 · Z -1.3294Score 70.7972

Bionic Bay is an often impressive, often frustrating experience. It nails the look and feel of grade-A games like Limbo and Inside, but fails to hold up once you start to scrutinize its puzzle-platformer label. There’s a worthwhile game to enjoy here—one with responsive controls, satisfying action, and a visual polish that puts other games to shame. Unfortunately, the puzzles are lackluster, with too many ideas that come and go with little development or follow-through. If you come into Bionic Bay expecting the next Portal, you’ll be sorely disappointed. Come in expecting a solid platformer with occasional frustrations, however, and you’ll fare far better.

Read original review

Bread & Fred75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

Ultimately, if you’re looking for a casual, easygoing experience with some friends, this isn’t a game I’d recommend. But if you’re up for a legitimate challenge and aren’t worried about potentially losing your mind or loved ones, I can’t give it anything less than a sterling score. Assuming you’re like me and lie somewhere in the middle, I’ve got to split the difference.

Read original review

CONTROL Resonant75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

Taken as a part of the whole, Control Resonant delivers an emotional first draft of a far more interesting shared world. Dylan is no superhero, not yet anyway, nor interesting enough to be an antihero; but there is time enough for him to grow into one through the echoes and darkness of the Remedy Connected Universe — if he’s given more opportunity to shine. I hope we know where we’ll see him again sooner rather than later.

Read original review

Demon Tides84/100 → 84 · Z -0.0011Score 84.0799

I may harp about Demon Tides’ issues, but that’s only because I want this game to succeed. Fabraz continues to create some of the most interesting collectathons on the market, and not since A Hat in Time have I found myself so enthralled by a game’s frame-by-frame platforming mechanics. Like A Hat in Time, though, the jank is real. I wish the game’s colorful visuals and open-world design could shine properly, but performance issues and bugs often drag down the experience. And yet, the game offers far too much fun for me not to recommend it. I 100%’d everything in about 25 hours, and I’d be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy every second.

Read original review

Denshattack!90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

The latest offering from developer Undercoders is neither expected nor simple. Each time I thought I had Denshattack!’s gameplay or narrative pinned down, I was delightfully lurched in another screeching direction.  There are a few key stops that Denshattack! makes during its nine-part tale that — no spoilers — make this well worth your time, and it boasts a vibrant world and cast of characters who have something critical to say.

Read original review

Dispatch80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3806Score 80.2849

AdHoc Studio has created an intriguing premise for a narrative game in Dispatch, a “workplace comedy” in a novel setting. Buoyed by a stellar cast that strikes just the right balance of “aha, so that’s who that is” in its celebrity status with powerful performances from its heavyweights, the first two episodes of Dispatch left me thoroughly wanting more. While Dispatch does lack some of the freedom of prior Telltale experiences (at least thus far), the quality of the narrative and presentation is enough to get me hooked for now. I’m eagerly anticipating Episodes 3 and 4, and I can’t wait to share my thoughts on them with you all soon. In the meantime, if a lower-stakes, more comedic narrative experience in a superhero world speaks to you, Dispatch is worth checking out.

Read original review

Dressmaker82/100 → 82 · Z -0.1909Score 82.1824

Dressmaker has quickly evolved from a potential-filled demo to a delightful, fully fledged game. While there are more things I’d love to see (perhaps in a future update?), it’s a wonderful play as it is, especially for the $15 price point. I’ve had an amazing time with Dressmaker, and I’d absolutely recommend it to anyone with a passion for fashion, design, or creativity.

Read original review

Esoteric Ebb89/100 → 89 · Z 0.4733Score 88.8237

Esoteric Ebb will delight those who love fantastical tabletop adventures but have been craving a single-player experience, especially if you are remotely into medieval stuff, silly stuff, political stuff, and/or male identity stuff. I am not alone in thinking that it's one of the best successors to Disco Elysium, a game I very much loved. There's strong potential for Esoteric Ebb to get a sequel, or even some DLC, and I'll be lining up to try it. I think Esoteric Ebb is an excellent example of the CRPG genre, though it is pretty deep into its systems and those who are new to this style or don't enjoy it will be hard-pressed to click with it. But if you do love a TTRPG, you're gonna love it. I'm confident that, at the end of the year, I'll be putting it on my list of best indie games.

Read original review

Eternal Strands73/100 → 73 · Z -1.0448Score 73.6435

The team at Yellow Brick covered a lot of ground in this first game, both in scope and physically in game with the number of areas available to explore. They did a lot of good things within their budget but I would love for them to scale back, hone the rougher edges, and focus on making them great. If you’re a fan of experimenting in combat with a charming cast, I recommend Eternal Strands for you. The story won’t move you, and the combat, while at times challenging, isn’t anything new. But if you’re curious, you’ll find the magic that keeps you coming back.

Read original review

Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade89/100 → 89 · Z 0.4733Score 88.8237

Despite some story misgivings, Episode INTERmission makes for an exceptional piece of DLC. It adds thrilling combat, a fun new character in Sonon, and Final Fantasy VII Remake’s best mini-game to date. It also includes a few bonus scenes that—without giving anything away—fans of the base game will want to watch. At $20, Episode INTERmission isn’t the cheapest proposition, but it’s certainly a worthwhile one. If you’re lucky enough to have a PlayStation 5, do yourself a favor and give it a go. Yuffie fans, rejoice!

Read original review

Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave is already one of the best games on the Nintendo Switch 2, and it will likely maintain the staying power that Three Houses did on the Switch 1 before it. It does need some touching up, and hopefully the incoming expansion updates will be well worth it. I like to think of Fortune’s Weave as four complete story-driven games tied to a much more gameplay-oriented third act that serves more as an extended catharsis than as a story. I acknowledge that drawing that big a divide between them is a big ask, but if that mindset works for you, you’ll probably come out thinking the game is a masterpiece. Even if you don’t, it will still probably be a ton of fun.

Read original review

Frostpunk 288/100 → 88 · Z 0.3784Score 87.875

11 Bit Studios should be extremely proud of Frostpunk 2; it’s an intoxicatingly detailed and beautiful survival management game. For those who do want more Frostpunk, Frostpunk 2 delivers and then some. Fans of games like Crusader Kings 2 will rejoice, and these added social elements may delight fans of Sid Meier’s Civilization series.  The array of laws and choices means Frostpunk 2 is hyper-replayable, for those interested in that sort of thing. Just a glance at the Steam Achievements list makes it clear that there’s a lot you can do and different approaches you can take. I’m already considering what I’ll do next time.

Read original review

KARMA: The Dark World75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

KARMA: The Dark World is a love letter to David Lynch. While its framing narrative is a little too straightforward, its dream sequences craft nightmarish spaces that linger in the player’s imagination. KARMA won’t be for everybody, but neither are its inspirations. I hope to replay the game soon, revisiting the textual and puzzle box collectibles for additional hints at the future story that Pollard Studio seemingly wants to tell.

Read original review

Kingdom Come: Deliverance II75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

Kingdom Come: Deliverance II is best enjoyed as a kind of Renaissance Faire rather than a 15th-century simulator. The game is at its best when it gives players freedom to explore. Sadly, the main quest has too many pain points where player autonomy is stripped, in favor of a trope-heavy narrative that feels ripped from a 2004 comedy sketch. Its best moments are rare, but when they do land, Kingdom Come: Deliverance II rivals the feeling of playing Red Dead Redemption or Oblivion for the first time.

Read original review

Milki Delivery80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3806Score 80.2849

Even when the gameplay is slow, Milki Delivery is a good reminder of how we should probably all slow down a bit. It's a very sweet, wholesome, gentle experience, and if that's what you need right now, then you will find what you're looking for here.

Read original review

MOUSE: P.I. For Hire98/100 → 98 · Z 1.3271Score 97.3626

Just when I thought the first-person shooter genre had gone stale on me, MOUSE: P.I. For Hire walked in, tipped its hat, and changed my mind. This game won me over with its endless charm, its witty and genuinely cheesy dialogue — the cheese puns never stop, and I didn’t want them to — and a level of aesthetic commitment that extends to every corner of Mouseburg. A few structural quirks in the case sequencing keep it from a perfect score, but MOUSE: P.I. For Hire is a triumph — as close to perfect as it gets. Fumi Games has built a world that deserves to be explored, a story that earns its weight, and a combat system that keeps you coming back for one more run. At $29.99, this game is worth every cent.

Read original review

Nine Sols85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0938Score 85.0287

Nine Sols is easily the most challenging Metroidvania game I’ve ever played, but its difficulty is just one facet of what makes it a truly remarkable game. Whether you’re drawn by demanding gameplay, stunning visuals, or immersive storytelling, Nine Sols commands your attention and warrants your time.

Read original review

Perfect Tides: Station to Station93/100 → 93 · Z 0.8528Score 92.6188

I enjoyed Perfect Tides: Station to Station far more than I expected I would. It’s gritty, entertaining, and painfully relatable. It’s also very likely changed my opinion on point-and-clicks forever. For a simple, somewhat emotionally exhausting, story-oriented game, it definitely hits the mark. There are areas where I felt it could have been improved mechanics-wise, and I doubt I’d play through it again, but I do absolutely think it’s worth a try for anyone with an appreciation for storytelling, art, or comically large eyes.

Read original review

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown94/100 → 94 · Z 0.9476Score 93.5676

The Lost Crown isn't a perfect game. Quests can be buggy, graphical errors pop up now and then, and you may find yourself fighting to jump in the right direction. Overall, however, it's a magnificent package that's well worth your time. Sargon’s journey was a joy to experience, and I will long remember the elation from nailing a hard puzzle. What could have been a simple odd project from Ubisoft is instead both a love letter to a beloved genre and a wonderful next step for Prince of Persia. My only hope is that you can love the exploration and journey as much as I did.

Read original review

Resident Evil 7: biohazard95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0425Score 94.5163

Resident Evil 7: Biohazard is an incredibly well-rounded addition to the survival-horror genre. It successfully reimagines the Resident Evil franchise while helping series newcomers begin their RE journey without the intimidation of pre-established lore or the need to play older, fixed-camera games (such as the original Resident Evil, or Resident Evil 0). Nearly 10 years later, the game still holds up incredibly well.

Read original review

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

I spent a very welcome 12 hours in the world of Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy, which does succeed as both prequel (as advertised) and sequel. The Plague Tale games consistently feel like a hodgepodge of ideas. This game provides a multitude of possibilities for where the series could go next, from more medieval Tomb Raider to re-envisioned ancient horrors. Ultimately, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is a kaleidoscope: a game full of mirrors that reflect light differently based on how it is held. From the right angle, it shines beautifully; however, when Asobo Studio lets its inspirations outshine the game's uniqueness, A Plague Tale Legacy becomes yet another third-person adventure game with an unnecessary skill tree.

Read original review

Silver Pines90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

Despite its narrative shortcomings, Silver Pines is a terrific survival-horror adventure, perfectly suited for a handheld like the Steam Deck or Nintendo Switch. As a Twin Peaks or detective-themed metroidvania, there’s nothing quite like it. The game marries gameplay and narrative design to create a compelling experience that never lets up.  As much as I loved its Pacific Northwest, surrealist police procedural vibe, I wish that its characters and venues felt a little more unique. Silver Pines is so rich for what it does differently than other indie and legacy metroidvanias out there, so it’s a shame the game can’t quite pull away from its obvious homages. Even as an imitation, though, there's plenty here to love.

Read original review

Sovereign Tower85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0938Score 85.0287

If you like games that put you in the king's seat, you'll love Sovereign Tower. It's a lot of fun to hear requests from the populace, make decisions, and maximize knights' load-outs for their quests. However, if you don't like details or making decisions or reading, you probably won't enjoy it. The game is more than a bog-standard visual novel game due to its knight min-max puzzling, but it does heavily rely on the written word and relatively still character frames. That being said, the narrative of Sovereign Tower is as rich as the kingdom you'll end up leading. I had a blast wearing the crown.

Read original review

Split Fiction93/100 → 93 · Z 0.8528Score 92.6188

Split Fiction is another great addition to the Hazelight catalog—one that solidifies the studio as the paragon of co-op gameplay. If you thought It Takes Two was a fluke, think again. Split Fiction learns from its predecessor’s story missteps, doubles down on the great platforming, and deftly pays homage to gaming royalty. The result is Hazelight’s most creative game to date, and—in my humble opinion—its best.

Read original review

Star Wars: Galactic Racer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3806Score 80.2849

Star Wars: Galactic Racer is an invaluable addition to the racing game canon precisely because it is excellent, and because it is a game wholly different in style than each of the Forza, Gran Turismo, Need for Speed, and Mario Kart franchises before it. It is important and healthy for the continued development of the art form to experience innovation not only in licensed property but also in the very ways in which we play our favorite games, in genres we falsely believe to have already traversed their creative limits. With a stronger narrative, Galactic Racer wouldn’t just be making a case as one of the better games of the year; it would be in the conversation for one of the best Star Wars IP releases this century.

Read original review

Stray79/100 → 79 · Z -0.4755Score 79.3361

Stray is as good a weekend binge as any, even if it failed my little cat-owner heart or made me grimace over rice paddy hats. As a video game, Stray is far from perfect, but as a cat-riding-in-a-bucket simulator, it’s pretty incredible.

Read original review

Tenebris Somnia73/100 → 73 · Z -1.0448Score 73.6435

Tenebris Somnia is unusual, and I think that’s a good thing. In promotional materials, the most boasted accolade is that of the award-winning film crew behind the cutscenes. The team did a wonderful job of making the live-action segments feel cinematic and synchronizing them nicely with the actual gameplay sections, but on occasion the other parts of the game can feel neglected as a result. The game advertised was an incredibly scary experience, but I found the fear factor a little underwhelming. If you want a game that feels almost like a digital escape room with the way its puzzles are presented, Tenebris Somnia is the game for you. But if you’re looking for a genuinely horrifying experience, fumbling to survive while fighting something straight out of a nightmare, maybe give the game a pass or at least temper your expectations.

Read original review

The First Berserker: Khazan90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

In the end, what is The First Berserker: Khazan? It’s a deeply rewarding and engaging experience, if challenging a boss 50 times in a row sounds fun to you. The story is a huge miss, the characters are boring, and the setting is all of the drab of Dark Souls with none of the wonder, but the peaks here are incredible, and if you can endure the journey, Khazan is an awesome, awesome experience.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026)100/100 → 100 · Z 1.5169Score 99.2601

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026) is a perfect remake of a perfect game. It honors everything that made the original 1998 game a classic while updating every aspect of the experience for the modern player. It looks great, sounds even better, and plays like butter. The addition of voice acting and new cutscenes provides a cinematic flair befitting Link’s flagship adventure. It doesn’t take many risks, but it doesn’t need to. Nearly 30 years ago, Nintendo showed us what’s possible with great writing, great design, and great heart. Now, in 2026, history has repeated itself.

Read original review

The Mermaid Mask90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

There are a few times in The Mermaid Mask where characters, such as a tormented author, will make comments about how hard it is to make a sequel or that "this is a lot of work; I don't know if I'll do it again." And I can't disagree; it seems incredibly difficult. I've been editing my own novel for a few years now and it is... quite painful. But what keeps me going is the idea that some day, my mom might get to read my book and really love it, and maybe other people will, too. So, I say to SFB Games and brothers Vian, if you have finished your journey with these games, I would understand, but I'd be sad — The Mermaid Mask is an excellent game, and I can only imagine how brilliant the next one would be.

Read original review

Tombwater88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3784Score 87.875

Tombwater sets up an intriguing space in the current indie game landscape. A Western horror game disguised as a Soulslike is a brilliant sale, but Tombwater is so much more. It is a triumphant realization of the 2D Zelda formula in a non-medieval, Bloodborne-esque setting. I hope I get to return to this world sooner than we’ll likely return to Yharnam.

Read original review