SourceCritic

Wartales

79.6845SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 77.3793 · 29 reviews

2023 · PC, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

CD-Action70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9665Score 74.4263

As a whole, Wartales might not be a masterpiece, as it suffers from repetitiveness and lack of polish, but it provides lots of fun. Built on a foundation established by classic RPGs, it offers a varied world that feels alive and is rewarding to explore. The combat is dynamic despite being turn-based and the multitude of available skills lets you develop thousands of builds for your band of mercenaries. Overall, Wartales has huge potential and is definitely worth coming back to.

Read original review

Evilgamerz77/100 → 77 · Z -0.6645Score 77.4459

Although Wartales isn't perfect, the many small details that are slowly presented to the player make for a very enjoyable experience. You can play the game in many different ways and the game promotes a lot of experimentation. The game is simple in presentation, but it manages to add enough charm. In particular, the fact that each location looks different ensures that you will not get bored quickly. The new regions and the gameplay change little to the core of the game and the challenge lies mainly in exploring, balancing and expanding your group of mercenaries. Do I have enough food? Do I have enough food to feed everyone? Do I have enough resources and medicines to survive a surprise attack? This is a game where your loyal mercenaries and the journey are what matter most, not the final destination.

Read original review

FingerGuns60/100 → 60 · Z -1.569Score 68.4011

In conclusion: Wartales is a mix of great ideas tempered by some questionable design decisions. I really want to love this game, and there is plenty of fun to be had, but I can’t help but feel like there was a missed opportunity to make a good game a true great. For fans of the genre I do recommend picking it up and giving it a go, but I really hope that the game gets expanded upon in the future to let it live up to its full potential.

Read original review

Gameblog80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0621Score 83.4702

Wartales is an excellent sandbox RPG that gives you total freedom on the path to experience.

Read original review

Gameblog.fr80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1534Score 82.5573

Wartales is an excellent sandbox RPG that gives you total freedom on the path to experience.

Read original review

GameCrate85/100 → 85 · Z 0.102Score 85.1112

Wartales surprised me. It is a rare game that lets you play without getting in the way. Within minutes you will be out in the world, building your party and writing your story. That is something to be cherished in a world full of games that hold your hand to a painful degree or RPGs that take ten to twenty hours just to get to the meat of things. Wartales knows how to let players explore and have fun and doesn’t actively try to stop you from doing so, which is, unfortunately, all too rare these days. If you want a game that respects your time, look no further than Wartales.

Read original review

Games Freezer65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3969Score 70.1218

A GOTY Contender Crippled by Technical Issues

Read original review

Games.cz80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2062Score 82.0295

A wonderful simulator of a mercenary band, with so much content it’s going to last you for a long time. The story of your party is told through many small vignettes rather than a coherent story, but you can shape your marauders however you want. The turn-based combat is fun, so are the complex RPG systems. Dozens of hours of fun are guaranteed here.

Read original review

GamesCreed84/100 → 84 · Z -0.0099Score 83.9924

The more you play Wartales, the more you’ll find that many of the mechanics get deeper and deeper. The game is enjoyable as a whole. RPG-style strategy games are always more fun when played with a large group of people, and Wartales delivers on that front. It’s not a heavy RPG by any means—the story and dialogue are pretty sparse—but the turn-based combat is where it shines.

Read original review

GameStar71/100 → 71 · Z -1.3271Score 70.82

A mechanically solid, but also strangely artificial-looking DLC that mainly boosts your in-game bank account.

Read original review

Gaming Professors85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2634Score 86.7251

Wartales definitely has a lot to offer and is already clearly among the best in its category. The developers at Shiro Games have incorporated the best they could into the game, focusing on the harshness of the medieval setting and its gloomy atmosphere, combined with tactical RPG elements and turn-based combat. Combined with survival elements and various moral choices that can influence the world, this is clearly a great combination. However, some game mechanics remain a bit of a mystery—these aren’t exactly bugs, but it would be helpful to explain how they work in the tutorial.

Read original review

IGN France80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1869Score 82.2223

A fascinating Tactical RPG that could have managed its resources to better some key aspects of its universe and its gameplay. We hope for a sequel, or a big DLC.

Read original review

IGN Portugal80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5678Score 78.4136

Wartales offers a fantastic sandbox to explore. The nature of this system implies a rather insipid storyline and uneven pace, but in the end, the real treasure is the mercenaries you meet along the way. For those looking for a strategy sandbox with good depth in which to invest many hours, this is a choice that is hard to ignore.

Read original review

Impulsegamer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4201Score 88.2918

A creative merge of survival simulation, turn-based combat and tactical RPG.

Read original review

Indie Games Devel88/100 → 88 · Z 0.383Score 87.9215

Every mistake, every waste of valor points, every death of an ally, every failed mission, serves as a teacher. There are few videogames (and I assure you, being a hopeless lover of the most difficult games) that manage to convey such a sense of triumph and achievement as Wartales. We as players grow alongside our characters, treasure the harsh lessons taught by the game, devise ever more imaginative tactics to bypass or nullify the obstacles in our path, and eventually come to dominate the game.

Read original review

KeenGamer88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3048Score 87.1389

Wartales provides many great things and mechanics to differentiate it from other games within the genre. From its wonderful battles, the vibrant world, and the fantastic Camping system, Wartales manages to shine as a strong contender. Although there are some negatives, like resource problems and confusing battle mechanics, Wartales is a solid entry for those who seek to scratch their RPG itch.

Read original review

LEVEL (Czech Republic)80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2971Score 81.1199

A great advantage is that if you find any part of the game too hard or easy, you can adjust the difficulty of any part of the game. [Issue#328]

Meristation78/100 → 78 · Z -0.7783Score 76.3078

Wartales is an interesting tactical game mixed with survival elements. It has an engaging and fun combat, but the severe lacks of resources makes it a bit frustrating.

Read original review

MGG80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2457Score 81.6345

Even if it looks rather sober at first sight, Wartales is a rich and interesting game, with a neat content. Leading your mercenaries around the world, taking advantage of local opportunities in your own way, and fighting freely is addictive. There's also enough variety in exploration and encounters to keep you on your toes. The combat system is well thought out, with solid fundamentals and innovative elements. While a lot of effort has been put into making it accessible, it still rewards observation and experimentation, which may appeal to players who don't like to be held by the hand, but others may feel a little lost.

Read original review

MMORPG.com85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0714Score 84.8056

The world of Wartales is more complex than it first appeared. Once I settled down and paid attention to the depth that Wartales offers, I finally started to enjoy my time playing. Wartales is full of rules and mechanics to master. There is plenty of land to explore and mischief to be had, and although the character and party progression seem thin at first, there is a wealth of advancement options layered into the gameplay.

Read original review

Multiplayer.it80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1974Score 82.117

We played Wartales for about seventy hours with the desire to play it again to try to manage the party in a completely different way. This is probably the best compliment we can pay to the Shiro Games game, which after Evoland and Northgard has created another little gem, perhaps a little rough in certain aspects and with some annoying problems, but certainly worthy of being played and in its own original way in approaching the genre of role-playing games.

Read original review

NintendoWorldReport60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8562Score 65.5291

undefined.Wartales is a game that I very much want to like, and suspect I would, were I playing it on PC or presumably a more powerful console. I have plenty of positive things to say about it but at the end of the day, it just doesn't run well on Switch. Wartales is a very interesting game, but between poor tutorialization and awful performance on Switch, it may be buried a bit too deep to be worth playing on this platform.

Read original review

NME60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2789Score 71.3025

Wartales walks far enough off the beaten path to be interesting, but it isn’t quite bold or elegant enough to be essential.

Read original review

PC Gamer83/100 → 83 · Z 0.1419Score 85.5097

Don't be fooled by its drab exterior, Wartales is a deep and richly rewarding exercise in party creation.

Read original review

Pure Nintendo40/100 → 40 · Z -2.7444Score 56.6473

Any potential Wartales displays as an outlaw fantasy RPG is negated by frequent crashes. There's fun to be had with party management and a robust turn-based combat system, but until the stability issues are addressed, the game's not worth the frequent backtracking previous save points.

Read original review

Saving Content80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2329Score 81.7626

Wartales is unlike anything else I’ve played this year, as it boasts a massive landscape of near-emergent gameplay where you are not the hero of the story, but you do have a crucial role to play in it. It’s a grim, dark world to take part in, but it’s utterly fascinating at the events that take place, and how you can help shape or unmake it. The dynamicism in which things unfold makes replayability high, and the inclusion of multiplayer co-op is the perfect kind of game night with friends. Shiro Games have crafted something special here, and Wartales excels for letting you make your own successes or failures through the choices you make along the way.

Read original review

Softpedia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0838Score 84.9288

All in all, Wartales offers enough variation and strategy layers to make the journey not just enjoyable, but also challenging and rewarding. If you liked Battle Brothers, you’re going to love Wartales.

Read original review

The Games Machine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6749Score 90.8403

Wartales is an intelligent and brutal video game, capable of exalting through excellent game design and mind-boggling contexts and secondary missions. It is impossible to read a very graceful and alive story in a modern way, and the work can be seen in the classic role-playing game as well as it can still be seen. It absolutely is there.

Read original review

WhatIfGaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4835Score 79.2557

Manage a band of companions and explore the vast world of Wartales. Recruit different mercenaries from different regions and create the best roster of fighters and become a well-known force to be reckoned with. Be an ambitious adventurer or a most wanted outlaw. This is an RPG sandbox game that every medieval strategist has ever dreamed of playing.

Read original review