SourceCritic

Perfect Tides: Station to Station

86.0333SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 86.1979 · 24 reviews

A point n' click sequel to Perfect Tides about the momentum and whiplash of young adulthood. Explore the big city through 18-year-old Mara's eyes. Collect items, nurture ideas, and experience complex relationships while attempting to find your place in the world.

2026 · PC, Nintendo Switch

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

4P.de85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2408Score 86.4988

An indie gem where every pixel breathes love for its characters. An old-school point-and-click adventure whose story starts slowly but then develops an irresistible pull. Perfect Tides: Station to Station is great storytelling on a small screen.

Read original review

Adventure Game Hotspot94/100 → 94 · Z 0.8106Score 92.1967

Station to Station is as worthy a follow-up to the brilliant original Perfect Tides as anyone could have hoped, continuing Mara’s story with the same insight, compassion and immersive writing while deepening and expanding its narrative through interesting new mechanics.

Read original review

Buried Treasure95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8805Score 92.8958

Station to Station is often hilarious, often mortifying, and perpetually honest. As Perfect Tides so wonderfully depicted incredible specifics of adolescence, this sequel speaks as truthfully and intricately about the emerging of adulthood. It captures those moments of profound bliss and shattering devastation, alongside the beauty in the mundanity between. And it makes me miss those times with that magical girl from university, and so unbelievable grateful it’s so long in the past and never to be repeated.

Read original review

Checkpoint Gaming85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3465Score 87.5566

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is a superb second chapter to an incredibly underrated point-and-click adventure, taking advantage of real-life stories and struggles to paint a beautifully moving and engaging story about a creative trying to make it big while making sense of the world. It too is a perfect time-capsule game of the early 2000s, filled with laser-sharp wit and references. Within is profound prose that uses an unconventional approach to game narrative to tell a divine coming-of-age tale that’ll be relatable to many. Bolstered by gorgeous pixel work, striking on-two’s animation and unique mechanics for the genre, Mara’s tales of love and loss as a creative in New York are quintessential storytelling for those who value game narratives. Come on in, the water’s damn fine.

Read original review

Digitale Anime75/100 → 75 · Z -1.3774Score 70.3173

"A deeply human and moving narrative" Perfect Tides: Station to Station offers a narrative adventure experience focused on college life and creative ambition, presented in a deeply personal and moving way. The strong writing, innovative mechanics, and polished art design make it a successful sequel and a title in its own right. Despite its relatively slow pace and limited world, the depth of the emotional experience and interactive choices make the game a valuable addition for fans of interactive storytelling.

Read original review

Digitec Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3178Score 80.9134

"Perfect Tides: Station to Station" is not a game that overwhelms me. It accompanies me. It challenges my patience, my compassion and my willingness to think in small steps. This story of an uncertain year is told in cautious pixels and whispering sounds. It is a quiet, honest look at growing up. Those who engage with it will experience a game that is not spectacular, but deeply moving.

Read original review

Edge Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1163Score 85.2543

This is a story about finding your voice, but it also grapples with an uncertain time, when some outcomes are beyond our control or experience. [Issue#420, p.104]

Metacritic Users68/100 → 68 · Z -1.6806Score 67.2852

Metacritic user score 6.8/10 (12 ratings).

Minimap90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4575Score 88.6666

But there’s more here than just the pieces I connected to. Perfect Tides: Station to Station is filled with so much life that I think anyone can find something to relate to.

Read original review

Movies Games and Tech90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5906Score 89.9976

A wonderfully written examination of what on earth it means to be an adult. Gameplay and art both feed back into the central themes, creating a heartfelt story, with a dash of pretentiousness.

Read original review

Multiplayer.it80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0856Score 83.2353

quote not available

Read original review

Multiplayer.it80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1974Score 82.117

Mara Whitefish's new adventure is sometimes irreverent, at other times sentimental, but it's always genuinely true. So much so that you find yourself getting angry at one character or another, only to realize that, as teenagers, we probably behaved the same way.

Read original review

Nindie Spotlight84/100 → 84 · Z 0.1975Score 86.0661

An impeccably written, and brutally honest, adventure that explores the anxieties of trying to transition to adulthood

Read original review

NintendoBoy100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2563Score 96.6544

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is one of those games that's so relatable it sometimes hurts. What's been created here is a game based on real life for real people. It's a game that says a lot about Mara, but it can also say a lot about ourselves and our relationships with others, whether friends, romantic partners, or family, but also about what we think of ourselves and how all these mundane experiences shape us.

Read original review

NoobFeed80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1883Score 82.2085

Station to Station doesn’t require that you have anything to do with writing, schooling, or even the time period it’s set in. The only thing it wants from you is to remember what it was like to doubt yourself while the world went on. In this way, it turns small, everyday moments into something deeply meaningful.

Read original review

OpenCritic Recommend %93.75/100 → 93.75 · Z 0.904Score 93.1313

93.8% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (16 reviews).

Quest Daily85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0247Score 84.3377

Stepping into Perfect Tides: Station to Station felt like being a teenager again: angsty, emotionally heavy, and stuck in that strange limbo of a summer holiday where everything feels too big. Consuming a story about another angsty, emotionally heavy girl trying to navigate the world, I felt seen in a way I hadn’t since my teen years.

Read original review

Shacknews80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2289Score 81.8024

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is more somber than wistful, more grounded than nostalgic, and more realistic than fanciful. The 2003 setting feels circumstantial rather than deliberate as a storytelling device, and the autobiographical piece of it bleeds from every word of text.

Read original review

So Many Games90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is a messy, disjointed and incredibly uncomfortable window into the life of a writer who still needs to find their way in the world, but all of this comes together to build an amazing narrative that engulfs the player, showing them to embrace discomfort and learn to be their best self. Sadly, a lack of meaningful accessibility options does lose the game half a star.

Read original review

The A.V. Club91/100 → 91 · Z 0.3919Score 88.0106

Quote not available

Read original review

The Gamerheads Podcast100/100 → 100 · Z 0.9198Score 93.2892

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is a coming-of-age story filled with moments of real happiness, and just as many moments of self-doubt. There are times where Mara, the protagonist, is fully depressed, and the game doesn’t shy away from exploring that. It digs into relationships and intimacy, along with everything that comes with them: heartbreak, hurt feelings, and broken friendships. And choosing dialogue options during those moments truly put me right in the thick of it with Mara. I also love that Mara is a writer, and that part of the experience involves writing papers. It pushes me to explore, learn, and gain experience so I can write better, which is a clever mechanic that fits the story perfectly. The art is phenomenal too, adding even more weight to the emotional rollercoaster the game delivers. But at the end of the day, it’s the writing that makes Perfect Tides: Station to Station stand out. Mara is flawed, but she’s also incredibly relatable, and it’s hard not to get pulled in and root for her through the entire journey.

Read original review

The Punished Backlog93/100 → 93 · Z 0.8528Score 92.6188

I enjoyed Perfect Tides: Station to Station far more than I expected I would. It’s gritty, entertaining, and painfully relatable. It’s also very likely changed my opinion on point-and-clicks forever. For a simple, somewhat emotionally exhausting, story-oriented game, it definitely hits the mark. There are areas where I felt it could have been improved mechanics-wise, and I doubt I’d play through it again, but I do absolutely think it’s worth a try for anyone with an appreciation for storytelling, art, or comically large eyes.

Read original review

ThreeTwoPlay90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3421Score 87.5122

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is the perfect point-and-click adventure for millennials but also appeals to younger audiences who are just turning 18 or are at least not too far off. Meredith Gran manages to paint a relatable picture of a young woman coming of age and I'm quite sure there are situations everyone out there will initially shake their head and ask, "Mara! Why?!" only to realize a moment later that they probably would have reacted the same way when they were younger. The writing tasks and books offer a bit more gameplay variety than its immediate predecessor, but it never gets truly difficult, which I didn't really mind. The dialogues and the story entertained me so well throughout the entire game and I hope that we will see more of Mara someday.

Read original review

Thumb Culture80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1505Score 82.5858

I went into Perfect Tides: Station to Station not entirely sure what to expect, but I can honestly say this is a gem of a game. Mara is an entertaining main character that you can easily connect to even though you’re thrown into the middle of her story. Everything works in perfect tandem to create a truly fun experience. My favourite thing about this game is that your choices actually feel like they have some weight to them, unlike other choice-based games where things feel inconsequential. Perfect Tides: Stations to Station is an easy winner of the Thumb Culture Gold Award as it is an enjoyable little game, definitely worth the amount that it’s listed for. Check out the trailer below to get a better look at what’s in store for Mara.

Read original review