SourceCritic

Thick as Thieves

68.2597SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 64.2245 · 49 reviews

2026 · PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, PC

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

But Why Tho?55/100 → 55 · Z -2.3862Score 60.2291

With updates, Thick as Thieves has the potential to deliver a more exciting heist simulator, but it won’t do that with just two characters and two maps to choose from. For now, all it provides is mindless repetition and half-baked stealth.

Read original review

CGMagazine65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5206Score 68.8849

Thick as Thieves lays the foundation for an excellent stealth-based Immersive Sim, but locks so much of what could've been built on it behind draconian online multiplayer design.

Read original review

Checkpoint Gaming35/100 → 35 · Z -3.389Score 50.2008

From the same studio that released the unfinished and chastised Underworld Ascendant comes another game prematurely released with the idea of fixing it later. Thick as Thieves is a game made by pioneers of immersive stealth sims, developers who should know better than to release such a clearly incomplete product like this. It’s poorly executed, staggeringly average, and deeply underwhelming, a game really only for those so desperate for stealth-focused ventures they can overlook a bland story, tedious gameplay, and clunky controls atop a content-sparse introductory chapter.

Read original review

COGconnected68/100 → 68 · Z -1.428Score 69.8112

I remember seeing a preview of Thick as Thieves when it was a PvPvE-focused game. It feels like the shift to single player/co-op stripped away some intangible but important elements. What remains is a fun but limited stealth action game, with lots of potential and room to grow but disappointingly stingy at launch. There’s an old joke about how a restaurant’s food sucked, and also, there wasn’t enough of it. Thick as Thieves is a reasonably-priced $5 game with a solid foundation, but needs more playable characters, maps, depth, and encouragement for creativity. I look forward to checking in from time to time.

Read original review

CrazyGameCommunity.it65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4538Score 69.5535

Thick As Thieves is a title that certainly shines more in cooperative, but it still remains a rather limited experience and not extremely satisfying in the long term.

Read original review

Eurogamer Germany40/100 → 40 · Z -3.1046Score 53.0453

Passably playable, yet extremely short stealth-action game that captures neither the moody atmosphere nor the well-tuned mechanics of the games it is paying homage to.

Read original review

Final Weapon60/100 → 60 · Z -1.3757Score 70.3345

Thick as Thieves has the bones of a great stealth experience with rewarding exploration, satisfying loot management, and a world that strongly evokes Looking Glass Studios’ legacy. However, leftover extraction-game design, forced contract progression, limited combat options, and locked characters hold it back from fully stepping out of the shadows.

Read original review

Game872/100 → 72 · Z -1.0496Score 73.5948

Thick as Thieves is an odd game that suffers from its barebones campaign and questionable launch content, but its incredible stealth gameplay and low price tag at five dollars easily carry the experience. Between its immersive atmosphere and layered heist levels that reward patience and experimentation, there’s still something to appreciate in its moment-to-moment gameplay. Still, it feels like a game that needed more time to properly reveal its grander vision, showing its cards too sparsely, without the kind of prep-time you’d expect from a master thief’s plan.

Read original review

GameGrin60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9368Score 64.7227

Thick As Thieves needs a little more time in the oven, but it could become something great in the future.

Read original review

Gameliner60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2203Score 71.8881

Thick As Thieves is a charming co-op stealth experience with clear caveats, that despite its flaws leaves you hungry for the bigger, bolder heist it could become.

Read original review

GameOnly40/100 → 40 · Z -3.1277Score 52.8138

Playing Thick As Thieves felt more like interacting with an expanded demo or an early access title than a full release. One thing that deserves praise is that the developers communicate the available content in the store page quite clearly. Right now, however, it’s a game that offers very little.

Read original review

Gamereactor UK50/100 → 50 · Z -2.2676Score 61.4152

There are parts of Thick as Thieves I enjoyed. The world has a strong stylistic core and some of the background elements in the story piqued my interest, too. It's also quite hard to bomb on a game that does just cost £5. However, it is a drastically disappointing project, too. When we're a decade removed from Dishonored 2 this year, I would have loved for a game, any game, to try and take its place. Good level design is appreciated in Thick as Thieves, but it's hard to really praise when you've only got two levels. But hey, I could just be a grump about this, and for the price Thick as Thieves is at, it may be worth trying, just to see if you enjoy it more.

Read original review

GAMES.CH70/100 → 70 · Z -1.6251Score 67.8397

"Thick as Thieves" isn't a complete disaster, but the gap between what this game promises and what it actually delivers is remarkably large.

Read original review

GAMES.CH70/100 → 70 · Z -1.7229Score 66.8617

Thick as Thieves raises an interesting question about the worth of games. Because simply measured by the hours you can play and the craftsmanship that’s on display, Thick as Thieves is worth its small asking price. Yet it does not feel like a good deal, because after the first two hours you’ll have seen most of what the game has to offer. The few additional ideas the game hermetically seals behind grinding away at repetitive missions. It’s got the potential to bloom into something interesting, but right now it’s a proof of concept that’s unfortunately marketed to a very saturated co-op gaming market.

Read original review

Games.cz70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0267Score 73.8246

Thick as Thieves isn't overly deep mechanically or narratively, but it offers a charming world, two exceptionally well-designed maps, and a few clever ideas. The sneaking and stealing work as intended and provide solid fun for a few hours, especially in co-op. It lacks bold ambition, better sound design, and more varied obstacles, but as a bite-sized stealth experience at a low price point, it holds up surprisingly well.

Read original review

Gamesource Italia61/100 → 61 · Z -1.666Score 67.4307

Thick as Thieves is a product that's both difficult and very easy to judge, a stealth game in its infancy that doesn't have much to distinguish it from other games, but it does decently well the few things it's decided to focus on. If you want to invest in a growing product and lose yourself for 2-3 hours in nostalgic memories of the Thief of old, then perhaps this is the game for you. Otherwise, you can easily wait for the title's eventual evolution, or its—at this point not yet inevitable—demise...

Read original review

Gaming Age80/100 → 80 · Z -0.577Score 78.321

There’s no denying that Thick As Thieves is fun for what it is. It’s the kind of game where you’ll experience everything it has to offer and you’ll come away wanting more – and even if we don’t get it, the price here probably makes this bite-sized offering too good to pass up.

Read original review

Gaming Boulevard60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7939Score 66.1523

Thick as Thieves annoyed me more than I wanted it to, because the good parts are easy to see. The atmosphere is strong, some escapes really do get tense, and the idea of learning a location piece by piece fits the thief fantasy well. But the game keeps getting in its own way. Too many objectives are vague, too many systems are left half-explained, and solo runs start to feel like you are wasting time rather than pulling off a clever heist. Co-op might help with that, but it was not available in the review build, so I can only judge what I played. And as a solo stealth game, Thick as Thieves has promise, but not enough direction or variety to make that promise pay off.

Read original review

Gaming Professors55/100 → 55 · Z -2.9164Score 54.9269

Thick as Thieves is a game that may not have lived up to all of its original ambitions, but it still manages to offer something that’s quite rare these days. It marks a return to the classic concept of stealth games, where patience, planning, and the ability to improvise are what matter most.

Read original review

GAMINGbible60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7713Score 66.3781

If anything, it makes me want to play a fuller version of the game with more maps, deeper stealth mechanics, and more level variety, but given that it feels a little rushed out the door, I’m not sure if OtherSide will have the budget to finish this. In other words, it’s fun for a fiver, but it does feel like a small chunk of something far bigger and more interesting that we may never get to see.

Read original review

GamingBolt70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0206Score 73.8856

While Thick as Thieves is a short game lacking in many basic features like rebindable controls, it's an easy game to recommend thanks to its compelling gameplay loop, emphasis on replayability, and a co-op mode.

Read original review

IGN70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1356Score 72.7353

I wish Thick as Thieves had more to do overall, but it’s hard to find much fault with what’s here. Its thieves come with cool toys, its two levels are gorgeous and expansive, and there’s a particular joy in playing co-operatively. Even the story is pretty cool, if you can get past the fact that it’s almost all told through text. There are some irritations here – I’ll see you in hell, Hauntstables – but Thick as Thieves was a game I wanted to play, and not just for this review. And when it all comes together and you pull off the perfect heist at the last second? It’s pretty rad. Now if you’ll excuse me, my partner and I need to get back to Elway Manor. Those rich people aren’t going to rob themselves.

Read original review

JsemGamer65/100 → 65 · Z -0.9971Score 74.1203

Thick as Thieves has the foundations of a strong cooperative stealth game, with clever use of light and sound, flexible infiltration routes, enjoyable gadgets, and an atmospheric Dishonored-like world. Unfortunately, just two main locations, repetitive contracts, limited tools, and frustrating time limits make it feel more like the remains of a much more ambitious project than a fully realized adventure.

Read original review

KonsoliFIN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.108Score 83.0107

A tight, yet creative stealth game builds a fun whole on top of the genre's conventions.

Read original review

Life is Xbox72/100 → 72 · Z -0.8681Score 75.41

Thick as Thieves isn’t trying to change the world, but it doesn’t really need to when it costs less than a fast food meal. If you have a friend to play with, sneaking through the shadows and accidentally messing up heists together is an absolute blast. Yes, it’s a bummer that there are only two maps right now, playing all by yourself feels pretty empty, and the missing PC settings are a headache. But honestly, for just $4.99, it’s a total Worth that and it leaves me genuinely excited to see what the developers cook up next.

Read original review

Loot Level Chill70/100 → 70 · Z -1.192Score 72.1709

Thick as Thieves is a solid stealth steal-em-up that will probably be elevated by finding a few sticky-fingered friends to play with.

Read original review

MKAU Gaming60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2101Score 61.9902

Stealth is optional; it’s always a funny line to most when playing a stealth-based game, especially to those who choose to charge right in like a bull in a china shop, but in this game, it is not only necessary but also prudent to do so.

Read original review

Multiplayer.it60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0833Score 63.258

*Thick as Thieves, however, doesn't even attempt to challenge this premise; on the contrary, it offers a truly classic interpretation of this subgenre—one characterized by predetermined, repetitive routes, guards who forget about you after a mere few seconds, and alarm systems that are nowhere to be found. The problem is that the randomized placement of objects does nothing to fundamentally alter the two maps, which—once explored inside out—have very little left to offer.

Read original review

NoobFeed78/100 → 78 · Z -0.3509Score 80.5819

Thick As Thieves feels like a stealth game made by people who really know why old-school stealth games were so fun. It gets rid of systems that aren't needed and works on infiltration, tension, and experimentation alone. It stands out right away in a genre that has become surprisingly rare because of that method.

Read original review

Oyun Günlüğü68/100 → 68 · Z -1.283Score 71.2612

Although the game risks becoming repetitive quickly, it easily justifies its price.

Read original review

PCMag Middle East70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2425Score 71.666

Thick as Thieves is a small but stylish stealth experience that punches above its weight thanks to excellent level design, immersive sim sensibilities, and a fantastic atmosphere. It’s polished, clever, and extremely fun – especially with a friend in co-op.

Read original review

Pizza Fria53/100 → 53 · Z -2.7315Score 56.7757

Thick as Thieves is a game that, in many moments, feels more like an alpha version than a truly finished product. The title offers little content and unfortunately fails even in basic aspects of its main mechanics.

Read original review

Pure Dead Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1531Score 72.56

Thick As Thieves is a solid, low-stakes stealth romp that knows its limits and mostly sticks to them. It won’t revolutionise the genre, but it delivers satisfying sneaking, fun gadgets, and that glorious dopamine hit of a pocket full of stolen goods. The amount of content at launch may be an issue for some, and I do hope we get updates at a decent clip, but for a game that tasks you with stealing, it's ironic that the price tag of a fiver feels like you are stealing from the developers. If you’ve got a friend to team up with, it becomes even more enjoyable, turning potential frustration into shared laughter when your carefully planned heist devolves into chaos.

Read original review

RageQuit.GR60/100 → 60 · Z -2.8268Score 55.8235

It would be unfair to say it doesn’t have its moments as a stealth-action game, but at this early stage it feels more like an enhanced demo than a full-fledged release. Be that as it may, the ultra-low price of just 5 euros at least manages to offer the feeling of an "investment" and the prospect of the game's further expansion in the future.

Read original review

Ragequit.gr60/100 → 60 · Z -2.9166Score 54.9256

It would be unfair to say it doesn’t have its moments as a stealth-action game, but at this early stage it feels more like an enhanced demo than a full-fledged release. Be that as it may, the ultra-low price of just 5 euros at least manages to offer the feeling of an "investment" and the prospect of the game's further expansion in the future.

Read original review

Saudi Gamer50/100 → 50 · Z -2.7054Score 57.0369

Thick as Thieves feels like a promising idea that never fully materialized. With proper execution, it could have stood among the best in its genre, but its thin content and lack of polish leave it stuck as little more than a concept.

Read original review

SECTOR.sk80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2592Score 81.4994

Thick as Thieves delivers a fun stealth experience that rewards creativity and tests your thieving skills through environmental interaction and multiple approaches. Sneaking and core gameplay mechanics work well, though the current progression systems still feel somewhat limited and could benefit from further expansion over time.

Read original review

SECTOR.sk80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2008Score 82.0827

Thick as Thieves delivers a fun stealth experience that rewards creativity and tests your thieving skills through environmental interaction and multiple approaches. Sneaking and core gameplay mechanics work well, though the current progression systems still feel somewhat limited and could benefit from further expansion over time.

Read original review

Softpedia70/100 → 70 · Z -1.5838Score 68.2535

Thick as Thieves is not a visually impressive game, nor will it win prizes for the soundtrack. But I enjoyed its gameplay, and the environmental storytelling attempt is rather interesting. I wished they had brought more content with this release, but hopefully it will end up getting more down the line. As it stands, though, it’s still a competent stealth title that’s bleeding content, however what’s there is worth playing even if it’s on the short side.

Read original review

SteamDeckHQ60/100 → 60 · Z -2.1715Score 62.3763

Thick As Thieves' troubled development has unfortunately resulted in a game full of half-baked ideas and limited replayability. While there are a couple of hours of enjoyment to be had, as well as a modest price tag, bugs and a lifeless world are a far cry from what was promised.

Read original review

The Wand Report50/100 → 50 · Z -1.6445Score 67.6466

There's not much out there that isn't worth at least checking out for a fiver if you're interested, but Thick As Thieves has some tricky locks to crack before it reaches its full potential.

Read original review

TheBigBois75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7867Score 76.2238

Is a promising, unfinished, remarkably fun $5 game that filled an obvious gap in the co-op stealth market. The pedigree behind it is real, the core design is right, and the developer’s post-launch responsiveness suggests this has a genuine future if the sales numbers support continued development. It should have been Early Access. It wasn’t. Buy it for what it is — an excellent afternoon of co-op heisting and a proof of concept for something that could be great — not for the hypothetical product it might eventually become. For more stealth and indie game coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read original review

Thumb Culture60/100 → 60 · Z -1.3087Score 71.0038

Thick As Thieves, as it stands, is less of a game and more of a highly polished paid demo. Everything is decent, but nothing is spectacular. The core stealth loop is solid, but balancing around randomised co-op and a lack of combat removes some of the deeper gameplay and narrative systems that really make stealth shine. The art style is charming, but not especially memorable. The audio design is decent, but can be mostly ignored thanks to the more convenient X-ray system. And the game’s total content is too sparse to really be considered a full game, but large enough to not warrant a “demo” title. I enjoyed my short time with it, and I believe it could become solid down the line. However, as it stands, Thick As Thieves is more of a promise of a game. For now, I’ll be giving it the Thumb Culture Silver Award and my continued attention.

Read original review

Thumb Wars80/100 → 80 · Z -0.541Score 78.6808

While playing Thick as Thieves, I found myself often enjoying the landscape of the game world, both inside the maps and out, as they were well designed with most rooms having a reasonable amount of detail, if not a lot. The gameplay of Thick as Thieves is a lot of fun, allowing stealth players to use all they have mastered, along with various tools, to their advantage in order to steal everything that isn’t nailed down. In regard to the game’s story, it was really interesting to see, as it didn’t just explore the game as we explored it, but it also expanded upon what we didn’t see and the hidden lore that was buried within.

Read original review

Twisted Voxel60/100 → 60 · Z -2.6245Score 57.8461

Warren Spector’s Thick as Thieves delivers a bite-sized, budget-friendly homage to classic immersive sims that shines brightest in co-op. However, a lean content offering, sterile solo play, and an underwhelming text-heavy narrative keep this otherwise mechanically sound, Edwardian-era heist from pulling off the ultimate crime.

Read original review

Virtualni Kutak85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0181Score 84.2721

Thick as Thieves delivers exactly what stealth fans have been missing, a beautifully designed, highly complex world where exploration, patience, and map knowledge matter just as much as pure gameplay skill. For just five euros, it offers far more depth, tension, and fun than you’d ever expect at that price point.

Read original review

WayTooManyGames55/100 → 55 · Z -1.8094Score 65.9976

Thick As Thieves is not a completely bad game, and there is genuinely the foundation for something better here, but as it stands, it is an underwhelming stealth experience. The core ideas have some promise, yet they are wrapped in a bare-bones package that does not offer much of an interesting challenge unless you push through repetitive contracts just to unlock the difficulties where the game actually starts to come alive.

Read original review

Worth Playing75/100 → 75 · Z -0.9824Score 74.2667

Thick as Thieves is a good game if you are OK with a more simplified stealth experience. It is a title that's easy to get into for stealth novices but provides some challenge for genre veterans if you do some real grinding to unlock higher difficulty levels. It would be nice to see a timetable for when new scenarios and levels would arrive, but what's available is good enough for those who want a quick stealth experience before moving on to bigger titles and returning once a big update drops.

Read original review

ZTGD65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4955Score 69.1363

As the content here feels more akin to a very generous demo than a complete package. I really like the idea of Thick as Thieves, but in its current iteration it has found it self stuck between its PvP past and its Co-Op future and try as it might, to me, Thick as Thieves is trying to cater to both audiences and in the end satisfying neither.

Read original review