SourceCritic

Kill Screen

24 reviews. Catalog baseline μ_global 84.0911, σ_global 12.4306.

μj and σj are this outlet's raw mean and spread. μ′j and σ′j are the shrunk values used when scoring a game—pulled toward the catalog so a thin history cannot dominate. See how the score works.

Raw mean μj71.875
Raw spread σj17.5791
Shrunk mean μ′j78.6617
Shrunk spread σ′j14.7188

Reviews from this outlet

Aragami56/100 → 56 · Z -1.5396Score 68.6947

A good game, like any good work of art, should make you wonder; it should give you a reason to care about what happens, just as it should give you reasons to enjoy what it asks you do. Aragami feels only half-invested in doing both of those things, so it does neither. By failing to follow through on its own best ideas, it leaves us with nothing but a shadow of the game that could have been.

Read original review

Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 260/100 → 60 · Z -1.2679Score 71.4123

For all its physical beauty, it can be an ugly game—remember that family-murder, remember that awkward, stilted script. How well can you look past this ugliness to find the redeeming qualities within?

Read original review

Dark Souls II83/100 → 83 · Z 0.2947Score 87.0386

[T]here's still something powerful about DS2's dogged preservation of old forms

Read original review

Dark Souls III86/100 → 86 · Z 0.4986Score 89.0768

When you climb the craggy steps to fight Sword Master, you're maybe 15 minutes into the game, which is enough time to see that it is great.

Read original review

Darkest Dungeon83/100 → 83 · Z 0.2947Score 87.0386

It is a beautifully gothic dungeon-crawler with a wealth of clever mechanics, the most unique of which is that, as your adventurers delve deeper into Lovecraftian tunnels, coves, and ruins, they become stressed.

Read original review

Fallout 476/100 → 76 · Z -0.1808Score 82.2827

Bethesda’s team creates maps that are a joy to explore.

Read original review

Furi75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2488Score 81.6033

Furi is undoubtedly repetitive, but that doesn’t need to be a strike against it.

Read original review

INSIDE88/100 → 88 · Z 0.6344Score 90.4356

Playdead’s greatest feat in creating Inside was making it look like they never created it in the first place.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes59/100 → 59 · Z -1.3358Score 70.7329

Ground Zeroes is an assured, above-average stealth shooter, something there are an abundance of. For years there has been a vocal group of people who have sought to temper the excesses and eccentricities of Hideo Kojima. In Ground Zeroes, Kojima has finally found an editor.

Read original review

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain69/100 → 69 · Z -0.6564Score 77.5269

The Phantom Pain is different. It, like its predecessors, wants to remind the player that war is, indeed, hell. But, in giving over to structural bloat it obscures the tremendous promise established in its opening hours, trading the narrative power of violent anguish for a routine, Sisyphean take on torment.

Read original review

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor77/100 → 77 · Z -0.1129Score 82.9622

These theoretical games are why it can feel like Shadow of Mordor is not “a good Lord of the Rings game” but simply a good game. But the truth is that it is a good game in spite of the fact that it has bones that threaten to burst from the fantasy skin laid overtop; that it is yearning to mutate out of this Lord of the Rings form and into something truly revolutionary.

Read original review

No Man's Sky87/100 → 87 · Z 0.5665Score 89.7562

This is the experience of playing No Man’s Sky, a series of recurring structures that overlap and intersect, a surprisingly knowable collection of repeatable actions.

Read original review

Quantum Break62/100 → 62 · Z -1.132Score 72.7711

While the interactive core of Quantum Break is a serviceable ode to pulp science-fiction, the episodes are a reminder of what makes the genre enjoyable beyond metaphysical thought exercises: the ridiculousness.

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization VI75/100 → 75 · Z -0.2488Score 81.6033

The suburbanization, the cartoonish aesthetic, and the “one more turn” addictiveness are still recognizable parts of the core experience people keep coming back for. It is still a full, massive, joyous videogame, even if I have to squint to find the joy beneath mere wit—but the two extremes are now growing wider and wider apart. How long before the fabric of the game snaps under the strain?

Read original review

Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth70/100 → 70 · Z -0.5885Score 78.2063

Truth be told, though, Beyond Earth likely won’t have quite the staying power of either Alpha Centauri or Civilization V. Ultimately, Firaxis’s latest effort feels more like a sci-fi mod of Civilization V than a fully-formed project in its own right. But perhaps we should not be so quick to dismiss it, if not for play, then at least for thought.

Read original review

SOMA80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0909Score 85.0004

As the title suggests, SOMA wears its sci-fi influences proudly on its sleeve.

Read original review

Stardew Valley73/100 → 73 · Z -0.3847Score 80.2445

Despite all odds, it seems Stardew Valley is a different game than the one it mimics. And a pretty fun, different game at that.

Read original review

Stellaris69/100 → 69 · Z -0.6564Score 77.5269

Like Mass Effect, Dune, Foundation, and countless other sci-fi universes, it builds its extraterrestrial world from the ground up. Stellaris only borrows from all of their palettes to paint its own picture of the night sky—and a game about aliens feels all the less foreign as a result.

Read original review

Super Mario 3D World0/100 → 0 · Z -5.3443Score 30.6482

Super Mario 3D World is an embodiment of joy.

Read original review

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt87/100 → 87 · Z 0.5665Score 89.7562

No other developer has brought an open world to life the way CD Projekt Red has here.

Read original review

Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege67/100 → 67 · Z -0.7923Score 76.1681

Rainbow Six: Siege has the basic pieces in place to offer that experience but sabotages them by forcing the illusion to rub against the real world in ways the fantasy isn’t prepared to handle. More often than not, playing Siege, one doesn’t feel like a soldier. You feel like a player. And that’s precisely what this game doesn’t want.

Read original review

Total War: WARHAMMER80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0909Score 85.0004

Warhammer’s world is sketched out by an ocean of rules, obsessed with the collision of fantasy with the specter of realism.

Read original review

Uncharted 4: A Thief's End80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0909Score 85.0004

Uncharted 4 offers nothing profound, assured in its own way that it has nothing to prove.

Read original review

XCOM 283/100 → 83 · Z 0.2947Score 87.0386

Under these terms, XCOM 2 isn’t so much a game about liberating humanity from its extraterrestrial overlords, but a statement about the kinds of stories our games can tell and allow to be told, even when they aren’t especially valued for their narrative. It speaks to the sense that we might not just want stories in our games, but authored fields of narrative possibility.

Read original review