3DNews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5356Score 89.4472Score 89.4472Z 0.5356The Mermaid Mask turned out to be not only the most successful game about detective Grimoire, but also one of the best detective adventures in recent years.
Read original review
Adventure Game Hotspot91/100 → 91 · Z 0.563Score 89.7215Score 89.7215Z 0.563The Detective Grimoire series reaches a new apex in The Mermaid Mask, which first equals and then outshines its beloved predecessors in nearly every way that matters.
Read original review
Console Creatures80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1411Score 82.6805Score 82.6805Z -0.1411The Mermaid Mask is a smart and thoughtful game where you’ll use your deduction skills to uncover the mystery behind the death of Captain Mortuga. In that journey, you’ll experience various twists and hard truths that come together to tell a smart story well worth the price of admission, and it’s bolstered by a wonderful cast that is having a blast playing these characters.
Read original review
Digital Chumps90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2834Score 86.9249Score 86.9249Z 0.2834The Mermaid Mask from developer SFB Games is a point-and-click marvel that brings with it a good story, modern gameplay design, and a respectful tip-of-the-hat to an old genre.
Read original review
Edge Magazine80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1163Score 85.2543Score 85.2543Z 0.1163For three or four hours, we get to fully inhabit the role of detective, putting our theories into action while in response the game delivers one major revelation after the next. The answers it supplies are all satisfying - never a given, in this genre - and by the time it's all wrapped up, the all-important supporting cast have been left in some interesting places. [Issue#426, p.118]
Game Informer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3039Score 87.1297Score 87.1297Z 0.3039The Mermaid Mask is the best Detective Grimoire adventure yet. Its art, music, voice cast, and puzzle design are all worthy of praise, but they're held together by a great story and a fun script, complete with all the quips and twists I've come to expect from SFB's mystery series. I spent my entire playthrough engrossed and engaged, and I hope the development team gets to make plenty more sequels.
Read original review
GameHope.com85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3916Score 88.007Score 88.007Z 0.3916The Mermaid Mask is just as successful, if not more so, than its two predecessors.
Read original review
Gameliner60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2203Score 71.8881Score 71.8881Z -1.2203The Mermaid Mask is an enjoyable detective adventure that shines thanks to its memorable characters, engaging murder mystery, and the entertaining chemistry between Grimoire and Sally. While the investigation remains compelling throughout, its low difficulty and predictable finale may leave seasoned sleuths wanting more. Minor technical and audio issues occasionally disrupt the experience, but it still delivers a compact and satisfying point-and-click mystery for genre fans.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4499Score 88.5898Score 88.5898Z 0.4499So, does The Mermaid Mask structure that decent denouement? Absolutely. The Mermaid Mask is a polished, clever, and thoroughly charming addition to the Detective Grimoire series. It manages to iterate on the mechanics of Tangle Tower without losing the cozy, inquisitive spirit of the original flash games. It is arguably the series’ greatest entry yet, it sets a remarkably high bar for future sequels by perfectly balancing complex puzzle-solving with the undeniable charm of its characters. Yes, it may be a little easy for die-hard fans of the genre, and there is a lot of dialogue but for fans of detective fiction and point-and-click adventures, this is a must-play. Magnus Mortuga might be dead, but the series has never been more alive.
Read original review
GamerFocus78/100 → 78 · Z -0.5813Score 78.2777Score 78.2777Z -0.5813The Mermaid Mask is an excellent detective adventure with a well-crafted narrative full of mysteries, memorable characters, fun puzzles, and plenty of personality. Some pacing issues in the first half and a spanish translation that omits a few details detract from the experience, but it's well worth immersing yourself in the mysteries of the submarine Mortuga alongside Grimoire and Sally.
Read original review
Gaming-Village80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0236Score 83.8551Score 83.8551Z -0.0236Actually, the word “pleasant” describes The Mermaid Mask very well. The story, the characters, the sound, and the graphics are exactly that: pleasant. Not mind-blowing, but very, very nice.
Read original review
Guardian80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2475Score 81.6162Score 81.6162Z -0.2475Some players may find this completion percentage approach too formulaic, especially if they exhaust their current inventory and resort to pixel hunting to locate the rest. And the pacing does falter in the final chapter, where the game presents you with a more literal checklist to work through before you get to tie up each character’s loose ends and make your final accusation. But while the conclusion of The Mermaid Mask feels far more satisfying than that of Tangle Tower, these games are far more about the twisty journey and the laughs you have along the way.
Read original review
Kakuchopurei90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5888Score 89.9792Score 89.9792Z 0.5888The Mermaid Mask is a well-written adventure title with a quirky and fun cast of characters and weirdos, great pacing, brain-taxing logic puzzles that fit with the world it's in, and a juicy mystery with good amounts of deducing and second-guessing on the player's side.
Read original review
Loot Level Chill80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4067Score 80.0241Score 80.0241Z -0.4067Everything in The Mermaid Mask comes together to create one seriously compelling whodunnit packed with charm, wit and driven by a memorable cast of characters.
Read original review
Maximum Utmost90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5988Score 90.0794Score 90.0794Z 0.5988For a lot of The Mermaid Mask's runtime, I often reflected on how flawlessly it delivers on its intent. The art, animation, voice acting, and music are excellent in the ways that support the narrative, and the narrative itself is top shelf. You may not be given very much agency when it comes to solving the mystery, but it doesn’t feel that way, and the time spent with the quirky, whimsical, but believable characters is a delight. This is one that you’ll want to investigate.
Read original review
Nindie Spotlight87/100 → 87 · Z 0.4507Score 88.5983Score 88.5983Z 0.4507This follow-up adventure to the excellent Tangle Tower once again delivers on a promise of smart writing, fun characters, and approachable mystery solving
Read original review
Nintendo Life80/100 → 80 · Z -0.038Score 83.7116Score 83.7116Z -0.038The Mermaid Mask finds a brilliantly entertaining niche between deduction game and point-and-click. The tangled mystery of the death of Captain Mortuga is full of compelling twists and every suspect adds a surprise along the way. Some tacked-on logic puzzles slightly break the dramatic flow, but not enough to undo the magic of a well-constructed puzzle box of a game.
Read original review
NintendoWorldReport95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8823Score 92.9139Score 92.9139Z 0.8823It is so hard to weave a compelling mystery adventure but SFB Games have simply struck gold with this fourth Detective Grimoire adventure. The passion for their work oozes from the game and I think it is impossible to not love all of these characters. Frankly I cannot wait to see them return to the world of Detective Grimoire. But until then, The Mermaid Mask is a must for anyone looking to dive into the weekend with an engrossing mystery experience.
Read original review
Noisy Pixel90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5494Score 89.585Score 89.585Z 0.5494The Mermaid Mask is a charming and expertly crafted detective adventure that combines an engrossing locked-room mystery with exceptional character writing, sharp humor, and outstanding presentation. While a few interaction quirks occasionally interrupt the investigation, its memorable cast, intuitive puzzles, and captivating atmosphere make it one of the year's standout mystery games.
Read original review
NoobFeed90/100 → 90 · Z 0.625Score 90.3415Score 90.3415Z 0.625The Mermaid Mask is a talkative, gorgeous, occasionally too generous mystery that leans on its cast more than on puzzles. The title stands as one of the better detective games out this year.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %96.42857142857144/100 → 96.4286 · Z 0.9915Score 94.0064Score 94.0064Z 0.991596.4% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (28 reviews).
Pixel Byte90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6726Score 90.817Score 90.817Z 0.6726SFB Games knows how to make a great whodunit. Combatting the usual point-and-click slog of characters sluggishly pointing out an observation, everything is wittily described. The Mermaid Mask shines as a murder mystery because of the attention to every painstaking detail. The theatrical cast, stylish art style, and impeccable structure make for one of those cases that beg to be solved.
Read original review
Shacknews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6898Score 90.9892Score 90.9892Z 0.6898The Mermaid Mask is a mystery full of quirk and intrigue that pulls the player in and keeps them going with a riveting story of wayward souls and their mysterious benefactor. I easily lost track of time getting to know the ins and outs of all of this cast, their triumphs and tragedies, and their secrets and ambitions. I loved the animated swagger and dialogue that brought them to life and the music that emphasized their personas. I also loved the digging and piecing together of puzzles and the characters to which they related. It’s a little wordy compared to its action, and you can throw clues at the wall until one sticks in some cases, but The Mermaid Mask still feels like a smart, silly, and charming mystery that will lock mystery lovers into its intriguing tale of ambition, legacy, and obsession.
Read original review
Siliconera90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6233Score 90.3246Score 90.3246Z 0.6233The Detective Grimoire game The Mermaid Mask is pretty much a perfect point-and-click adventure.
Read original review
So Many Games70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059Score 73.6059Z -1.0485As far as narrative puzzle games go, The Mermaid Mask definitely doesn’t disappoint: the world, the people inhabiting it, and the dialogue in between will always be a treat, though it is let down by some pacing issues in its grand finale, as well as a few puzzles that are needlessly obtuse. Regardless, it proves itself a worthy addition to the Detective Grimoire series and hopefully not the last we will see. Sadly, a lack of meaningful accessibility options also means the game loses half a star.
Read original review
SomGeek90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6635Score 90.7258Score 90.7258Z 0.6635The Mermaid Mask is undoubtedly one of this year’s true highlights in the world of detective adventures. A very well-crafted mystery, interesting characters, and a satisfying resolution — what more could you possibly need?
Read original review
SteamDeckHQ90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4375Score 88.4665Score 88.4665Z 0.4375The Mermaid Mask is that wonderful blend of mechanics, setting, and storytelling that all just works, to quote a certain Bethesda bloke. While it is ‘just a point-and-click puzzle game’, it is much greater than the sum of its parts, and I loved almost everything about it.
Read original review
STWGames Italia89/100 → 89 · Z 0.5172Score 89.263Score 89.263Z 0.5172The Mermaid Mask is an excellent cozy mystery adventure that draws the player into a compelling narrative without ever pushing them too hard. In addition to excellent writing—both in the progression of events (an essential element of a good mystery) and in character development—the game also stands out thanks to its distinctive visual style and top-notch art design. A few lulls in the middle don’t detract from the overall experience, which still manages to hold your attention right up to the game’s excellent conclusion—an aspect that had left more than a few players feeling underwhelmed in Tangle Tower. This experience is recommended for anyone looking for a lighthearted mystery, but also for those who want to discover one of the most successful and enjoyable indie games of the year.
Read original review
The Gamerheads Podcast100/100 → 100 · Z 0.9198Score 93.2892Score 93.2892Z 0.9198The Mermaid Mask is a fantastic point-and-click whodunit adventure. I love that the game doesn’t overtly hold my hand, allowing me to work through the case on my own, yet it’s so well designed that it still points me in the right direction. The art and music are so well done, and the voice acting is top-notch. It also features some of the best writing and humor I’ve experienced in a game. If you’re a fan of quirky murder mysteries like Knives Out, you need to check out The Mermaid Mask.
Read original review
The Punished Backlog90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5681Score 89.7725Score 89.7725Z 0.5681There are a few times in The Mermaid Mask where characters, such as a tormented author, will make comments about how hard it is to make a sequel or that "this is a lot of work; I don't know if I'll do it again." And I can't disagree; it seems incredibly difficult.
I've been editing my own novel for a few years now and it is... quite painful. But what keeps me going is the idea that some day, my mom might get to read my book and really love it, and maybe other people will, too. So, I say to SFB Games and brothers Vian, if you have finished your journey with these games, I would understand, but I'd be sad — The Mermaid Mask is an excellent game, and I can only imagine how brilliant the next one would be.
Read original review
The Wand Report100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4101Score 98.1925Score 98.1925Z 1.4101Sharp, full of wit, and driven by a charming writing and voice acting, The Mermaid’s Mirror is more proof that within broader industry existential anxieties and subsequent self-destruction, you don’t need photorealism and bank-breaking budgets to create something cinematic, compelling, and enchanting.
Read original review
Thumb Culture100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0077Score 94.1677Score 94.1677Z 1.0077The Mermaid Mask is to me difficult to say if it’s great or amazing. The reason I hesitate is because of the fact, that I don’t want to discourage SFB Games from making another entry into this series. Sure the last game was back in 2019 being Tangle Tower and I cannot blame them. Making something as great as the Tangle Tower is difficult. However, they should know that they lived up to that game with The Mermaid Mask.
It goes to show that since Newgrounds when they made the first Grimoire game. Then made the next entry on PC which surpassed the Newgrounds version. Following after with Tangle Tower and now Mermaid Mask are all showing that you guys haven’t lost your touch. Here’s to hoping for another entry in about 6 or 7 years from now. I give The Mermaid Mask the Thumb Culture Platinum Award
Read original review
Use a Potion95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7689Score 91.7805Score 91.7805Z 0.7689The Mermaid Mask is a clever, charming, and incredibly polished mystery that had me hooked the entire way through. Whether it’s the intriguing storytelling, the rewarding sleuthing, the vibrant visuals, or the excellent sound design, it hits an incredibly high standard throughout, all whilst delivering enough of a challenge to ensure each part of the case that you crack is rewarding… it’s just really, REALLY good, and arguably, one of the best detective games you’ll play this year.
Read original review
Video Chums77/100 → 77 · Z -0.4639Score 79.4521Score 79.4521Z -0.4639The Mermaid Mask presents an intriguing story wrapped in a super-impressive presentation although it could do with an improved hint system to help it from becoming tedious and repetitive. 🧜♀️
Read original review