SourceCritic

Quarter to Three

21 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj66.6667
Raw spread σj27.8317
Shrunk mean μ′j76.9164
Shrunk spread σ′j18.7722

Reviews from this outlet

Arma 340/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

When it clicks, the game is second-to-none which is why I’ll continue to play despite its many issues. With no campaign, spotty multiplayer, and poor canned scenarios, Arma III just isn’t a complete product at this time.

Read original review

Armello40/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

I admire what League of Geeks has attempted because I’m their target audience. But it’s deeply frustrating to peer down through this smear of bad decisions at a design I really want to play. This should be a great fifteen-minute adventure. It has the necessary components: smart interlocking gameplay systems, snappy pacing, adorable artwork and animation, a truly imaginative setting. But it’s not a fifteen minute adventure. It’s an hour-long interface nightmare. Armello, which would be a great boardgame, is a terrible videogame.

Read original review

Borderlands 2100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

I'm not terribly surprised that the studio that made the first Borderlands has created such a wildly good gunplay-based action RPG. But I'm surprised that the studio that stitched together Duke Nukem Forever and all those Brothers in Arms games has also made it such a joy to discover for reasons other than the awesome guns and gunplay. Bravo, Gearbox.

Read original review

Children of Morta80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1643Score 85.7338

But what the elevator pitch and basic description don’t convey is Children of Morta’s unique charm.

Read original review

Company of Heroes 220/100 → 20 · Z -3.0319Score 53.7717

Company of Heroes 2 might be the steepest tumble from game design genius to crassly missing the point that I’ve ever seen.

Read original review

Cyberpunk 207740/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

Cyberpunk’s running time is littered with familiar problems and zero interest in their solutions. It’s a design cluttered with the failings of a hundred other designs. The safe and familiar failings of the medium that can’t be pinned to CD Projekt specifically, but are nevertheless embraced with something that feels like enthusiasm. So I sigh and carry on to the ending of my choice, looking in vain for the actual cyberpunk in a sprawl of contrived and bland sci-fi.

Read original review

DmC: Devil May Cry80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1643Score 85.7338

DMC Devil May Cry is a best-case scenario for what happens when you take an established series and hand it over to a new developer to let them have a turn.

Read original review

Doki Doki Literature Club!80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1643Score 85.7338

The first hour or so are intentionally insufferable. Some of the best horror takes its time establishing what’s normal, because it has to show you what it’s going to break. Without normal, you wouldn’t know what’s weird. Without real, you wouldn’t know what’s surreal. Without victims, you wouldn’t know what’s monstrous. Without the anime dating sim, you wouldn’t know Doki Doki Literature Club.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto V100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

The primary accomplishment in Grand Theft Auto V isn’t gameplay. It’s character. Grand Theft Auto V believes so strongly in its characters that everything else — even gameplay — is secondary.

Read original review

Guild Wars 2100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

I can count on two hands the games I've loved as much as I now love Guild Wars 2. This isn't just a great example of the genre and arguably the Second Coming of MMOs. It isn't even just one of the best games I've ever played. This is what happens when a group of talented, smart, dedicated, imaginative, bold, consumer-friendly creators get together and spend years solving problems and making something wonderful.

Read original review

Hades100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

Hades success is very much indebted to its pacing. Game pacing is difficult in the best of circumstances; it’s impossible without extensive testing, consideration, and willingness to change things for the sake of player experience. This is all easy for people like me to say, with our monocles and berets and copies of the Chicago Manual of Style, plus maybe some Foucault if really pressed. “It’s all about the player experience.” “Design is law.” You can talk all day. But when the player starts getting frustrated at the lack of progress, or insufficient game cues, you might find yourself in a tough spot as a designer. How you get out of it, or if you even do, says a lot about your skill with design and production.

Read original review

Journey40/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

It mostly reminded me of some of the dull and barely interactive bits of Uncharted 3. I think the lesson here is that deserts are often poorly suited to games without dune buggies...There's no challenge and no real gameplay, which isn't necessarily a criticism. It's sort of like Shadow of the Colossus without any colossi, or Ico without the little girl.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1643Score 85.7338

Phantom Pain is a celebration of R-rated power fantasies and even a light sprinkling of grindhouse sex and violence, not the least bit inappropriate for a game with an M-rating. Here’s the only litmus test you need: if it’s good enough for movies, it’s good enough for videogames.

Read original review

Red Dead Redemption 2100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

Imagine an arthouse movie with summer blockbuster production values, as if Terrence Malick had been given a Star Wars movie. Imagine if Ubisoft had made Gone Home. Like Arthur Morgan himself, Red Dead Redemption 2 is meditative, laconic, a slow burn, drawn out and unhurried, sometimes even morose, more concerned with characters than spectacle. Let us go then, it suggests.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization VI40/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

It’s not my place to second guess game design. As you know, you go to Civilization with the game you have, not the game you might want or wish to have at a later time. But it is my place to note that when I go to Civilization, I’m looking for more than just a laid back single-player cities builder with the AI frittering idly in the margins. I cut my teeth on Sid Meier’s grand strategy without a brain-dead tactical layer drizzled over the top. I admire a lot of what Firaxis is doing to move on from the mess of Civilization V. They’re headed in the right direction, even if they are dragging a lot of baggage.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth40/100 → 40 · Z -1.9665Score 64.4257

All the decisions I’ve made have snowballed into a massive unwieldy clockwork of inconsequence, lumbering towards an inevitable conclusion like a giant Katamari ball consisting of all those little decisions, none of them steering it in any meaningful way, but each of them lending the monstrosity a tiny bit of mass. Then the ball reaches the requisite mass and a screen tells me I’ve won and I’m back at the main menu. No recap, no score breakdown, no map to admire, no ranking. Poof.

Read original review

SOMA100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2297Score 96.3878

As with any thoughtful storytelling, Soma works on multiple levels.

Read original review

Stellaris20/100 → 20 · Z -3.0319Score 53.7717

Imagine that your favorite history professor has written a sci-fi novel. You’re intrigued. You read it. It’s dry, bereft of imagination, and misses the point of sci-fi by light years. It’s even full of typos and some of the pages are blank. But you still read all 912 pages. It’s flat. It’s lifeless. It’s terrible. You’re crestfallen. That’s Stellaris.

Read original review

Super Mario 3D World60/100 → 60 · Z -0.9011Score 75.0798

If you’ve sampled a wider range of platformers, and if you don’t have an inherent predilection for Mario worlds, Super Mario 3D World will proceed like a pleasant enough curiosity. It’s a bit like hearing oldies on a radio station. It’s familiar and safe. Then it’s over and out of your head entirely, leaving you room to discover new and better music.

Read original review

The Last of Us60/100 → 60 · Z -0.9011Score 75.0798

There is no risk of failure in a game like this. There is only the risk of having the play the same section yet again. In a survival game, that’s anathema. A survival game without meaningful death isn’t a survival game. It’s just a game.

Read original review

XCOM: Enemy Unknown80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1643Score 85.7338

It knows. It understands. But not blindly, not slavishly. More than a fan of X-Com, this game is a fan of the tenets of modern game design. It's doing exactly the right thing, in exactly the right ways, at exactly the right time.

Read original review