SourceCritic

Pirates of Black Cove

59.0256SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 55.8571 · 21 reviews

2011 · PC

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

AusGamers60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3482Score 60.6091

If the developers had stuck to just sailing and ship-combat, Pirates would be a charming game. Unfortunately, it's only half of one.

Read original review

Bit-Gamer60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8832Score 65.2593

Let down by the poor combat and the long, tedious segments on land, Pirates of the Black Cove struggles to stand out from the crowd.

Read original review

Cheat Code Central78/100 → 78 · Z -1.1743Score 72.3477

An enormous world filled with missions to tackle, secrets to uncover, and ships to sink. Add that to the fact that sea battles are incredibly addictive and you have quite a package.

Read original review

Destructoid70/100 → 70 · Z -1.099Score 73.1014

If you are a big enough pirate fan and willing to overlook Pirates of Black Cove's faults in favor of its charm, there is enough fun to be had to make its budget price a barrrrgain. Should such pirate puns lead to haemorrhaging in your brain's language centers, however, then this might not be the game for you.

Read original review

Eurogamer Sweden40/100 → 40 · Z -3.478Score 49.311

This is not Sid Meiers Pirates. It's a quest based single player game which happens to have its setting in the Caribbean. And the first hour just keeps on repeating itself.

Read original review

Game Over Online62/100 → 62 · Z -2.7054Score 57.0374

Overall, Pirates of Black Cove is a difficult game to recommend. It looks nice enough, and the voice acting is better -- and more prevalent -- than you might expect from a budget title, but everything else is second rate.

Read original review

Gamereactor Denmark90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3163Score 87.2544

Quotation forthcoming.

Read original review

Gamers.at55/100 → 55 · Z -2.6816Score 57.2753

Pirates of Black Cove brazenly copied Sid Meier's Pirates! but can not put the individual gameplay-elements together into a successful whole. The game lacks depth and repetitive gameplay bored after a few hours. Rather play the great 1987 original, because it's much more fun than this uninspired infusion.

Read original review

Games.cz50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6676Score 57.4147

Although it's a pirate-game with a glimpse of freedom, it's choking on its bad story. You will be entertained for couple of hours by upgrading of your own ship, sea battles or by island-raiding. However, after that the entertainment disappears under a surface like a holey sailboat. Pirates of Black Cove cast anchor more to younger players than to the old ones.

Read original review

GameSpot35/100 → 35 · Z -3.9048Score 45.043

It's better to walk the plank than to sail the seas of the boring and buggy Pirates of Black Cove.

Read original review

GameStar48/100 → 48 · Z -3.9719Score 44.3716

There's just one basic problem with Pirates of Black Cove: the developers forgiot to deliver a game. What's the point of all the items and upgrades if nothing really makes a difference?

Read original review

GameTrailers50/100 → 50 · Z -3.4774Score 49.3169

It just never offers more than a middling gameplay experience for its price. That on its own might satisfy the casual freebooters, but when you couple that mediocrity with abysmal NPC pathing, inexplicable bouts of lag, and the game's tendency to crash at key moments, even they may find themselves tossing this one down in Davy Jones' locker for good.

Read original review

GameWatcher75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7722Score 76.3693

For all its faults though, Pirates of Black Cove is a very endearing game.

Read original review

GRYOnline.pl35/100 → 35 · Z -4.3359Score 40.7317

I'm sorry to say that Pirates of the Black Cove is one of the simpliest pirate games I have ever played. Gameplay is shallow, the game is buggy, short and most importantly - ugly. That overwhelming rotten scent can't be scattered by a light, funny, cartoonish atmosphere and diversified missions. It's a sad example of wasted potential and lack of attention to finishing up the all of the game's elements.

Read original review

IGN55/100 → 55 · Z -2.3296Score 60.7953

Aside from its uninspired combat and limited scope, Pirates of Black Cove is an endearing game at times. I wanted to love it, and kept diving back in hoping that something would click. It didn't.

Read original review

LEVEL (Czech Republic)50/100 → 50 · Z -2.2909Score 61.1822

Action pirate strategy offers arcade playability and easy-to-learn concepts but suffers with technical issues and poor A.I. of your ship's crew. [Issue#208]

Multiplayer.it50/100 → 50 · Z -3.0263Score 53.8285

Enjoyable during the first hours of playing, Pirates of Black Cove shows very early its casual gameplay, badly developed.

Read original review

PC Gamer UK65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4979Score 69.112

It's certainly never short of ideas, but inept execution sends Pirates of Black Cove toppling off the gangplank. [Nov 2011, p.134]

Pelit (Finland)57/100 → 57 · Z -3.8823Score 45.2681

Thumbs up for Pirates of Black Cove being a pirate themed strategy game, thumbs down for oversimplified gameplay, boring missions and way too slow tempo. [Oct 2011]

The A.V. Club33/100 → 33 · Z -2.8929Score 55.1623

And the fairly linear plot isn't supported by characterization; the story consists almost entirely of rumors of generic treasure that your character easily verifies. As with most of Pirates Of Black Cove, it's not actively bad, just remarkably inessential.

Read original review

XGN55/100 → 55 · Z -2.5345Score 58.7461

The charming style and the fun battles at sea will keep you entertained for a while but the fun reaches a low during fights on land and the random crashes that you'll encounter in this game. Pirates of Black Cove had a lot of potential but unfortunately doesn't do much with it.

Read original review