SourceCritic

Play.tm

36 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj91.8889
Raw spread σj9.0853
Shrunk mean μ′j88.3445
Shrunk spread σ′j10.6059

Reviews from this outlet

BioShock98/100 → 98 · Z 0.9104Score 93.1951

By far and away the very pinnacle of first-person shooters, with 2K achieving those heady heights by braving to not just push against established genre barriers and expectations but to rip them out and place BioShock atop the pile as a landmark pseudo-RPG first-person shooter that will be a benchmark of quality for many years to come. Staggering.

Read original review

Braid94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

Braid is the most gorgeous slice of chocolate cake you can possible imagine wrapped in a silk cloth and tied with a pink ribbon. It's a paradoxical experience of simplistic charm and over-bearing sensory and logical complexity. No one in the gaming world should miss out on playing this game, to do so would be a tragedy.

Read original review

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare95/100 → 95 · Z 0.6275Score 90.3665

The single-player is a little short, but the action is relentless and polished to the point of reflection, the multiplayer, meanwhile, will keep you coming back time and again. This is the next-generation. A bona fide masterpiece.

Read original review

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6275Score 90.3665

The cinematic appeal of the singleplayer action makes it infectious and hugely memorable in a way few if any other games can manage. That this is bundled with the best multiplayer experience of any game really leaves us in little doubt that this is the complete package.

Read original review

Champions Online70/100 → 70 · Z -1.7296Score 66.7947

Champions Online holds a lot of promise and is the type of game that brings a smile to your face as you play despite its flaws, but it does still need some work.

Read original review

Company of Heroes93/100 → 93 · Z 0.439Score 88.4807

Company of Heroes is superb; a perfect blend of intelligent strategy and powerful visceral action, delivering such a natural World War II experience you'll be left wondering if you're even allowed to enjoy it as much as you do.

Read original review

Fallout 396/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Bethesda's apocalyptical Fallout 3 belies its own jaw-dropping desolation by delivering a near-faultless action RPG that manages to not only execute compelling first-person gameplay but also provides an influential and in-depth character evolution system that's supported by an intriguing storyline and a mind-boggling game world that screams "Game of the Year" at every turn.

Read original review

Final Fantasy XIV Online49/100 → 49 · Z -3.7097Score 46.9944

Final Fantasy XIV offers the potential but for now, it's lacking in too many areas to recommend.

Read original review

Gears of War83/100 → 83 · Z -0.5039Score 79.052

It refines and codifies the advances that prior titles have made before it and packages all these lessons in what are undeniably sumptuous visuals.

Read original review

Gears of War 296/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

I pity the developers that have to release their games around the same period as this, because Gears of War 2 is magnificent.

Read original review

God of War II97/100 → 97 · Z 0.8161Score 92.2522

As action games go GOWII certainly has one of the most elegantly plotted and skilfully woven stories ever, perfectly mining its mythological setting to deliver an experience full of all the delightful twists, awe inspiring set pieces and huge battles that you'd hoped for.

Read original review

God of War III94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

Some of the most engrossing combat and visceral action the PS3 has to offer - presented expertly.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars93/100 → 93 · Z 0.439Score 88.4807

It says something about the virtues of Chinatown Wars that the only thing possibly denying it the perfect GTA status is the soundtrack. The mini-games are plentiful but never outstay their welcome, the slick presentation pushes the boundaries of the DS, and the range of content creates an extensive but wonderfully accessible game. It's phenomenal, a game that I keep dipping into whenever the possibility arrives, and a desperately needed addition to the DS's library.

Read original review

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas91/100 → 91 · Z 0.2504Score 86.595

GTA may be looking its age and some of its more favoured structural ideas are beginning to feel a little dated, but Rockstar continue to revel in the mastery of presenting a consuming environment to the player and inviting them to do within it what they wish.

Read original review

Half-Life 295/100 → 95 · Z 0.6275Score 90.3665

An ephemeral and controversial ending, along with the few issues described above, means that for me, Half-Life 2, while a compelling and highly enjoyable game, falls short of the size of impact that the first title had on the gaming world.

Read original review

Halo 396/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

While Halo 3 doesn't look as good as games like "Gears of War" and "BioShock" it makes up for that with superb lighting effects, an engaging storyline and a multiplayer mode that will be played countless times over.

Read original review

LIMBO94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

Extraordinary. It's as if the word were invented for it.

Read original review

LittleBigPlanet93/100 → 93 · Z 0.439Score 88.4807

LittleBigPlanet is one of the most inviting game world's ever imagined, the concept is a masterstroke, the implementation slick.

Read original review

Mass Effect 297/100 → 97 · Z 0.8161Score 92.2522

Mass Effect 2 is a work of unreserved genius that not only surpasses its predecessor in almost every conceivable department, but also deserves to be listed alongside the greatest science-fiction properties in any medium. The perfect blend of rich, lustrous visuals, an evocative soundtrack and pure gameplay quality make Mass Effect 2 without question one of the best games of this or any generation, and anyone who believes otherwise, is just plain wrong.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

With, literally, entire discs full of extras, a new camera within the main game, the two original Metal Gear titles and an Online mode that finally makes full use of the PS2 broadband adapter, Subsistence is a game that should be in everyone's PS2 collection.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7868Score 76.2234

While Guns of the Patriots boasts lashings of in-game invention and creativity that's largely wrapped up in superb style and execution, it's all so unforgivably tainted by jaw-dropping gameplay brevity that it's truly difficult to raise the many, many good points above what is, for the most part, a succession of cut scenes that leave the player with an overwhelming sense of disconnection from one of gaming's most compelling characters and interactive franchises.

Read original review

Okami96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Okami is nothing short of an artistically inspired gaming masterpiece.

Read original review

Portal 297/100 → 97 · Z 0.8161Score 92.2522

A joy to play. There is no other way to describe it.

Read original review

Red Dead Redemption96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Perhaps not only the best game Rockstar has made thus far, but it's one of the best games we've ever played - an unreserved work of genius. It has its flaws and is by no means perfect, but Red Dead Redemption is to the Western what GTA is to the crime genre and should be held up as a definitive example of how open-world games are supposed to be made.

Read original review

Rome: Total War89/100 → 89 · Z 0.0618Score 84.7092

Niggly controls, cheating AI, cluttered management screens, a rash of aggravating bugs and an unshakeable sense of over familiarity all combine to keep Rome: Total War from being an outright classic.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization IV96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Firaxis have managed to thoroughly overhaul one of the classic games of all time and drag it up from its dark ages into the renaissance era. Even with its speedier gameplay Civ IV will be the cause of many sleepless nights and damaged relationships.

Read original review

Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Packed with a never-ending stream of variety across 30 single-player missions, StarCraft II certainly ticks all the boxes for those looking to ease themselves into the action against an A.I. opponent.

Read original review

Street Fighter IV94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

Despite a few incredibly minor niggles, Street Fighter IV arguably represents a new zenith for the series and puts every other beat 'em up in the shade. Visually and technically superior in every conceivable way, Street Fighter IV revives a much loved franchise and is unquestionably something genuinely special that will be appreciated for many years to come, much like its hallowed forebear.

Read original review

Super Mario Galaxy96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

Galaxy opts for a slow strong confident delivery rather than the showy tricks of its impostors. This may mean it takes a little while before you are really convinced. But, spend a little time and we are sure that you will be coming back again and again, just to be reminded of what it takes to make a great platform game in every sense of the word: running, jumping and exploration.

Read original review

Super Mario Galaxy 297/100 → 97 · Z 0.8161Score 92.2522

Playing through the game you can't help but be aware of the minds behind this marvel. This is not just ingenious, but also well balanced, always fair and never inconsistent. You know where you are with Super Mario Galaxy 2 because you are spending time with some old friends. Not really the characters themselves - familiar and cute as they are - but the creative talents behind it all.

Read original review

Super Smash Bros. Brawl85/100 → 85 · Z -0.3153Score 80.9378

Despite its absolutely luminal reception, there is a strong argument that Brawl will appeal to the two polar opposites of the gaming community but fall flat to the majority of 'middle class' gamers in between. The very casual gamer will enjoy the chaos and the pyrotechnics, the hardcore gamer will love the bizarre mojo they can discover to gain their edge, but the middle of the road party player will probably soon tire of the impetus of play without being able to access the deeper mysteries.

Read original review

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion93/100 → 93 · Z 0.439Score 88.4807

Oblivion excels in almost every department but emerges as absolutely more than the sum of its parts. When viewed as a complete creation, the RPG genre can offer little else to compare; the console market has never known such deeply involving and open-ended imagination; and there's certainly nothing on the Xbox 360 that better deserves the 'killer app' motif to-date.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

A wonderful title that invokes the very best of both the RPG and adventure genres, incorporating exploration, puzzles, narrative and platforming into a extensive and splendidly formed package.

Read original review

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

It might not be the utterly revolutionary Zelda title that we all expected and its not without its faults, but one thing is clear: Twilight Princess is worth the Wii's price tag alone, even if the fishing does put you at risk of a coronary.

Read original review

The Orange Box94/100 → 94 · Z 0.5332Score 89.4236

And don't forget: The blend of near-faultless quality and originality associated with the amassed content threatening to burst free of Valve's collection can be secured for the price of a single Xbox 360 title, which near demands that The Orange Box finds its way onto your disc tray at the earliest possible opportunity.

Read original review

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves96/100 → 96 · Z 0.7218Score 91.3093

A game that manages to feel like a genuinely significant step forward while retaining everything that was so great about the original. The addition of a stunning multiplayer component and the creative freedom of the Cinema mode are like the enjoyably overindulgent pudding after a wonderfully satisfying main meal that make you thankful for elastic waistbands.

Read original review