SourceCritic

So Many Games

36 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj82.2222
Raw spread σj12.4969
Shrunk mean μ′j83.0717
Shrunk spread σ′j12.4668

Reviews from this outlet

Backyard Baseball70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

Backyard Baseball hits both of its main targets, the fastball and the breaking ball, if you will. It effectively channels the memories of playing the original games for longtime fans while also being a fairly approachable game for a new generation of kids, especially on the lower end of the difficulty choices. For older players who didn’t play the original games, it’s still a pretty chill, arcadey baseball experience that promises to not get as sweaty as the more sim-style baseball games out there. It’s not going to the hall of fame, but it makes solid contact more often than not.

Read original review

Big Walk90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Big Walk is a game about walking and talking with your friends through a gorgeous visual and sonic environment modeled on the Australian bush. Escape-room-style puzzles offer just the right amount of challenge. It’s a game that encourages trust, bonding, and communication. Walking the island, our momentum picks up as the vistas, free public transportation, and smartly designed puzzles inspire us to focus on enjoying our time together. The game principally cultivates affinity, and it shines bright in the epiphanies sown throughout the friendscape, shared warmly and excitedly between players.

Read original review

Cairn80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

Kami, the mountain that Aava sets out to summit in Cairn, is a harsh, unrelenting cacophony of jagged edges, pushing the player back at every turn. But through the smallest movements, there is a building sense of triumph as you make the ascent to the peak, which The Game Bakers masterfully designed into the cliff surfaces and tense gameplay. The occasional slip, left without feedback, stings and can disjoint the game’s pacing, but ultimately in Cairn there is a new perspective on games that centre their design on difficulty and force you to reconcile how and why you’ll endure their friction.

Read original review

Clair Obscur: Expedition 3390/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is a rare kind of RPG—one that’s as interested in the quiet, human moments as it is in epic battles. It asks you to pay attention, to care, and to grow alongside its cast. When the journey was over, I found myself thinking less about the enemies I’d defeated and more about the conversations I’d had, the choices I’d made, and the lasting impression of a world where every shadow has a story.

Read original review

Dark Scrolls60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8507Score 65.5846

Dark Scrolls is a trip down memory lane that emphasizes more tripping than memories. While charming in its adherence to retro stylings, it’s a lesson in why some of that game design is no longer the standard for roguelikes. For folks itching to relive the glory days of figuring out how to play a game all on your own, Dark Scrolls is a hunk of coarse sand paper to scratch that particular itch.

Read original review

Denshattack!100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

A perfect mix of colour, sound and satisfying gameplay makes Denshattack! a must-buy, both for completionists and score-chasers, but don’t let the simple controls fool you; this can be a difficult game, especially for those chasing those exclusive high scores!

Read original review

Desktop Explorer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

For Recurring Dream, Desktop Explorer is their debut game, and with its incredible detail, intricate and clever puzzles, strong script and narrative, it’s one they should be proud of and hold their heads up high for. With some adjustments to its accessibility, this would be an easy recommendation, but as it stands, I’d suggest bringing a guide and a notepad if you want to fully experience this tale for yourself.

Read original review

Dispatch100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

Having not been all that good at video games for most of my life, I fell in love with games that focused on great stories, usually with interactions a bit more limited than in fully fledged RPGs and the like. It’s why I still adore series like Life is Strange and (most of) the Telltale games. AdHoc Studios takes the foundations of those games and brings them up to the next level. The polish is astounding, with perfect performances, brilliant art and music, and fantastic, thoughtful writing hidden underneath a heap of swear words. Dispatch is brilliant, and you should play it.

Read original review

Fields of Mistria100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

This is easily one of the best additions to the farming sims genre in a while. Even considering the number of excellent titles the genre has seen in the past few years, this one rates very highly. The charming art, the wonderful music, the great storylines – they all just come together so perfectly and will be enjoyed by anyone infatuated with farming sims or cosy games in general, as well as being a perfect entry point for anyone new to the genre. Now, to finally find that final ingredient for my engagement ring. Hold on, my beloved Juniper, I’ll be there soon!

Read original review

Frostpunk 260/100 → 60 · Z -1.8507Score 65.5846

Sharing only a name and a concept, Frostpunk 2 does a great deal to distance itself mechanically from its precursor, a choice that is both bold and a little bit disappointing. A polished veneer and interesting gameplay interactions do very little to make up for a marred UI and a host of visual glitches. In time this could become an incredible sequel, but in its current state it remains lacking in substance.

Read original review

Go-Go Town!90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

What fun this game is. At times it can feel almost overwhelming, especially when shops run out of ingredients while a bunch of garbirds are roaming the streets, you’re puking rainbows and all of your storage is full. But it never becomes frustrating, and you always find a way out of trouble. Or you can thrive in the chaos, if you’d prefer. Go-Go Town! leaves it up to you. It’s a full-on toybox where you get to decide just how you want to play, and you’ll have a blast no matter

Read original review

Hermit and Pig90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Hermit and Pig goes to unexpected lengths, and it’s a better and more timely game for it. The narrative is sharp, the battles immersive, and the characters rich. It’s a tightly packaged game that balances playfulness, wit, and bite across a rural community scratching out a way of life threatened by corporate greed. Hermit and Pig are unlikely but extremely likeable heroes that will endear any fans of offbeat, satirical RPGs.

Read original review

Hollow Knight: Silksong100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

Hollow Knight: Silksong is, like its predecessor, a masterclass in video game design. From a fully realised world to polished combat, it's hard to find fault outside of some general gripes around the increased difficulty. Pharloom may march to a different beat when compared to Hallownest, but it sings a similar melody all the same.

Read original review

Kejora50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6528Score 57.5632

For Berangin Creative’s debut game, Keejora is good first attempt. Even with the game’s problems, there’s still just enough here to make for a worthwhile playthrough, but the game’s unutilised potential brings down what could have been something quite special.

Read original review

Lifted80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

I want to keep this review short and sweet, just like the game. This isn’t the deepest game of all time. There’s nothing groundbreaking here. But it ran smoothly even on my potato laptop, and I was grinning from ear to ear the entire time, which doesn’t happen much. If you like platformers and a good, silly time, you’ll love this one for sure. The only thing holding me back from a perfect score is that it does play oh so very safely within the boundaries of the genre, so it’s hard to call it a “must play.” That said, this is a very, very fun game, and you are guaranteed a fun time!

Read original review

Mina the Hollower90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Mina the Hollower is a testament to the importance and beauty of iterative game design. While it wouldn’t exist in its current form without each of its individual inspirations, it’s able to use those familiar reference points as a launching pad into something far greater and more dense than any game that it’s inherited DNA from. Between a world stuffed to the absolute brim with discoveries to make, the absurd level of player expression, and the ways in which the game surprises (and how it’s constantly able to do so), this is a new gold standard for not just overhead Zelda-likes but action-adventure games in general.

Read original review

MIO: Memories in Orbit80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

If, like me, you are a Metroidvania geek, you’ll have a great time with MIO, just as long as you don’t come in with too high of an expectation, and for everyone else – especially people who turned away from Silksong – this might be the Metroidvania you’ve been looking for.

Read original review

Mixtape100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

Mixtape’s series of musical vignettes is a breath of fresh air and yet another example of how indie games can do it better. There’s so much variety in the activities you actually perform, but in the end it all boils down to a story about three kids who don’t have the easiest lives, find each other, and now have to face an uncertain future. It’s a hell of a throwback, with the soundtrack to end all soundtracks, and it literally brought me to tears through its fantastic writing and, like Stacy, knowing which song to play at just the right moment.

Read original review

MOUSE: P.I. For Hire90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

I hoped MOUSE: P.I. For Hire would be a good game, but I wasn’t prepared for what the game actually delivers. From a heavy, depth-filled narrative to sharp, butter-smooth gameplay mechanics, this hit on all the right points. Yes, it’s a little too long, and I did get lost in a few instances, but this is forgivable when you consider everything the game gets right. There’s much more to discover that I haven’t touched upon, and I really hope you will jump in to find those out, because this is one you don’t want to miss out on.

Read original review

Opus: Prism Peak80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

OPUS: Prism Peak is an inventive, heartwarming narrative experience that exists in an incredibly believable, creative and original world. Eugene’s plight will resonate with many, and when you combine all this with a robust and fun camera mechanic, a deep and well-written script, loveable characters and some of the best visuals you could ask for, you have a game that not only slots proudly into the OPUS series but also shines bright in a sky packed with stars.

Read original review

Perfect Tides: Station to Station90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Perfect Tides: Station to Station is a messy, disjointed and incredibly uncomfortable window into the life of a writer who still needs to find their way in the world, but all of this comes together to build an amazing narrative that engulfs the player, showing them to embrace discomfort and learn to be their best self. Sadly, a lack of meaningful accessibility options does lose the game half a star.

Read original review

Pieced Together90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Pieced Together is a delightful exploration of friendship, the beauty a relationship like that can bring into life, and the sadness you can experience once that seemingly unbreakable bond seems to drift apart. It has clearly been created by people who have learned important lessons from life and are able to look back at their younger selves with a level of reflection that evades so many people. This is an experience for gamers of a certain age, with millennials set to be hit straight in the nostalgia while also relating to Connie’s life as a 30-something. Maybe I should get back in touch with some long-lost friends after all…

Read original review

R-Type Dimensions III70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

There is clearly so much affection for the franchise in R-Type Dimensions III – the renewed graphics give a more polished look, the soundtrack is superbly made and the quality-of-life changes make a huge difference. Sadly, the new graphics also bring a fairly drastic change to the overall visual style, which can make gameplay more challenging.

Read original review

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

Sophia’s story carries on what made her character so endearing in previous A Plague Tale games, but with a great deal more swashbuckling. The combat shines the brightest even as the story ventures into the dark reality of a world swamped with Macula. While the storytelling is bolstered by incredible voice acting and strong writing, ultimately Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy owes much of its narrative to exposition, filling in gaps about the Macula over character development for the cast.

Read original review

ReStory: Chill Electronics Repairs70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

In conclusion, Restory is mostly a chill time and a zen-like experience. with only some of the less likable characters breaking that immersion. In the plus column, the attention to detail in the hardware art design is truly incredible and worth high praise! In the negative column: I had issues with the zoom level, and I wasn’t a fan of the misalignment of story threads. All told, Restory: Chill Electronics Repairs is a lovely entry into the genre of job simulators and cozy games, and it is exactly what it promises to be.

Read original review

Schrödinger's Call80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

Schrödinger’s Call took me by surprise. It tells tales that will grip you, ones you’ll need resolutions to and ones you’ll think about when away from the game. It’s a way of telling its narrative not only through its words but also through its impactful visuals and music, which created an unforgettable experience. It’s easy, slightly predictable and stretches out too much in places, but when there’s such good storytelling on show that’s accessible to all skill types, it’s an easy recommendation.

Read original review

Sektori100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3579Score 97.6699

This probably sounds supremely, plainly obvious given the way in which I write about them, but I love video games. More than that, the best ones I’ve ever played go beyond love; they leave me with an itch, as if an electric current is running beneath my skin and reminding me of what I like about being alive. And baby, Sektori sure did leave me with an itch.

Read original review

Servant of the Lake80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed Servant of the Lake! It’s outside my usual comfort zone for games, but I felt confident and capable with the puzzles, and I enjoyed the ride it took me on. It’s not the most amazing, awe-inspiring work of art in the world, but it knows what it’s about and it commits to the bit. It’s a genuinely excellent addition to the game library of anyone who enjoys visual novels, point-and-click games, or puzzle games.

Read original review

Songs of Glimmerwick80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

If you’re looking for a cosy game this autumn, and the wait for Witchbrook has you a bit annoyed, I would very much recommend checking out Songs of Glimmerwick. With a story that’s worth investing your time in, fully realised characters that will utterly charm you, and a colourful world to explore at your own pace, there’s just so much here to love. The game’s length can seem a bit daunting, but once it has its hooks in you, the hours will fly by, and before you know it, you’ll have enjoyed the true magic of a game that holds you like a warm hug.

Read original review

Star Wars Outlaws70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

Star Wars: Outlaws is easily deserving of four stars, with a tight gameplay loop, solid stealth and well-made combat mechanics hampered only by a fairly procedural foundation, limiting players in the same ways they are promised the freedom to play the way they see fit. Sadly, the requirement to log into an online account to play an offline single-player game loses the game half a star.

Read original review

TetherGeist80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2464Score 81.6272

TetherGeist is a remarkably inventive precision platformer, full of brilliant ideas and bursting with kinetic energy. Its main mechanic is a delight to use, and things are kept fresh throughout the runtime with creative new ways to swoop, swing and swerve your way from left to right. It’s unfortunate that the storytelling and writing fail to fulfil the story’s full potential, but that doesn’t stop this being one of the very best indie platformers I’ve ever played. I recommend you tether yourself to this game as soon as you can, especially if you’re a fan of the genre.

Read original review

The Mermaid Mask70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

As far as narrative puzzle games go, The Mermaid Mask definitely doesn’t disappoint: the world, the people inhabiting it, and the dialogue in between will always be a treat, though it is let down by some pacing issues in its grand finale, as well as a few puzzles that are needlessly obtuse. Regardless, it proves itself a worthy addition to the Detective Grimoire series and hopefully not the last we will see. Sadly, a lack of meaningful accessibility options also means the game loses half a star.

Read original review

Tides of Tomorrow70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

In the end, Tides of Tomorrow is a beautiful kaleidoscope of possibilities, fractured by a clichéd script and some reductive gameplay sequences. The environmental design is vivid and evocative, revealing the majesty of the natural world prevailing over plastic waste. The story seed system was a genuinely interesting narrative experiment, and the resource management elements led to some superb tension in both the story and the multiplayer interactions. I hope this studio keeps experimenting with the unique ways video games can tell a story, because the ideas coming out of the Digixart lab are what make the future of the industry so exciting.

Read original review

Titanium Court90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

This surreal, reality-twisting, mind-bending marvel of a game is a joyous experience. Its core gameplay is a fun mashup of several genres, but it shines most in its hilarious writing and witty deployment of metafiction, playfully pushing at the boundaries of fiction and reality. It’s pure magic!

Read original review

Well Dweller90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5557Score 89.6485

Well Dweller is full-stop one of my favorite Metroidvanias in recent years. Its combat against standard enemies aside, everything else on offer is best in show for the genre, especially its art style, tone, and soundtrack. If you long for a melancholy metroidvania with unique abilities that doesn’t sacrifice accessibility like so many others in the space, then boy do I have good news for you about the ongoing work of Kyle Thompson.

Read original review

Will: Follow The Light70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0485Score 73.6059

Through all of its faults, Will: Follow the Light still has something to give by shining a light on father-son relationships through an intriguing and sometimes surreal story. Its strong voice cast (including Cissy Jones) aids its pluses, and each gives great performances, but it is hard to ignore its frustrations that let it down quite considerably.

Read original review