3DNews90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5356Score 89.4472Score 89.4472Z 0.5356A wonderful remake that captures the spirit of Gothic and gives it a modern twist.
Read original review
4News.it75/100 → 75 · Z -1.1069Score 73.0223Score 73.0223Z -1.1069The return to the Colony turned out to be a profoundly dichotomous experience. A journey of the mind and heart that leaves you with a sweet, conscious, and almost heart-wrenching melancholy. Alkimia Interactive has performed a veritable philological miracle in terms of atmosphere, demonstrating immense courage in its determination to preserve at all costs that ruthless ecosystem and that sense of isolation and total immersion that made Piranha Bytes’ original work so successful. The title’s main problem, however, does not lie solely in a technical implementation that drags too much baggage along with it—including unstable frame rates, crippling tearing, sudden freezes, and bugs that risk compromising the gameplay experience and progression. The real knot to untie lies, in reality, within each of us. Gothic 1 Remake acts as a mirror that forces us to come to terms with our own evolution as gamers. And, in a broader sense, as human beings. It is a work we cannot help but love for its moving conceptual integrity. Yet at the same time, we struggle to digest it because of that very structural slowness and ruthlessness that clash violently with the syncopated rhythms of our lives. For those who still have a deep desire—and, above all, the “luxury of time”—to be able to “slow down,” the Valley of Mines offers one of the most visceral, authentic, and rewarding adventures of recent years. For everyone else, the encounter with this glorious, rugged, and uncompromising relic of the past may prove difficult to handle.
Read original review
4P.de90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7516Score 91.6068Score 91.6068Z 0.7516For me, the Gothic Remake is the ultimate gaming highlight of 2026—the refinement of a classic and a sheer delight for action-RPG fans! Only technical flaws and a somewhat overly deferential adherence to the source material detract from this fan dream come true.
Read original review
AltChar70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1993Score 72.0981Score 72.0981Z -1.1993With patches and patience, Gothic 1 Remake could become essential. Right now, it is a promising and frustrating experience in roughly equal measure.
Read original review
BaziCenter65/100 → 65 · Z -1.7071Score 67.0203Score 67.0203Z -1.7071Gothic 1 Remake doesn't try to re-tell history; it just wants to paint over it. On one hand, you get the same atmospheric, brilliantly constructed world, now looking better than ever. On the other, that gorgeous world is still weighed down by decades-old gameplay mechanics and rigid level design. If you're hunting for a modern RPG built on modern standards, look elsewhere. But if you're an old-school purist who misses this legendary setting, or someone willing to tolerate clunky mechanics to experience a true classic, this remake does exactly what it sets out to do.
Read original review
BuffGaming.rs90/100 → 90 · Z 0.497Score 89.0614Score 89.0614Z 0.497Gothic 1 Remake looks set to modernize a cult RPG classic without losing the identity that made the original so beloved. With a larger world, improved combat, expanded lore, and faithful design choices, it has the potential to become the definitive way to experience Gothic for both longtime fans and newcomers alike.
Read original review
Capsule Computers85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0547Score 84.6377Score 84.6377Z 0.0547Gothic 1 Remake captures the harsh, unforgiving charm of the original with big visual gains, even if the jank remains.
Read original review
CD-Action85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3332Score 87.4236Score 87.4236Z 0.3332The time I spent playing the Gothic remake was — and I still find it
hard to believe — an experience truly reminiscent of what shook my world
25 years ago. It’s not just about nostalgia — it’s about respect for the
series from Alkimia.
Read original review
CGMagazine60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9282Score 64.809Score 64.809Z -1.9282Gothic 1 Remake is stubbornly faithful to the original to the point where it wears its flaws just like its triumphs, a frustrating experience.
Read original review
Checkpoint Gaming75/100 → 75 · Z -0.4006Score 80.0854Score 80.0854Z -0.4006Against all odds, the Gothic 1 Remake is an incredibly faithful adaptation of the original cult-classic while also making both visual and mechanical improvements. While it certainly isn’t perfect, it manages to make an important part of gaming history more accessible and doesn’t ever forsake its vision to appeal to modern audiences. It may be too frustrating for some, but anyone ready to embrace brutal life in the Colony will find a lot to be immersed in.
Read original review
Cloud Dosage68/100 → 68 · Z -1.4113Score 69.9782Score 69.9782Z -1.4113Gothic 1 Remake brings back a harsh single-player RPG set inside The Colony, where training, camp politics, and dangerous exploration all shape your progress. The game makes you slow down, listen, and learn the world instead of chasing markers. The frame rate cap, pop-in, audio bugs, and clumsy menus kept getting in the way. There’s a good RPG here for fans who miss this kind of challenge, but I’d wait for more fixes before jumping in.
Read original review
COGconnected68/100 → 68 · Z -1.428Score 69.8112Score 69.8112Z -1.428To its great credit, Gothic 1 Remake does not try to smooth out the challenge or design approach of the 2001 original, choosing instead to make significant graphical upgrades and add layers of improvement to combat and other mechanics. It turns on its head the front-loaded pacing gamers have come to expect, holding off the most rewarding gameplay for many hours in. It can be punishing, not because the player lacks skill, but because its world is just that way. Updates and patches will hopefully iron out performance and the bugs, but Gothic 1 Remake will always primarily appeal to RPG fans undaunted by its unforgiving approach to the genre.
Read original review
Comunidad Xbox85/100 → 85 · Z 0.3186Score 87.2772Score 87.2772Z 0.3186Gothic 1 Remake entiende perfectamente lo que significa rehacer un clásico. No pretende convertirlo en un juego de rol que siga las tendencias actuales.
Read original review
Console-Tribe79/100 → 79 · Z -0.1391Score 82.7Score 82.7Z -0.1391we can say that Gothic 1 Remake is not a game for everyone, and it does absolutely nothing to become one. It is a respectful and rigorous act of love towards a way of understanding role-playing games that many thought were extinct, a work that requires patience, absolute dedication, and the willingness to accept a significantly above-average level of initial disorientation from the player. The historical flaws related to the structural stiffness of the combat system have unfortunately remained in place, partially masked by a modern control system but still evident in tense situations, and the imperfect technical framework found on Xbox Series X prevents the title from reaching the absolute excellence to which it could have aspired with greater polish in the optimization phase. It remains, however, an imposing, dirty adventure, pulsating with a life of its own, and endowed with an unparalleled atmosphere, capable of reminding today's industry that sometimes, to move forward and truly evolve, you have to have the courage to not forget where we came from.
Read original review
Digitale Anime85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2337Score 81.7546Score 81.7546Z -0.2337"A Faithful Return to the Classic"
Gothic 1 Remake delivers a deep RPG experience that retains the spirit of the original game and succeeds in a superbly visually updated world. Despite some technical issues and a limited combat system, it remains one of the most outstanding classic RPGs remakes of recent years.
Read original review
Digitally Downloaded90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4778Score 88.8688Score 88.8688Z 0.4778However, while it might still be for a niche audience, this is very much an example of how to do a remake correctly. The developers have addressed the big issues in the original Gothic, while maintaining and building on everything that made it such a cult icon.
Read original review
DualShockers75/100 → 75 · Z -0.709Score 77.0007Score 77.0007Z -0.709Gothic 1 Remake reinvents a timeless PC classic from the 2000s, and does so in a way that's bound to be controversial. The original Gothic was already a game that aged rather poorly, so remaking it in such a faithful way is admirable, but leaves the game without the ability to become what it could be. The core concept of Gothic is brilliant in its potential, but it was always held back by hardware limitations. The remake makes it look and sound nicer, but didn't go as far as it should have to take advantage of what it has.
Read original review
Echo Boomer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4063Score 80.0279Score 80.0279Z -0.4063Gothic Remake keeps the soul of the original intact, to the point where it doesn't care whether the player can keep up or not. This is a classic RPG with modern graphics, ready to punish us for the smallest mistake and perfectly happy to watch us fail. And that's exactly how it should be.
Read original review
Edge Magazine70/100 → 70 · Z -0.5758Score 78.3328Score 78.3328Z -0.5758Like one of its grizzled mercenaries, it's hard to know and harder to like. But, whether you make friends with it or not, it demands your respect. [Issue#426, p.108]
EmuGlx.org80/100 → 80 · Z -0.5066Score 79.0254Score 79.0254Z -0.5066Gothic 1 Remake is a game that will kill you, force you to learn why, and then make you grateful for the lesson - and if that sounds like a good time, welcome to the Colony.
Read original review
Eurogamer Germany60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6686Score 67.4047Score 67.4047Z -1.6686If you want that old Gothic feeling and gameplay – and make sure you do! –, then by all means, buy this. For everyone else, I have a list of over 50 RPGs from the last 10 years that all stand in some way on the shoulder of this ancient giant. And they are all way better games.
Read original review
Everyeye.it78/100 → 78 · Z -0.4821Score 79.2697Score 79.2697Z -0.4821Gothic Remake faithfully recreates the classic RPG, featuring detailed environments, high challenge, and a rugged yet captivating experience.
Read original review
Everyeye.it78/100 → 78 · Z -0.4688Score 79.4028Score 79.4028Z -0.4688Gothic embodies a philosophy regarding RPGs—and video games in general—that has all but vanished today. That is why it is so surprising to see it return in its original form, yet with a completely new look. If Alkimia Interactive’s goal was to bring that same experience back to screens without reinventing the wheel, the mission was a resounding success. We can only hope to one day get our hands on a *Gothic 2* remake as well. However, technical flaws and bugs remain—particularly concerning quest progression—that deserved more attention. Likewise, a more modern take on the combat system would have enhanced the game's overall appeal without necessarily betraying its identity. Ultimately, the Gothic 1 remake is a project of stubborn fidelity; it successfully preserves the original game's charm, yet it is perhaps too timid to distinguish between intentional ruggedness and inherited clunkiness.
Read original review
Explosion Network70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1789Score 72.3022Score 72.3022Z -1.1789A classic RPG remake stemming from a time when RPG were more brutal and let the player explore and discover the world of their own volition. Begin by being literally tossed into the world and have to struggle to survive.
Read original review
FingerGuns50/100 → 50 · Z -2.3393Score 60.6979Score 60.6979Z -2.3393Smudged on all sides with technical bugs, crashes, audio failures and performances mishaps, the best of Gothic 1 Remake's qualities only just manage to shine through the grime. While there's a truly compelling game nestled under the surface, this nugget of ore needs more sprucing up before it's ready to be sold on.
Read original review
Game Informer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6988Score 77.1026Score 77.1026Z -0.6988Despite all the games it influenced over the years, Gothic still stands alone. This remake is both faithful and fresh, providing much-needed improvements and wider accessibility in spite of its unforgiving nature and undeniable eurojank (a term the original Gothic helped establish). Newcomers may feel the game is a relic in some ways, but anyone interested in an underplayed yet seminal classic owes it to themselves to give Gothic 1 Remake a shot.
Read original review
Game872/100 → 72 · Z -1.0496Score 73.5948Score 73.5948Z -1.0496Gothic Remake delivers a very specific kind of RPG experience with conviction, but not without clear friction. On one hand, its identity is extremely strong: the progression system is rewarding once it clicks, the faction structure meaningfully shapes how you experience the world, and the sense of learning the colony through struggle is something few modern RPGs attempt at this scale anymore. But on the other hand, that same identity comes with trade-offs that are hard to ignore. The early hours can be so punishing that they risk pushing players away before the systems properly open up. Technical issues like crashes and bugs also interrupt what is already a demanding experience. Add to that the repetition in quest structure and moments of pacing slowdown, and you get a game that can feel uneven. It’s a game that absolutely knows what it wants to be, whether that's a strength or a barrier depends entirely on how much friction players are willing to accept in exchange for its highs.
Read original review
GameBlast75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5562Score 78.5293Score 78.5293Z -0.5562Gothic 1 Remake honors the classic by maintaining and improving its core elements. The slow progression is compensated by a clear evolution of the hero, while the challenging combat and dark setting shine in the new graphics engine. However, Unreal Engine 5 introduced bugs and performance drops that await correction. Furthermore, the chest-cracking minigame is excessively complex for the title's purpose.
Read original review
Gamefa60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2115Score 61.9763Score 61.9763Z -2.2115Gothic Remake has both notable achievements and considerable shortcomings in its journey to remake one of the most enduring RPGs in history. While sporting a more modern look, the game still preserves the deep role-playing mechanics and high player agency in quest completion—qualities that, although entirely indebted to the classic original, are far less common in today's RPG landscape. On the other hand, however, some fundamental issues can significantly overshadow the experience and frustrate the player. Furthermore, the developers' excessive effort to remain faithful to certain aspects of the classic version has caused not only the positives but also the negatives—sometimes in even greater doses—to carry over into the remake, occasionally leaving an unpleasant impression on the player. This title may offer a modern-graphics experience of Gothic 1, but as a "remake," it fails to shine particularly brightly.
Read original review
Gameffine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3773Score 80.3186Score 80.3186Z -0.3773Gothic 1 Remake is everything a good remake should strive to be. It stays remarkably faithful to the spirit of the original while delivering meaningful improvements across nearly every aspect of the experience. Even its more drastic changes feel like natural extensions of the Gothic formula rather than unnecessary departures. Can it replace the original? That's a difficult question for me to answer objectively, as I have too much history with Classic. However, if you're new to the series, there is no better place to begin. What ultimately keeps the remake from true greatness are its technical shortcomings and the inherent challenges of balancing a single-player RPG. There are certainly areas where it could be refined further, but even in its current form, Gothic 1 Remake stands as one of the year's strongest releases and a worthy revival of a beloved classic.
Read original review
Gameliner70/100 → 70 · Z -0.578Score 78.3113Score 78.3113Z -0.578Gothic 1 Remake stays remarkably faithful to the original, perhaps even a little too faithful, offering a demanding journey that refuses to hold your hand and makes every bit of progress feel earned. The challenge remains rewarding throughout, but the combat continues to feel stiff and cumbersome even after significant advancement, which undermines the action-RPG experience. Audiovisually, the remake is largely impressive aside from its often lifeless NPCs, making it an easy recommendation for longtime fans but a game newcomers should approach with caution.
Read original review
GameMAG80/100 → 80 · Z 0.066Score 84.7512Score 84.7512Z 0.066Gothic 1 Remake turned out to be a rather mixed remake. The final result was influenced by the team's inexperience and budget constraints, which led to a certain rawness in the remake and the implementation of both successful and unsuccessful solutions. Despite this, Alkimia Interactive handled the legacy of Piranha Bytes with care, recreating Gothic 1 in a way that makes it accessible to a wider audience.
Read original review
Gamemeca74/100 → 74 · Z -0.9942Score 74.1495Score 74.1495Z -0.9942Gothic 1 Remake successfully revives the brutal, uncompromising atmosphere of the classic CRPG experience. However, its punishingly unfair early-game design and frequent, game-breaking bugs severely hinder the player's progression. While nostalgic fans might enjoy the challenge, the technical state requires urgent developer attention.
Read original review
GameOnly80/100 → 80 · Z -0.094Score 83.1509Score 83.1509Z -0.094Could Gothic Remake be better? Of course. Fortunately, it turned out to be just good enough and I genuinely hope to see a remake of the next installment as well, because the developers at Alkimia Interactive have convinced me that they’re up to the task. By the time you’re listening to this review, I’m probably already playing through it again, this time joining a different camp. So all that’s left for me to do is recommend a visit to the Valley of Mines, more beautiful than ever before.
Read original review
Gamer Guides79/100 → 79 · Z -0.3905Score 80.1865Score 80.1865Z -0.3905Gothic Remake does an incredible job of visually updating and modernizing a punishing RPG, while keeping the spirit and soul of the classic alive. It’s a part of gaming history, and while performance isn’t great and it can be punishing, you won’t find much else like it.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club80/100 → 80 · Z -0.309Score 81.0007Score 81.0007Z -0.309I am happy to announce that I am a new fan! I was willing to adapt to what the developers wanted me to experience, and even to the hours I lost due to bugs. Gothic is an open-world action RPG that I want to recommend to everyone without an asterisk. It’s a fantastic and beautiful world, filled with challenging enemies, engaging gameplay, and a sense of wonder I haven’t felt in a long time. However, playing on console was less than ideal, and in my opinion, it should’ve been released only on PC as a timed exclusive so that a proper console version could be released later. I feel like I’m saying this too often lately, but this game is a must-play for fans of this genre. Just wait a bit until it’s been ironed out.
Read original review
Gamer.no70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8166Score 75.9256Score 75.9256Z -0.8166Gothic 1 Remake offers a ruthless, uncompromising world full of secrets and unique moments – but technical issues and an unforgiving learning curve will test even the most patient players.
Read original review
Gamereactor UK70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7361Score 76.7303Score 76.7303Z -0.7361It is very faithful to the original, for better or worse, and the surface is still rough, prickly and full of Euro-jank. But if you scratch beneath it long enough, a rather fine gem emerges. A slightly grubby and uneven gem, to be sure, but still a gem.
Read original review
GamersGlobal85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1422Score 85.5135Score 85.5135Z 0.1422People who don't know the original might have a hard time finding into the game with the lack of handholding and tutorials. But the story and atmosphere are strong, the world vast and varied, the dub great and the music beyond any doubt. As fan of the original Gothic, I am so very pleased how Alkimia Interactive captured all these strenghts and even added new areas, NPCs and quests in a way like they've always been there. Some troublesome bugs are still there but the devs already seem to be on their way to squash them. As they say in Gothic: All will be well.
Read original review
Games Freezer75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6014Score 78.0767Score 78.0767Z -0.6014If you like Piranha Bytes titles, you’ll love this, and if this is your first time in the world of Gothic...it could well be a little different to other RPGs you’ve played, but it will absolutely reward your patience if you click with its style.
Read original review
GAMES.CH85/100 → 85 · Z 0.175Score 85.8415Score 85.8415Z 0.175"Gothic 1 Remake" successfully manages the difficult balancing act of breathing new life into a classic of German gaming history.
Read original review
GAMES.CH85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1116Score 85.2075Score 85.2075Z 0.1116Gothic 1 Remake is one of the most confident games of the year. It does not compromise on the 2001 vision of giving the reigns to the player and has next to no guidance through a merciless and unforgiving world. This leads to a gameplay experience that is perfect for some, but off-putting for others, but the promise of making the original Gothic accessible through large and small changes, most notably the presentation of the game, is thoroughly fulfilled.
Read original review
Games.cz70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0267Score 73.8246Score 73.8246Z -1.0267Gothic 1 Remake is precisely the return of a classic that fans hoped for. Alkimia Interactive managed to preserve the original’s unique atmosphere, timeless story, and sense of adventure while dressing it in a beautiful, modern audiovisual presentation. However, the remake fails to mask some of the original's issues alongside its own technical flaws: unbalanced difficulty, tedious backtracking, a weaker final act, and numerous bugs prevent it from being an absolute triumph. Still, it remains a great RPG that will remind veterans why they fell in love with Gothic in the first place, while offering newcomers the best way yet to experience one of the most influential fantasy games of its era.
Read original review
GamesCreed74/100 → 74 · Z -0.7668Score 76.423Score 76.423Z -0.7668Gothic Remake retains the atmosphere of an old favorite but makes it playable for a new generation of gamers. It might not be the flawless modern RPG recreation that many were hoping for, but it does a nice job of explaining why Gothic still matters after more than 20 years.
Read original review
GamesNight60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8471Score 65.6198Score 65.6198Z -1.8471Gothic 1 Remake is a game of two halves. It’s got an interesting world that I wanted to explore, and the story and writing are well done. But there are a lot of systems that are consistently pushing up against you, stopping me from enjoying the finer points of the game. If you have nostalgia for the original, this may be easier to push through, but this remake blends well-done visuals and a great setting with a lot of mechanics and design that have aged poorly. There is a good game in Gothic 1 Remake; it’s just a lot harder to reach than it should be, and by the time you reach it, that frustration damages the overall experience.
Read original review
Gamesource Italia80/100 → 80 · Z -0.149Score 82.6007Score 82.6007Z -0.149Gothic 1 Remake doesn't aim to simplify or sugar-coat the experience to make it more accessible at all costs. On the contrary, it seems intent on preserving that sense of achievement that comes from overcoming difficulties. The spirit of Gothic lives on: if you're one of its longtime fans and you're passionate about a challenge, you'll find much of what made them fall in love with the original series, as well as plenty to enjoy!
Read original review
GameSpace75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8694Score 75.397Score 75.397Z -0.8694Gothic 1 Remake manages to revive the spirit and atmosphere of the original, faithfully following the predecessor’s guideline. While the game has its own problems and issues, it still worth playing. Either you are a veteran and know your way through the colony, or a newbie who doesn’t know the prison rules, you will receive a satisfying experience.
Read original review
GamesRadar+80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3691Score 80.4005Score 80.4005Z -0.3691Brilliant, bizarre, and a bit too obnoxious for its own good, Gothic 1 Remake is a solid remake of a hugely influential RPG. Dedicated to keeping the deeply unique and unfriendly spirit of the original alive, this still feels like little else, though I can't help but wish it was willing to add more polish.
Read original review
GameStar76/100 → 76 · Z -0.7522Score 76.5696Score 76.5696Z -0.7522The remake is Gothic through and through, with thoughtful improvements and a few old weaknesses. It's worth checking out—and not just for those feeling nostalgic.
Read original review
Gamesurf65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4772Score 69.3193Score 69.3193Z -1.4772We could spend time debating whether the gameplay system of Gothic 1 has aged well or poorly, but we would end up stuck in the usual divide between those who love its classic gameplay and those who would have preferred a more modern overhaul. The key point is that, knowing you are approaching a no-compromise gaming experience with deliberately clunky mechanics, Gothic 1 Remake offers an experience that is, at least in theory, just as enjoyable today as it was in 2001. In practice, however, Gothic 1 Remake is held back by its technical performance, with an abundance of bugs, inaccuracies, and even the occasional crash, making it difficult to fully enjoy everything the game has to offer. It is a real shame that a title with such a dedicated fanbase—and the potential to gain new ones—suffers from such a problematic state. Even after several patches, the situation does not appear to have improved significantly. Gothic 1 Remake could be a solid action RPG, capable of bringing back an excellent blend of exploration and gameplay systems, but at the moment the technical side acts as a bottleneck. Perhaps, with a major code overhaul, the team at Alkimia Interactive could manage to resolve at least part of the issues, but for now the undeniable strengths of the project struggle to outweigh its weaknesses. That said, with a healthy and generous dose of patience, it is still possible to experience this original adventure—revived (but not fully refined)—which remains, even today, full of charm.
Read original review
Gaming Boulevard75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6767Score 77.3238Score 77.3238Z -0.6767Gothic Remake 1 is a faithful return to a legendary RPG: it captures the original’s charm, rewarding progression, and immersive world while modernizing its visuals and adding meaningful quality-of-life improvements. Yet outdated combat mechanics, technical stuttering, and rough animations hold it back from true greatness. For longtime fans, this remake is a fun revival; for newcomers, it remains a demanding but deeply rewarding RPG adventure. For veteran players, the game will have almost everything they wanted due to the refreshing remade features; however, I do believe newcomers will feel a bit out of touch with the core game plan and vision of the game due to the lack of hand-holding and its time-consuming grind.
Read original review
Gaming Professors90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7934Score 92.0248Score 92.0248Z 0.7934Gothic 1 Remake isn’t just a remake of an old game. It’s an attempt to revive a specific type of RPG that’s almost nonexistent today. It’s not merely a return of a famous franchise, but a reminder of a time when RPGs were built on character growth through patience, exploration, tough combat, curiosity, and hardship. A reminder of a time when there was no need to explain every step and when exploring the world was a true adventure. After all these years of waiting, what emerged wasn’t just another remake. It was a modern incarnation of one of the most important RPGs in history. And even though it has a few flaws, it’s a title that shows why Gothic was so exceptional.
Read original review
GamingBolt60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8893Score 65.198Score 65.198Z -1.8893Gothic 1 Remake definitely deserves praise for preserving everything good about the original release and for its revamped visuals. However, that isn't enough to excuse its poor performance and dated combat, facets crucial to the experience that actively prevent it from being easy to recommend.
Read original review
Generación Xbox84/100 → 84 · Z -0.1324Score 82.7669Score 82.7669Z -0.1324They've succeeded in helping a new generation of players understand why Gothic remains a benchmark within the genre.
Read original review
GIGA70/100 → 70 · Z -1.4764Score 69.3273Score 69.3273Z -1.4764Gothic Remake stays true to its old-school roots, rewarding patience while punishing mistakes. Still a bit rough (around the edges) but rewarding for those willing to embrace its unforgiving design.
Read original review
GRYOnline.pl75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8379Score 75.7125Score 75.7125Z -0.8379Alkimia has delivered a game that captures the strengths of its predecessor, led by a brilliantly constructed world and the brutal harshness of life in the Mining Valley. Defying contemporary trends, Gothic Remake doesn’t hold the player’s hand and rewards them with a great sense of satisfaction as they make progress. It’s just a shame that we’ve ended up with a game plagued by so many bugs.
Read original review
GRYOnline.pl75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7574Score 76.5167Score 76.5167Z -0.7574Alkimia has delivered a game that captures the strengths of its predecessor, led by a brilliantly constructed world and the brutal harshness of life in the Mining Valley. Defying contemporary trends, Gothic Remake doesn’t hold the player’s hand and rewards them with a great sense of satisfaction as they make progress. It’s just a shame that we’ve ended up with a game plagued by so many bugs.
Read original review
Hinsusta90/100 → 90 · Z 0.503Score 89.121Score 89.121Z 0.503The Gothic 1 remake is exactly what fans were hoping for: a technical overhaul that never loses its gritty character. I had an absolute blast playing this brutal game. It requires patience—you have to save often, proceed with caution, and rely on tactics to get through it—but the reward is a wonderful role-playing experience.
Read original review
Hobby Consolas75/100 → 75 · Z -1.2496Score 71.5949Score 71.5949Z -1.2496So if you're the kind of player who appreciates not having everything handed to you on a silver platter, has the patience to explore every corner, talk to all the NPCs, save your game constantly to avoid unpleasant surprises, and appreciates a realistic progression system... you're going to enjoy Gothic 1 Remake .
Read original review
IGN70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1356Score 72.7353Score 72.7353Z -1.1356Gothic 1 Remake is undeniably the best way to play this cult classic RPG, even if certain aspects of it have aged like milk.
Read original review
IGN Adria60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2534Score 61.5574Score 61.5574Z -2.2534When you look at the whole picture, the Gothic 1 Remake is an extremely faithful recreation of the original - one that will likely put off most players except hardcore fans who crave games that feel like they hate you more than an ex after a toxic breakup.
Read original review
IGN Deutschland60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8418Score 65.6732Score 65.6732Z -1.8418Gothic Remake presents the cult classic in a gorgeous new look and with a handful of carefully-placed changes and improvements. It remains as relentless and challenging as fans remember and, just like the original, refuses to hold your hand. During our test, technical issues and messy AI ruined our fun and ultimately doomed our playthrough to get irretrievably stuck. If Alkimia Interactive can fix the technical problems and bugs, the remake will without a doubt become the best method to experience Gothic once more or for the very first time. Whether or not they can pull it off, remains to be seen.
Read original review
IGN Spain70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2719Score 71.3726Score 71.3726Z -1.2719Gothic 1 Remake pays homage to the original with a third-person RPG that aims to challenge the player. With no interactive maps, compasses, waypoints, or on-screen markers, we must listen closely to the characters and rely on them to get through the early stages, which will gradually draw us into this great adventure. The improvements go beyond the visuals to offer a better-designed world in terms of gameplay, smoother combat, and a rewritten story full of new possibilities. A return that isn't without its flaws but marks a good first step for future remakes
Read original review
IGN Turkey65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3946Score 70.1454Score 70.1454Z -1.3946Gothic 1 Remake is a remake that clearly shows a lot of effort went into it. However, it has remained so faithful to its roots that, rather than being a challenging action-RPG adventure, it has ended up as a game that is overly archaic, repetitive, and likely to appeal only to a specific niche of players. On top of that, with serious performance issues and bugs stemming from the Unreal Engine, it falls slightly short of expectations as a remake.
Read original review
Impulsegamer52/100 → 52 · Z -2.8673Score 55.4181Score 55.4181Z -2.8673For the hardcore fans of the franchise that just wanted a 1:1 remake of the original without anything added or removed, Gothic Remake is a dream come true. But even the avid Gothic fans are not safe from the performance horrors caused by the Unreal Engine 5, and that makes the Gothic Remake not everybody’s cup of tea.
Read original review
INDIANTVCZ80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0428Score 83.663Score 83.663Z -0.0428An excellent title for both newcomers and longtime fans, delivering virtually the same experience in a new, more beautiful, and more polished package. This is how remakes should be made! It's no surprise that the community is already asking for a remake of the second game. While it's a significantly better title than the original in terms of both storytelling and technical execution, there's still plenty of room for improvement. And Alkimia Interactive have proven that they can absolutely pull it off.
Read original review
Invision Community70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9618Score 74.4727Score 74.4727Z -0.9618Gothic 1 Remake is a rare breed that actually respects its source material instead of trying to reinvent itself. It’s not perfect, and it definitely won’t suit everyone, but it delivers exactly what long-time fans wanted — and that’s something a lot of modern remakes fail to do.
Read original review
JsemGamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0071Score 84.0202Score 84.0202Z -0.0071Gothic 1 Remake successfully preserves the dark atmosphere, harsh progression, and old-school sense of discovery that made the original so memorable, even if technical issues and occasional clunkiness keep it from feeling fully polished.
Read original review
Just Play it65/100 → 65 · Z -2.0409Score 63.6822Score 63.6822Z -2.0409Gothic succeeds in recreating its world in a way that preserves the spirit of the classic version, but it suffers from many flaws that stand in the way of enjoyment. It may appeal to those looking for the depth of a classic RPG, as it stays faithful to old-school conventions, but it is not for players seeking innovative experiences with high technical and graphical performance.
Read original review
KonsoliFIN60/100 → 60 · Z -1.4387Score 69.7038Score 69.7038Z -1.4387The fans are surely delighted by this remake, but does it succeed in pleasing other people as well?
Read original review
Manual dos Games73/100 → 73 · Z -1.3875Score 70.2158Score 70.2158Z -1.3875Gothic 1 Remake is a faithful reimagining of the 2001 classic, preserving its core essence while delivering an immersive world that encourages players to explore and forge their own path. This approach may prove frustrating for those expecting a modern RPG experience, but it richly rewards players willing to embrace its harsh, dangerous world with a compelling adventure filled with memorable moments.
Read original review
Merlin'in Kazanı82/100 → 82 · Z -0.3273Score 80.8185Score 80.8185Z -0.3273Gothic 1 Remake faithfully revives the original's harsh RPG design with a strong atmosphere, rewarding progression, and memorable world-building. Technical issues and its unforgiving nature keep it from greatness.
Read original review
Merlin'in Kazanı (Turkey)82/100 → 82 · Z -0.1723Score 82.3682Score 82.3682Z -0.1723Gothic 1 Remake faithfully revives the original’s harsh RPG design with a strong atmosphere, rewarding progression, and memorable world-building. Technical issues and its unforgiving nature keep it from greatness.
Read original review
Metacritic Users83/100 → 83 · Z 0.0065Score 84.1558Score 84.1558Z 0.0065Metacritic user score 8.3/10 (830 ratings).
MGG65/100 → 65 · Z -1.8314Score 65.7769Score 65.7769Z -1.8314Even though it’s far from perfect, Gothic 1 Remake succeeds in significantly modernizing the original game while preserving everything that made it so charming. It’s still an old-school RPG, offering players a great deal of freedom and the chance to lose themselves in a world that’s both extremely harsh and distinctive, without ever holding their hand. But now, it’s much richer visually, and some of the gameplay flaws have been smoothed out a bit. This doesn’t erase all the clunkiness and flaws of the original game, while the improvements to combat and the interface clearly didn’t go far enough. The numerous bugs and performance issues are also real problems at this point. Even for Gothic fans and those seeking an old-school experience, it’s best to wait before diving in, for an optimal gaming experience.
Read original review
MondoXbox80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4863Score 79.2282Score 79.2282Z -0.4863Gothic Remake is primarily designed for fans of the original masterpiece, retaining its ruthless, uncompromising philosophy. While quality-of-life updates make it slightly more accessible, the brutal difficulty remains a steep wall for newcomers. It’s a punishing experience that delivers rare satisfaction. Despite a lack of innovation, it’s an excellent starting point for the franchise's rebirth.
Read original review
Multiplayer.it80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1974Score 82.117Score 82.117Z -0.1974Gothic 1 Remake was designed first and foremost for Gothic fans: it is graphically more modern, the quality of life has been improved, but the core elements have remained the same, for better or worse. Our advice is to read the review carefully before deciding whether it is right for you, because in a case like this, the score can be misleading like never before. On our end, we decided to reward the dedication shown in modernizing the still much-beloved original experience, with a work that we consider successful in relation to its target audience. Perhaps it lacks a bit of courage, but hopefully at this point Alkimia can continue their work of reviving the series, and the potential success of this first chapter gives them the necessary confidence to dare more.
Read original review
NextGen Player80/100 → 80 · Z -0.523Score 78.8607Score 78.8607Z -0.523Gothic 1 Remake is a great reminder that old-school RPG design still has its place in gaming. I loved how The Colony makes you listen, make careful decisions, earn each step forward, and accept any setbacks. The remake respects the original’s identity while giving its prison-fantasy setting a much stronger presentation using Unreal Engine 5. For gamers who miss RPGs with danger, consequence, and real growth, this version delivers a fantastic adventure that stayed with me after long after the story concluded.
Read original review
Niche Gamer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6483Score 90.5743Score 90.5743Z 0.6483Gothic Remake proves it is still possible to build one, and to build it without a soulslike label, without hand-holding disguised as inclusion, and without ever once doubting whether the player can handle what is being asked of them.
Read original review
NoobFeed70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0016Score 74.0755Score 74.0755Z -1.0016Gothic 1 Remake is a faithful return to the beloved setting of the original game for its fans, improved with better graphics and more content. It’s a fascinating but tough approach to get into a style that will not give in for folks who have never played an RPG before.
Read original review
NookGaming80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1929Score 82.1626Score 82.1626Z -0.1929Gothic 1 Remake is a special title. It bottles all the magic of the original game and has managed to tinker with it enough to keep it authentic but accessible to an entirely new fanbase. It’s still rough as all hell, but this only helps make it captivating. And in a world of gaming where stories are often told through cutscenes, the Gothic Remake makes you tell your own story through its actions, setting, and sense of challenge and immersion. It might be a bit more on the niche side thanks to its rough parts and difficulty, but for you masochists and immersion seekers, Gothic 1 Remake is going to take you right into the Prison Colony, beat you up, steal your ore, and by the Sleeper, you are going to thank it and go back for more!
Read original review
Oyun Günlüğü65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5498Score 68.5936Score 68.5936Z -1.5498Gothic 1 Remake was well-received by audiences but its critical flaws may disappoint many players.
Read original review
Oyungezer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3054Score 81.0371Score 81.0371Z -0.3054Its unforgiving difficulty in the opening hours and lack of the convenience features modern players have grown accustomed to may make Gothic 1 Remake a tough sell for those who prefer a more relaxed experience. But there's no question that this remake is the definitive way to experience this cult classic. The sense of accomplishment it delivers is something few games can match, and that's simply a fact.
Read original review
Oyungezer Online80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3118Score 80.9731Score 80.9731Z -0.3118Its unforgiving difficulty in the opening hours and lack of the convenience features modern players have grown accustomed to may make Gothic 1 Remake a tough sell for those who prefer a more relaxed experience. But there's no question that this remake is the definitive way to experience this cult classic. The sense of accomplishment it delivers is something few games can match, and that's simply a fact.
Read original review
PC Gamer60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9225Score 64.8657Score 64.8657Z -1.9225Gothic 1 Remake may have made concessions for new players, but remains an RPG for people who think Daggerfall was the last good Bethesda game.
Read original review
PC Games80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4042Score 80.0492Score 80.0492Z -0.4042Gothic Remake is a fantastic, atmospheric reimagining that more than does justice to the original.
Read original review
PCMag Middle East80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3521Score 80.5705Score 80.5705Z -0.3521Gothic 1 Remake is a successful resurrection of a cult classic that refuses to sand off its rough edges. Those willing to meet the gameon its own terms will find a deeply immersive RPG with a distinct identity.
Read original review
PLAY! Zine87/100 → 87 · Z 0.215Score 86.2412Score 86.2412Z 0.215Gothic 1 Remake is a brutal, breathtaking return to the legendary Mining Colony. Rejecting modern hand-holding, this faithful reimagining drops you into a living, reactive world where every step must be earned and survival depends on your wits. From its rewarding, evolving combat to its stunning Unreal Engine 5 visuals, it is a hardcore game tailored for true RPG purists who aren't afraid of a real challenge.
Read original review
PlayStation Universe65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5917Score 68.1737Score 68.1737Z -1.5917The PS5 version of Gothic 1 Remake is held back by performance woes, but underneath this lies an iconic RPG with deeply immersive gameplay. For new players, it's hard to recommend the PS5 version in its current state, whereas fans who can look past the graphics and 30 FPS limit may find appreciation in this blast from the past.
Read original review
PSX Brasil70/100 → 70 · Z -1.5092Score 68.9992Score 68.9992Z -1.5092Gothic 1 Remake definitely has no intention of abandoning its original core principles in favor of so-called greater accessibility or conforming to current genre standards. This gives it a certain authenticity, but at the same time it also limits it from exploring more sophisticated possibilities in world design, resource management, campaign progression, and adaptability to different playstyles, becoming somewhat anachronistic and unbalanced in terms of cost and reward for the experience.
Read original review
Push Square50/100 → 50 · Z -2.1701Score 62.3899Score 62.3899Z -2.1701Gothic 1 Remake is a faithful retelling of the original Gothic, warts and all. Perhaps too ambitious for its budget, it offers even hardened gamers a truly unique, hardcore roleplaying experience. While weighed down by a litany of bugs and issues, there is a lovingly made product underneath – but it's hard to recommend in its current state.
Read original review
RageQuit.GR87/100 → 87 · Z 0.1428Score 85.519Score 85.519Z 0.1428Gothic remake is an anachronism-an intentional one at that. It eschews most contemporary practices in game design and accessibility, in favor of an old school, unfiltered approach. And it works - this is a glorious as well as uncompromising game.
Read original review
Ragequit.gr87/100 → 87 · Z 0.1541Score 85.6325Score 85.6325Z 0.1541Gothic remake is an anachronism-an intentional one at that. It eschews most contemporary practices in game design and accessibility, in favor of an old school, unfiltered approach. And it works- this is a glorious as well as uncompromising game.
Read original review
ReGame It85/100 → 85 · Z -0.015Score 83.9409Score 83.9409Z -0.015Gothic Remake faithfully preserves what made the original a genre-defining RPG. Its gradual character progression, rewarding role-playing systems, and immersive NPC routines still feel remarkably ahead of their time. Rather than reinventing the formula, the remake strengthens the legacy of a game that remains one of the finest examples of classic RPG design, even by today's standards.
Read original review
RPG Fan90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4838Score 88.929Score 88.929Z 0.4838I don’t think Gothic 1 Remake completely replaces the original. In many respects, I still prefer the latter. Yet, I do think there is a growing contingent of gamers who are tired of being patronized by placating RPG design, and that’s reflected in the success of Gothic 1 Remake and other games that don’t hold your hand. For those who might get filtered by the jank of the original, Gothic 1 Remake offers a compelling way to return to a time when RPGs respected the player’s intelligence and abilities, or perhaps to experience it for the first time. And by proving that a nearly 30-year-old design needed reverence rather than reinvention, Gothic 1 Remake quietly makes the case that the best a “remake” can do is trust that the original was right all along.
Read original review
RPG Site80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2252Score 81.8391Score 81.8391Z -0.2252Gothic 1 Remake is definitely a game I recommend to RPG fans, and it's a strong enough vision of a Remake that I honestly feel that anyone interested in Gothic in general could start here and get the same type of experience instead of playing the original if they wanted to (though I am glad I played both and encourage that as well). However, it is a game that does require some patience and tolerance for friction and just a little bit of tedium, which might not be to everyone's taste. Gothic 1 Remake was clearly developed by a team that respects the original game and knew how to reimagine it for a modern audience without compromising what originally made it so special and influential so many years later, creating a very remarkable game in its own right.
Read original review
Saudi Gamer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0594Score 73.4969Score 73.4969Z -1.0594Gothic 1 Remake succeeded in preserving the spirit of the original game more than attempting to fully modernize it a decision that gave it a unique identity but also left many of its old issues intact. As a result, the experience carries a special charm for longtime fans, yet it suffers from clear flaws that prevent it from reaching the level it could have achieved had it dared to redesign some of its core foundations.
Read original review
Screen Hype80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4747Score 79.3444Score 79.3444Z -0.4747The spotty performance and the lingering clunkiness keep it from greatness, and not every player will vibe with a game that actively refuses to make their life easier. But if you give the Colony the time it demands, you will find one of the most immersive RPG worlds ever made, looking better than it ever has.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6768Score 77.3227Score 77.3227Z -0.6768The Gothic hero is back in decent form. It boasts modern graphics and offers a compelling story and precise character development. However, the progression is slow and demanding, which can be frustrating in the first few hours.
Read original review
SECTOR.sk75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6128Score 77.9627Score 77.9627Z -0.6128The Gothic hero is back in decent form. It boasts modern graphics and offers a compelling story and precise character development. However, the progression is slow and demanding, which can be frustrating in the first few hours.
Read original review
Softpedia85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0838Score 84.9288Score 84.9288Z 0.0838Gothic 1 Remake looks great, feels amazing to play, and there are so many great choices you can make here. You can be a mage, a warrior, the ultimate bowman or anything you see fit. Plus, following the game’s story will bring many exciting challenges on its own, from using spells to fighting unexpected enemies. Overall, it’s an excellent adventure that everyone should check out, especially if you never played the original. Gothic 1 Remake is the ultimate version of a cult classic, and being able to relive this genre-defining RPG with all the modern bells and whistles was a delight.
Read original review
SpazioGames63/100 → 63 · Z -2.0031Score 64.0604Score 64.0604Z -2.0031Gothic Remake is not a game to be dismissed outright, and it manages to earn a narrow passing grade mainly thanks to what already worked twenty-five years ago: the constant sense of discovery, the satisfaction of overcoming seemingly impossible challenges, and the feeling of genuinely shaping the fate of the game world through your own choices.
Read original review
SteamDeckHQ80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4321Score 79.7698Score 79.7698Z -0.4321Gothic 1 Remake is exactly the kind of RPG I wish we saw more often. It doesn't try to impress you with constant cutscenes or turn you into a hero within the first few hours. Instead, it drops you into a dangerous and punishing world and lets you earn everything yourself. Not every mechanic is great; some systems feel outdated, and there are definitely moments where the game tests your patience. But when everything comes together, the sense of progression and adventure is inescapable.
Read original review
STWGames Italia80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2018Score 82.0729Score 82.0729Z -0.2018The Gothic Remake experience is certainly not for everyone, but those willing to pluck up the courage to get through the first few intense hours of gameplay will find it well worth their while, thanks to entertaining gameplay and a vast, detailed world just waiting to be explored. However, the game inherits some of the original’s flaws, whilst adding others specific to this new remake.
Read original review
The AU Review80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2881Score 81.2103Score 81.2103Z -0.2881Gothic 1 Remake successfully revives a cult-classic franchise by preserving the uncompromising friction that made it famous. Fans of The Elder Scrolls or Kingdom Come: Deliverance will appreciate seeing the foundational mechanics that helped inspire those series.
Read original review
The Beta Network60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0102Score 63.9896Score 63.9896Z -2.0102A faithful and atmospheric RPG with excellent world-building and replayability, held back by repetitive quest design, underwhelming combat and a few frustrating technical hiccups.
Read original review
The Games Machine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4394Score 79.6972Score 79.6972Z -0.4394Gothic Remake has plenty of both good and bad aspects: the work by the team at Alkimia faithfully captures the spirit and brutality of the original game, immersing it in an incredible visual style, but just like 25 years ago, the title is plagued by technical issues and bugs of various kinds. That said, it’s a rediscovery of one of the best RPGs ever produced by the gaming industry, capable of captivating players with a brilliant story and a tangible, satisfying sense of progression. Perfect for longtime fans, and perhaps there are a few curious newcomers out there who will discover Gothic this way, through a generally solid remake.
Read original review
The GameSlayer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1333Score 82.7578Score 82.7578Z -0.1333The Gothic 1 Remake is exactly what we hoped it would be, a modernized take on an uncompromising classic that does exactly what the original did, just on modern hardware with some extras thrown in to delight long-time fans. This is the game that inspired many of the RPGs that we know and love today, so those who enjoy games like The Witcher owe it to themselves to try this experience - and stick with it to be truly rewarded.
Read original review
The Wand Report80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1883Score 85.9742Score 85.9742Z 0.1883Gothic is an idiosyncratic and sometimes stale remake, with a multitude of technical issues. Yet the purity and strength of the original game’s vision shines through.
Read original review
TheBigBois80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3028Score 81.0629Score 81.0629Z -0.3028Alkimia Interactive has crafted a faithful remake that captures what made the original a genre-defining masterpiece: a genuinely reactive world that respects player freedom. Gothic 1 Remake is flawed in specific, addressable ways — the combat plateau, magic balance, lockpicking frustration, compressed endgame — but none of those flaws undercut what the game fundamentally achieves. The Colony breathes. The world doesn’t care about you until you make it. And walking through the New Camp cavern for the first time, watching your eyes adjust to the darkness and the glow of the huts, remains one of the most transportive moments 2026 has offered. For fans of the original, this is the homecoming they deserved. For new players, this is the best possible introduction to one of the most distinctive RPGs ever built.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis80/100 → 80 · Z 0.0041Score 84.1317Score 84.1317Z 0.0041Gothic 1 Remake is a superlative reinterpretation of an all-time classic game. Whilst the initial difficulty level and complete lack of handholding or quest markers etc. might be a hard sell to gamers used to more modern design choices, there is such a wealth of gaming experience to be enjoyed here. The obstacles set up mean that every small amount of progress feels hard earned and the sense of achievement is far greater than in many modern games. The sheer thrill of exploration and character choices make for an RPG that has been liberated from the technical limitations of its origin.
Read original review
Thumb Culture80/100 → 80 · Z -0.1505Score 82.5858Score 82.5858Z -0.1505Gothic 1 Remake really blossoms and shines once players get through the excruciatingly slow start, with the seemingly endless back-and-forth conversations and tasks. Whilst I do appreciate how heavily this game focuses on NPC interaction, and its importance in forming alliances, Gothic fails to make me care about any of these Old Camp Shadow thugs, Brotherhood of the Sleeper cultists, or New Camp Mercenaries. Diego is the only character that even comes close to being likeable.
Gothic 1 Remake’s biggest achievement is to truly deliver that vintage gameplay experience to players. If you’re a big fan of old-school game design, minimal guidance, and unforgiving difficulty, then this game is for you. For players who have grown accustomed to modern quality of life features like fast travel and auto-saves, Gothic 1 Remake can feel rather frustrating. One of my personal pet peeves was the trainer-based progression system. I had to track down one of the many NPCs who can train me to level up a certain skill.
Yes, I know I sound like I didn’t enjoy the game. On the contrary, it brought me back to my childhood, when games didn’t have guides, floating arrows pointing where you had to go next, or glowing objects that stood out so you knew which ones you could interact with. If you’re looking for that old-school feel, Gothic 1 Remake will not disappoint.
Gothic 1 Remake gets the Thumb Culture Gold Award!
Read original review
Try Hard Guides80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2995Score 81.0966Score 81.0966Z -0.2995The Gothic 1 Remake is a beautiful graphical upgrade of one of the most incredible RPGs of all time, and I have no doubt that returning fans will love it. However, the game’s performance issues dampen the mood, and certain new bugs and a lack of quality-of-life improvements make it less than a perfect remake. These issues and the lack of modernizing polish may also make it harder for new players to get into the game, especially when paired with the obviously and purposefully dated, difficult gameplay.
Read original review
Uagna75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7512Score 76.5789Score 76.5789Z -0.7512Gothic Remake is a heartfelt love letter to one of the cornerstones of Western role-playing games. With this ambitious project, Alkimia Interactive accomplishes a remarkably difficult feat: modernizing the combat system and expanding the narrative while preserving the unforgiving, gritty, and punishing spirit that made the 2001 original a timeless classic. Unfortunately, this compelling return to the Colony is held back by a troubled technical performance, plagued by frequent crashes and optimization issues that fall short of expectations. Even so, the game is clearly a labor of love—one that pays tribute to its source material while retaining all of its enduring charm. It comes highly recommended for both longtime veterans and newcomers alike, provided they are willing to endure the engine’s significant technical shortcomings or wait for the inevitable post-launch patches to smooth out the experience.
Read original review
Vandal75/100 → 75 · Z -0.9475Score 74.6163Score 74.6163Z -0.9475Punishing yet ultimately gratifying, this remake revives the oppressive atmosphere and uncompromising difficulty of the original. It rewards patience with deep sociological complexity despite the intentionally clunky combat and total absence of modern guidance. This polarizing experience successfully prioritizes heritage over accessibility, delivering a brutal journey for dedicated fans.
Read original review
Vgames80/100 → 80 · Z -0.6517Score 77.5738Score 77.5738Z -0.6517Gothic 1 Remake is a rough yet refreshing return to an older style of role playing game. Dated quest design, awkward combat and a frustrating economy hold it back, while its hostile world, meaningful exploration and refusal to guide the player make the Colony feel genuinely dangerous. Few modern RPGs are willing to make the player feel this small, and that courage makes the journey worth taking.
Read original review
Virtualni Kutak85/100 → 85 · Z 0.0181Score 84.2721Score 84.2721Z 0.0181The Gothic 1 Remake is a testament of how you should approach remakes of classics. Treating them with respect and modernize them for a new generation to play. For newcomers to the series and veterans alike, Gothic 1 Remake is a worthy comeback.
Read original review
WayTooManyGames80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0584Score 83.5067Score 83.5067Z -0.0584Technical issues can be annoying, but there is still far more good here than bad. For its extraordinary sense of immersion, its vibrant and believable world, and one of the most satisfying progression systems in the genre, I ultimately give Gothic Remake thumbs up, and wholly recommend it.
Read original review
WellPlayed55/100 → 55 · Z -2.0816Score 63.2749Score 63.2749Z -2.0816A memorable, atmospheric adventure that grinds down unsuspecting players before granting them any ounce of power, this remake of a role-playing game ahead of its time feels more frustrating than fresh.
Read original review
ZdobywcyGier.eu80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4958Score 79.1328Score 79.1328Z -0.4958Is it worth buying Gothic 1 Remake if you loved the original or are just looking to dive into this world? My answer is: no. Or at least not right now. The remake is a terribly optimized game riddled with all sorts of bugs. In a few months, once the developers have fixed at least some of the issues—and the game itself may have dropped in price a bit—go ahead and head to the stores. Personally, I had a phenomenal time playing it and felt like that little kid in elementary school again, stepping into the Miners’ Valley for the very first time. The remake is great, and I can’t wait to give it another go, this time playing as the other side. I’m also really hoping that the revamped version of the sequel gets the green light. But is the remake better than the original, and is it worth choosing it over the original? To be honest, I see plenty of room for both titles to coexist on the market as equals. That way, you can play the timeless original one time and fire up the modern remake another time. Both games have their pros and cons, which defy the classic framework for evaluating games. And while I know I won’t convince the most die-hard fans, I still recommend that every fan of the series pick up this new version someday. As for newcomers who’d like to explore this universe for the first time? It’s definitely worth checking out the original, but all things considered, the remake—despite its distinctly retro gameplay and hardcore difficulty—seems like a much better starting point today.
Read original review
ZTGD70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0993Score 73.0984Score 73.0984Z -1.0993And while this was the first time, I have experienced this title, I can’t say that it was as good as some newer titles but also not as bad as some. It kind of exists, like its story, in the middle of the road.
Read original review