SourceCritic

Probably Stolen - Cyberpunk Pawnshop Simulator

78.5231SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 75.3333 · 9 reviews

Probably Stolen is a cyberpunk shopkeeping simulator set in a dystopian space station. Craft, trade, and smuggle goods of questionable origin, navigate faction loyalties, and stop rampant AI by killing those it controls. Earn enough to buy out your shop before rising rent forces your hand.

2026 · PC

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

DualShockers65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5105Score 68.9858

For Questing Goose Studio's first title, Probably Stolen is a fairly impressive game with its easy-to-understand controls yet complex system that perfectly sets up gamers to play for hours on end exploring the many ways they can make a living in the game's cyberpunk space station. Beyond that aspect and its interesting visual designs, however, Probably Stolen is somewhat hampered by its own design, as running the store can get monotonous very quickly and its shopkeeping mechanics can possibly dissuade people from trying out the game in favor of games that don't closely reflect people's real life day-to-day jobs. In short, Probably Stolen is a shopkeeping game full of ample replay value with its difficulties, Specializations, and relationships, but one that doesn't feature enough diversity in its gameplay mechanics and dialogue to keep most people playing for long.

Read original review

GameBlast55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2236Score 61.855

Probably Stolen barely manages to reach the so-called break-even point, morally incapable of covering its own operating costs. It's a game that doesn't go beyond the bare minimum of competence, lacking the ideas to stand out both among other cyberpunk games and within the simulation genre.

Read original review

Gameliner80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0643Score 84.7346

Probably Stolen is a versatile management game that combines trading, production and faction politics in a world full of robots, counterfeit goods and corrupt enforcers. There is always something to do, making it dangerously addictive, although the sheer number of tasks can sometimes become overwhelming and the lack of guidance may cause you to miss out on certain opportunities. Despite these minor flaws, Probably Stolen is an entertaining management game that can easily keep you hooked for hours.

Read original review

GameSpew80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1597Score 82.4939

A cyberpunk shopkeeping simulator, there's a lot more to Probably Stolen than just keeping your shelves stocked and serving customers. You'll also be inspecting counterfeit goods, keeping factions happy and scavenging for goods yourself, making this a rich and fully involved simulator that you won't be able to put down.

Read original review

Metacritic Users90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7938Score 92.0288

Metacritic user score 9.0/10 (162 ratings).

Softpedia80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4721Score 79.3703

Overall, I had an excellent time playing Probably Stolen and it’s one of those games that you will enjoy right until the end. It delivers great replay value, and you have a rather intense risk vs reward loop that keeps you glued to the screen. I also liked the complex faction system present in the game, along with the great secondary mechanics that break the standard shopkeeper sim loop you know from this genre. The downside of Probably Stolen is that it becomes rather repetitive, especially after you get the 20-30-day mark. Additionally, it throws a lot of mechanics in front of you, like tracking item values, managing storage limits, juggling faction demands, etc. All of that can become overwhelming at times. Even so, I felt that Probably Stolen successfully manages to create a refreshing, intense and rewarding shopkeeper simulator that everyone should try out. By offering so much replay variety and a sleuth of mechanics, it can offer you dozens of hours of fun, if you can stomach some of the repetitive aspects.

Read original review

The Games Machine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4394Score 79.6972

The management game from Questing Goose Studio offers a surprising number of possibilities, bolstered by numerous gameplay systems and a remarkable degree of freedom in terms of specialization. Less patient players might struggle with the initial complexity and the repetitive nature of the experience—but then again, the life of a merchant is never easy.

Read original review

The Wand Report70/100 → 70 · Z -0.4226Score 79.865

Probably Stolen is enterprising, entrepreneurial and expansive. Multilayered in its shop sim approach, there’s a lot of fun to be had making big decisions as you watch your morals precariously teeter between good, bad and ugly.

Read original review

Vandal78/100 → 78 · Z -0.6414Score 77.6772

Few games in this genre manage to turn an act as prosaic as setting a price into a source of such intense tension. Each day poses questions that are simple to ask but difficult to answer: do we trust or remain suspicious? Do we seek a gain today, or do we secure our future? This duality—recurring dozens of times throughout our 20-hour playthrough—sustains the game’s momentum. In our view, its greatest achievement lies in transforming a mundane task into an exercise in intuition. Here, setting a price is an act of interrogation; selling becomes a negotiation with one’s own conscience; and every day that a rental is successfully completed feels like a Pyrrhic victory. The variety of professions, the economic pressure, and the elusive morality of the various factions keep the experience engaging for many hours. The trade-off, however, comes in the form of an accumulation of windows to manage in the later stages, a contemplative pace, and a control scheme designed exclusively for the mouse.

Read original review