SourceCritic

Thumb Wars

20 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj88
Raw spread σj7.4833
Shrunk mean μ′j85.6547
Shrunk spread σ′j10.4517

Reviews from this outlet

007 First Light90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

007 First Light is exactly what a modern-day James Bond game should be. Action-packed set pieces, decent combat, fun shooting, a story that feels like you’re responsible for the world and a smattering of sex appeal. All wrapped up in a beautiful, globe-trotting adventure that makes you stop and stare, whilst Bond, played by Patrick Gibson, spits out some snarky, witty comment to anyone that’ll listen. Great fun, great first entry in the IP and a game that’ll be up there come award season.

Read original review

Aphelion90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

For me, the overall world of Aphelion was incredible to behold, as the scenery was very beautiful, and I couldn’t wait to see what was waiting for me around each corner. The gameplay was very challenging in the sense that it was fun to play, but there were a few issues during my run that made it very problematic and made me lose my patience. The game’s story was fantastic, with emotions bursting at the seams with every cutscene, dialogue, and location being filled with so much emotional impact that even a person like me, who doesn’t feel emotion that often, was able to feel for Aphelion.

Read original review

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3725Score 97.8165

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is a masterpiece that continues to grow from strength to strength as its incredible story progresses, making it an unmissable title for 2025 and beyond. It is a work of art that must be experienced at least once. Its story, cast, gameplay, and music blend together to create an experience that raises the bar for video games across genres, while its combat and levels are a dream come true for RPG fans.

Read original review

CONTROL Resonant100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3725Score 97.8165

Overall my experience with Control Resonant ended with me being very pleased with everything involved, as the combat was very in-depth and was constantly shifting, allowing for new gameplay styles and combinations. The story followed Remedy Entertainment’s usual style that kept me guessing right to the credits, and even then I wasn’t sure what I saw was the truth or if there was more to find. Finally, the game’s world was simply a lot of fun to explore with the various abilities being unlocked that made it easier while also providing me with enough challenges that I had to come back in the future.

Read original review

Farthest Frontier80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

During my time with Farthest Frontier, I found it to be a fun and relaxing game that allowed me to slowly piece together what I needed to do while also creating a beautiful cityscape from the ground up. The overall mechanics of the game were relatively simple, with very little to learn throughout my entire playthrough. However, there were a few moments when I found myself confused and struggling to understand one or two mechanics. The world itself is wonderful, with numerous landscapes and locations to choose from, each filled with incredible detail.

Read original review

Hell is Us80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

Hell is Us hits so many of the milestones the developers clearly wanted to, with ominous, environmental storytelling brilliantly achieved, a dark and brooding story that’ll have you questioning your own humanity, and a supernatural tale that weaves into all of that seamlessly, elevating it further. Issues with optimization aside, you’d be missing out if you don’t give Hell is Us a real chance, and it may just be Nacon’s best offering yet.

Read original review

KARMA: The Dark World90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

Overall, Karma: The Dark World was an enjoyable experience that managed to keep me on my toes with the gameplay loop as well as have me questioning everything that was going on as I explored some of the most haunting locations both in reality and mind.

Read original review

Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

Ryu Ga Gotoku Studio has crafted a thing of beauty here. Managing to send the already finely balanced franchise into the land of absurdity with the pirate theme, the studio still pulled together a tight enough experience that’ll have you laughing, shouting, crying, and enjoying every single moment. More Majima moving forward, please.

Read original review

MIO: Memories in Orbit90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

MIO: Memories in Orbit for me was a very fun experience that provided a lot of challenges in terms of combat, while also providing me with the option to downscale the difficulty if I needed to in rather unique ways. The biggest draw for me was the beautiful world that the game is set in, with the incredible watercolor detail and the breathtaking views that were waiting around each corner. The story was also very good and was a very big tear-jerker, but it was very challenging to ensure I saw it all due to the hidden lore pieces scattered around the game.

Read original review

MOUSE: P.I. For Hire80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

Mouse P.I. For Hire is a ridiculous good time, with solid level design, good-to-great voice performances and an art style I will not shut up about. Gunplay is hit and miss, mostly hit, and the pop culture references can be a bit too much sometimes, but if anyone were to ask if they should play Mouse? Well, that’d be the easiest yes of the year.

Read original review

Opus: Prism Peak80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

The best thing I can say about Opus: Prism Peak is that I was thinking about it long after I rolled credits. It doesn’t do much gameplay wise, but what it does do, it does incredibly well. Tight story, actual important message and some genuinely heartfelt moments meant even my cold, cynical heart was warmed a little. You won’t regret giving this a punt.

Read original review

Pragmata90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

Pragmata feels like a love letter to numerous sci-fi IPs, and while it may have taken six years to actually release, it seems every single day was one well used by the developers. Gorgeous to look at, fun to play and like a brain worm that’ll keep you thinking about it, Capcom is having an incredible 2026, and a great flagbearer for taking a risk on new IPs.

Read original review

Resident Evil Requiem100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3725Score 97.8165

Overall, Resident Evil: Requiem is a very fun game that blends horror and chaotic gunplay well together, allowing for two different gameplay genres to blend together in a way that doesn’t force the player into a bad situation but allows them to alter their gameplay style on the fly. The game’s overall story is brilliant, with a lot of memorable moments that will stick with gamers for years, while also bringing back old memories from the original games. The game’s world is beautiful with so much detail that players will never be able to spot it all, while also being able to use this game world to their advantage within the gameplay loop.

Read original review

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is a big step up for the franchise in a lot of ways. It's better in the puzzle and exploration department, with beautiful areas designed to perfection. The combat is a new addition that makes it more fast-paced compared to previous titles, and the audio is top notch. Seriously, I can't shut up about it. The story does pull at the heart strings whilst also expanding everything we thought we knew about the universe, but is maybe a chapter or two too long. It's not the best in the franchise, but it's close to the complete package.

Read original review

Split Fiction100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3725Score 97.8165

Hazelight Studios has crafted an adventure that almost transcends what it is, a video game, and goes a long way to prove that games are as much art as books and films. Split Fiction is one of the best games of the year, this generation of gaming ,and potentially ever, with equal measures of finesse in its execution and brass balls to take some big risks. It’s one of those games you don’t want to miss.

Read original review

The Blood of Dawnwalker90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

While I played through The Blood of Dawnwalker, I had a fantastic time exploring the game's open world as I fought the numerous monsters and humans in gruelling combat with fantastic abilities that look as cool as they feel. I was also able to enjoy the large story with its numerous consequences and choices that lasted the entire game. Although the gameplay is fun it can get repetitive doing the same side content, but it is very far and few between allowing a break between them.

Read original review

The First Berserker: Khazan80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

A beginner’s introduction to difficult games, The First Berserker: Khazan has many of the accessibility options Soulslikes/Action RPG fans have cried out for, and it does it all with an excellent combat system, interesting lore and story, and some fine visuals.

Read original review

The Relic: First Guardian80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

The Relic: First Guardian is Project Cloud Games debut title. It has some issues, like performance issues and a lack of some basic mechanics like jumping, but the world-building, the skill tree, the combat, the bosses and the feeling of wonder we all need and love from Soulslike is present. It has jank sure, but it has heart, and it’s one of my favourite experiences of the year, and something that I will continually be heading back to for the next few months.

Read original review

Thick as Thieves80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

While playing Thick as Thieves, I found myself often enjoying the landscape of the game world, both inside the maps and out, as they were well designed with most rooms having a reasonable amount of detail, if not a lot. The gameplay of Thick as Thieves is a lot of fun, allowing stealth players to use all they have mastered, along with various tools, to their advantage in order to steal everything that isn’t nailed down. In regard to the game’s story, it was really interesting to see, as it didn’t just explore the game as we explored it, but it also expanded upon what we didn’t see and the hidden lore that was buried within.

Read original review

Tides of Tomorrow90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4158Score 88.2487

During my time with Tides of Tomorrow, I had a lot of fun exploring the game’s colorful and unique world, as each location had plenty to explore and uncover while also being very different from each other in more ways than one. In terms of the game’s story, I enjoyed it quite a lot as the overall tone of the game was very dark in a lot of ways, but also hit quite hard as it commented on topics like pollution, with other topics sitting with me long after the credits rolled. The best part for me was the gameplay mechanics, as following another player and sharing the response to their actions was a lot of fun, but it did lead me to suffer too many consequences to the point I was locked out of too many options within my playthrough.

Read original review