SourceCritic

TheReviewGeek

33 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj73.1818
Raw spread σj13.6968
Shrunk mean μ′j78.3767
Shrunk spread σ′j13.0939

Reviews from this outlet

007 First Light55/100 → 55 · Z -1.7853Score 66.2379

007 First Light has the look, sound and occasional swagger of a Bond adventure, but once you start poking at its systems, the illusion quickly falls apart.

Read original review

A Plague Tale: Innocence90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8877Score 92.968

In an endless sea of looter shooters, multiplayer battle royales and microtransaction-riddled titles, Plague: Tale Innocence is a breath of fresh air. With a simple, 10 hour narrative and a well paced story, Plague Tale backs up its compelling plot line with some cleverly evolving gameplay, with each of its deliciously dark chapters an absolute delight to play through. Created by a passionate team of 40 or so people, Plague: Tale Innocence is a reminder of what this medium can produce with a bit of creativity and passion, leaving this reviewer saddened when the journey ended. Despite the visuals not quite matching traditional blockbuster game standards, the atmosphere and general aesthetic of the game more than makes up for this, making Plague Tale: Innocence one of the best games of the year.

Read original review

Crimson Desert80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309

Crimson Desert is a messy, ambitious RPG that constantly battles against itself. It’s frustrating and uneven, but its sheer scale and ideas make it hard to walk away from. A bold and often brilliant experience, this is the kind of game that sticks with you long after you’ve put it down.

Read original review

Death Stranding60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4035Score 70.0565

Hideo Kojima reminds me a lot of George R.R. Martin and George Lucas. With a bit of restraint, these men have managed to achieve greatness in their respective fields. Without that overarching influence to keep them on the straight and narrow, and with free reign to conjure up something wholly self-published and original, these artists have struggled to reign themselves in and rekindle that early career magic, producing lacklustre and ever-so-slightly egotistical pieces of fiction. Death Stranding then, is Hideo Kojima following in that same vein.

Read original review

Deliver Us The Moon75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

With its excellent balance of exploration, puzzle-solving, and story-telling, as well as the very impressive visuals and immersive atmosphere, Deliver Us The Moon offers a great experience to anybody who is willing to strap themselves in for the ride.

Read original review

Demon Tides65/100 → 65 · Z -1.0216Score 73.8751

Demon Tides is a stylish and ambitious platformer that shines in bursts, , but is too often held back by its mechanical and technical shortcomings.

Read original review

Eternal Strands65/100 → 65 · Z -1.0216Score 73.8751

Eternal Strands has a few nice ideas and tons of potential with its robust magic system. The giant boss fights are a definite stand-out but all of this is hampered time and again by basic gameplay design that usurps the fun. In an effort to try and add in this magical physics system, the trade-off is very limited stamina, big magic cooldowns and an inability to level up base stats. That’s before mentioning some of the performance issues and pretty mindless side quests to pad the run-time. There are elements here that make Eternal Strands a super fun game, but after completing everything this one has to offer across its 25 hour run-time, it’s a disappointingly mixed experience overall, which is a real shame.

Read original review

Ghost of Tsushima85/100 → 85 · Z 0.5058Score 89.1494

Ghost Of Tsushima is a visually stunning game that matches its beauty with an incredibly fun and tactically sound combat loop. The open world is diverse, full of interesting locations to visit and helped by a simple but effective tale about a Mongol Invasion. The game does suffer from the same issues other open world games do too but there’s at least a consistent effort to make Tsushima stand out from the pack. And stand out it does. Sucker Punch deliver a powerful, memorable game that caps off this gaming generation on a high.

Read original review

God of War90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8877Score 92.968

The fact that God of War still holds up after its release in 2018 speaks volumes about the great work Santa Monica Studio have done with this “not really a reboot but not really a sequel” game. When it dropped on Playstation as an exclusive, it rightly received critical and fan acclaim the world over. Fast forward to 2022 and that same experience is now available to PC users, in a port that’s just as good – if not better – than its Playstation counterpart.

Read original review

Haste75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

Fast, high-octane action and an addictively moreish premise; Haste is an experiment that really shouldn’t work but absolutely does. It’s certainly not perfect, but what’s here makes this one of 2025’s best arcade games so far.

Read original review

Hell is Us75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

Hell is Us isn’t perfect, but it’s a highly enjoyable experience. While the story and characters don’t quite hit the mark, its rich mythology, striking world design, and varied combat make it easy to recommend. It’s not a Souls-like, but this adventure packs plenty of soul.

Read original review

Hollow Knight: Silksong90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8877Score 92.968

Yes, this is a challenging game, and the Rosary Bead currency is in desperate need of refinement, but this is still an absolute joy to play through. Platforming is tightly designed, combat is both crunching and punishing, and the story beautifully told across this 15–20 hour adventure. Silksong is a game that not only meets expectations but often surpasses them. It’s haunting, challenging, and expertly crafted — a journey that lingers long after the credits roll. Minor flaws aside, this is one of 2025’s standout releases, and a game that firmly cements Team Cherry as masters of the genre.

Read original review

It Takes Two60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4035Score 70.0565

It’s such a shame then that the narrative fails as badly as it does because when it comes to gameplay, most of It Takes Two is brilliantly designed. Much like The Last Of Us Part 2, this is going to be a narrative that divides many people. Unlike TLOU2, the mature themes here are tackled immaturely, with a weird tinted veil that completely brushes over the complexities of the issues being discussed. Gameplay-wise, this title is a blast to play through. Narratively though? This one’s a clanger.

Read original review

Kejora45/100 → 45 · Z -2.549Score 58.6008

Kejora’s gorgeous art can’t mask a clunky, buggy core that feels undercooked and frustrating far more often than it is enjoyable.

Read original review

Lies of P80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309

They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and when it comes to Lies of P, this game pays homage to Dark Souls and Demon’s Souls beautifully. It’s not going to win any contests for originality, but the original content here is certainly worth of remembrance. The puppet aesthetic is excellent, the story engaging, and the sheer amount of customization, alongside some memorable boss fights, makes this one of the best Souls-like games outside FromSoft’s catalogue.

Read original review

Life is Strange: True Colors75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

Alex Chen’s journey is a good one and the five chapters provide a concise, slick story that gets the job done without much fuss. Unfortunately this also exemplifies how often certain areas are reused and the relatively simple choices given to players. Thankfully, True Colors dazzles its flaws with a vibrant, enjoyable adventure that’s well worth checking out

Read original review

MIO: Memories in Orbit80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309

Memories in Orbit delivers outstanding atmosphere and exploration, held back slightly by combat that never quite evolves.

Read original review

Mixtape50/100 → 50 · Z -2.1672Score 62.4194

Mixtape desperately wants to be a coming-of-age indie film, and the moments where it remembers it’s supposed to be a video game often feel reluctant, shallow and mechanically underwhelming.

Read original review

MOUSE: P.I. For Hire75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

Mouse: P.I. For Hire is a stylish shooter that blends noir storytelling with fast, frenetic combat. Its varied levels, memorable boss fights and striking aesthetic make it easy to get swept up in the experience. However, rigid level design, unbalanced weapons and some questionable gameplay mechanics hold it back. It’s messy, creative, and occasionally frustrating — but when it clicks, Mouse: P.I. For Hire feels genuinely special.

Read original review

Ori and the Will of the Wisps90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8877Score 92.968

Ori and the Will of the Wisps doesn’t reinvent the Metroidvania wheel but it does polish it up in such a way that it feels like a whole new experience. It’s a game that confidently showcases some of the best platforming and environmental puzzles of the year and does so with a picturesque beauty that makes this such a joy to play through.

Read original review

Phantom Blade Zero85/100 → 85 · Z 0.5058Score 89.1494

Phantom Blade Zero is a fantastic action-adventure game. It's a slick, smooth experience that blends wuxia-inspired gameplay with Souls-like DNA, all while oozing charm and history at every turn.

Read original review

Pragmata85/100 → 85 · Z 0.5058Score 89.1494

For all its inventive systems, Pragmata ultimately succeeds because of the bond between Diana and Hugh. The “Dad Space” label might raise a smile, but it captures the heart of the experience perfectly. Tight combat, strong worldbuilding, and a genuinely engaging character dynamic keep everything firing on all cylinders around that. Clocking in at around 8–12 hours, this one never overstays its welcome. This is a confident new IP from Capcom, and one of the year’s best action games.

Read original review

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309

Prince Of Persia: The Lost Crown is a great Metroidvania. It’s very easy to get addicted to exploring every nook and cranny of this world, and it helps that the visuals are gorgeously rendered too. It’s certainly no Hollow Knight or Castlevania, but Lost Crown is a solid, highly enjoyable game with a harmonious balance of combat, puzzles and exploration.

Read original review

Resident Evil 285/100 → 85 · Z 0.5058Score 89.1494

Resident Evil 2 is not just a fantastic remake, it’s a very good horror game in its own right. The atmosphere, voice acting and sound design are outstanding, with each environment set up to maximise the horror. The story can be completed in around 8 hours or so but the different play modes and separate storyline for Claire gives you incentive to play through this one again to experience the whole story. It’s worth doing too and with no microtransactions, loot boxes or free to play mechanics in sight, Capcom have delivered a refreshingly straight forward game, one that’s easily up there with one of the best of 2019.

Read original review

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4035Score 70.0565

Gorgeous visuals and an excellent soundtrack can’t disguise an action-adventure that borrows so heavily from better games without ever matching their strengths.

Read original review

Servant of the Lake70/100 → 70 · Z -0.6397Score 77.6937

Servant of the Lake is a creepy and enjoyable point-and-click adventure packed with bizarre charm and varied puzzles, even if some design choices keep it from reaching greater heights

Read original review

Star Wars Outlaws40/100 → 40 · Z -2.9309Score 54.7822

Ubisoft have marketed Star Wars: Outlaws as a AAAA experience. And I whole heartedly agree. It absolutely is… if AAAA stands for Absolutely Atrocious And Abysmal.

Read original review

Stray90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8877Score 92.968

There’s a lot of love that’s gone into crafting this game and Stray deserves its plaudits. This is a fantastic game and easily one of the best in 2022.

Read original review

Symphonia80/100 → 80 · Z 0.124Score 85.3309

Symphonia is a pretty straightforward precision platformer. Its short length is really the only big drawback here as the rest of the game is an absolute delight to play through. The orchestral soundtrack is excellent, the visuals look great, and the levels designed in such a meticulous and imaginative way that you’ll find yourself having heaps of fun with this – even in the challenging sections where you’ll die repeatedly.

Read original review

The Blood of Dawnwalker55/100 → 55 · Z -1.7853Score 66.2379

The Blood of Dawnwalker has a great story and ideas, but repetitive combat and frustratingly undercooked systems leave it feeling less than the sum of its parts.

Read original review

The First Berserker: Khazan85/100 → 85 · Z 0.5058Score 89.1494

Despite a few wobbles, The First Berserker: Khazan is a lovely surprise. It's certainly not an easy game by any stretch of the imagination, nor is it a perfect Souls-like. It has some issues with boss HP and a couple of level design flaws but cleverly creative inclusions like an Easy Mode (although it's more of a "Not quite so difficult" Mode), bonus Lacrima from failed boss attempts and a lot of variety to skills and build-types makes this a very solid Souls-like. In fact, I'd go so far as to say it's the best on the market since Lies of P. This one's a very easy recommendation.

Read original review

The Last of Us Part II65/100 → 65 · Z -1.0216Score 73.8751

The Last Of Us Part II will be an incredible game for some and a disappointing, narratively disjointed mess for others. Graphically, the title is easily one of the best looking on Playstation 4 and the level design is second to none. The art feeds into this beautifully too, with an aesthetic that switches colour palettes and ideas throughout the 25 hours to prevent the game stagnating. Unfortunately all of this is undermined by characters with very little depth, a narrative that flits between personas and flashbacks with little rhyme or reason, and some genuinely unsatisfying conclusions for almost every character at the end, save for Ellie. As someone who loved The Last Of Us, Part II is a tough pill to swallow. It’s a game that asks perhaps the biggest question of all – why should I care about these characters? And that’s something this never really answers with much conviction.

Read original review

Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodhunt75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2579Score 81.5123

If you’re thirsty for another Battle Royale game, this might just be what you’re looking for. With decent graphics, fun traversal techniques, and some interesting character classes, you should have a good time, whether you take on your victims alone or with a team of two other players.

Read original review