SourceCritic

Carole Quintaine

29 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj91.2069
Raw spread σj7.9498
Shrunk mean μ′j87.5887
Shrunk spread σ′j10.2281

Reviews from this outlet

007 First Light85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

007 First Light is a true success. While not without its flaws, IO Interactive's title manages to place a bold, modern, and refreshing James Bond at the heart of a captivating adventure with perfectly controlled pacing. Halfway between Hitman and Uncharted, it delivers an experience that lives up to the expectations one would have for a James Bond film: spectacular and stylish.

Read original review

Armored Core VI: Fires of Rubicon75/100 → 75 · Z -1.2308Score 71.7832

The 6th installment of the Armored Core series returns stronger than ever, despite sometimes unnecessarily arbitrary balancing in terms of difficulty and a serious lack of outstanding Bosses, veterans of the license will find with the pleasure of unique driving sensations as exhilarating as they are spectacular but also sometimes completely unreadable, leaving more than ever casual players aside.

Read original review

Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Black Flag Resynced marks the return of a great Assassin’s Creed game, but more importantly, the return of a true adventure. It is the kind of game that makes you want to set sail, explore, hunt for treasure, watch the sun go down over the ocean, and remember why Black Flag remains such a special entry in the series even today.

Read original review

Astro Bot100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Astro Bot is an excellent, brilliant game, full of good ideas, innovation and magic. It's a love letter to PlayStation but also and above all to video games. Asobi's game knows how to renew itself at every moment and offer something fun and intelligent in its gameplay mechanics. Fun and colorful, it offers a generous and definitely unforgettable experience. The GOTY 24 is undoubtedly here!

Read original review

Atomic Heart85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

Atomic Heart is a colorful title with a gripping story and powerful dialogue. Its universe between Bioshock and Wolfenstein absorbs you and takes you on a fast-paced adventure alongside a damn crazy and rather well-written hero. Not everything is perfect and everything remains fairly standard, but the experience is devilishly satisfying thanks to its effective gameplay, well-thought-out puzzles, lots of humor and fun. A really good explosive cocktail!

Read original review

Cyberpunk 207790/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Cyberpunk 2077 is an incredible game both in its universe and its mastered narration. Its scenario and the characters are perfectly written and one is immersed as rarely in an emptied game and this despite many bugs to be solved without delay. The progression of the character, the dialogue and the RPG aspect far outweigh the other facets of the game which, without being perfect, are nevertheless effective. CD Projekt Red’s title has a crazy identity and it is an unforgettable experience.

Read original review

Death Stranding100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Death Stranding stands as a powerful author’s game which drives a strong message of how our over-connected society is evolving, and how we can help other players. Unlike many AAA games, it shines on a truly spiritual level. Well written, engaging and visually magnificent, it offers, despite some pacing flaws, an astonishing solo game with elegant multiplayer elements. A unique representation of Hideo Kojima’s talent.

Read original review

Death Stranding 2: On The Beach95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7246Score 91.3371

Death Stranding 2 is a game of incredible grandeur. It follows in the footsteps of its predecessor while bringing enormous improvements to the quality of life of Sam Porter, and therefore of the players… Deliveries that aren’t always fun, hassles, long distances to cover… but all this to tell (extremely well) something so beautiful, so important. We love Death Stranding 2 terribly if we liked the first opus because it manages to make the ordinary extraordinary, by putting us in the shoes of this delivery man like no other, alongside complex and surprising characters, through such a dazzling universe… Because after all, what matters is the journey, right?

Read original review

Dragon Ball: Sparking! Zero90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Dragon Ball Sparking Zero is undoubtedly the Ultimate Dragon Ball game! With its game modes dedicated to creation and its deep and nervous gameplay not to mention a monumental roster, it is the worthy successor to Budokai Tenkaichi. We could regret that the Story mode is more of a summary focusing only on the highlights, but this mode remains incredibly rich, offering different points of view through the main fighters of the Dragon Ball universe. And even if some bugs can frustrate during combat, the overall experience remains enjoyable! In short, the best Dragon Ball game is here!

Read original review

Elden Ring100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Elden Ring is a game with a breathtaking universe, with crazy ambition. The effective gameplay coupled with the immense pleasure of exploration that is always rewarded are matched only by the fierce requirements of the game. More accessible than other FS productions, it offers the opportunity to discover a world of crazy elegance, with an artistic direction that is quite simply masterful. A generous world we no longer want to leave. An absolute masterpiece.

Read original review

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Shadow of the Tree is a real game in its own right, generous, powerful, with almost perfect execution. It manages to completely separate itself from Elden Ring, with an identity of its own and an extremely careful atmosphere. Despite a somewhat "light" ending and a slight imbalance in terms of bosses, we emerge from this adventure with a feeling of exhilaration specific to great journeys. Yet another monument to be added to the long list of From Software masterpieces, a delight of incredible violence, a definitely enchanting journey. Masterful!

Read original review

Final Fantasy XVI80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7419Score 76.6717

Final Fantasy 16 is a very good game, offering a touching and extremely well-told story. We feel that the story of Valisthéa and Clive and his friends is at the heart of the experience, much more than the gameplay. The latter is enjoyable thanks to the use of the powers of the Primordials and the fights with the creatures are visually incredible. Despite a very interventionist format and uninteresting side quests, FF 16 takes us on board and leaves us with a masterful journey.

Read original review

Ghost of Tsushima85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

Finally, even with its flaws (camera, perfectible AI, not very original screenplay...) Ghost of Tsushima takes you away. Its system of character evolution and its enjoyable gameplay make it a good experience, but it’s above all its highly elegant atmosphere that makes it the game, with details of absolute finesse and very cinematic sequences. The world offered to the player is a breathtaking beauty and one that yields an indescribable pleasure to roam. A sublime Haiku that feels like a graceful breeze around you after finishing it... Good Job Sucker Punch!

Read original review

God of War: Ragnarok100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

God of War Ragnarök is an absolute masterclass! Visually fantastically beautiful, it offers an adventure with a controlled, extremely generous, strong, human narration, with incredibly well-written characters, reversals of situations and dantesque fights with gameplay that is still just as nervous and even richer than that of the episode preceding it. The quality of Santa Monica's work is once again at the rendezvous with this pure video game masterpiece.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto VI100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

GTA 6 is an absolute masterpiece. Rockstar delivers a story of rare emotional power, with top-notch storytelling, deep and complex characters, masterful direction, a frenetic pace, and a profoundly alive world of unparalleled richness. I've never seen anything like it! Visually, it's a true revolution: to be honest, I've never seen anything so impressive in a video game. Add to that fantastic music and this incredible ability to make us feel so much emotion and adrenaline simultaneously… Simply exceptional. It's a true lesson in video game design, a monumental work that pushes the boundaries of the medium and reminds us why I love video games so much. Ultimately, there's Rockstar, and then there's everyone else.

Read original review

It Takes Two95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7246Score 91.3371

It Takes Two is an incredible game thanks to its ingenious and addictive gameplay and its fresh and neat universe. Josef Fares has a real gift for offering experiences in successful cooperation but here he sets the bar very high with a multitude of brilliant ideas at the heart of a touching and well-told story. A must to share without moderation!

Read original review

Monster Hunter Rise80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7419Score 76.6717

Monster Hunter Rise is a good Monster Hunter combining all the good ingredients of the license with a nice novelty: the Filoptères. These offer verticality and true dynamism to the gameplay with new possibilities. Everything seems faster, from harvesting to moving thanks to the Chumsky. The sets, the atmosphere, also contributes greatly to the quality of the overall experience, and if it is not a sometimes-capricious camera and some quests that get a little repetitive, we cannot blame the Capcom title much.

Read original review

Onimusha: Way of the Sword90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Despite some repetition, an overlong finale and an occasionally frustrating camera, Onimusha: Way of the Sword delivers a remarkable experience. Its highly addictive gameplay, rewarding progression, striking atmosphere and Musashi’s incredible charisma make this long-awaited comeback a resounding success.

Read original review

Ori and the Will of the Wisps90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Ori and the Will of the Wisps is a poignant story and its gameplay is richer than that of its predecessor; it offers plenty of new features with an interesting RPG dimension. The world of Moon Studios is always as magical for the eye and the mind, and enchanting music brings the perfect final touch to this dazzling adventure. Nevertheless, the game suffers from real technical problems: frequent framerate drops and freezes prevent you from fully enjoying this journey. Aside from that, Ori and the Will of the Wisps is almost perfect.

Read original review

Pragmata85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

Pragmata is a fantastic game with a beautifully crafted world! It offers unique gameplay, with a duality that might surprise some but works incredibly well once you get the hang of the hacking/shooting system. The combat is fast-paced and frenetic, and even if the loop is repetitive, it's genuinely enjoyable, especially since the two main characters are endearing and you'll want to see this adventure through to the end with them. Another great idea from Capcom.

Read original review

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7246Score 91.3371

Prince of Persia is a true masterpiece! Brilliant in its puzzles, demanding in its combat with its extremely nervous gameplay, gripping, thanks to a truly neat universe and a well-told story, it offers a strong experience, full of good ideas, in the purest tradition of Prince of Persia. Well done Ubisoft!

Read original review

Resident Evil Requiem100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Resident Evil Requiem delivers a powerful return to Raccoon City, blending emotional weight with masterfully paced survival horror…Its dual-protagonist structure offers two distinct yet perfectly balanced gameplay experiences. A stunning and confident evolution of the franchise that honors its legacy while pushing it forward.

Read original review

Saros85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

Saros offers an intense and highly addictive experience. Its world is impressive, its gameplay is exhilarating and the constant progression finally reduces frustration with each run. Furthermore, it boasts a well-told story, arguably more in-depth than Returnal's, which was already very well narrated. However, it's not without its flaws! Some bosses are less memorable than others, and some biomes are clearly less inspired than others... but it remains a brutal and extremely rewarding game.

Read original review

Split Fiction90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2357Score 86.4486

Split Fiction is an incredible game for two people to experience. It offers rich and varied gameplay, with ever more intelligent mechanics, but also a neat universe like all Hazelight productions. Josef Fares' studio has created yet another great gem for fans of the gameplay school. Well done!

Read original review

Star Wars Outlaws85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2531Score 81.5602

Star Wars Outlaws is a very good game with a neat, generous open world and extremely faithful to the Star Wars saga. The atmosphere is fantastic and we really find the atmosphere of the first films. The Uncharted-style sequences are really great to play and even if the infiltration moments end up being repetitive, certain parts will be unforgettable for fans of the saga, if only because we cross cult places. In addition, the reputation system reinforces the feeling of leading a real scoundrel's life, with real freedom and real consequences... The best Star Wars game I have ever played.

Read original review

Stray75/100 → 75 · Z -1.2308Score 71.7832

Stray is a good game, with a captivating universe. Beyond its pleasant artistic touch, its atmosphere is delicious, its gripping story and the characters that we will meet there are touching in a certain way. The gameplay mechanics are simple, we would have liked to go further on this aspect, but it works well and we take pleasure in embodying this cat, leading the investigation and going to the end of the adventure even if we would have appreciated its lasting a little longer.

Read original review

The Last of Us Part II100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

We wondered if The Last of Us 2 would manage to surpass the giant The Last of Us. It’s done, no problem! Powerful, visceral, this follow-up highlights the talents of Naughty Dog who tell a strong, deeply human story with real meaning. Beyond masterful gameplay and the sublime universe of the game, the player is pushed into his entrenchments, facing himself, with rage in the belly, tears in the eyes and head upside down. Simply a masterpiece!

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026)100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

This Nintendo Switch 2 remake is an absolute masterpiece. Breathtaking art direction, modernized gameplay that stays true to the original, brilliantly designed dungeons, memorable bosses, and beautifully re-orchestrated music… I rediscovered all the magic of my favorite adventure of all time, with the joy of experiencing it in a whole new light. A timeless masterpiece.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2134Score 96.2256

Zelda Tears of the Kingdom is a masterpiece! Its unparalleled sense of travel, its generosity, its intelligent gameplay already make it a cult title, which will leave its mark on the video game industry. In this sequel to Breath of the Wild, there are no more limits to the imagination, simply the pleasure of discovering, of creating but also of living a dantesque adventure, an epic journey in which the new possibilities make you dizzy. One of the greatest games of all time.

Read original review