SourceCritic

Mafia

65.2829SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 65.6667 · 33 reviews

2004 · PC, Xbox, Playstation 2

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

1UP65/100 → 65 · Z -1.6771Score 67.3201

Since aiming and movement is too difficult to track enemies as they appear, a typical mission will have you die on the first enemy, learn his location and kill him before he can strike back, only to be felled by a second enemy, and so on.

Read original review

3DAvenue84/100 → 84 · Z -0.2037Score 82.0541

Everything about the game oozes both style and the replication of a 1930s era is second to none.

Read original review

Armchair Empire67/100 → 67 · Z -2.6213Score 57.8779

The same features, story, and style of the era survive the port, although the graphics, gameplay, and sound are roughed up.

Read original review

Boomtown60/100 → 60 · Z -2.4083Score 60.0085

Mafia looks, sounds and feels dated on the Xbox, maybe because we’ve been spoilt and we know what the machine is capable of this just doesn’t satisfy.

Cheat Code Central80/100 → 80 · Z -0.9677Score 74.4138

Mafia, when compared to other Xbox games, is still one hot little package, but compared to itself, it leaves a little to be desired.

Computer Games Magazine67/100 → 67 · Z -1.3311Score 70.7801

The most satisfying aspects of the game are the fantastic plot, excellent voice acting, and distinct score. [May 2004, p.11]

Console Gameworld77/100 → 77 · Z -1.1544Score 72.5475

While there certainly are a lot of things that could have been done better with the Xbox version of Mafia, it still remains an enjoyable game.

Read original review

Edge Magazine50/100 → 50 · Z -1.9601Score 64.4899

A frustrating port of an above-average game. Rather than attempting to significantly tweak Mafia's structure and narrative … the developer has attempted to replicate the PC experience to the letter. It has been only partially successful. [Mar 2004, p.109]

Electronic Gaming Monthly62/100 → 62 · Z -3.2609Score 51.4818

Highly frustrating missions pepper the game, usually filled with cheap enemies who have impeccable aim and a superhuman ability to absorb multiple shotgun blasts at point-blank range. [Apr 2004, p.116]

Read original review

Eurogamer50/100 → 50 · Z -2.236Score 61.7313

We're sorry to heap such bile on a game that we actually like at times, but it's a bit like hearing a bad cover version of a song that you've grown to like that some people still maintain is rubbish. Our advice? Buy the PC version of Mafia.

Read original review

Frictionless Insight60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8691Score 65.4006

For some people, the story will be compelling enough to make it worth playing through the single-player missions once, but the same effect can be comparably achieved by renting "Goodfellas" again.

Read original review

Game Chronicles65/100 → 65 · Z -2.913Score 54.9613

Even when it hits the $20 bargain bins it's still going to be a bad game. I can't stress enough that if you have a PC remotely capable of playing Mafia then please get the PC version.

Read original review

Game Informer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6988Score 77.1026

With compelling storytelling, and one ingenious mission after another, Mafia has enough firepower to keep you playing until the end. [June 2004, p.132]

Read original review

GameBiz75/100 → 75 · Z -1.3568Score 70.523

It is still a nice paced game that will take you a while to beat and require a fair bit of time for the not-so-talented gamer, but graphics have seemed to have dropped to a level that the PS2 can handle, and the camera angles are shocking along with the aiming system.

Read original review

GameCritics45/100 → 45 · Z -2.538Score 58.7115

The bland graphics, clunky controls, and atrocious load times (nearing 40 seconds in some instances) are nearly insurmountable shortcomings.

Read original review

GameSpot71/100 → 71 · Z -0.9868Score 74.2234

If you only played the Xbox version of Mafia, you'd still get a sense of the game's ambitious nature, and you'd enjoy some of its finer points, but you'd also miss out on the PC version's outstandingly good graphics and its more seamless gameplay experience.

Read original review

GameSpy60/100 → 60 · Z -2.7144Score 56.9472

The control scheme and bugs are by far the worst parts of the port, though they're not the only rough spot. Graphically, the game holds ground better.

Read original review

GameZone70/100 → 70 · Z -1.4688Score 69.4033

Don't get this game specifically for the driving or the shooting sequences. Rather, pick it up if you appreciate a solid story based action game with the mimicry of "GTA" (without all of the bells and whistles).

Read original review

Gaming Age67/100 → 67 · Z -1.5009Score 69.0817

On one hand, there's a strong narrative featuring beautiful cinematics and atmospheric music to set the mood perfectly. On the other, you have clunky on-foot controls combined with frustrating gameplay.

Read original review

IGN68/100 → 68 · Z -1.2948Score 71.1433

Sadly, beneath the awful looking exterior, the gameplay on Xbox is mixed at best. The poor framerate doesn't help any, the stiff controls are only worsened, and pretty much everything about the PC version is either watered down, ruined, or lost altogether.

Read original review

Maxim Online40/100 → 40 · Z -3.5426Score 48.6651

The play and story will ring familiar to anyone who’s played the "Grand Theft Auto" series—which is good—but the guy responsible for the crummy graphics should slip on a pair of cement galoshes and take a long walk off a short pier.

Read original review

MS Xbox World70/100 → 70 · Z -1.3826Score 70.2655

With a little patience regarding the overall speed of the game you will find an entertaining title that will grip you to the end. Not essential but a good game all round.

Read original review

Next Level Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -2.0752Score 63.3387

The Xbox is so capable of performing graphics that could blow these out of the water. There is so much to like about this game, but people are going to be turned off by how bad these graphics have made a downgrade from its PC brother.

Read original review

Official Xbox Magazine73/100 → 73 · Z -1.3416Score 70.6756

Mafia's real crime, though, is that it's a very good game wrapped in an absolute technical mess. [June 2004, p.74]

PGNx Media77/100 → 77 · Z -1.4838Score 69.2528

A big part of what made the PC version be so great was the whole atmosphere; you felt like you were in Chicago in the 1930s. Unfortunately, the visual inedibility of the Xbox version takes a good chunk of this feeling.

Read original review

RealGamer72/100 → 72 · Z -1.2283Score 71.808

A decent game with realistic if not frustrating driving sequences and an intriguing storyline.

Read original review

TeamXbox64/100 → 64 · Z -2.539Score 58.7016

Mafia contains none of the features which make a game next-gen on the Xbox. There is no online, multiplayer, or system link play. The game is brought to us by a two year old pc game so it is safe to say that the graphics have been seen before.

Read original review

TotalGames.net60/100 → 60 · Z -3.1009Score 53.0823

Though the feeling is epic and the ideas are there, the pace and quality is lacking.

Read original review

Worth Playing70/100 → 70 · Z -1.4767Score 69.3237

It is actually above-average, and one of the better games out there in comparison to the majority of what has been released these past few years.

Read original review

Xbox Nation Magazine40/100 → 40 · Z -3.2699Score 51.3917

Just another example of blown potential. [June 2004, p.87]

Xbox World Australia70/100 → 70 · Z -1.86Score 65.491

You shouldn’t need double-jointed thumbs nor the kind of patience required to endure its faults. As it is, I can only recommend Mafia to those that for one reason or another cannot play the game on the PC. It isn’t a bad game, it’s just not all that it could be.

Read original review

XboxAddict60/100 → 60 · Z -2.8202Score 55.889

The storyline alone makes this game worth taking a look at. Even though the driving aspects seem stiff and slow (and there is the occasional buffering/loading problem when you hit near the halfway point of the city), it is cool to tool around in the vehicles and on the streets of the 1930s.

Read original review

Xequted78/100 → 78 · Z -0.7844Score 76.2476

Driving tasks are fun but the on-foot missions are much more entertaining. If you can stomach the glitchy camera, lock and load for a truly epic and cinematic gaming experience.

Read original review