covergeek50/100 → 50 · Z -2.7561Score 56.5297Score 56.5297Z -2.7561I'm strangely fond of this bizarre 3D Sonic entry, but with an $80 price tag and zero recourse for Switch 1 owners it's a hard sell. Putting aside the merit of the game itself, there are very few circumstances in which I would recommend picking up the Switch 2 version of Sonic Frontiers over any of its non-Nintendo SKUs.
Read original review
Cubed340/100 → 40 · Z -2.3832Score 60.2594Score 60.2594Z -2.3832As both an upgrade to the problematic Switch version and a celebratory re-release for Sonic’s 35th anniversary, Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition is thoroughly disappointing. Although the game underneath is far from exceptional, its unsatisfying visuals - unaided by the new improvements - ruin the potential it actually has, making for a release that leaves a lasting bitter aftertaste.
Read original review
DualShockers70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1098Score 72.9933Score 72.9933Z -1.1098If you don't have Sonic Frontiers already on the Switch, this is the version you definitely want to get. Considering it's been four years since the game came out, though, there's a high chance you have it already and don't want to pay full price for only a slightly prettier, glitchier game. There's a small market for this game, but if that happens to be you, you'll at least enjoy what it offers all the same.
Read original review
Final Weapon20/100 → 20 · Z -4.0275Score 43.8157Score 43.8157Z -4.0275There is absolutely no reason to pick up the Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition. It costs too much, the technical issues are too vast, and the gameplay is borderline exhausting. I wanted to be able to give the original game another chance and declare, once and for all, it was a gem of a release that got unfairly panned by critics and fans alike. Instead, I found myself with one of the worst ports I’ve ever played. I’ve been deeply interested to see where the Sonic franchise goes next, but if Frontiers: Definitive Edition is any indication, maybe the series can use a break.
Read original review
Impulsegamer66/100 → 66 · Z -1.6562Score 67.5295Score 67.5295Z -1.6562Though it is still the best way to experience this open-world adventure of Sonic, it is still an underwhelming port of a mediocre game.
Read original review
MKAU Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5548Score 89.6391Score 89.6391Z 0.5548Sonic Frontiers allowed fans to really step into the shoes of the blue hedgehog. Even though it’s a little rough around the edges, Sonic Frontiers was a huge step in the right direction and the Definitive Edition, with every update and new content included, shows what a modern Sonic game is capable of. The feeling it gives you is unlike anything that’s come before it. It has to be played to be believed.
Read original review
Nintendo Insider60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2906Score 61.185Score 61.185Z -2.2906Sonic Frontiers is an ambitious game with a lot of rough edges, but it’s one that I enjoy. Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition offers a graphical boost over the original Nintendo Switch version and includes much of the DLC from the get-go, and in that sense, it’s at least an improvement. Still, neither of its two graphical modes really get the job done as well as you might like. Either way, you’re making some kind of heavy compromise that affects the gameplay. Considering the lack of affordable upgrade options here, it’s really hard to recommend this to anyone but new buyers who are locked into the Switch 2 ecosystem.
Read original review
Nintendo Life40/100 → 40 · Z -3.0009Score 54.0821Score 54.0821Z -3.0009So what are you getting with Sonic Frontiers - Definitive Edition? Considering all of the 'new' content is free for all players anyway, better performance and slightly improved visuals are your lot. This could have — no, should have — been a free upgrade, or at the most a reasonably priced upgrade. That Sega is asking for full price is a joke.
Read original review
NintendoBoy70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1223Score 72.8681Score 72.8681Z -1.1223Sonic Frontiers is more than I expected, yet still less than SEGA's longtime mascot deserves. That is not to say the game is bad. The biggest issues here are technical, stemming directly from a lack of polish and the jarring nature of the game's art direction.
Read original review
NookGaming70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8889Score 75.2018Score 75.2018Z -0.8889While Sonic Frontiers – Definitive Edition is absolutely a misnomer, it’s a fine way to play the game if you haven’t already. The updates it has received since its initial release in November 2022 make the game worth revisiting, with lots of new content that’s fun to play even if they don’t necessarily fix any of the game’s more foundational problems. There’s a good game to enjoy even with the warts present in Sonic Frontiers, but given the cynical nature of this version’s release, it’s hard not to feel like they should have gone harder in improving it. While I wouldn’t expect every problem to be addressed, things like fixed bugs and technical issues would surely have gone a long way in making a fun game even more easy to enjoy.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %50/100 → 50 · Z -0.5254Score 78.8375Score 78.8375Z -0.525450.0% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (10 reviews).
Pocket Tactics60/100 → 60 · Z -2.1489Score 62.6025Score 62.6025Z -2.1489Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition offers the same fun open-world story that you all know, though it still has too many empty spaces and lacks variety in activities. Furthermore, the game's performance isn't quite where it should be, especially when you consider how well Sonic x Shadow Generations runs on Switch 2. I appreciate the birthday celebrations, though.
Read original review
ProjectN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6426Score 77.665Score 77.665Z -0.6426Unfortunately, Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition on Nintendo Switch 2 is best suited for players who have never experienced the game before or those who primarily play on Nintendo's platform. While it represents a significant improvement over the original Switch version, its performance and visual quality still fall short of what is available on other platforms. Combined with the lack of either a free or paid upgrade path for existing owners and its full retail price, it's a difficult purchase to recommend for anyone who has already played the game elsewhere.
Read original review
Respec50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6203Score 57.8885Score 57.8885Z -2.6203In its current state, Sonic Frontiers - Definitive Edition is not definitive in any way. It doesn't deliver the best portable version or the best way to play Sonic Frontiers on TV. It is a big upgrade over the Switch 1 version, but the lack of an upgrade path for existing owners means it is even harder to recommend for its target audience. This is only really worth getting on a discount if you only play on Switch 2 and have never experienced Sonic Frontiers before. If you have access to other platforms, it is hard to recommend this without major caveats.
Read original review
TierraGamer60/100 → 60 · Z -3.1179Score 52.9118Score 52.9118Z -3.1179Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition fails to live up to its title, offering an experience that does very little to improve upon the original Switch version. It retains many of the issues that this release had an opportunity to leave behind. While the gameplay can still be enjoyable, this edition is difficult to recommend, especially if you have the option to experience Sonic's adventure on another platform.
Read original review
TodoJuegos85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2593Score 86.6845Score 86.6845Z 0.2593Sonic Frontiers - Definitive Edition does not reinvent the original adventure, but gives it the stability, cleaner image and smoother performance it clearly needed. Running across the Starfall Islands on Nintendo Switch 2 feels much better, especially with such a complete edition.
Read original review
Video Chums84/100 → 84 · Z 0.2157Score 86.2477Score 86.2477Z 0.2157Sonic Frontiers - Definitive Edition contains a stellar core game that performs exceptionally well on Switch 2 and, hey, that's pretty cool.
Read original review
What's It Like?72/100 → 72 · Z -1.0978Score 73.113Score 73.113Z -1.0978Sonic Frontiers Definitive Edition is a bit on the expensive side, and having no upgrade path available feels like it punishes those loyal to the brand who bought the first iteration, because they had to pay full price to get an improved version of the game when the Switch 1 version had so many issues. Despite the issues around the upgrade, there is a lot of gameplay here in Sonic Frontiers. Levels are huge and sprawling, and deliver a sense of wonder and speed. When it’s fun, it’s really fun, but when it’s frustrating, it can be downright infuriating. Still, Sonic Frontiers is a game that can be incredibly easy to love. The Switch 2 version is undoubtedly the best way to experience it on Nintendo hardware, as it fixes many of the technical shortcomings, but the extra cost for returning players might leave a bit of a sting.
Read original review