SourceCritic

Silver Pines

85.6899SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 85.0192 · 104 reviews

Private investigator Red Walker finds himself in Silver Pines, a place half-abandoned, half-forgotten, in the middle of nowhere on a job to track down Eddie Velvet. A musician who has vanished. As the case begins to reveal a dark past, Walker soon slips into a strange and nightmarish descent beyond his control. Silver Pines is a survival horror metroidvania set in small town America. Fight nightmarish terrors and solve puzzles, while carefully managing your scarce resources as you uncover the mysteries that could hold the key to redemption.

2026 · PC, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch 2

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

AdventureGames.hu80/100 → 80 · Z -0.127Score 82.8216

Silver Pines is a very atmospheric, high-quality horror adventure with powerful atmosphere, a haunting story, and exploration-based gameplay that can easily keep anyone busy for around 15 hours if they want to find everything (or even 19, if you get as lost in it as I sometimes did). It was one of the most pleasant surprises of the year for me in the indie scene. From the demo I already suspected the full game would be a good experience, but not that it would be this good.

Read original review

Alternative Reality85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1973Score 86.0643

Silver Pines above all manages to turn a small town into a place to understand, fear and remember. Exploration, clues and resource management work together effectively, giving value to the storytelling. Art direction and soundtrack complete an experience able to disturb even in its quietest moments. The combat does not reach the same quality and some passages show certain limits: stiffness, repetition and a few solutions that are a bit too familiar keep the game from always maintaining the same intensity. These are noticeable compromises (and understandable given that it is a debut title), but they do not overshadow the character of the production. For those looking for a horror adventure based on atmosphere, preparation and the pleasure of discovery, Wych Elm's debut is a very convincing proposal.

Read original review

BaziCenter90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4893Score 88.9843

Silver Pines is a game that leaves you in the heart of its cruel world to discover the secrets of the puzzles yourself, deal with the strict resource management system and find a way forward in the dark corridors of the Red Walker.

Read original review

BuffGaming.rs85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0039Score 84.1297

Silver Pines: is an atmospheric horror adventure that combines a surreal mystery reminiscent of Twin Peaks with disturbing creatures and elements inspired by Silent Hill and Resident Evil. Exploration, cleverly designed puzzles, and a practical photography system for documenting clues are among its biggest strengths, while the lack of clear guidance can occasionally make progression frustrating. Despite a few shortcomings, it's a compelling choice for psychological horror fans who enjoy uncovering the secrets of a world where nothing is quite what it seems.

Read original review

CGMagazine100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3325Score 97.4157

Silver Pines is a masterpiece, blending gorgeous animation, a compelling mystery and rewarding exploration that makes its haunting town hard to leave.

Read original review

Checkpoint Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7741Score 76.3499

Silver Pines draws plenty of inspiration from its contemporaries, but unlike other love letters to gaming and television classics, it finds the means to make things its own. While it fails to sell me on the combination of the horror and Metroidvania genres, Silver Pines’ fascinating premise, thought-provoking ending, and remarkable art direction kept me seated from beginning to end.

Read original review

Chicas Gamers84/100 → 84 · Z 0.0075Score 84.1664

Silver Pines is a fascinating blend of classic survival horror and Metroidvania that stands out for its intriguing narrative, extraordinary art direction, and an atmosphere evocative of the genre's greatest icons. Although its gameplay leaves room for improvement and its influences occasionally wear on its sleeve, Wych Elm succeeds in crafting an experience with a distinct identity that will thoroughly delight fans of psychological horror.

Read original review

COGconnected85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2372Score 86.463

Silver Pines begins with a missing-person investigation, and, above all else, I was never eager to put the case away. Its atmosphere, storytelling, and soundtrack combine to deliver an excellent horror experience, even if the combat doesn’t quite measure up. If you love Silent Hill’s cryptic characters or David Lynch’s bizarre small-town mysteries, this is an easy recommendation. Those looking for deep, demanding combat may come away disappointed. Twin Peaks taught us that the owls aren’t what they seem, and Silver Pines embraces that same philosophy. It may look like a tribute, but it plays like the real deal.

Read original review

Comunidad Xbox87/100 → 87 · Z 0.4684Score 88.7756

Silver Pines knows exactly where it comes from. Its focus on exploration, puzzles, and limited resources shows that it still...

Read original review

Console Creatures80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1411Score 82.6805

There are lots of Metroidvania games out there these days, but it’s hard to find one that nails Silver Pines’ dark, moody vibes. The puzzles are never too difficult, the characters and story beats are well thought out, and the game’s survival aspect never feels overly punishing. If you’re looking for a creepy story and setting, with minimalist but sharp gameplay, Silver Pines could be your go-to title right now.

Read original review

CriticLenz95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9178Score 93.2695

"Silver Pines blends layered storytelling, striking visuals, and exploration mechanics into a standout psychological horror experience driven by curiosity and unease rather than cheap scares."

Read original review

Cubed370/100 → 70 · Z -0.4577Score 79.5137

Silver Pines stands as a hauntingly beautiful, if flawed, love letter to the golden era of survival horror. While its central identity twist leans perhaps a bit too heavily on the well-worn tropes of Silent Hill 2, Memento, and Twin Peaks, the journey through this storm-ravaged mountain town is an absolute triumph of atmosphere. It suffers from some noticeable technical bugs and optimisation stutters, but the sheer mechanical tension of its clunky combat and punishing payphone save system keeps you entirely glued to the screen.

Read original review

Denjin Den75/100 → 75 · Z -0.4652Score 79.4395

Silver Pines is an excellent game, built on the genre’s core foundations and successfully translating its defining mechanics into a 2D, Metroidvania-style structure without ever feeling disjointed. Where it falls short, however, is originality: there isn’t a single idea that feels truly unique or distinct. This applies not only to the gaming landscape, but also to its cross-media influences, which the developers seem to have mined with all the subtlety of a stick of dynamite.

Read original review

Digital Chumps90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2834Score 86.9249

Silver Pines has all the makings of a Lynchian classic by way of a Metroidvania. Though it has a handful of shortcomings, this welcome and fresh take makes the most of its ambition and Americana horror.

Read original review

DualShockers95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8939Score 93.0304

Silver Pines is a cerebrally divine love letter to David Lynch and all the narrative trademarks he was known for, from the cult classic Twin Peaks to Blue Velvet and Lost Highway. It digs even deeper to its spiritual successor Silent Hill, from the fog-filled streets to the nightmares that lurk with bared teeth, and embraces all those inspirations with the utmost grace and respect while still very much telling its own story. Combat can take a bit to get used to, but feels satisfying after a while with plenty of options at Walker's disposal. Meanwhile, the core investigation aspect of the game is well-executed if a bit unforgiving to the distracted player.

Read original review

Duuro Magazine100/100 → 100 · Z 1.1043Score 95.1338

I went in hoping for a clever blend of two genres and came away with one of my favorite games of the year. The bosses can be punishing, and the Xbox Ally X has occasional dips, but neither issue took much away from the mystery, the remarkable art, or the simple joy of finding a new way through Silver Pines. I loved every minute of the 14 hours it took me to complete. An essential game!

Read original review

Edge Magazine70/100 → 70 · Z -0.5758Score 78.3328

Silver Pines may run on borrowed atmosphere, but the pieces fit together with uncommon skill. [Issue#430, p.123]

Entertainium90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4462Score 88.5529

Visit Silver Pines, it’s got great coffee, a cozy mystery, and gooey monsters to boot. Call in and book your room now!

Read original review

EntreMandos90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6129Score 90.2199

I think it's one of those games that shows there's still room for innovation within the classic survival horror genre without having to copy its formulas to a T. Wych Elm has managed to combine Metroidvania-style exploration, puzzles, resource management, and psychological horror into an adventure with its own unique personality—one that aims to be a clear contender for Indie Game of the Year.

Read original review

Eternal Games80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4854Score 79.2371

In the end, Silver Pines delivers a distinctive survival-horror experience that successfully blends investigation, exploration, combat, and puzzles within a dark world full of secrets. It features a mysterious story, carefully written characters, and wonderful dialogue, alongside a world design that encourages exploration and puzzles that offer a genuine challenge to the player. Despite its clear inspiration from renowned horror games, it possesses its own distinct identity and succeeds in leaving a memorable impression after finishing it. However, the experience is not without its flaws, most notably weak encounters, enemy repetition, and an imbalance in certain strikes—aspects that could have made it much better had they received more attention. Nevertheless, I believe Silver Pines is well worth playing, especially for fans of horror, mystery, and puzzles, as it is one of those experiences whose secrets you will enjoy discovering right up to its final moments.

Read original review

Everyeye.it88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5444Score 89.5347

Silver Pines demonstrates remarkable confidence in its atmosphere, exploration management, and resource utilization, while also revealing room for improvement, especially in its combat mechanics.

Read original review

Everyeye.it88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5457Score 89.5481

For a debut work, the result is remarkably impressive: Silver Pines demonstrates a high degree of confidence in building atmosphere, managing exploration, and handling resources—though there is still room for improvement, particularly regarding combat mechanics. The game expertly blends the essence of a true survival horror with the exploratory structure of a Metroidvania, proving that there is still plenty of scope for experimentation within both genres. Silver Pines is a successful, high-caliber project—the kind of surprise that arrives quietly, yet points toward new, as-yet-unexplored directions.

Read original review

Evilgamerz95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0518Score 94.6087

Silver Pines feels like a true work of art, but it does have one minor drawback, and that is that you sometimes have to persevere a bit to find your next key to success by navigating the map. However, that also has its charm. Especially in the beginning, you really stand there with your mouth open, gazing at the style of this title, and I find that admirable. The world opens up with every step you take and every item you find. The dialogues are short enough and not long-winded, meaning you practically never skip them, making you genuinely want to and try to keep following the story, no matter how many hours you’ve already put into the game—and that is certainly at least fifteen by the end. Furthermore, you don’t necessarily have to discover everything, but you do want to. For that reason alone, Silver Pines might well be one of the most surprising games of this autumn, and there are still quite a few top titles to come. As far as I’m concerned, this game deserves a great deal of respect, even though many people probably haven’t seen this title pass by in the crowded lineup yet.

Read original review

FingerGuns80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0284Score 83.8074

Silver Pines fuses the familiar elements of Metroidvanias and repurposes gameplay systems from survival horrors to innovate in well trodden territory. There's some teething problems with its formula like its less-than-great narrative pace, and some systems not working in conjunction with the rest of its stellar gameplay. However, these are small critiques of what is otherwise an atmospheric, engaging and truly great game.

Read original review

Game890/100 → 90 · Z 0.6271Score 90.3623

Silver Pines proudly wears its darkened, beating heart right on its sleeve, and it is in that unabashed love for its influences that it emerges a confident, distinct experience for survival-horror fans both new and old. Its central mystery will keep you awake and desperately thinking for an answer, while its old-school horror gameplay is a fun, uncompromising love-letter to the genre that remains compelling despite the rough edges. It’s an acquired taste that’s a lot like black coffee: strong, bold, and deeply engaging. To that end, Silver Pines is a damn, fine cup that’ll keep you wired for days.

Read original review

GameBlast90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6944Score 91.035

Every corner of this rain-battered town tells its own story in an effective, mature manner, uniting environmental storytelling, immersive sound design, and exemplary fidelity to the foundations of survival horror and metroidvania. The result cements Silver Pines as a remarkable debut for Wych Elm, delivering an intriguing, authentic investigation that honors its classic inspirations while forging a memorable artistic identity of its own.

Read original review

Gamefa85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0791Score 84.8819

Silver Pines is one of those survival horror games that tries to deliver a unique, memorable, and highly engaging experience by applying interesting twists to the genre's rules and, of course, combining them with its Metroidvania design and exploration philosophy. From the gripping narrative, captivating world-building, and mysterious characters to a structured and cohesive approach in the mechanical dimensions of survival horror and its combination with Metroidvania environmental design philosophy, they all form a mechanism that will immerse you completely. The game's artistic approach contributes to the overall presentation, and the voice acting serves as a powerful complement to it. While some moments or dimensions of the experience feel shaky, ultimately Silver Pines is a solid survival horror experience that fans of the genre shouldn't overlook.

Read original review

Gameliner90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7067Score 91.1578

This chilly yet atmospheric little town has everything it takes for a fantastic horror experience, provided you’re willing to make a few concessions. If you can accept this, an incredible game awaits you, one that has everything it takes to make the hairs on the back of your neck stand on end and drown you in melancholy. For a restless dream of a Metroidvania, Silver Pines is the perfect final destination.

Read original review

GameMAG80/100 → 80 · Z 0.066Score 84.7512

Silver Pines can't be called a groundbreaking horror game. However, it's a solid project with excellent atmosphere of magical mysticism, decent puzzles, and an interesting story. The only thing that can spoil the impression is the unsuccessful combat system.

Read original review

Gamer Guides73/100 → 73 · Z -0.9233Score 74.8583

Silver Pines is a decent Metroidvania game that plays like a solid survival horror title. However, its poor combat can detract from the overall experience, although fans of the genre should still have this on their radar.

Read original review

Gamer Social Club90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4499Score 88.5898

The greatest compliment that I can give to Silver Pines, is that if David Lynch envisaged a Twin Peaks game, I expect it’d look something like Wych Elm’s sensational Metroidvania. The collision of a Twin Peaks-like town, 2D survival horror gameplay and Castlevania exploration was an ambitious project, but I’m delighted to say it has comfortably delivered. The town of Silver Pines is a wonderfully sinister place to explore, it’s story deep and intriguing, and presentation a horrific delight. Silver Pines is the best horror game you can play for Halloween 2026.

Read original review

GamerFocus86/100 → 86 · Z 0.2301Score 86.3918

Silver Pines proves that the survival horror and Metroidvania genres were made for each other. It isn't particularly scary and enemy encounters could be better, but its mysterious *Twin Peaks*-inspired narrative, excellent atmosphere, and superb map design make it an unmissable experience.

Read original review

GameSpew90/100 → 90 · Z 0.66Score 90.6907

Silver Pines is a stunning debut for Wych Elm, being a game that combines the survival horror and Metroidvania genres to great effect. This is a game dripping with atmosphere that will quickly get its hooks in you and not let go. Only its clunky combat brings it down a little, but not enough to stop you from having a blast with it.

Read original review

GamesRadar+90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6195Score 90.2858

Compelling, atmospheric, and brilliant, Silver Pines is a dive into mystery that's hard to put down and even harder to let go. It makes you feel like a detective, an action hero, and a man on the brink of uncovering horrifying darkness all at once.

Read original review

GamesRadar+90/100 → 90 · Z 0.404Score 88.1316

Compelling, atmospheric, and brilliant, Silver Pines is a dive into mystery that's hard to put down and even harder to let go. It makes you feel like a detective, an action hero, and a man on the brink of uncovering horrifying darkness all at once.

Read original review

Gamesurf80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0963Score 83.1282

Silver Pines wears its influences openly, but manages to turn them into a distinctive and coherent survival horror experience. The town itself becomes the real protagonist, rewarding players who remember routes, interpret documents and understand how combat resources can also become exploration tools. Backtracking and puzzles can occasionally become obscure, some interactions feel cumbersome and enemy variety is limited. Still, its atmosphere, resource management and carefully constructed mystery remain compelling long after the credits roll.

Read original review

Gaming Boulevard90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4404Score 88.4953

Silver Pines is a horror search-action game that borrows concepts from established games in the genre and uses them wonderfully to strengthen its own gameplay. The tanky controls and limited inventory kept me anxious as I tried to survive in this abandoned town, while the slowly unravelling story made me doubt whether Red Walker was as sane as he first seemed. The search for Eddie Velvet is a gaming experience that will haunt you like few other PI investigations can.

Read original review

Gaming-Village80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0236Score 83.8551

For me, Silver Pines is less the Metroidvania it's marketed as and much more a classic survival horror game set in a large, interconnected world. And as such, it works brilliantly.

Read original review

GamingBolt80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1518Score 82.5732

Silver Pines follows in the lineage of Silent Hill and Twin Peaks, but as a 2D survival horror game that incorporates elements from Metroidvanias and old school adventure games, it feels like a unique concoction that stands out all its own.

Read original review

GamingTrend90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2904Score 86.9947

The fusion of Silver Pines’ many elements is what allows it to stand out among the horde of alternative survival horror games.

Read original review

Geeks &a; Com80/100 → 80 · Z -0.373Score 80.3608

Silver Pines blends survival horror, investigation, and Metroidvania exploration into a compelling adventure filled with mystery and suspense. Its atmospheric 2.5D presentation, engaging puzzles, and resource management mechanics make exploring the town particularly rewarding. However, awkward combat controls and challenging encounters can lead to frustrating moments. Despite these shortcomings, its fascinating world and strong investigative elements make it a memorable horror experience.

Read original review

Guardian80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2475Score 81.6162

Silver Pines is a game to sit back and wallow in, like a private eye, kicking off his wingtip shoes and pulling that bottle of bourbon from the bottom drawer as rain trickles down the window and sodium street lights paint the walls a sickly shade of yellow.

Read original review

HCL.hr63/100 → 63 · Z -1.7943Score 66.1479

Silver Pines draws you into a beautifully crafted, haunting world with striking visuals and an unsettling atmosphere. However, its appeal gradually fades as excessive and boring backtracking disrupts the pacing, stiff combat makes encounters repetitive, and a surface level narrative struggles to engage. Despite its potential, the game rarely moves beyond familiar territory, struggling to establish an identity of its own.

Read original review

Hobby Consolas84/100 → 84 · Z -0.1881Score 82.2104

Silver Pines proudly embraces its influences. Whilst not exactly original, the legacy of Silent Hill, Resident Evil and the early greats of survival horror brings to life a visually appealing game that is consistent in its gameplay and compelling in its narrative.

Read original review

Insider Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.272Score 81.3716

Ultimately, this debut title from Wych Elm Games is a decent outing, and it’s one that boasts a sumptuous retro vibe, great acting, and interesting combat mechanics. The art style is impressive, the duration is more than worthwhile for the $30 launch price, and I’m a fan of the characters and how they’re presented. I just really wish it wasn’t a 2.5D Metroidvania game.

Read original review

Jeuxvideo.com85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3774Score 87.8656

A respectful homage to Silent Hill and Twin Peaks, Silver Pines stands out primarily for its sublime rotoscoped art direction and its bold fusion of the Metroidvania genre with the suffocating tension of survival horror. Despite some slight stiffness in its gameplay, the game’s methodical exploration loop, unforgiving resource management, and visceral shooting mechanics make for an absolutely memorable ten-hour nocturnal journey.

Read original review

JsemGamer89/100 → 89 · Z 0.5869Score 89.9602

Silver Pines is a wonderfully surreal metroidvania-survival horror hybrid that excels through its Lynchian atmosphere, rewarding exploration, constant sense of progression, clever environmental puzzles, excellent soundtrack, and a mysterious story that leaves plenty of room for interpretation. Frustrating encounters with multiple enemies, fairly simple boss fights, restrictive inventory management, and some intrusive survival mechanics occasionally disrupt the flow, but they do little to diminish an experience that is remarkably easy to get lost in. jsemgamer.cz

Read original review

Jump Dash Roll80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1093Score 82.9984

Silver Pines is a playable episode of an investigative horror show, with atmosphere and exploration to spare

Read original review

Kakuchopurei80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1677Score 82.4144

While a bit rough in some places, you cannot deny the artistry and love behind this horror metroidvania experience. If you have huge love of all things Silent Hill and Twin Peaks, or just video game survival horror in general, you do owe it to yourself to enthrall yourself in this indie wonder.

Read original review

KonsoliFIN90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5573Score 89.6641

The dark visual style, the Lynchian atmosphere, the clever puzzles, and the map that slowly opens up and rewards exploration. Silver Pines is one of the big surprises of the fall, and in many ways I enjoyed it even more than Silent Hill: Townfall – despite the considerable differences in the size and budgets of the teams behind them. For its price point, Wych Elm’s debut is a highly recommendable thriller for fans of the genre, and it certainly doesn’t lack atmosphere.

Read original review

Life is Xbox85/100 → 85 · Z 0.068Score 84.7716

Silver Pines is an entertaining game that plays it safe by following tried and tested methods from the psychological horror playbook. However its unique art style in a metroidvania presentation make it an interesting combination to explore all it has to offer. horror fan or not, Silver Pines has something to offer you.

Read original review

Loot Level Chill80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4067Score 80.0241

Silver Pines has so many facets to its art style, gameplay, and mechanics, with a enjoyable approach to horror and some great nods to old films and games.

Read original review

Meristation90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4624Score 88.7156

Silver Pines is a glorious revival of the 90s survival horror formula. Fans of the early Silent Hill and Resident Evil games will be thrilled by a title that perfectly distills those classics' formulas, opting for 2D gameplay with strong Metroidvania elements.

Read original review

Metacritic Users87/100 → 87 · Z 0.4563Score 88.6546

Metacritic user score 8.7/10 (219 ratings).

MKAU Gaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3668Score 80.4228

Overall, Silver Pines is one of those unexpected gems; the storyline is what rates this game so highly in my view. While the 2D platform aspect can be quite limiting, the developer has squeezed every inch out of it. Admittedly, the combat can be lacking, but you can easily overlook it when you look at the whole package: survival, puzzles, and horror. For such a small development team, Silver Pines is a little gem. I reviewed this on Xbox, but it’s also available on PS5, Switch, and Steam. Go check it out; you won’t be disappointed.

Read original review

Movies Games and Tech90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5906Score 89.9976

Silver Pines is a sharp, moody debut. It mixes survival horror and Metroidvania design with real confidence. The hand-drawn art is gorgeous. All in all, the atmosphere is thick and unsettling. The mystery pulls you forward, and the world rewards curiosity. Combat feels stiff and lacks satisfaction. The game commits to old-school design. If you love atmospheric horror and don’t mind a slow burn, Silver Pines is a must-play this Halloween season.

Read original review

Multiplayer.it80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0856Score 83.2353

It's a compact, tense survival horror game, blending exploration, puzzles, and resource management without ever feeling like the sum of the games it's inspired by.

Read original review

Neutral Game82/100 → 82 · Z -0.3401Score 80.6902

Silver Pines is a standout indie survival horror experience, blending haunting atmosphere, compelling mystery, and clever Metroidvania exploration. Despite some clunky combat and confusing navigation, its distinctive style and psychological tension make it one of 2026’s best indie horror games.

Read original review

Nindie Spotlight91/100 → 91 · Z 0.7884Score 91.9747

Brings a new and distinctive feel to the eShop, blending what would normally feel like an adventure game with horror to create a satisfying and creepy experience

Read original review

NintendoBoy85/100 → 85 · Z 0.067Score 84.7613

Silver Pines delivers a striking and highly atmospheric experience, successfully blending the tension of survival horror with the compelling structure of a 2D metroidvania.

Read original review

Noisy Pixel80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2996Score 81.0955

Silver Pines delivers a memorable blend of survival horror and Metroidvania-inspired exploration, pairing a surreal Lynchian mystery with tense resource management and a densely interconnected town. Its influences can feel overly familiar at times, but strong atmosphere, clever puzzle design, and punishing combat give the experience a distinct identity.

Read original review

NoobFeed80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1883Score 82.2085

Silver Pines rarely nudges you to charge in without thinking. Instead, you read your surroundings, hold onto clues, stretch your supplies, and slowly figure out how the whole town fits together. Puzzles and exploration matter more than fighting, and the mood and story give you a good enough reason to put up with the awkward moments.

Read original review

NookGaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5032Score 89.1233

​Silver Pines is an excellent addition to the horror genre and a great choice for Halloween 2026. It’s quirky, immersive, terrifying, and thought-provoking. It succeeds where many games with larger budgets fail, earning its place among the best recent survival horror titles. The only horrifying aspect of the game is that it doesn’t have a more distinct identity and chooses to lean a little too strongly on its inspirations. The upside, however, is that it serves as a fantastic gateway drug into the surreal world of David Lynch’s brand of horror. The owls may not be what they seem, but Silver Pines absolutely is: it could be the next great horror game in your collection.

Read original review

Oyungezer75/100 → 75 · Z -0.852Score 75.5715

A production with a fantastic atmosphere that pays tribute to the cult classics that inspired it, while captivating players with its visual aesthetic and art direction. Unfortunately, clunky combat mechanics, a story that falls short of expectations, and increasingly repetitive gameplay hold Silver Pines back from becoming one of the year's best.

Read original review

Oyungezer Online75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8338Score 75.7527

A production with a fantastic atmosphere that pays tribute to the cult classics that inspired it, while captivating players with its visual aesthetic and art direction. Unfortunately, clunky combat mechanics, a story that falls short of expectations, and increasingly repetitive gameplay hold Silver Pines back from becoming one of the year's best.

Read original review

PCMGAMES80/100 → 80 · Z -0.49Score 79.1912

Silver Pines is one of the biggest surprises of the year. Its blend of Metroidvania and survival horror works wonderfully thanks to well-crafted exploration, an intriguing story, and an atmosphere that draws you in from the start. The combat is a bit clunky and doesn't quite measure up to the rest of the game, but it doesn't detract from an adventure that comes highly recommended, especially if you're a fan of Resident Evil.

Read original review

Pixel Byte90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6726Score 90.817

Silver Pines is an incredibly ambitious first entry from new developer Wych Elm. Yes, it deliberately takes the addictive Resident Evil inventory system and Silent Hill’s imprecise but unnerving combat. The narrative itself percolates Twin Peaks and The X-Files to a perfect distillation of them, but never losing its identity. Wrapping it up in a metroidvania layout that dukes it out with the best of them, and you have a wicked formula for success. Red may be having the worst night of life, but you most certainly will enjoy one of your best.

Read original review

Pizza Fria88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3457Score 87.5485

Silver Pines is an excellent survival horror game. Although it falters in some aspects of its narrative development, the game masterfully leverages its greatest strength: adding Metroidvania-style exploration to a combination of ideas that were already very good on their own.

Read original review

Play Watch Read80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0604Score 83.4874

Silver Pines borrows many elements from well-known series such as The X-Files, Twin Peaks, Resident Evil, and Silent Hill. However, the studio does so in a respectful and well-executed manner. Everything just fits together, and the visual style is impressive. Silver Pines is the kind of game that invites you to explore every detail—though, given the many releases arriving this autumn, you’ll likely only get around to it once you’ve finished those larger titles.

Read original review

PlayStation Universe85/100 → 85 · Z 0.059Score 84.6811

Silver Pines tries to mesh two very different genres, combining survival horror with 2D Metroidvania. This makes for a refreshingly paced approach to the formula, asking you to step into the shoes of a down-on-his-luck detective as he tries to figure out what happened in Silver Pines. The horror elements may not weigh very heavily on the experience, but it helps to build intrigue for the Metroidvania side of the game, making it very compelling to explore the map. Silver Pines makes a name for itself in spades.

Read original review

Power Unlimited Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4147Score 79.9437

Silver Pines doesn’t really have a single unique mechanic or element of its own. What it does come up with, however, is a surprisingly seamless combination of all those familiar elements. I’d even go so far as to say it manages to perfect some of them. [Issue#375, p.54]

PPE.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3792Score 80.2992

Silver Pines is a successful blend of survival horror and metroidvania, effectively evoking genre classics with its excellent atmosphere, distinctive town, and limited resources.

Read original review

Press Attack80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4914Score 79.1767

Silver Pines is a metroidvania survival horror game developed by Wych Elm and published by Team17. In his quest to find the missing musician Eddie Velvet, private detective Red Walker travels to Silver Pines, a small town in the United States that is practically deserted due to a severe weather alert that forced everyone to evacuate. Searching for clues to Eddie Velvet's whereabouts, Red Walker scours the town and soon realizes that something dark hangs over it. Strange and aggressive creatures roam the area, making the detective's life difficult. He must investigate the case of the missing musician while trying to unravel the mystery of Silver Pines, all while attempting to survive the town's dangers. Silver Pines brings a breath of fresh air to survival horror games, with a new visual and perspective approach, while maintaining the standard characteristics of the genre. Its deliberately slow pace is essential for building tension, along with excellent sound and visual appeal. The story is initially intriguing, but loses momentum over time. The controls, while serving their purpose in the narrative, didn't appeal to me as much, being a bit frustrating at times. The exploration and investigation, as well as the puzzles, are the highlight for me. Even though I'm seeing everything in third person and with a side camera that allows me a wide field of view, you really feel scared and apprehensive about moving forward without knowing what's coming. Silver Pines shows that it's possible to be innovative even in genres that seem to need nothing new.

Read original review

ProGamers.life90/100 → 90 · Z 0.52Score 89.2914

Silver Pines is a beautiful homage to David Lynch, Angelo Badalamenti, and Alan Parker; it draws upon the influences of these masters to craft its own story which, within the classic survival horror framework, stands as one of the genre's finest examples and one of the best games of the year.

Read original review

PS3Blog.net90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7618Score 91.709

2.5 survival horror Metroidvania set in a creepy town in the middle of nowhere

Read original review

PSX Brasil90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4984Score 89.0754

Silver Pines is an immersive 2D survival horror game that skillfully blends Lynchian suspense, psychological terror, and the classic resource management of renowned PlayStation-era survival horror titles. Its contrasting visuals, excellent voice work, and highly interconnected level design are its greatest strengths. On the other hand, the limited variety of enemies and the simplicity of the combat could be better. Even so, it is an easy recommendation for fans of the genre and of David Lynch's universe.

Read original review

Pure Dead Gaming95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9008Score 93.0994

Silver Pines evokes the likes of Resident Evil, Silent Hill and Twin Peaks. Fans of those, or of a strong metroidvania, should treat this as a must-play. In a year as stacked as 2026, it’s difficult for games to get the time they deserve, but it would be criminal to let this one slip through your fingers. One of my favourite horror games this generation.

Read original review

Push Square80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1239Score 85.3303

Silver Pines is a spectacular take on the metroidvania genre, weaving survival horror, Lynchian mystery, and some tantalising visuals into one big atmospheric thriller. There's inspiration from Silent Hill and Alan Wake, but amidst all the influence, Silver Pines manages to be its own unique thing and one of the biggest surprises of 2026.

Read original review

RageQuit.GR93/100 → 93 · Z 0.8027Score 92.118

For their very first attempt, Wych Elm have knocked it out of the park. The influences from the masterworks of Lynch, Remedy and Silent Hill, the thriller steeped in ’90s Americana, the discovery of the city’s secrets, and that sense of unease and anticipation about what we’ll encounter every time we step into a new area, blended together in an unforgettable experience.

Read original review

Ragequit.gr93/100 → 93 · Z 0.8365Score 92.4563

For their very first attempt, Wych Elm have knocked it out of the park. The influences from the masterworks of Lynch, Remedy and Silent Hill, the thriller steeped in ’90s Americana, the discovery of the city’s secrets, and that sense of unease and anticipation about what we’ll encounter every time we step into a new area, blended together in an unforgettable experience.

Read original review

Region Free80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2104Score 81.9875

If you're a fan of horror games, Metroidvanias, and David Lynch, you owe it to yourself to play Silver Pines. It's that simple.

Read original review

República DG92/100 → 92 · Z 0.7599Score 91.6902

Silver Pines delivers a heavy story, blending classic and modern noir elements into an experience worthy of a podium finish at major gaming awards.

Read original review

Screen Hype100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2934Score 97.025

For their very first game, Wych Elm have blown it out of the park. I recommend Silver Pines to everyone: fans of horror, Metroidvanias, and detective stories. I even encourage those new to those genres to try it out, as it encapsulates a beautifully cinematic experience with a story you’ll want to uncover for yourself.

Read original review

SECTOR.sk80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2592Score 81.4994

Silent Hill isn't the only dilapidated, spooky town where something evil lurks. Welcome to Silver Pines. The game also brings the Resident Evil series to mind, though it is presented in 2D and makes significant use of Metroidvania elements.

Read original review

SECTOR.sk80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2008Score 82.0827

Silent Hill isn't the only dilapidated, spooky town where something evil lurks. Welcome to Silver Pines. The game also brings the Resident Evil series to mind, though it is presented in 2D and makes significant use of Metroidvania elements.

Read original review

Smash Jump90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6066Score 90.1567

I loved my time with this game and even amongst an impressive crop of horror titles I feel confident that Silver Pines can go toe to toe with the best of them. Silver Pines is well worth a visit.

Read original review

SomGeek85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2945Score 87.0359

Silver Pines is a somewhat unconventional addition to the survival horror genre. However, it makes excellent use of tried-and-tested mechanics and beloved genre tropes, making it a definite hit with any fan of the genre. Were it not for a few minor shortcomings, it could have been a truly perfect and unique experience.

Read original review

SteamDeckHQ90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4375Score 88.4665

Silver Pines is a great survival-horror that came just at the perfect time. The story is intriguing, the atmosphere is gloomy and creepy, the puzzles are intricate and interesting, and the combat is decent and enjoyable. The minor missed steps with its story and aiming guns are easily forgiven when looking at the bigger picture, and it’s hard not to love it.

Read original review

STWGames Italia88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4373Score 88.4641

In short, if you grew up on classic survival horror games and love fragmented narratives, the desolate town of Silver Pines is a destination you absolutely can't afford to miss.

Read original review

Supernovas85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0755Score 84.8462

For those who miss the careful exploration found in classic survival horror games and enjoy adventures that blend investigation with Metroidvania-style progression, Silver Pines has a lot to offer. It is an experience with a distinct identity, though some of its mechanics could still use further refinement to match the quality of its presentation.

Read original review

TechStomper90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2844Score 86.9354

Silver Pines's combat could do with a little more polish and the backtracking can wear thin, but there’s plenty here to keep horror fans hooked.

Read original review

The Games Machine81/100 → 81 · Z -0.328Score 80.8115

Silver Pines blends survival horror, adventure, and Metroidvania elements with surprising balance. The gameplay hinges entirely on Red Walker’s vulnerability: few resources, a limited inventory, slow reloads, aim without a crosshair, and combat where every mistake counts. Exploration works well thanks to shortcuts, secret passages, and tools that open up new paths in areas you’ve already visited. The atmosphere, level design, and tension management are excellent. Less successful are some overly scripted encounters, enemy designs that aren’t always memorable, and a rather basic adventure component. An interesting hybrid, stronger than the sum of its parts.

Read original review

The Punished Backlog90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725

Despite its narrative shortcomings, Silver Pines is a terrific survival-horror adventure, perfectly suited for a handheld like the Steam Deck or Nintendo Switch. As a Twin Peaks or detective-themed metroidvania, there’s nothing quite like it. The game marries gameplay and narrative design to create a compelling experience that never lets up.  As much as I loved its Pacific Northwest, surrealist police procedural vibe, I wish that its characters and venues felt a little more unique. Silver Pines is so rich for what it does differently than other indie and legacy metroidvanias out there, so it’s a shame the game can’t quite pull away from its obvious homages. Even as an imitation, though, there's plenty here to love.

Read original review

The Wand Report80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1883Score 85.9742

A clumsy combat system and too much cause to engage with it are not enough to derail this excellent and atmospheric horror that repeatedly brings to mind horror masters but refuses to relitigate them through pastiche and hero-worship, even as it evokes the best of them.

Read original review

TheSixthAxis90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7514Score 91.605

Silver Pines is yet another excellent indie horror game and would not be out of place as part of the Silent Hill franchise. The combination of survival horror and more involved platforming exploration works fantastically well, while the town is chock-full of hidden secrets with enigmatic mysteries to solve.

Read original review

Tourens80/100 → 80 · Z -0.299Score 81.1009

Silver Pines offers such an immersive experience that once you start playing, you won’t want to stop for a long time. Considering that this is the development team’s first game, I can say that despite some shortcomings, they’ve produced a quite successful title.

Read original review

Uagna90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6963Score 91.0537

Silver Pines is an atmospheric game, a Metroidvania-style survival horror title that draws heavily from genre classics like Silent Hill, Resident Evil, and Alan Wake, as well as from television and film, such as Twin Peaks, The X-Files, and The Shining. However, these inspirations don’t reduce Wych Elm’s work to a mere collection of references; thanks to excellent storytelling, they allow the game to carve out its own path between nightmare and mystery. Solid gameplay underpins the experience, reinterpreting the genre’s conventions without forcing a radical overhaul. It’s also impossible not to mention the excellent art direction, featuring rotoscoped animations, and the soundtrack, with atmospheric music that heightens the tension. Silver Pines is a haunting adventure, a glimpse into the mystery of identity that straddles the line between reality and imagination.

Read original review

Uagna.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6265Score 90.3565

Silver Pines is an atmospheric game, a Metroidvania-style survival horror title that draws heavily from genre classics like Silent Hill, Resident Evil, and Alan Wake, as well as from television and film, such as Twin Peaks, The X-Files, and The Shining. However, these inspirations don’t reduce Wych Elm’s work to a mere collection of references; thanks to excellent storytelling, they allow the game to carve out its own path between nightmare and mystery. Solid gameplay underpins the experience, reinterpreting the genre’s conventions without forcing a radical overhaul. It’s also impossible not to mention the excellent art direction, featuring rotoscoped animations, and the soundtrack, with atmospheric music that heightens the tension. Silver Pines is a haunting adventure, a glimpse into the mystery of identity that straddles the line between reality and imagination.

Read original review

Use a Potion85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2006Score 82.0848

Silver Pines nails that classic survival horror game vibe, all whilst adding some impressive modern touches to exploration across its Metroidvania-style world. I had a really good time uncovering its world, solving its satisfying puzzles, and unravelling its unsettling narrative (even if it is guilty of being a bit derivative in places), whilst the gorgeous visuals really do give it a distinct sense of style. It’s just a really, really good game - horror fans have truly been spoilt lately, and Silver Pines is another release they won’t want to miss out on.

Read original review

Vandal80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4373Score 79.7179

Wych Elm delivers a solid old-school survival horror experience with interconnected exploration, puzzles, resource management, and a haunting watercolor-inspired art style that creates a compelling atmosphere, although its clunky combat and deliberately dated mechanics may not appeal to everyone.

Read original review

VDGMS80/100 → 80 · Z -0.514Score 78.9508

Resident Evil, Silent Hill and even Dead Space are among the greatest survival horror classics that can easily be seen as inspiration for Silver Pines. Rather than just being a love letter to this era, Silver Pines strongly carves out its own identity with Metroidvania inspired level design without the backtracking pitfalls. Like many survival horror, combat is the weakness, especially at the bosses, and coincidentally, it suffers the same problems that Prince of Persia had due to its visual style with a lack of precision. Outside of that and a few other minor complaints, Silver Pines is one of the most unique survival horror games in years and an absolute must for fans of the 90’s and early genre icons.

Read original review

Virtualni Kutak85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0181Score 84.2721

Carried by its genuinely stellar atmosphere, Silver Pines should be considered an essential, "you can't-miss this" experience for all survival horror aficionados. The lack of fast-paced map traversal and its overall glacial pacing will undoubtedly turn some people away, but the game absolutely has plenty to offer open-minded players looking for a refreshing change of pace and a welcome break from high-octane action and hardcore platforming gauntlets.

Read original review

Xbox Achievements80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2202Score 81.8889

The early moments of Silver Pines are like a warm blanket. All the fixtures and furniture are in place. A private detective in a long brown coat. A ...

Read original review

ZTGD90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4856Score 88.9469

Dan does some creepy exploration in his latest review.

Read original review