Analog Stick Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2544Score 81.5472Score 81.5472Z -0.2544Tombwater captures the soul of a soulslike game and wraps it in a retro-western inspired skin, while offering a deeper focus on story without short-changing the mechanics you’d expect from the genre. The basic map definitely hurts exploration, and the lack of accessibility will mean the game is unplayable for some people, but even then, it’s impossible not to recommend Tombwater to fans of soulslike games and retro games alike.
Read original review
Cinelinx80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7442Score 76.6494Score 76.6494Z -0.7442Tombwater is a perfect addition to the Metroidvania soulslike genre. It did a phenomenal job of bringing Eldritch Horror to the wild west and making it a truly immersive and fun experience. Even with the issues with controls for non-mouse and keyboard users and the sometimes questionable sound choices, this game has absolutely stolen my heart with its storytelling and beautifully horrifying art and atmosphere.
Read original review
COGconnected89/100 → 89 · Z 0.629Score 90.3811Score 90.3811Z 0.629All in all, Tombwater is one of my favorite Soulslikes, if not one of my favorite games, period. I’m not usually a fan of Zelda-likes, but I could barely put this one down. And only part of that was because I kept getting lost and wandering into a new miniboss arena.
Read original review
GameBlast80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1393Score 82.6979Score 82.6979Z -0.1393Tombwater is a well-crafted blend of top-down soulslike, horror, and western setting. Even though its limited map doesn't offer much help for planning backtracking, the diversity of locations and how they intertwine to form a greater whole, dotted with secrets to discover, makes exploration one of the highlights of this fun pixel art eldritch adventure.
Read original review
Gameliner90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7067Score 91.1578Score 91.1578Z 0.7067A top-down soulslike was still relatively new territory for me, but Tombwater proves the perspective is well worth exploring. It offers a compelling narrative, varied combat, and an engaging gameplay loop, with meaningful upgrades and tools introduced at a steady pace to keep momentum strong, while its distinct environments reinforce the game’s grim tone. Navigation can be a bit unclear and the controls take some getting used to, but thanks to its stability and many strengths, those flaws are easy to overlook.
Read original review
GameSpew90/100 → 90 · Z 0.66Score 90.6907Score 90.6907Z 0.66Zelda meets Dark Souls, Tombwater is a fantastic action adventure set in a Lovecraftian reimagining of the Wild West. Tricky combat is king here, but thanks to difficulty options you can choose to focus on exploring the rich world around you and uncovering its secrets. This is a real hidden gem, and one that really should be on any action-adventure fan's radar.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %100/100 → 100 · Z 1.1082Score 95.1732Score 95.1732Z 1.1082100.0% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (11 reviews).
Pixel Byte85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2653Score 86.744Score 86.744Z 0.2653Along its 15- to 20-hour playthrough, what makes Tombwater hard to put down is its level design. Smartly placing shortcuts that are unlocked once a difficult boss or area is advanced through, it is purposeful in its ravaged layout. Obtaining new abilities, such as rock climbing and a special shot from your gun to light torches, incentivizes you to explore every cursed nook and cranny.
Read original review
Softpedia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0838Score 84.9288Score 84.9288Z 0.0838Tombwater is very good at mixing two very different inspirations into a coherent experience. Bloodborne, moved into two dimensions, supplies the core combat mechanics, the feeling of eerie transformation, the magic system, and the fire. The Wild West brings in the characters, the dusty town, and the taciturn main character. Anyone who loves both will have a lot of fun exploring this world, discovering its past, conquering its many challenges, and developing their combat abilities. It helps that players have the option to make the game easier in the Settings menu once they start their adventure. Tombwater can be frustrating at times, but its core combination of ideas is very good.
Read original review
The Punished Backlog88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3784Score 87.875Score 87.875Z 0.3784Tombwater sets up an intriguing space in the current indie game landscape. A Western horror game disguised as a Soulslike is a brilliant sale, but Tombwater is so much more. It is a triumphant realization of the 2D Zelda formula in a non-medieval, Bloodborne-esque setting. I hope I get to return to this world sooner than we’ll likely return to Yharnam.
Read original review
VDGMS95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8449Score 92.5404Score 92.5404Z 0.8449Good Western games are few and far between and great ones are even more of a rarity. There have only been a few handfuls of truly great westerns like the Red Dead series, Oddworld: Strangers Wrath, Outlaws, Oregon Trail and a small selection of others, but now Tombwater needs to be placed in these hallowed halls alongside these icons.
Tombwater features gameplay inspired by The Legend of Zelda and Bloodborne that gets paired with a faithful western story revolving around an anti-hero trying to live an honest life, who becomes forced to pursue frontier justice in this Eldritch universe. The result is an experience that would make Clint Eastwood proud as Tombwater is one of the greatest Westerns games ever crafted.
Read original review