SourceCritic

Official Xbox Magazine

44 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj90.9318
Raw spread σj10.5279
Shrunk mean μ′j88.1586
Shrunk spread σ′j11.2993

Reviews from this outlet

Batman: Arkham City100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

A week after beating the main campaign (at which point, we dove right back to side missions), its final image is lodged in our heads. And that's okay, because every time we think of Arkham City, we smile.

Read original review

BioShock100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

Play it, talk about it, experience it--a game like Bioshock won't happen again for a good long while. [Nov 2007, p.80]

Read original review

BioShock 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

BioShock 2 isn't a groundbreaking follow-up that rewrites all the rules laid down by its predecessor. No, think of it as a sequel that fills in the gaps, adding exciting new dimensions to what's come before... You will be utterly absorbed. [Mar 2010, p.68]

Borderlands 290/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

Borderlands 2 features an insane amount of content. Expect to spend at least 40 hours finishing the main story campaign, and much more than that to complete all the optional missions. Once you beat the campaign, you can replay the game in harder Vault Hunter mode with your veteran character for even better loot and rewards.

Read original review

Braid90/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

Braid is absolutely a game you shouldn’t miss.

Read original review

Burnout 3: Takedown93/100 → 93 · Z 0.4285Score 88.3759

Powersliding through a curve at 75 mph and missing a tractor trailer by a hair's breadth should prompt a few calls to your cardiologist. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll scream until you giggle. The pure visceral experience of Burnout 3 is as intense as racing gets. [Oct 2004, p.58]

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

Simply put, Call of Duty 4 does everything right and nearly nothing wrong. But where it elevates itself above even the best 360 shooters is how all of the good stuff is ludicrously good. The campaign never lets up, while multiplayer is a triple-A affair in itself. [Dec 2007, p.36]

Read original review

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Modern Warfare 2 is easily one of the year’s best games. Because it’s more iterative than innovative, though, it’s not quite as perfect as we’d expected, but it is a terrifically fun, nerve-wrackingly intense spectacle that you’d be crazy to miss.

Read original review

Castle Crashers85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2795Score 81.2958

Every inch of the hand-drawn kingdom is brimming with endearing eccentricity. [Oct 2008, p.76]

Read original review

Dark Sector55/100 → 55 · Z -2.9346Score 54.7453

Dark Sector assumes you’ve played a metric ton of games. And even if you have, you’re still likely to get confused and frustrated. Some kind of hint when you’re clearly not grasping it would’ve gone a long way toward easing the pain.

Read original review

Devil May Cry HD Collection75/100 → 75 · Z -1.1646Score 72.4456

Though Devil May Cry 2's faults required more than just an HD makeover, we won't let one bad apple spoil the bunch. For $40, we're finally getting two of the most extensive and excellent action games of all time, with a decent HD makeover. And that's a deal worth smiling about.

Read original review

Dishonored90/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

Arkane Studios has crafted what's likely the year's best new IP, and by tapping into elements of so many of this generation's greatest games, this adventure sneaks up, grabs you, and won't let go.

Read original review

DmC: Devil May Cry90/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

The surface changes lead to a more varied world and relatable characters, while the action itself is a benchmark for the genre.

Read original review

Fable75/100 → 75 · Z -1.1646Score 72.4456

The push and pull between the great and sketchy in Fable Anniversary can wear over the course of the game, but its infallible, messy charm still manage to make it every bit the enjoyable time sink it was back in 2004.

Read original review

Fallout 3100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

Games this captivating do not come along often. Between its engrossing story, ginormous world, well-crafted RPG side, and white-knuckle FPS combat, Fallout 3 completely, utterly gives you your $60 worth. [Dec 2008, p.52]

Read original review

Gears of War100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

No longer a covert operation, Epic's sci-fi shooter Gears of War has finally emerged, and it's pretty much everything we hooped it would be, as well as a few things we didn't expect. [Holiday 2006, p.41]

Read original review

Gears of War 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Our favorite new addition to the Gears multiplayer family, however, is Horde. A fiveplayer co-op romp played on any of the 15 maps, Horde throws wave after wave of increasingly difficult Locust foes at you and your friends for 50 rounds, putting your teamworking skills to the ultimate test.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto Double Pack91/100 → 91 · Z 0.2515Score 86.6058

Whether you've played them or not, the pair of masterpieces contained in the Grand Theft Auto Double Pack are too good to pass up, especially when it's a two-for-one deal. [Holiday 2003, p.97]

Grand Theft Auto IV95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

If it were up to us, we'd have included a few better missions, weapons, and cars earlier in the game - if only for a temporary taste. That would definitely improve the pacing (while leaving plenty of surprises for later), and it'd have ensured that ADD players don't stop early without seeing the brilliant content that's down the road. [June 2008, p.40]

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto V100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

From skydiving and submarine exploration to bounty-hunting and watching animated shorts, GTA V is absolutely crammed full of things to do, and it looks amazing while you do them.

Read original review

Halo 297/100 → 97 · Z 0.7825Score 91.9159

You'll be surprised and stunned by some of the turns that not only imbue the story with great depth and meaning, but indelibly impact the actual game you're playing... Halo 2 is the single greatest achievement on the platform. [Dec 2004, p.44]

Halo 3100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

This 10 is based on the fact that Bungie has successfully raied the level of what to expect in future shooters and how much stuff you can cram into one game with a high level of polish and expertise--and not as an afterthought or as padding. [Nov 2007, p.50]

Read original review

Halo: Combat Evolved95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Surpassed the hype completely. [Dec 2001]

Left 4 Dead 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

An undisputable improvement over its predecessor in every way, and it steals its own crown as best co-op game on the Xbox. It's chainsaw-twirlingly good. [Holiday 2009, p.64]

Read original review

LIMBO95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

And really, what the team at Playdead has achieved here--in their very first game, no less--is just tremendous. [Oct 2010, p.72]

Mafia73/100 → 73 · Z -1.3416Score 70.6756

Mafia's real crime, though, is that it's a very good game wrapped in an absolute technical mess. [June 2004, p.74]

Mass Effect 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Mass Effect 2 overcomes its few gameplay weaknesses with a fantastic weave of dynamic combat, lavish presentation, and engaging character and weapon customization. But for all the myriad improvements that make Mass Effect 2's visuals so appealing and its combat so exhilarating, it's ultimately the way it moves us that makes it so memorable. [Feb 2010, p.56]

Mass Effect 395/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

From the visceral combat to the excitement of finishing Shepard's 100-hour fight, Mass Effect 3 is a rare, magnetically engaging treat that'll compel you to stay up well past your bedtime to do "just one more quest." Safe travels, fellow Shepards. See you starside.

Read original review

NFL 2K393/100 → 93 · Z 0.4285Score 88.3759

The best football game on the Xbox (or any other system) this year. [Oct 2002, p.100]

Ninja Gaiden Black90/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

Black does what the original did best, and hits the elevator button and ascends to an even higher level. [Nov 2005, p.134]

Pac-Man Championship Edition DX90/100 → 90 · Z 0.163Score 85.7208

In fact, it's the opposite: a cranked-up and damn near hypnotic high-energy sprint across a flashy, ever-shifting psychedelic racetrack. [Feb 2011, p.79]

Read original review

Portal 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Portal 2 isn't dessert - it's a delectable multi-course meal at a five-star restaurant. Make your reservation now.

Read original review

Remember Me (2013)75/100 → 75 · Z -1.1646Score 72.4456

While we have issues with some of Remember Me’s major features, the overall adventure is well worth experiencing. Even if some fights and branching paths lead you toward frustration, they’re merely parts of a journey that showcase a wildly unique story and the visuals to match.

Read original review

Rock Band 395/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

It's not only an achievement within it's own genre, but a landmark for the entire medium as well. [Nov 2010, p.64]

Sonic Adventure55/100 → 55 · Z -2.9346Score 54.7453

Sonic Adventure may have been a 3D revolution for Sega's storied franchise when it debuted in 1999, but in these HD-ified days, it just feel dated. [Nov 2010, p.69]

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic94/100 → 94 · Z 0.517Score 89.2609

Nothing short of breathtaking... The "Star Wars" game that fans of the movies have been waiting for since 1977. [Sept 2003, p.74]

Street Fighter IV95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

If you're a novice, a training mode and eight levels of difficulty will help you find your way. If you're a pro, SFIV contains all the depth you've ever loved about the series, without compromise. Capcom simply got the feel of Street Fighter perfectly right. [Feb 2009, p.76]

Read original review

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Take heed when staring at Oblivion on a store shelf: Your $60 will go father than it ever has, but prepare to get hooked for the long haul. [Apr 2006, p.69]

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim100/100 → 100 · Z 1.048Score 94.571

Skyrim is the kind of game you can completely lose yourself in for at least a hundred hours, even if you somehow manage to complete the main quest in fewer than twenty. If you aren't normally drawn to role-playing games, get over it - to miss out on this extraordinary gaming experience would be positively criminal.

Read original review

The Orange Box95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

The Orange Box packs so much quality content into one $60 title that it sets an almost dangerous precedent for all other developers and publishers. [Dec 2007, p.58]

Read original review

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell96/100 → 96 · Z 0.694Score 91.0309

By fully intersecting its Xbox-caliber visual and audio presentation with wide-open stealth action gameplay, it submerges you in a gripping, nerve-pounding atmosphere that will leave you begging for more. [Dec 2002, p.50]

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory99/100 → 99 · Z 0.9595Score 93.686

Between the compelling gameplay of the single-player missions, the value of the versus mode, and the perfect integration of co-op play over Live, this is the definitive Xbox game. The zenith of the platform... An utterly spectacular accomplishment. [Apr 2005, p.72]

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6055Score 90.1459

Superior to the original Splinter Cell in every aspect: gameplay, graphics, sound, presentation, and to a degree, innovation. [May 2004, p.70]

Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.722Score 76.8707

Engaging combat carries Space Marine's campaign and multiplayer a long way, although we can't help but feel like a little more time - or maybe ambition - would have made this game a superstar. Still, it's one heck of an entertaining fragfest, and the ideas here should nicely set up a bolder, hopefully more memorable sequel.

Read original review