3DNews55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2459Score 61.6325Score 61.6325Z -2.2459Highguard has some nice ideas, and sometimes it is really fun to play, but mostly it feels like a beta-test version of a game to come and not like the full-released title.
Read original review
4P.de70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2916Score 71.1747Score 71.1747Z -1.2916Highguard is a competent shooter that tries to appeal to too many people and thus stumbles over its own feet.
Read original review
CBR70/100 → 70 · Z -1.4208Score 69.883Score 69.883Z -1.4208However, issues like high cosmetic prices, lacking game modes, and overall feeling of a lack of polish, weigh heavily on the game as it stands. None of these problems feel insurmountable, but they do prevent Highguard from reaching its full potential at launch. Highguard is a good game with flashes of greatness and the possibility of becoming something truly special if its developers continue to build on its promising core.
Read original review
Edge Magazine50/100 → 50 · Z -1.9601Score 64.4899Score 64.4899Z -1.9601For the moment, however, the original ideas in the details of its design are suffocated by bigger problems in its structure and pacing. [Issue #421, p.110]
Game Rant80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1666Score 82.4256Score 82.4256Z -0.1666The core gameplay of Highguard is fun, so much so that I can see myself playing it as my go-to multiplayer game for the rest of the year. And as the year goes on, Highguard should become an even better game. As it stands, my biggest issue with the game is its lack of content compared to its competitors, but that should be addressed in future updates.
Read original review
Game860/100 → 60 · Z -2.1675Score 62.4165Score 62.4165Z -2.1675Wildlight Entertainment has actually created a concept with immense potential to revolutionize the industry, combining multiple game modes and elements into something truly unique. However, the whole thing crashes and burns due to a shaky foundation of gameplay mechanics and a multitude of other issues. To put it simply, Highguard was a gamble that was revealed a little too early and needs much more time in the oven to become the next big thing.
Read original review
GameMAG40/100 → 40 · Z -3.1396Score 52.6954Score 52.6954Z -3.1396Highguard absolutely does not deserve the hype around its release, which was largely stirred up by Geoff Keighley. Instead of a surprise launch, the developers should have conducted extensive testing to identify all the core issues with the gameplay foundation from the start. However, the train has now left the station, and the audience's attention has shifted to other projects.
Read original review
Gamer.no50/100 → 50 · Z -2.3299Score 60.792Score 60.792Z -2.3299While Highguard has received far more hate than it deserves, the game just isn't all that good in its current state. It's a mishmash of genre tropes that never quite come together, and even the odd enjoyable moment isn't enough to make it worth your while.
Read original review
GameRant80/100 → 80 · Z -0.122Score 82.8713Score 82.8713Z -0.122Wildlight Entertainment's debut game Highguard is a thrilling blend of other shooter games that could become your next multiplayer obsession.
Read original review
GAMES.CH86/100 → 86 · Z 0.2339Score 86.4305Score 86.4305Z 0.2339Highguard is a top-notch PvP shooter, not your average fare, but rather a highly creative and unique game concept whose main mode blends three phases into a virtually ever-changing gameplay experience. Individual gameplay elements, such as the armor system, might initially seem disconcerting, but prove their worth in practice. Further improvements and new content are also to be expected and could elevate an already strong online action game to an even more outstanding one.
Read original review
Games.cz50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6676Score 57.4147Score 57.4147Z -2.6676Highguard delivers an original concept but fails to execute it as well as needed. Attractive yet lifeless maps, an unnecessary opening phase, and weak balancing of weapons and heroes weigh it down. In a coordinated trio, it does deliver some adrenaline-fueled and tactical firefights, yet it excels at nothing in particular. The gameplay mode quickly grows tiresome, resulting overall in a completely forgettable experience, one of many that have come and gone before.
Read original review
GameSpot60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8784Score 65.3072Score 65.3072Z -1.8784Highguard isn't ready for prime time. It's not an awful game that's unplayable. It has extremely fun moments when you're playing with your friends, but they're fleeting. It's not something that I would introduce into my rotation of multiplayer games. In its current state, Highguard is an aggressively okay game that needs a lot of work.
Read original review
GamesRadar+60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6746Score 67.345Score 67.345Z -1.6746Despite its clear flaws, Highguard is far from the failure that some would have you believe.
Read original review
GameStar71/100 → 71 · Z -1.3271Score 70.82Score 70.82Z -1.3271Highguard is a fascinating shooter game that still feels like a construction site: It will need some patches to reach its full potential.
Read original review
Gamesurf65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4772Score 69.3193Score 69.3193Z -1.4772Highguard is a smart, messy experiment. When its two-phase loop hits the right density and coordination, the Shieldbreaker turns matches into tense, goal-driven sieges, and the gunplay has the bite to carry the climax. But that same structure can stretch into long prep stretches and noticeable downtime, especially in 3v3 and solo queue, where timing and intent rarely line up. On PC it holds up well, yet the world and Wardens still lack the kind of personality that sticks. Bottom line: a solid concept with rough edges, best for players who want a deliberate raid shooter rather than nonstop firefights.
Read original review
Gaming Nexus85/100 → 85 · Z -0.1425Score 82.6665Score 82.6665Z -0.1425Highguard is a fresh take on the multiplayer hero shooter, featuring balanced gunplay and thrilling raid mechanics that had me saying, "Just one more match." Throw in strong art direction with a high fantasy setting, and it gets an easy recommendation from me.
Read original review
GamingBolt40/100 → 40 · Z -3.6268Score 47.8229Score 47.8229Z -3.6268Wildlight Entertainment's PvP raid shooter mash-up of multiplayer elements offers a repetitive, uninspired and dull time.
Read original review
IGN70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1356Score 72.7353Score 72.7353Z -1.1356Highguard’s compelling gunplay makes its unique raid mode quite memorable, even if the version we have right now feels a bit like a rough draft.
Read original review
IGN Italy55/100 → 55 · Z -2.6938Score 57.1532Score 57.1532Z -2.6938A free shooter that doesn't make the most of its best ideas: the potential is there, but at the moment it suffers from balance, performance, and repetitiveness issues.
Read original review
Jeuxvideo.com75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6342Score 77.7494Score 77.7494Z -0.6342Highguard is undoubtedly a unique proposition in the world of live service and online shooter games, effectively silencing those who expected something derivative. It's clear that this experience isn't for everyone and lacks the diversity to be truly engaging at launch. This makes it a risky gamble. Nevertheless, Highguard was created with passion and will offer anyone willing to give it a try some truly great moments thanks to its well-crafted gameplay loop. But above all, it conveys the feeling that it was created with care and dedication.
Read original review
NoobFeed70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0016Score 74.0755Score 74.0755Z -1.0016Highguard is successful because it knows its limits and designs around them. It doesn't try to be too big or flashy to be understood. Besides, it gives you a tightly constructed tactical experience that is based on purpose and clarity. A single design theory is supported by all systems.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %39.130434782608695/100 → 39.1304 · Z -0.8805Score 75.2862Score 75.2862Z -0.880539.1% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (23 reviews).
Oyungezer75/100 → 75 · Z -0.852Score 75.5715Score 75.5715Z -0.852Highguard is definitely not a bad game. But it’s also not the kind of game that opens a new era. And honestly, expecting every game to redefine a genre would be absurd anyway. That’s why you should give this already free game at least a chance, because it does include some gameplay elements that might genuinely surprise you. Outside of those, it delivers an experience that’s fairly close to a classic FPS.
Read original review
PC Gamer65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4738Score 69.3536Score 69.3536Z -1.4738I'm not saying Wildlight should've simply made an entirely different kind of FPS, but I do think it could benefit from not taking itself so seriously. We're shooting AK-47s from bearback, smashing walls with hammers, and playing keep-away with a sword—that's the fun I wish Highguard leaned into.
Read original review
Push Square60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4054Score 70.0367Score 70.0367Z -1.4054Highguard has potential, but it's not quite being met yet. As it stands today, this is a fun yet bloated shooter that lacks the spark you'll find in other games in the genre, like The Finals. It'll play to the tactical players out there, and it seems that Wildlight is committed to improving the game. But with a game mode that crams every type of shooter into a single experience, Highguard is a jack of all trades and master of none.
Read original review
Restart.run60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8565Score 65.5264Score 65.5264Z -1.8565Highguard sets a strong foundation for something more interesting to come down the line, if given the proper time and feedback. The core of what's there is solid, it just needs more refinement.
Read original review
Restart.run60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7759Score 66.3321Score 66.3321Z -1.7759Highguard sets a strong foundation for something more interesting to come down the line, if given the proper time and feedback. The core of what's there is solid, it just needs more refinement.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk55/100 → 55 · Z -2.3476Score 60.6156Score 60.6156Z -2.3476Highguard is a game that demonstrates that a new multiplayer concept alone is insufficient. While the premise is interesting, the developers failed to strike the right balance. The 3v3 battles did not help the game at launch, and there was little content. The game may never recover from its poor start.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2608Score 61.4827Score 61.4827Z -2.2608Highguard is a game that demonstrates that a new multiplayer concept alone is insufficient. While the premise is interesting, the developers failed to strike the right balance. The 3v3 battles did not help the game at launch, and there was little content. The game may never recover from its poor start.
Read original review
SmashPad80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0441Score 83.6505Score 83.6505Z -0.0441It’s unfortunate that most people reading this have already made up their minds about Highguard, some through playing it themselves, others dismissing it outright due to a number of factors, and the few that just aren’t into this kind of game and are reasonable about it. If you are reading this and there’s a spark of curiosity in you about it, dive in.
Read original review
TechRadar Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1445Score 72.6458Score 72.6458Z -1.1445The bones of Highguard are solid: the gunplay feels crisp, traversal is slick, and the rounds can be incredibly tense. But at launch, myriad balance issues, overcomplicated round structure, and repetitive-feeling matches dampen the game. Wait for a few months until it's been chiseled into shape.
Read original review
The Outerhaven60/100 → 60 · Z -2.1826Score 62.2647Score 62.2647Z -2.1826There is definitely fun to be had in Highguard, especially with a group of friends but as it stands I wouldn’t bet on it become the new Apex of the genre because it’s nowhere near that level.
Read original review
The Outerhaven Productions60/100 → 60 · Z -2.017Score 63.9214Score 63.9214Z -2.017There is definitely fun to be had in Highguard, especially with a group of friends, but as it stands, I wouldn’t bet on it becoming the new Apex of the genre because it’s nowhere near that level.
Read original review
This Is Game68/100 → 68 · Z -1.5495Score 68.5966Score 68.5966Z -1.5495Highguard delivers solid shooting mechanics reminiscent of Apex Legends, but it is severely hampered by terrible optimization and disjointed gameplay systems that fail to mesh organically. While it avoids the disastrous fate of Concord thanks to its unique siege and vehicle combat, the experience is currently marred by muddy graphics and poor audio, making it feel like an intriguing but unpolished experiment.
Read original review
VGChartz70/100 → 70 · Z -0.3601Score 80.4897Score 80.4897Z -0.3601From minute tweaks to large siege towers, Wildlight's detail-oriented attitude helps lift Highguard above the usual Hero shooter fare.
Read original review
WayTooManyGames55/100 → 55 · Z -1.8094Score 65.9976Score 65.9976Z -1.8094Is Highguard a bad game? Debatable. It’s not the worst game ever and the absolutely hateful reviews the game has received from people who haven’t even played it are baffling, but it is… remarkably unremarkable.
Read original review