SourceCritic

Bread & Fred

72.0154SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 68.4286 · 14 reviews

2024 · PC, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One, PlayStation 4

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

CGMagazine60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9282Score 64.809

Bread &a; Fred has interesting ideas, but its frustrating execution and disrespect for the player’s time keep it from being enjoyable.

Read original review

Checkpoint Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7741Score 76.3499

Bread &a; Fred is a delightfully enraging cooperative physics puzzle that combines charming pixel art, adorable animations, and a challenging platformer experience. The game's world, filled with cute penguins and vibrant environments, will bring smiles to faces. The chaotic gameplay and repeating failure might bring frustration but will be followed by big laughs and lots of fun with your penguin partner. Still, for solo players without someone to play with local co-op, this game won't be for you.

Read original review

COGconnected60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2116Score 61.9751

Bread & Fred is a novel concept that fails to deliver due to its frustrating climbing mechanics. The idea of climbing a large mountain and working with a partner to do so is appealing; however, the inconsistent physics and anger-inducing design that allows you to lose progress in an instant hinder the game. Although SandCastles Studio adds an array of assist options to address these concerns, at its core, the game struggles to balance challenge with enjoyment. The fundamental design flaws overshadow the creative premise, resulting in an experience that is more exasperating than entertaining.

Read original review

GameBlast80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1393Score 82.6979

Bread &a; Fred is an excellent option for those who like to play with someone at their side. The penguins' adventure is full of charisma, tension and frustration but it offers some hours of fun and arguing among players. The title also adapts itself to diverse situations, having a singleplayer mode and accessibility options that make it more pleasant to casual players.

Read original review

Gamezebo60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7703Score 66.3885

As with many co-op platfomers of this type the controls need to be spot on to avoid being frustrating, and sadly Bread and Fred doesn’t quite nail this aspect. Too often we found ourselves struggling to get out of an area because of slightly finickity physics or overcomplicated controls, and it didn’t feel as if the blame lay at our door. If you stick with it things do improve though, with the slightly fudged controls being workable and the game offering some interesting level design and ideas.

Read original review

LadiesGamers.com65/100 → 65 · Z -1.8555Score 65.5359

Bread and Fred was not the cuddly co-op adventure I was expecting. Frustrating in co-op and unplayable in single-player. This wasn’t for my wife, who I roped into playing this experience with me, or me. Costing me almost my marriage. I can see an audience who likes these overly hard games loving the challenge, particularly streamers and speedrunners. For all I know, this is another one of those experiences maybe I just don’t get as I’m getting older and not with the cool gamer kids. For most, I would advise approaching this with caution unless you want to test the length of your best gaming friendships

Read original review

Movies Games and Tech70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9293Score 74.7986

I really enjoyed my time with Bred and Fred, but the single player mode really makes it a more frustrating experience than it needs to be. This is a title that I can highly recommend if you have someone who wouldn’t mind sitting down and putting a couple of hours into it with you. Otherwise, I highly recommend that you prepare yourself for a frustrating time as you throw a rock around in efforts to achieve the same results as someone else who has a competent partner with them.

Read original review

Nindie Spotlight65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4063Score 70.0285

Whether tackling it solo or with a friend, this is a pretty brutal take on mountain climbing

Read original review

NintendoBoy60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9152Score 64.9393

Bread &a; Fred is definitely very funny, and it even makes you chuckle sometimes. It was cool to see Patricio and his mom replicate the meme, and the photos are really cool, but I couldn't get into the gameplay, always feeling frustrated and tired.

Read original review

Pure Nintendo70/100 → 70 · Z -0.673Score 77.3607

Bread & Fred is a unique platformer with moments of brilliance and frustration in equal measure. It looks lovely and has a great approach to co-op gaming, along with the inclusion of Jeff in single-player mode. It’s hard, so grab a patient partner if you want to enjoy this one.

Read original review

Shacknews80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2289Score 81.8024

Bread &a; Fred has solid platforming mechanics, and the introduction of the rope opens the door to brand-new frustrations and gameplay elements. It succeeds greatly at producing a co-op experience that’ll either have you at the throats of your friends and loved ones, or laughing uncontrollably, even if it feels like there isn’t much more substance beneath the surface.

Read original review

The Games Machine83/100 → 83 · Z -0.1051Score 83.0401

Bread &a; Fred is hard in solo, almost impossible in co-op, it still manages to be a lot of fun provided you have a lot of patience and understanding with your partner. Dedicated to those who love extreme platformers, but casual players might find it too frustrating.

Read original review

The Punished Backlog75/100 → 75 · Z -0.855Score 75.541

Ultimately, if you’re looking for a casual, easygoing experience with some friends, this isn’t a game I’d recommend. But if you’re up for a legitimate challenge and aren’t worried about potentially losing your mind or loved ones, I can’t give it anything less than a sterling score. Assuming you’re like me and lie somewhere in the middle, I’ve got to split the difference.

Read original review

Video Chums60/100 → 60 · Z -2.1143Score 62.9485

Bread & Fred is so brutally tough that I can only recommend it to co-op chums who relish mastering ridiculous challenges together.

Read original review