SourceCritic

The A.V. Club

52 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj84.7885
Raw spread σj20.9196
Shrunk mean μ′j84.5333
Shrunk spread σ′j17.8138

Reviews from this outlet

1348 Ex Voto16/100 → 16 · Z -3.8472Score 45.6192

It’s uncomfortable for a critic to think of a game in terms of what it could be, and not what it is. But having what little there is here, I’m left only with the sucking vacuum of this game that could have been more than a tedious medieval combat simulator, if it was more invested in exploring its ideas than being insecure about what a game needs to be.

Read original review

Aphelion58/100 → 58 · Z -1.4895Score 69.1964

At the end Aphelion devolves into trial-and-error frustration, with the game too often not working the way it taught you it would. There’s some thematic resonance in that—it falls apart just as Montclair and Cross’s mission did, just as the earlier expedition did—but it’s unintentional. Don’t Nod discovers that the edge of the solar system isn’t just farther than its ambitions can go; it’s so far it effectively breaks a game. Yes: Aphelion flies too close to the sun.

Read original review

Batman: Arkham City91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Arkham City and The Dark Knight (film) have something much more important in common: They're so sublime, they render their predecessors nearly forgettable by comparison.

Read original review

BioShock100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

A technical masterpiece with a story that reaches too far—but Andrew Ryan would have it no other way.

Read original review

BioShock 275/100 → 75 · Z -0.5352Score 78.7395

By striving to be nothing more than its predecessor, BioShock 2 achieves something less.

Read original review

Braid100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

This isn't a game about time, it's about memories, and how they can be repeated and eventually rewritten.

Read original review

Cairn50/100 → 50 · Z -1.9386Score 64.7055

Once acclimated to the core mechanics, climbs become a series of puzzles to solve, rather than tests of might. Some sections are challenging enough to mirror Aava’s frustrations, with me cussing and shouting whenever a foot placement didn’t register properly and made me fall to the previous piston—if I had been smart enough to put one, that is. Despite the monotony, however, I remained determined to see it through. The problem is that the foundation on which Cairn bases these hardships lacks not only a stronger stability, but purpose, as well.

Read original review

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

There's no substitution for the bone-deep abhorrence we harbor for Hitler and his henchmen, but Modern Warfare does an admirable job of creating villains out of arms dealers and ultranationalists.

Read original review

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 283/100 → 83 · Z -0.0861Score 83.2304

In spite of its good looks, Modern Warfare 2 has the slightest whiff of insecurity. It feels like the developers, under pressure to top the original Modern Warfare, engaged in a bit of hand-wringing this time around.

Read original review

Castle Crashers75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5352Score 78.7395

It's a fine line between "retro" and "rehash," and while Castle Crashers coughs up a few neat ideas, its freshest element is its art.

Read original review

Champions Online83/100 → 83 · Z -0.0861Score 83.2304

Champions Online currently has some pretty ugly bugs, but hopefully as it goes forward, the rough edges will get smoothed, and it will become the great game it has the potential to be.

Read original review

Dark Sector42/100 → 42 · Z -2.3877Score 60.2146

And the poor storytelling doesn't hurt the game as much as the tedium, and the feeling that the game is padded by five or six hours—which suggests that the real draw isn't dismemberment, but distraction.

Read original review

DC Universe Online42/100 → 42 · Z -2.3877Score 60.2146

The action-MMO set in a painstakingly recreated DC Comics world requires superhuman patience to even install, with assets verification, patch downloads, and the like taking a full day, depending on your Internet connection.

Read original review

East India Company42/100 → 42 · Z -2.3877Score 60.2146

It’s all the tedium surrounding the trade that sinks this ship.

Read original review

Fallout 3100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

A massive, enthralling achievement.

Read original review

Gears of War 291/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Highly addictive online modes dull the pain of mundane offline play.

Read original review

God of War II100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

The sense of scale is off the charts. From the opening brawl with the towering Colossus of Rhodes to the Island of Creation—a sprawling mega-level which takes a good half of the game to traverse—God Of War II's venue doesn't feel mortal for even a moment.

Read original review

God of War III83/100 → 83 · Z -0.0861Score 83.2304

As a technical spectacle, there's nothing like God Of War III, but while we're meant to truly feel the anguish of Kratos' bloody final battle, Sony hasn't yet trapped a ghost in the machine.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto IV100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Grand Theft Auto IV is, simply, the latest way to flip the bird. And damn if such a simple gesture doesn't feel good.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars is a game for all the people who found Grand Theft Auto IV too ponderous, scattershot, or just too damn different from the rest of the series.

Read original review

Halo 3100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Still, judging a game like Halo 3 on the single-player campaign is like taking a movie to task for its opening credits. Halo 3's multiplayer is its reason for existence.

Read original review

Hermit and Pig91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Hermit And Pig’s focus on mushrooms becomes an apt and immediate metaphor for our current moment. Like fungi, our communities function like a large, interconnected, singular organism. An attack on any one of us affects all of us, and it will be through mutual cooperation that we will get through the grim times ahead. The cartoonish depiction of our present societal ills allow the game’s messaging to motivate us in a time where we all might need it. Hermit And Pig is an uplifting take on sending the capitalists running with their tails between their legs, and a reminder that it will take your friendly neighborhood fisherman, a neurotic old lady, the young students of the next generation, and every other eccentric person in your community to save the world from those destroying it. It is the exact kind of game worth playing to kick anyone out of cynical doomerism. If Hermit and Pig can break out of their day-to-day—their “business as usual”—for the greater good, then so can all of us.

Read original review

Journey100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Journey is a marvel, a hallucination of gameplay that feels as deep and immersive as the borderless desert where it begins.

Read original review

LIMBO91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

But the sometimes grisly, sometimes pacific sound design is never less than pitch-perfect, and stuck between worlds or not, Limbo's three hours of play time are concentrated, puzzle-gaming heaven.

Read original review

LittleBigPlanet100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

When Sackboy drifts into freefall while skateboarding down a steep incline, that sinking feeling in your gut means that the game's exquisitely tuned physics are working.

Read original review

Mass Effect 2100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Great role-playing uses unpredictable situations to provoke unexpected responses in players, and accordingly, Mass Effect 2 is surprising time and again.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Hours of concentrated narrative abuse can't obscure or dilute the detailed game within.

Read original review

Nioh 383/100 → 83 · Z -0.0861Score 83.2304

Nioh 3 is, in other words, a game that exists, thrives, and potentially fails solely in the hands. It will give you as much of itself as you’re willing to accept—regardless of how crammed your gullet already is. It has no soul, and wouldn’t know what to do with one if it did. But it does inspire the kind of fascination inevitably produced by a machine that has been engineered meticulously for a singular purpose. It’s huge, aggressive, and—if I didn’t need to put a few more polish passes on this review—I’d probably be playing it right now. The crux is this: It’s impossible to imagine a better Nioh game. Whether that’s an expression of praise or damnation is left for the reader to decide.

Read original review

Okami100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

The game's music is enchanting, combat is simple but a blast, and it all comes with a full cast of endearingly kooky characters.

Read original review

Pac-Man Championship Edition DX100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

There are also a wealth of presentation options that cover the gamut of Pac-man's 30-year history.

Read original review

Pirates of Black Cove33/100 → 33 · Z -2.8929Score 55.1623

And the fairly linear plot isn't supported by characterization; the story consists almost entirely of rumors of generic treasure that your character easily verifies. As with most of Pirates Of Black Cove, it's not actively bad, just remarkably inessential.

Read original review

Portal100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Just as Valve's Half-Life 2 is the moody loner to Halo 3's high-school quarterback, Portal is smarter, cooler, funnier, and more sinister than almost any game this year.

Read original review

Portal 2100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

If there was ever any doubt that Portal could be expanded into a big, narrative experience with all the bells and whistles of a mainstream gaming hit, have no fear. Valve solved that puzzle with Portal 2.

Read original review

Pragmata91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Pragmata reaches its potential through unique combat that adroitly balances two very different systems, a story rooted in contemporary fears about AI and machination replacing humans that blossoms into genuine emotion, and consistently accomplished presentation that prevents any lulls or noticeable dips in quality. It confidently evinces a sheer, reliable competence that remains hard to find in big budget games like this, and maintains it until the end.

Read original review

Red Dead Redemption100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

The first goddamned good action Western that gaming has seen.

Read original review

Resident Evil Requiem75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5352Score 78.7395

Resident Evil: Requiem embodies the series' familiar extremes between horror and action in a novel way. Its two protagonists, Grace Ashcroft and Leon Kennedy, feel like they’re from different games, with Grace’s chapters embodying the slow pace and puzzle-solving of early Resident Evils, while Leon’s sections accelerate the action romp instincts of Resident Evil 4 even further. It’s an approach that peaks in an excellent first half that wields tonal whiplash to its advantage, before succumbing to second act blues as an increasing focus on nostalgia-bait dampens its originality.

Read original review

Rock Band 3100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

A superbly engineered game that is both the most ambitious and the best the genre has to offer.

Read original review

Saros75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5352Score 78.7395

Saros is not a brave sequel. (And it is a sequel, by any reasonable definition of the word.) It’s a safe one: An attempt to improve on a stable core structure, shave off its more alienating edges, and make something more palatable for the masses. The result, then, is competent, successful, and disappointing in equal measure. Arriving at a time when the PS5 was desperately in need of a killer app, Returnal was a much-desired dose of shock and awe, a staggering blend of narrative bleakness and gameplay exhilaration. But now the shock has dissipated, and the awe has been spent. Saros is a more accessible game, in terms of both its play and its story, and there are merits to that approach. It’s a good game, genuinely. But it’s not a great one, and, worse, at no point while playing it do you get the sense that it wanted to be one; that great and terrible and beautiful hunger to be more that eats at, damns, and exults its characters never seems to touch its own heart. Which might be for the best! But it leaves the game stripped of anything you haven’t likely seen before—and as a follow-up to a game that frequently made the jaw drop, that’s its own little kind of hell.

Read original review

Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

While it manages to pull off pathos, it's also filled with laugh-out-loud jokes, including the traditional ludicrous dialogue from your units.

Read original review

Street Fighter IV67/100 → 67 · Z -0.9843Score 74.2486

Is Street Fighter IV the best version? Absolutely. But once fans have relived their virtual-martial-arts glory days; once they’ve defeated Seth, the poorly named final boss; once the patina of nostalgia has worn off, most will wonder whether they needed to spend $60 on a game they already own.

Read original review

Super Mario Galaxy91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

The only word to describe fighting Bowser with an orchestral score in the background is "badass."

Read original review

Super Mario Galaxy 2100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

It's confounding how this simple world can evoke feelings of curiosity, wonder, and dread all at once.

Read original review

Super Smash Bros. Brawl91/100 → 91 · Z 0.363Score 87.7213

Matches play like a Destroy All Monsters mêlée, with up to four players duking it out until the last man, or Pokémon, stands.

Read original review

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Worth playing for the sense of discovery—each environment looks different from the last and requires a nuanced reaction—makes the action addictive.

Read original review

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Skyrim lets these rough edges show, because the element of chaos lets players feel like the game is happening to them, and they are alive in it-not just cogs in a pre-fab Game Experience. That's what sets Skyrim apart from some of its contemporaries. Where many games with lavish production values seek to direct players' imaginations, Skyrim seeks to ignite them.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

No, Skyward Sword isn't better than Ocarina Of Time. But of all the Zeldas to be released over the last 13 years, it comes closest. The game's greatest achievement is that it never stops aspiring to be more than it is. It never stops reaching for emotional moments, going full-tilt for players' hearts.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

Fifty-plus hours, an immense adventure, and a sexy new style? Twilight Princess may not perfect, but it's darn near close.

Read original review

Total War: Shogun 2100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

It's the ideal example of evolution trumping revolution in creating great video games.

Read original review

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves100/100 → 100 · Z 0.8682Score 92.7735

But the character interaction and the superb story will stay with players long after they've escaped its final trap.

Read original review

Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception50/100 → 50 · Z -1.9386Score 64.7055

Two years after Thieves, Uncharted's gameplay mechanics and conventions are no longer dated; they're borderline archaic.

Read original review

Universe Sandbox75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5352Score 78.7395

After a helpful (though light) tutorial, Universe Sandbox offers little guidance for aspiring unmoved movers. A more robust set of tutorials, a manual, or even the use of Steam Achievements to encourage varied behavior would go a long way toward helping players make their own music of the spheres.

Read original review

Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine83/100 → 83 · Z -0.0861Score 83.2304

Fortunately, it isn't pure fan service: It offers a fast-paced, gory start to a promising new franchise.

Read original review