3DNews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5356Score 89.4472Score 89.4472Z 0.5356A magnificent collection of puzzles that will take weeks to fully explore. The sheer number of unique riddles is consistently impressive in terms of their execution. Sadly, the same cannot be said about the plot: while it seemingly attempts to tell an engaging story, many of its details end up going in one ear and out the other.
Read original review
Adventure Game Hotspot95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8931Score 93.0218Score 93.0218Z 0.8931Pure puzzlers are BACK with Order of the Sinking Star, a delightfully challenging and constantly surprising new addition to the genre from the creative mind that brought us Braid and The Witness.
Read original review
AltChar80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3027Score 81.0639Score 81.0639Z -0.3027Order of the Sinking Star surprised me. I came in expecting a small, mobile-style stone pusher and found a big puzzle adventure with lovely music, real voice acting, and level design that keeps pulling you forward.
Read original review
Analog Stick Gaming85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1341Score 85.4325Score 85.4325Z 0.1341Jonathan Blow has always had a talent for making puzzle games that are much more complicated than they first appear. Order of the Sinking Star very much continues that trend, and in many ways feels like the biggest example of it yet.
Read original review
CBR80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5196Score 78.8954Score 78.8954Z -0.5196There are some stumbles with the presentation and story, but nothing to derail the excitement of puzzle solving.
Read original review
CGMagazine70/100 → 70 · Z -1.113Score 72.9607Score 72.9607Z -1.113Order of the Sinking Star is the newest game from Thekla, Inc but are its puzzles enough to keep players engaged, or will they burn them out?
Read original review
Console-Tribe80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0404Score 83.687Score 83.687Z -0.0404Order of the Sinking Star is the Holy Grail for puzzle game enthusiasts who want a game that truly pushes them to rack their brains and think carefully before making their next move. While its high difficulty and lack of hints may frustrate and drive away some players, if you are looking for a genuine challenge and have plenty of time to spare, you certainly will not be disappointed.
Read original review
CrazyGameCommunity.it85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3896Score 87.9873Score 87.9873Z 0.3896Order of the Sinking Star remains one of those rare titles that justify their own existence: unique, meticulous, and capable of transforming a niche genre into a monumental experience.
Read original review
Digital Chumps95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8136Score 92.2274Score 92.2274Z 0.8136Order of the Sinking Star is a daunting, all-encompassing puzzle game--one naturally expected from Jonathan Blow. With it comes sparks of brilliance, frustration, and inspiration often in equal measure, constantly testing the brain's ability to overcome.
Read original review
DualShockers80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3083Score 81.0081Score 81.0081Z -0.3083Order of the Sinking Star is the most unique puzzle game I’ve ever encountered. Seemingly endless innovation and evolution of mechanics are just some of the key aspects of this game. While it doesn’t always hit the mark in terms of story delivery or length, it maintains its unusual gameplay throughout the many hours of gameplay. If you’re a fan of puzzles, then there’s never been a game more made for you.
Read original review
Entertainium100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2542Score 96.6332Score 96.6332Z 1.2542Order of the Sinking Star is one of the purest puzzle experiences ever created.
Read original review
Everyeye.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7496Score 91.5876Score 91.5876Z 0.7496But approaching this work solely from the perspective of geometry and movement is too reductive and risks making it seem sterile, while the greatest surprises lie hidden among the rubble of those foundations that must be torn down with lateral thinking and shifts in perspective, in true Jonathan Blow style.
Read original review
GameBlast80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1393Score 82.6979Score 82.6979Z -0.1393Order of the Sinking Star is a massive puzzle game that comes highly recommended for fans of sequential challenges. The distinct settings of the four nations, combined with unique mechanics that blend together as the adventure unfolds, create a compelling experience that makes it easy to lose track of time. While the audio and subtitles have minor issues that could be fixed in the future, the storytelling could be a bit more direct to avoid disrupting the game's pacing as you progress through the levels.
Read original review
GameCritics90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7758Score 91.8494Score 91.8494Z 0.7758In a darkening world we have to be grateful for games that feel like idiosyncratic and mysterious opuses, because, while they’re never common, I sometimes worry they’re vanishing altogether. I’ve enjoyed every second of my time with Sinking Star, and will enjoy many hours more with it, and it will almost certainly be the most interesting new game to come out this year, GTA 6 included (you can use that blurb if you want, Thekla).
Read original review
Gameliner80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0643Score 84.7346Score 84.7346Z 0.0643Order of the Sinking Star demands a lot from its players, but rewards them with plenty of variety through four distinct directions, each with its own mechanics, style and story. The lack of hints and increasing difficulty can be frustrating, especially for casual puzzlers, but the way the different systems come together in the Gold Rooms creates satisfying aha-moments. It is a game that trusts players to think for themselves, making it a rewarding challenge for puzzle enthusiasts.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6885Score 77.2062Score 77.2062Z -0.6885Order of the Sinking Star’s sprawling world is a triumph of puzzle design, giving its countless mechanics room to develop, intersect, and surprise long after their initial introduction. Yet while its interconnected structure gives the gameplay a genuine sense of depth, the same cannot be said for its narrative. Its verbose dialogue, meandering audio logs, and self-conscious musings on game design seem to reach for the sort of philosophical complexity that defined Blow’s previous works, but rarely offer anything worth reflecting on. The result is a game whose puzzles continually reward curiosity, while its attempts at profundity leave me wishing there was less to read and more to solve.
Read original review
GamesCreed94/100 → 94 · Z 0.7471Score 91.5619Score 91.5619Z 0.7471Order of the Sinking Star is clearly doing a lot with the puzzle ideas it borrows from its four source games, and the way those systems eventually collide is impressive. At the same time, the broader puzzle genre has changed during the long development period, and other games have already explored sophisticated Sokoban mechanics in creative ways.
Read original review
GameSpot80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2573Score 81.5186Score 81.5186Z -0.2573Order of the Sinking Star might work better had it been a bit more curated in deploying its massive pile of puzzles, but the occasional frustration and overcomplication is an affordable price of admission to play around with so many fun ideas.
Read original review
Gamesurf85/100 → 85 · Z 0.364Score 87.7312Score 87.7312Z 0.364Order of the Sinking Star is a massive and often brilliant puzzle game, built around the idea of constantly evolving rules that initially seem to have exhausted their potential. Its best moments come when different mechanics begin to interact, forcing players to rethink what they thought they had already learned. That same ambition can also weigh the experience down. With more than 1,400 puzzles, the sheer amount of content can sometimes feel excessive, while the difficulty occasionally depends more on remembering old rules than on finding an elegant solution. Even so, it remains an exceptional game for anyone looking for a demanding puzzle experience and willing to invest a considerable amount of time.
Read original review
GamingBolt80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1518Score 82.5732Score 82.5732Z -0.1518Even if it isn't as strikingly cutting as previous efforts, Order of the Sinking Star is another great puzzle title from Thekla and Jonathan Blow that's worth getting lost in.
Read original review
Hardcore Gamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2222Score 81.8687Score 81.8687Z -0.2222Order of the Sinking Star is one of the most fascinating games we’ve played all year. It’s simple but challenging, always keeping the puzzles compelling while implementing new or adaptive mechanics throughout. It does suffer from story woes, and some of the puzzles can be frustrating at times, but still, Order of the Sinking Star remains something for the mind. It’s brilliantly put together, taking an incredible amount of time to complete. In the end, Order of the Sinking Star will captivate you like no other game can.
Read original review
Jump Dash Roll70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8749Score 75.3424Score 75.3424Z -0.8749An astonishingly ambitious puzzle adventure packed with ingenious mechanics and some superb brainteasers, although its enormous scale occasionally turns intellectual discovery into something resembling homework.
Read original review
KeenGamer85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0324Score 84.4152Score 84.4152Z 0.0324Order of the Sinking Star hands you more than a thousand handcrafted puzzles and no tutorials, and that trust makes it special. Intuitive character abilities, four distinct worlds, and a shared Overworld give every solution a sense of ownership, while undo and restart keep experimentation painless. The same philosophy backfires when progress stalls with no sign of what you missed, and the scale wears thin over long sessions. For patient problem-solvers, it is an excellent fit.
Read original review
KonsoliFIN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.108Score 83.0107Score 83.0107Z -0.108I’m simultaneously thoroughly impressed and mildly disappointed. Thekla's mammoth epic delivers exactly what I hoped for, yet despite its variety, I still find myself wanting more of one thing: variety.
Read original review
LadiesGamers.com95/100 → 95 · Z 0.7813Score 91.9045Score 91.9045Z 0.7813I’ve played lots of different puzzle games over the years; however, I’ve never played a game like Order of the Sinking Star, which combines so many different puzzle genres into one cohesive experience.
It’s not a casual puzzle game, and often I felt mentally exhausted, frustrated and amazed at the genius behind each puzzle. However, the satisfaction of completing these mind-bending conundrums makes Order of the Sinking Star worthy of the LadiesGamers top rating.
Read original review
MonsterVine100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2083Score 96.1741Score 96.1741Z 1.2083I’ve only scratched the surface of what Order of the Sinking Star has to offer. By my estimate, I still have around 600 or so puzzles left to discover and solve, many of which have remixed the very premise of the game in some truly surprising ways that I won’t dare spoil. But with several dozen hours of playtime logged, I can safely say that it is, without exaggeration, one of the best puzzle games I’ve ever played, standing toe-to-toe with the genre greats. There are very few games on the market that are this intentional with their design and are unwavering in their dedication to a handful of core principles.
For all the moments where I found myself stuck in my tracks or banging my head against a wall, there were many more “AHA!” moments and flashes of insight and realization that made the struggles all the more worth it. Order of the Sinking Star is unparalleled in communicating ideas and concepts without saying a single word, but more impressive is that I feel like I’m having a genuine conversation with it with each puzzle I solve.
Read original review
Nindie Spotlight80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1401Score 82.6898Score 82.6898Z -0.1401Takes a base of many smart puzzle mechanics, experiments with mixing them together, and pulls together an overarching puzzle adventure in the process full of challenges… if you stick with it
Read original review
Nintendo Life80/100 → 80 · Z -0.038Score 83.7116Score 83.7116Z -0.038Order of the Sinking Star is a puzzler made for the real sickos who could spend hours grinding down one stage. The mechanics remain simple enough to feel accessible, but are expanded upon with commendable creativity.While it doesn't let you experiment to any great degree, it will still leave you feeling like a genius after solving one puzzle before leaving you completely clueless in the next. Not everyone likes that feeling, but I relished it.
Read original review
Noisy Pixel100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3983Score 98.0745Score 98.0745Z 1.3983Order of the Sinking Star is a demanding and inventive puzzle adventure that constantly finds new ways to challenge your understanding of its rules. Its four distinct worlds, character-driven limitations, and increasingly intertwined mechanics make solving puzzles deeply satisfying, even if prolonged roadblocks can sometimes become exhausting.
Read original review
NoobFeed90/100 → 90 · Z 0.625Score 90.3415Score 90.3415Z 0.625Order of the Sinking Star targets people who enjoy stopping, thinking, and experimenting. If you prefer a balance of puzzles with a strong story or other gameplay, it may feel too singular, and the story, which trickles out at the pace of your puzzle solving, is hard to follow. Casual puzzle fans may find it tricky with no difficulty options.
Read original review
PCMGAMES80/100 → 80 · Z -0.49Score 79.1912Score 79.1912Z -0.49Order of the Sinking Star turns simple rules into a massive challenge that forces you to constantly change your way of thinking. Understanding its mechanics and discovering how they interact is its greatest reward, although its difficulty and scale can be overwhelming. If you enjoy puzzles and have the patience to experiment, this is a highly recommended game.
Read original review
Pizza Fria88/100 → 88 · Z 0.3457Score 87.5485Score 87.5485Z 0.3457For puzzle fans, Order of the Sinking Star brings together variety, good ideas, and combinations that keep its huge amount of content interesting for much longer than the number on the box would suggest.
Read original review
PlayStation Universe100/100 → 100 · Z 1.297Score 97.0616Score 97.0616Z 1.297Order of the Sinking Star then isn't just Jonathan Blow's most epic puzzling odyssey to date, it also happens to be (Braid notwithstanding) his most accessible title in years. Though the delivery of its dialogue can feel disparate at times, that is nowhere enough to detract from the soaring calibre that Order of the Sinking Star ultimately achieves. Crafted with love at every turn (make sure you don't skip the credits) and infinitely more respectful of the player than Blow's previous title, The Witness, Order of the Sinking Star might just be the best puzzle game on PlayStation 5.
Read original review
PPE.pl85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0233Score 84.324Score 84.324Z 0.0233Order of the Sinking Star is a very successful puzzle game with superbly designed levels and engaging gameplay. Not everything the creators of Braid got quite right, but it’s definitely worth giving this game a go if you enjoy puzzle games.
Read original review
ProjectN86/100 → 86 · Z -0.1727Score 82.3642Score 82.3642Z -0.1727Order of the Sinking Star is a clever, generous puzzle game from Jonathan Blow, with more than a thousand puzzles spread across four worlds whose mechanics gradually come together in surprising ways. The freedom to leave a puzzle and come back later keeps frustration low, and the story rewards players who enjoy piecing things together on their own. Its sheer size can become tiring, and the Switch 2 version has occasional frame drops and black-screen bugs, but it is a must-play for puzzle fans, best enjoyed in small doses.
Read original review
PS4Blog.net90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6735Score 90.8265Score 90.8265Z 0.6735An outstanding puzzle adventure with thousands of puzzles for you to solve
Read original review
PSX Brasil80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5054Score 79.0373Score 79.0373Z -0.5054To create Order of the Sinking Star, Thekla licensed four different Sokoban-style games from other developers and wove them into four campaigns forming a colossal, highly ingenious whole. Yet, this unprecedented scale becomes a weak point for both the narrative and the puzzle gameplay experience, as it can feel intimidating, confusing, and overly sprawling. Even so, the game appeals to two distinct audiences: those who want to dedicate hundreds of hours to unraveling every last detail, and those who simply wish to enjoy the puzzles for as long as they feel inclined—without minding that they might only experience a fraction of the game's vast content (which can still mean dozens of hours of gameplay).
Read original review
Push Square60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4054Score 70.0367Score 70.0367Z -1.4054I don't think a game has ever divided my brain in two like Order of the Sinking Star. Its unique structure and the way it blends together so many mechanics is great, the individual puzzles are cleverly and thoughtfully designed, and it's all delivered with plenty of polish.However, in making such a vast game, I think it runs out of steam before it gets the chance to really start to flex. That, combined with uninteresting dialogue and no real compelling hook (other than the promise of hundreds more puzzles), makes it harder to recommend.
Read original review
Rectify Gaming90/100 → 90 · Z 0.47Score 88.791Score 88.791Z 0.47Order of the Sinking Star is an excellent choice for anyone who enjoys mentally demanding games and the satisfaction of solving difficult puzzles. Its enormous scope and occasional frustrations may not appeal to everyone, but the variety of its worlds and the depth of its mechanics make it a compelling experience for dedicated puzzle fans. It can be challenging, sometimes to a fault, but those moments when everything finally clicks make the effort worthwhile.
Read original review
República DG74/100 → 74 · Z -0.8603Score 75.4885Score 75.4885Z -0.8603Order of the Sinking Star is an ambitious experience that rewards those who have the patience to observe, experiment, and think outside the box. The sheer amount of puzzles and a few moments of frustration can be exhausting, but they also make every solution you find on your own even more satisfying. For me, it is a game that shows how sometimes the best reward isn't being given the answer, but having the feeling that you actually managed to figure it out by yourself.
Read original review
Screen Rant90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5883Score 89.974Score 89.974Z 0.5883Even after The Witness, Braid, and the many PuzzleScript games and Sokoban-likes that form its foundation, I'm sure I've never played anything to match. It’s not just a game of the year contender; fall in its clutches, Order of the Sinking Star might also end up the game you simply play the most, even—and most importantly—when you’re far away from the screen.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5762Score 89.853Score 89.853Z 0.5762Order of the Sinking Star is a brilliant puzzle game that offers over a thousand intricate yet accessible challenges, capable of keeping players entertained for hundreds of hours. Its clever design and timeless appeal make it a great experience for both puzzle enthusiasts and casual players. It is one of the best puzzle games of the decade.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6232Score 90.3228Score 90.3228Z 0.6232Order of the Sinking Star is a brilliant puzzle game that offers over a thousand intricate yet accessible challenges, capable of keeping players entertained for hundreds of hours. Its clever design and timeless appeal make it a great experience for both puzzle enthusiasts and casual players. It is one of the best puzzle games of the decade.
Read original review
Shacknews100/100 → 100 · Z 1.6085Score 100Score 100Z 1.6085Order of the Sinking Star is a masterpiece. Its immaculate, mind-bending puzzles are perfectly designed to make you feel spectacularly stupid and then phenomenally smart. Its interconnected world, progressive revelation of layered mechanics, and post-credits continuation make it the ultimate Sokoban experience.
Read original review
Smash Jump80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2025Score 82.0658Score 82.0658Z -0.2025Any recommendation of Order of the Sinking Star is going to have a lot of caveats which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. It’s esoteric and strange in a way that only Jonathan Blow can accomplish and the puzzle design is close to perfection.
You can see the sweat and tears he put into ever puzzle and I can respect all the hard work that went into it. Unfortunately for me the narrative didn’t really hold the whole way through and I wasn’t really itching to find those additional endings. It’s a game that does one thing really well and the rest of it really just depends on your constitution and how much you love pushing blocks.
Read original review
SmashPad60/100 → 60 · Z -1.3862Score 70.2289Score 70.2289Z -1.3862Order of the Sinking Star is a remarkable puzzle game on a scope and scale I haven't seen in the many years I've been playing puzzle games, and it may be too big for its own good, with plenty of positives and negatives to consider.
Read original review
Softpedia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0838Score 84.9288Score 84.9288Z 0.0838Order of the Sinking Star is a great puzzle game created by one of the most celebrated creators working in the genre. It delivers four core worlds, each with a unique cast and a defining mechanic, and challenges players to find solutions while unlocking new challenges that will blend different gameplay elements. The lack of a clear hint system will lead to frustration for some, especially once the harder puzzles that mix mechanics arrive. The narrative isn’t central to the experience, and characters aren’t that interesting. Order of the Sinking Star’s puzzles are great, but their shared Sokoban elements lead to a relative lack of variety in the long run.
Read original review
SteamDeckHQ90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4375Score 88.4665Score 88.4665Z 0.4375There’s no doubt that Order of the Sinking Star is one of the best puzzle games out there. The continual evolution of mechanics sprawling across a puzzle-ridden overworld is vast and exciting, and it’s so cool to see it all come from the same core concept. I like that it tells different stories within this, which leads to the bigger mystery of where we are to begin with. Sometimes it can feel a little overwhelming with every new mechanic introduced and then asked to apply, but it can also create some interesting scenarios that are enjoyable to play through.
Read original review
STWGames Italia90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5971Score 90.062Score 90.062Z 0.5971Order of the Sinking Star is the game we expected from Jonathan Blow, for better or for worse: a massive, rigorous, and at times ruthless work that takes forty years of grid-based puzzle history and reimagines it as an adventure capable of surprising you room after room, without ever repeating the same idea twice.
Read original review
TechRaptor90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6574Score 90.6651Score 90.6651Z 0.6574Order of the Sinking Star takes a gaming mechanic that has been around as long as gaming and hasn't stopped iterating upon it. A must have for puzzle gamers, but maybe a second guess for the Switch version for right now.
Read original review
The Games Machine88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4521Score 88.6117Score 88.6117Z 0.4521Order of the Sinking Star is a colossal puzzle game that blends four gameplay systems: crates to push or pull, teleporting mirrors, stones that bounce on water, and gems with special powers. Over a thousand puzzles, intelligently balanced progression, and the fusion of these mechanics deliver memorable moments of insight and immense satisfaction. On the downside, the lack of hints can turn some levels into insurmountable obstacles, while the story, though well-voiced, remains in the background. A paradise for puzzle lovers, a nightmare for those with little patience.
Read original review
The Wand Report40/100 → 40 · Z -2.2554Score 61.5374Score 61.5374Z -2.2554An interesting concept gives way to a bloat that squanders the potential pulled from the games on which Order of the Sinking Star is based (and that it recreates). The result is puzzles curiously devoid of fun or reward and a slog of epic proportions.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0041Score 84.1317Score 84.1317Z 0.0041Order of the Sinking Star is an incredible, mind-boggling puzzle adventure that will push your grey matter to the brink. And sometimes past it.
Read original review
TheXboxHub80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3828Score 80.2629Score 80.2629Z -0.3828I want to turn the mirrors back onto the positives of Order of the Sinking Star, because it is such a marvel. I am yet to play anything like it. It’s so laden with riches that it’s embarrassing, as the saying goes.
Read original review
Thumb Culture100/100 → 100 · Z 1.0077Score 94.1677Score 94.1677Z 1.0077Order of the Sinking Star has been a game I’ve really enjoyed getting lost in. I’ve spent around 20 plus hours with it, and I already want to play more. There’s something incredibly satisfying about solving each puzzle and moving onto the next one. The sheer amount of content also gives me plenty of reasons to keep coming back. I still have so much of the story and puzzles left to experience. That makes it difficult to put the game down, even after several hours. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed my time with Order of the Sinking Star so far. For me, it has earned the highest honour, a Thumb Culture Platinum Award.
Read original review
Use a Potion80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6854Score 77.2369Score 77.2369Z -0.6854Order of the Sinking Star is a monumental achievement in puzzle design, taking a handful of simple rules and evolving them into a satisfying web of challenges. Sure, its immense length and tough difficulty can be overwhelming, but the sheer mechanical creativity and ingenuity in puzzle design on offer is simply staggering. There’s no denying that it won’t be for everyone, but those who embrace Order of the Sinking Star’s brilliant take on puzzling are in for a treat.
Read original review
Vandal90/100 → 90 · Z 0.583Score 89.921Score 89.921Z 0.583Jonathan Blow and Thekla deliver an enormous, brilliantly designed sokoban puzzle adventure with over a thousand handcrafted challenges, ingenious mechanics, and an open structure that rewards patience and logical thinking, although some mechanics are poorly explained, exploration can be cumbersome, and the audiovisual presentation and story lack the impact of the puzzles themselves.
Read original review
Video Chums80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1727Score 82.3645Score 82.3645Z -0.1727As a culmination of many puzzle concepts and a deeply rewarding sense of progression, Order of the Sinking Star is a shining star indeed. 🌠
Read original review
WayTooManyGames70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7588Score 76.5031Score 76.5031Z -0.7588I feel that I may have sounded overly harsh when talking about Order of the Sinking Star, but I want to clarify, once more, that as a puzzle game, this is outstanding. It’s a compilation of a seemingly neverending amount of finely crafted gauntlets that will test your skill, attention, and patience. I really have no qualms about its design and concept; I laud Jonathan Blow and his team in this regard. My massive gripes lie with how poorly optimized and buggy the game is, at least at launch, and most notably when testing on Switch 2. The combination of poor framerates, crashes, and bizarre aspect ratio glitches frustrated me to no end.
Read original review