SourceCritic

Polygon

72 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj80.9028
Raw spread σj13.1055
Shrunk mean μ′j81.8405
Shrunk spread σ′j12.907

Reviews from this outlet

Absolver85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Whatever gets added in the future, though, I hope that Absolver doesn’t lose its sense of focus. If the game had tried too much — if it had thrown me into more complicated duels, or forced me to use weapons more often — I don’t think I would have found it nearly as appealing. Instead, Absolver recognizes its singular goal of building a robust, satisfying martial arts combat system. It leans into those strengths, and it’s a better game for it.

Read original review

Arma 365/100 → 65 · Z -1.3048Score 71.0436

The game that Bohemia Interactive has released isn’t finished. It’s pretty at rest, but not always attractive in motion. At no point does it want to make itself clear.

Read original review

BioShock Infinite100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

For everything it has to say, for all the questions it asks —many of which have no easy answers — BioShock Infinite's big thoughts and complicated narrative don't obscure the brilliant action game that carries those messages through.

Read original review

Borderlands 275/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

Borderlands 2 is unquestionably a better game than Borderlands. The new emphasis on elemental weapons and dismemberment make for better combat scenarios, and the constant character improvement is a great push forward for players looking for long-term rewards. But sticking around for those payoffs requires more patience than I'd hoped.

Read original review

Castlevania: Lords of Shadow - Mirror of Fate50/100 → 50 · Z -2.4669Score 59.422

Mirror of Fate fails to build an identity of its own, but more damningly it fails to create a believable likeness of its lineage.

Read original review

Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 250/100 → 50 · Z -2.4669Score 59.422

That's really the biggest shame in Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2: It carries over all of the original game's weaknesses but fails to live up to its strengths.

Read original review

Company of Heroes 270/100 → 70 · Z -0.9174Score 74.9174

Company of Heroes 2 would be a singular kind of RTS, if the previous game didn’t exist. While Company of Heroes had its own host of practical issues that Company of Heroes 2 looks to fix — matchmaking and server stability among them — it’s difficult to see how the sequel makes enough forward progress. Company of Heroes 2 is a good game, and a great, unique multiplayer experience. But the most frustrating thing about Company of Heroes 2 is how disinterested it appears to be in showing players exactly what it does best.

Read original review

Cuphead85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

When I think of my time with Cuphead, instead of frustration I'll remember the dozens of tiny breakthroughs, when the impossible became possible, and a game that built an identity around difficulty helped me to feel, however briefly, undefeatable.

Read original review

Dark Souls III70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9174Score 74.9174

In so many important ways — its world design, its pacing, the technology powering it — Dark Souls 3 falls short of the mark. Do you play for the joy and stress of exploring dangerous, intricately crafted places full of hidden elements and endless side paths? Then I suspect you'll join me in being a little let down with the direction this sequel has gone in.

Read original review

Darkest Dungeon80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

In its best moments, Darkest Dungeon makes me feel crazy and hopeless. There's something I can't say for most games: The times when I most felt that I had irrevocably fucked up were also the times when the game was at its strongest.

Read original review

Destiny 290/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

As an overall product, Destiny 2 is an incredible feat. Bungie spent three years essentially beta-testing this game, and used the knowledge gained from its predecessor to improve and fine-tune just about every aspect of the experience. As with the original, there are still rough patches to pave over, but the astoundingly fun game here is beautiful, funny, varied and constantly rewarding to play.

Read original review

Dishonored90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Dishonored succeeds as an ambitious game not content to take one thing and do it well. It demands more than most games ever will of its player, and gives more to players than most other games will ever manage.

Read original review

Dishonored 285/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Despite a murderous new sense of difficulty and a few surprising, if minor, shortcomings, Dishonored 2 is a much more fleshed-out realization of the world of Dunwall and the star-crossed Kaldwin family. For such a miserable, conflicted place, Dunwall and the Isles are a place worth exploring, something gaming could use a lot more of.

Read original review

Divinity: Original Sin II70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9174Score 74.9174

Divinity: Original Sin 2 has an abundance of things to see and do, a staggering amount of secrets to unearth and plenty of tricks up its sleeve. Yet almost every cool moment I experienced sits shoulder-to-shoulder with an equally weighted disappointment. Ambitious and impressive as it often is, it’s ultimately a collection of incredibly pretty beads that just don’t string together as well as they should.

Read original review

DmC: Devil May Cry80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

The game's tone falls apart as it fluctuates between deadpan and dopey, but the action never falters. Fights are fast, intense and fun, and they're aided by a world where nothing is what it seems and nothing stays the same for long. I just wish Ninja Theory had matched the mesmerizing level design with a character who I actually want to spend time around.

Read original review

Dota 285/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

And this dichotomy is perhaps the best descriptor I can attach to Dota 2. It is frequently a game which occupies two opposite spaces simultaneously. It is the best game. It is also the worst game. No game has ever made me as miserable as Dota 2 has. But no game has made me feel so consistently rewarded for my time, and as consistently, wonderfully connected to the friends I play it with.

Read original review

Dragon Ball FighterZ85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Dragon Ball as a series has always forefronted epic battles. In each episode of the cartoon, godlike warriors transformed the landscape in fantastic one-on-one fights with ease. In FighterZ, anyone can feel like that in any fight. I’ve been waiting for a Dragon Ball game like this ever since I first saw the cartoon in grade school, and I’m so happy this day has come.

Read original review

Fable50/100 → 50 · Z -2.4669Score 59.422

A curiosity at best — and an infuriating disservice to the series' legacy at worst.

Read original review

Fallout 495/100 → 95 · Z 1.0196Score 94.2867

Fallout 4 brings great gameplay to match its world and ambiance

Read original review

Far Cry 565/100 → 65 · Z -1.3048Score 71.0436

It’s a finely tuned open-world game stapled onto a story that’s insultingly bad.

Read original review

Final Fantasy XV90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

The game contains pieces sure to disappoint players in both camps, but it also provides a refreshingly human take on the classic RPG journey that I hope will inspire future games in the franchise. Final Fantasy 15 can be baffling in some of its questionable choices, but across the board, it hits more than it misses. It hums with an energy and compassion that I loved, a sense of camaraderie, friendship and adventure that fills an old and struggling formula with new relevance.

Read original review

For Honor80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

For Honor feels very much like a well-made (and gorgeously presented) sports video game to me, in that it’s a stout challenge but honest about its expectations. In all of my failures I knew why I lost, and had only the feeble excuse that maybe I needed more time to plan my attack. Players must ask themselves if they're willing to put in the work and practice to meet the talented competition in For Honor, which presents a deep and long-playing proposition in its multiplayer even if the single-player campaign is rote and not worth revisiting. It's easy to give up against such uncompromising and fast-paced combat, but those who stay with it are there to fight for something other than mere survival.

Read original review

God of War100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

God of War is, in a single word, holistic. Every aspect is excellent on its own, but more importantly, it all serves and accentuates the larger vision. Some die-hard fans may fear this isn’t really God of War. I suppose they’re right. It’s even better.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto V95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0196Score 94.2867

Rockstar has expanded and improved upon so much of what's special about video games as mainstream spectacles, from the playful use of characters to the refined take on world design. The developer's progress makes the aspects of the game left in cultural stasis — the poorly drawn women, the empty cynicism, the unnecessarily excessive cruelty — especially agitating.

Read original review

Guild Wars 285/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

It rewards skill and variety rather than mindless grinding. And it does all of this in a massive, persistent world without asking for a subscription fee.

Read original review

Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Hellblade successfully weaves metaphors of grief and loss into fundamental game mechanics and rich folklore, and through these I felt like I truly was able to understand how someone else sees the world.

Read original review

Injustice 290/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Injustice 2 is NetherRealm once again outdoing itself. This is the best, most polished, most impressively produced story mode to ever feature in a fighting game. The game’s cast — more than a dozen of which are newly playable characters — is varied and interesting, thanks to additions like Swamp Thing, Supergirl and the Red Lantern who has a blood-vomiting space cat, Atrocitus. Even if you aren’t a diehard DC Universe fan, there’s bound to be someone on the roster you’ll love to play as...Plus, you get to beat up Superman.

Read original review

INSIDE95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0196Score 94.2867

Inside achieves something that Limbo didn't: It actually lives up to its opening moments, delivering astounding setpieces and an unforgettable final sequence. Those jaw-dropping last moments are a fitting endcap to this superbly crafted, beautiful game.

Read original review

Little Nightmares85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Little Nightmares' creepiness makes a lasting impression

Read original review

Mass Effect 3100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

As a bombastic action-RPG with no previous context, Mass Effect 3 is a dark, engaging game with great combat, a well-written story, and all the epic space-opera you could want. But for those who have played through Mass Effect and Mass Effect 2, it's something much more.

Read original review

Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Platinum Games has done something incredibly rare: honoring a beloved series while successfully broadening its reach into a whole new genre.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes55/100 → 55 · Z -2.0795Score 63.2958

It's staggeringly short and unsatisfying, feeling more like a cash grab than an honest-to-goodness installment in a beloved franchise.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

If this is where Kojima does finally leave the series he created, it will be a bittersweet send-off, both for Big Boss and one of gaming's most intriguing auteurs.

Read original review

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0196Score 94.2867

Shadow of Mordor is that ultimate rarity. It tells a fun little story that would be enough to hold up most games on their own. But it also provides all of the tools to ensure that the most interesting tales to come out of the game will be the ones that were not scripted.

Read original review

Middle-earth: Shadow of War75/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

If you can get past the microtransactions, Shadow Wars seems set to provide a much meatier extended playtime than Shadow of Mordor ever offered. But more than anything, that’s my biggest disappointment with Middle-earth: Shadow of War: Everything about it seems to come with a caveat, some small annoyance or two that you need to dig past to get to the still-very-fun game underneath. The Nemesis System is still a wonder that has yet to be replicated. The movement and combat are thrilling.

Read original review

Monster Hunter: World90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Monster Hunter: World scratches the itch for complexity, both in hunt for rare gear and skill with its weapons, but this time it’s a game that no one should be intimidated to get into.

Read original review

Neverwinter80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Neverwinter certainly has room to grow, but the amount of game that's available with no barrier of entry — neither fiscal nor educational — is mind-boggling. It misses the mark somewhat on that Dungeons & Dragons feeling of absolute character ownership, but that doesn't make the game any less refreshing to play. With its fast-paced combat and ubiquitously streamlined design, Neverwinter nails the concept of what an action-MMO should be.

Read original review

NieR: Automata80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Nier demands patience with its antics - not to mention its definition of "ending" - but its patience was rewarded.

Read original review

No Man's Sky60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6921Score 67.1697

These powerful universe creation algorithms have been grafted onto a game that is, beyond its initial hours, so light on imagination. No Man's Sky offers an incredible, impossible universe — but there's little to do within it.

Read original review

Ori and the Blind Forest90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Ori and the Blind Forest is a rare realization of fantastic design and production values in a space where I wasn't expecting to find it, displaying a spectacular level of confidence in what it is and what it does.

Read original review

Overwatch80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Overwatch can be great, but needs friends to back it up

Read original review

Persona 4 Golden100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

It's the tightest, best-written, and most must-play game Atlus has ever created. Persona 4 started as a strong, singular RPG; with Persona 4 Golden, it is a masterpiece.

Read original review

Persona 590/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

It successfully pushes this series to new heights of polish, allure and charm. It has a few blemishes, enough to distract a bit from the intriguing and weighty themes that the game wrestles with. But even through the rough patches, Persona 5 doesn’t give up a drop of its colorful personality.

Read original review

PlanetSide 275/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

You should play it because its most exciting moments don't occur when you turn the corner and paint a target in your sights. They occur when you're sitting in a troop transport, rolling towards an opposing force, and wondering how the battle will unfold - even if those battles aren't always perfect.

Read original review

Plants vs Zombies: Garden Warfare 280/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

If Garden Warfare was an attempt to make a multiplayer only shooter that just about anyone could enjoy, Garden Warfare 2 takes that a step farther by removing the original's budget-priced compromises. Making the original Popcap concept into a shooter isn't novel anymore, and I hope that the developers pay attention to the game's potential balance challenges over time to make sure that "asymmetric" doesn't become "lopsided." But Garden Warfare 2 stands strong on its own, and with friends.

Read original review

Quantum Break85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

There's some wonky shooting and a few cringe-worthy story cliches present. But ineffective cover systems and narrative fridges notwithstanding, Quantum Break feels like the first action game taking real lessons from the Netflix binge-watch era, and in that respect, it's a surprising success.

Read original review

Rain World50/100 → 50 · Z -2.4669Score 59.422

With core systems opaque and unnecessarily limited, all I ever felt equipped to do in Rain World was fail.

Read original review

Remember Me (2013)80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Remember Me eyes trouble the most pointedly when it falls prey to overused video game conventions. But Remember Me's fiction and world-building make it more than just another running, jumping and climbing oriented beat-em-up - they make it a future worth exploring.

Read original review

Resident Evil 7: biohazard90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

It's hard to know if Resident Evil 7 will stand the test of time as much as classics like the original, or RE4. Taken on its own, however, it's an excellent game that pushes the series in worthy new directions.

Read original review

Risk of Rain 280/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Has Risk of Rain 2 had as much of an impact as Mario 64? Of course not. Its scope is decidedly narrow and its ambitions are confined to a small world focused on frantic combat in a straightforward, never-ending gameplay loop. But did Risk of Rain 2 reframe a game that I still consider close to perfection? Absolutely. Should Hopoo ever make a Risk of Rain 3, I’m hard-pressed to imagine what it will look like — my imagination swims at the thought of universes the studio hasn’t shown me yet.

Read original review

Sea of Thieves65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3048Score 71.0436

Sea of Thieves has the foundation of an incredible experience. It is a true pirate game that simulates the experience of piracy perfectly. And yet, after those first few jaw-dropping hours, you’re going to start feeling less like Blackbeard and more like Blackbeard’s accountant.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization VI85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2448Score 86.539

Civilization 6 is an advance on the previous game, offering more variety, smarter use of assets and a wider palette of potential activities. It remains the best of its kind, always demanding my attention, forever creating new narratives out of stats and maps. But it fails to move the concept of a history simulation beyond the ambitions set 25 years ago. We've reached the point where Civ games are as much a simulation of themselves, as they are of the march of human progress.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

Packed with big ideas about science and science fiction, it meticulously interlocks dozens of strategic gaming systems that work together at a level that approaches genius.

Read original review

SOMA90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

I don't know if SOMA will scare people as much as Amnesia did, but it is without a doubt a stronger game, with better pacing, smarter writing and more powerful subject matter.

Read original review

Stardew Valley90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

No simulation or game is an exact copy of what it’s trying to emulate, but Stardew Valley, above all, expertly explores the connection that someone can have with their environment, their work and the people around them.

Read original review

Stellaris75/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

What I'm most hoping for are official, bolt-on replacements for systems like diplomacy and ship building, which just aren’t quite as polished as I’d like to see at release.

Read original review

Stray100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

Stray is the work of sly cat people, and it’s a triumph

Read original review

Super Mario 3D World90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

It gets the balance right between nostalgic touches and clever new twists, and never once let me down with a boring boss or too-familiar retread. In all my years of playing with the Mario gang, I've never been quite so happy to hurl myself into the unknown, and 3D World delivers challenge, surprise and joy in almost every moment.

Read original review

Super Mario Odyssey95/100 → 95 · Z 1.0196Score 94.2867

For a character nearing 40 years old, it’s amazing that Mario has remained not only a beloved character but one whose games are generally expected to be great. From that perspective, it’s no surprise that Super Mario Odyssey is, yes, a great game. But more than that, it’s a fantastic, even fundamental addition to Mario’s legacy. From a plumber to a doctor to a tennis star to, uh, a Goomba, Mario has endured. No, this will not be the last Mario game, but it is almost certain to be lauded as one of his best.

Read original review

The Elder Scrolls Online60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6921Score 67.1697

We approached Elder Scrolls Online as fans of the series and as MMO lovers, but it came up short from both perspectives. It's missing that spark of magic that enticed us to get lost in Skyrim or Morrowind for months, or that made us happy to fork over a monthly fee just to access our current favorite game. It seems like so much effort was put into forcibly translating Elder Scrolls' style into the genre's norms, but the payoff for that effort isn't there.

Read original review

The Last of Us75/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

Naughty Dog commits to a somber tone that affects every piece of the game for better and worse. It achieves incredible emotional high points about as often as it bumps up against tired scenario design that doesn't fit its world. Survival in the post-apocalypse requires compromise, but The Last of Us has given up something vital.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild100/100 → 100 · Z 1.4069Score 98.1606

I guess, in the end, it’s not just that Breath of the Wild signals that Zelda has finally evolved and moved beyond the structure it’s leaned on for so long. It’s that the evolution in question has required Nintendo to finally treat its audience like intelligent people. That newfound respect has led to something big, and different, and exciting. But in an open world full of big changes, Breath of the Wild also almost always feels like a Zelda game — and establishes itself as the first current, vital-feeling Zelda in almost 20 years.

Read original review

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

The Witcher 3's subject matter, its almost defiant doubling down on its treatment of women as titillating props for Geralt and the player, even as it tries to flesh out more female leads, is its most disappointing aspect. This constant presence weighs down what would otherwise be an excellent bit of closure for Geralt's video game saga — which isn't helped by the control issues that often detract from sequences meant to break up open-world monotony.

Read original review

Titanfall 270/100 → 70 · Z -0.9174Score 74.9174

Titanfall 2 has the basics down, but loses much of the focus

Read original review

Total War: WARHAMMER II80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Pairing the tactical brilliance of the Total War series with the rich lore of the Warhammer universe is a natural fit, and Total War: Warhammer 2 fulfills the promise of that combination. It is a deep and challenging experience with an epic story to tell. It is also one of the most overwrought games of the year, a game where complexity seems to be piled on for complexity's sake.

Read original review

Uncharted 4: A Thief's End90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6322Score 90.4129

There is nothing cheap about how Naughty Dog has decided to retire this franchise — no door is left open for a crass surprise sequel — and there's nothing ambiguous about its resolution. Every other Uncharted game has, to varying degrees, posed a question — "can a thief be good?" — and summarily moved on without wagering a guess. In finding an answer, Uncharted 4's story soars, and presents a moving, fulfilling finale.

Read original review

V Rising80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

On the surface, V Rising appears to be just another survival game, slathered with a different coat of paint. In many ways, it’s hard to argue otherwise. However, it manages to layer complex systems inspired by the popular mythology of the vampire to distinguish it from the sea of survival games. While V Rising hasn't completely satiated my thirst in its current form, I’m hopeful that it will somewhere down the line.

Read original review

Warframe50/100 → 50 · Z -2.4669Score 59.422

You could play literally any other competent third person shooter from this or the last generation, and have a comparable — and very likely better — experience.

Read original review

Watch Dogs 280/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

In expanding the first game's clever hacking options and through a story about taking on a system overwhelmingly stacked against the people, Watch Dogs 2 strikes an even more powerful chord at this precise moment in time. And if it went just a little bit farther in embracing that story and found a better balance between silliness and seriousness, it would be essential, rather than just cathartic. [Provisional Score = 80]

Read original review

XCOM 280/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

Much more problematic, however, is the quality of the multiplayer component of the game. It is, in a word, dreadful.

Read original review

Xenoblade Chronicles 275/100 → 75 · Z -0.53Score 78.7913

enoblade 2 may remind you of a host of older console RPGs ranging from Grandia to Tales of Symphonia, and in the end it even circles back around to touch on other Xeno games. Ultimately, though, Xenoblade 2 is its own thing, and that's something rare and precious these days outside of the indie gaming space. Cherish this weird little creature, warts and all.

Read original review

Yakuza 080/100 → 80 · Z -0.1426Score 82.6651

The problem with tough guy heroes isn't that they're done too often, it's that they're so rarely done well. In that regard, Yakuza 0 felt like a revelation — even in spite of some significant shortcomings. It keeps a consistent, strong pace, and it doesn’t meander through side streets you’d rather avoid. But more importantly, it’s just so damned cool. It's vicious and grand, but bears its heart and soul. It has fun without completely sacrificing its gravitas.

Read original review