SourceCritic

Old World

82.3449SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 81.4118 · 17 reviews

Conquer the Old World in this historical, epic strategy game from Soren Johnson, Lead Designer of Civilization IV and Offworld Trading Company. Every year is a turn, and each leader is a mere mortal, so your lasting legacy will be the dynasty you leave behind.

2021 · PC

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

AusGamers85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0536Score 83.5547

There's a lot more to Old World than the glib description of "Civ meets Crusader Kings" can convey. Yet it succeeds because it feels like a genuine meeting between the two, a deeply considered merger that applies the strengths of both games to cover their weaknesses. It doesn't feel like you're playing Civ, but with some Crusader Kings characters butting in every now and again with some silly tale or grievance. It feels like you're playing Civ, but with some Crusader Kings characters who grow alongside you, whose relationships to you and each other actually matter, and who prove that the great stories of empires aren't about production rates per turn--they're about the people who lived through them. And their pet monkeys.

Read original review

Bazimag85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0165Score 84.2566

Old World is a 4X that unlike many titles of this genre doesn't try to just copy the biggest franchise of the genre and it is all the better for it that has made it a must play for the fans of this type of video games.

Read original review

COGconnected79/100 → 79 · Z -0.3505Score 80.5859

Old World clearly shows its origins, coming from a small team of developers intimately connected with 4x strategy games. It adds several new mechanics to an established genre, some of which are clearly brilliant and others that seem less significant. Old World succeeds in giving genre fans a clear alternative to their favorite games, but it seems unconcerned with welcoming the uninitiated, thanks to a fussy interface, lack of patient tutorials, and a focus on a fairly narrow slice of history and culture. Fundamentally, Old World both honors a tradition and gently pushes it forward.

Read original review

Cultured Vultures65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4243Score 69.8484

While the game has interesting concepts and ideas, some odd design choices and an atrocious tutorial hamper Old World’s ambition.

Read original review

GameBlast80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1393Score 82.6979

By investing in both interpersonal relationships and the complexity of its elements, Old World and its expansion Heroes of the Aegean impress. Even the confusing interface by modern standards of the genre and the low amount of initial leaders are not enough to prevent a recommendation.

Read original review

Gamefa85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0791Score 84.8819

Old World is a turn-based strategy game made by people who previously worked on games like Civilization. Old World mixes Civilization gameplay elements with Crusader Kings' story events and characters and creates a unique experience for the fans. The game has some issues in the UI, and its graphics are a little bit outdated. Also, it can be overwhelming for newcomers. All and All, It is a well-made strategy game that I can easily recommend to the genre's hardcore fans.

Read original review

GameStar85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2828Score 86.919

A thoroughly integrated and refreshing mix of classic 4X turn-based strategy, role-playing elements and varied events.

Read original review

Gaming Professors80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2666Score 81.4254

Old World is a fantastic historical 4X strategy game that leverages its historical foundations to great effect. The need to anticipate that every action will have consequences, the power of diplomacy, and the family ties that play a crucial role here—it all comes together beautifully. However, you may encounter persistent performance issues and stuttering throughout the game. Sometimes, certain diplomatic events can even be a bit tedious, as you simply have to attend to them even when you’d rather be managing your own family and the affairs of your empire. For fans of the genre, the game offers exactly what you’d expect, and for newcomers, it provides a great experience and an introduction to the world of 4X strategy games.

Read original review

IGN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3396Score 80.6953

Old World is a smaller-scale 4X game than its Civilization forbearers but its new ideas add both interesting depth and intimidating complexity.

Read original review

KonsoliFIN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.108Score 83.0107

Old World is a historical strategy game that blends the turn-based empire-building of Civilization with the character-driven dynastic management of Crusader Kings. Set exclusively in antiquity, the game introduces unique mechanics like limited city placement, card-based tech progression, and command points that restrict actions per turn, adding strategic depth. Players manage both their empire and royal family, making choices that shape the development of individual characters and the stability of the realm. While its innovations are notable—such as resource-driven building and specialist systems—it leans heavily on familiar genre conventions. A DLC campaign, Heroes of the Aegean, offers scripted historical scenarios. Despite lacking the bold freshness of Humankind, Old World is a solid and rewarding strategy experience, now more accessible with its arrival on Steam.

Read original review

LadiesGamers.com80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5371Score 78.7202

Playing Old World feels like you have an entire nation interacting deeply with other real civilizations covering a much smaller slice of history. It adds complexity and dimension to the 4X genre by taking the Civilization templet and adding to it to involve you in an epic story. I love it, as I enjoy the deep strategy it offers and the added relationship dynamics!

Read original review

Multiplayer.it85/100 → 85 · Z 0.2741Score 86.8318

Old World is a successful hybridization experiment, which lacks only in the interface, sometimes very unclear, and in explaining its main mechanics to the player, due to a really lacking tutorial.

Read original review

PC Gamer87/100 → 87 · Z 0.5009Score 89.1

A clever spiritual successor to Civilization full of both novelties and big ideas.

Read original review

PCGamesN80/100 → 80 · Z -0.033Score 83.761

Old World adds dimension and complexity to the 4X style, but its slow pace and intricate resource management hinder it from reaching its full potential.

Read original review

TestingBuddies80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3761Score 80.3303

Old World gets a lot right and is an exciting new 4X set in antiquity, well worth buying for genre fans despite weak graphics.

Read original review

Vamers100/100 → 100 · Z 1.1807Score 95.8984

Old World: Heroes of the Aegean marks the game’s debut on Steam, and it rightfully earns a spot on many favourites lists. It is truly unlike most 4X games currently available, and adequately serves to raise an already high bar. While the game can do with a bit more tutorialisation, there are enough pop-ups and explanations for adventurers to being their journey. Immersion is a massive focal point and the inclusion of supremely detailed stories and scenarios truly levels up the experience beyond what even the developers may have intended. It truly is an exceptional title, one worthy of taking the title as the king of 4X games.

Read original review

Worth Playing68/100 → 68 · Z -1.6745Score 67.3464

Old World has its moments, but it's a very niche offering. I wouldn't recommend it to someone who isn't hardcore about 4X games because the learning curve is brutal. However, if you've played the rest and you're looking for something new, and especially if the overload of stats is something you find compelling, check out Old World. At the very least, you get to enjoy Christopher Tin's majestic soundtrack.

Read original review