Analog Stick Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0315Score 73.7766Score 73.7766Z -1.0315Despite my wide array of criticisms, Echoes of Aincrad was still a pretty solid experience, but its gameplay and exploration are the weakest parts of the whole package. With a solid story and interesting characters, the recreation of the Death Game is as good as we've had it so far. Combat is fine enough, but exploration suffers due to invisible walls, and a stumbling in the dark approach to traversing it. Regardless, Echoes of Aincrad does make large strides in the right direction of being “that” Sword Art Online game we've always wanted, I just wish it felt more like the grand MMO it was needing to be.
Read original review
ani-game.com70/100 → 70 · Z -1.8301Score 65.7896Score 65.7896Z -1.8301I enjoyed my time with Echoes of Aincrad. It successfully does something different with the Sword Art Online formula by allowing players to experience the Aincrad incident through an entirely new perspective, and that alone makes it feel fresh. Strong combat, enjoyable progression, excellent presentation, and a genuinely engaging story make it an easy recommendation for fans of the series.
Read original review
Atomix70/100 → 70 · Z -1.7613Score 66.478Score 66.478Z -1.7613Echoes of Aincrad is arguably one of the most ambitious video games in the Sword Art Online franchise. Its alternate storyline, solid combat system, and polished audiovisual presentation combine to deliver an entertaining experience.
Read original review
Bazimag71/100 → 71 · Z -1.2308Score 71.783Score 71.783Z -1.2308If you are a fan of Sword Art Online, Echoes of Aincrad offers a chance to return once again to one of the series’ most beloved worlds. However, if you are entering this universe for the first time, you should know that despite all of its strengths, the game is less a revolution in the JRPG genre and more a faithful and charming experience for fans of the world of Aincrad. Ultimately, Echoes of Aincrad proves that even after all these years, the original idea behind Sword Art Online still retains its appeal: the dream of being inside a game that can be beautiful, exciting, and dangerous all at the same time.
Read original review
BuffGaming.rs70/100 → 70 · Z -1.4757Score 69.3346Score 69.3346Z -1.4757Echoes of Aincrad is a solid addition to the Sword Art Online franchise. While its restrictive world design prevents it from reaching its full potential, the new story, memorable characters, and faithful recreation of Aincrad make it an enjoyable experience for longtime SAO fans. If you've always wanted another adventure in Aincrad, this is still worth playing—just don't expect the open-world experience many fans have dreamed of.
Read original review
Capsule Computers50/100 → 50 · Z -3.1886Score 52.2053Score 52.2053Z -3.1886Echoes of Aincrad mixes mismatched genres, sluggish pacing, shallow exploration, and lackluster combat into a dated MMO‑like experience that is helped only by a few genuinely strong characters.
Read original review
Cerealkillerz69/100 → 69 · Z -1.7893Score 66.1978Score 66.1978Z -1.7893Sword Art Online deserved better than Echoes of Aincrad is able to deliver. The combat and the upgrade and crafting systems are enjoyable, but they're almost completely undermined by the painfully linear level design, the repetitive mission structure, and the way exploration is rendered virtually pointless.
The game's biggest strength is its story, which remains surprisingly serious for most of the adventure before eventually falling back on the usual "save the world" clichés. Unfortunately, your protagonist still feels like a supporting character throughout the story and could easily be removed from many of the cutscenes without changing much.
We recommend that everyone try the demo first to make sure the gameplay is something you'll enjoy, because otherwise the disappointment could be significant.
Read original review
CGMagazine70/100 → 70 · Z -1.113Score 72.9607Score 72.9607Z -1.113Echoes of Aincrad opens with your player being among the lucky (or perhaps unlucky) few who have been given access to the Beta of SAO.
Read original review
Checkpoint Gaming40/100 → 40 · Z -3.0155Score 53.9364Score 53.9364Z -3.0155I feel completely and unequivocally indifferent to Echoes of Aincrad. I feel no hate because that would require the game to connect with me at an emotional level — just indifference. And sometimes, that cold detachment is worse than pure, unbridled rage and hatred. This adolescent mess is one that I wouldn’t recommend even to the biggest fan of Sword Art Online.
Read original review
Chicas Gamers66/100 → 66 · Z -1.6782Score 67.3089Score 67.3089Z -1.6782A somewhat failed attempt to translate the Sword Art Online experience into the video game medium. Kirito and company will have to wait a little longer for the adaptation that finally does them true justice.
Read original review
Cloud Dosage66/100 → 66 · Z -1.6041Score 68.0501Score 68.0501Z -1.6041Boss fights finally made me slow down in Echoes of Aincrad. Instead of cutting through another easy enemy, I had to react to what was happening and create an opening for my partner to counter. The story moved too slowly between those fights, and blocked paths kept exploration tied to the current quest. Repeated enemies made the trip to the next boss drag. This is mainly for dedicated Sword Art Online fans who want another trip through Aincrad and can accept how often repetition gets in the way.
Read original review
COGconnected65/100 → 65 · Z -1.7218Score 66.8727Score 66.8727Z -1.7218Echoes of Aincrad had the makings of being the Sword Art Online game that people have been waiting for. While it made strides in the right direction, the game shed the “anime game” feel but now wears a “generic RPG” badge.
Read original review
Console Creatures60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8491Score 65.6006Score 65.6006Z -1.8491Echoes of Aincrad fails to leave a lasting impression, but for the hours you put into this Sword Art Online adventure, it satisfies the need for more games like this one. However, it’s bogged down by areas that are a chore to explore, and there’s not enough content to justify making the world’s hubs big, since there’s not enough to do in each one. With that in mind, there’s a whole list of things wrong, but also, the bones of this game move the needle forward, even if it isn’t by much.
Read original review
Console-Tribe66/100 → 66 · Z -1.4223Score 69.8686Score 69.8686Z -1.4223Echoes of Aincrad had the potential to be a remarkable title, but after careful evaluation, it ultimately feels as though it reached the market before it was truly ready. While its impressive visuals, powered by modern game engines, make for an eye-catching presentation, the experience ultimately struggles to deliver the substance needed to match its ambitions.
Read original review
CrazyGameCommunity.it75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5321Score 78.7704Score 78.7704Z -0.5321Despite various limitations, Echoes of Aincrad is a visually and technically solid tribute that offers SAO fans a unique way to experience the world of Aincrad from a fresh perspective.
Read original review
CriticLenz50/100 → 50 · Z -2.0798Score 63.293Score 63.293Z -2.0798Echoes of Aincrad is a title that, at first glance, offers a world full of potential for Sword Art Online fans and even newcomers. But the deeper you go, the more you encounter only repetition and weakness.
Read original review
Digital Chumps75/100 → 75 · Z -1.3074Score 71.0173Score 71.0173Z -1.3074Echoes of Aincrad from Game Studio Inc. is a wonderful open-world setup that brings gorgeous graphics, good backend character building, easy-to-get-into controls, and a very solid story. What it lacks is enemy variety and action-adventure elements that keep the gameplay engaging long-term.
Read original review
Digitale Anime85/100 → 85 · Z -0.2337Score 81.7546Score 81.7546Z -0.2337"The long-awaited Sword Art Online adventure"
Echoes of Aincrad delivers the most ambitious take on the Sword Art Online universe yet, giving players the chance to experience Aincrad firsthand rather than just follow its events. With its engaging combat system, expansive exploration, and sophisticated progression system, the game lays a solid foundation that could make it the best game in the series to date. Despite some minor performance issues and the lack of multiplayer, the current experience is very promising for fans of Sword Art Online and action RPGs.
Read original review
Digitally Downloaded50/100 → 50 · Z -2.2435Score 61.6557Score 61.6557Z -2.2435It’s just that we’re in the middle of a flood of high-quality JRPGs, from indie through to the big blockbusters, and Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad does limit itself in a way that doesn’t do it any favours. The creative and narrative vision is bold and respectable, but offering a poor aping of what many would consider to be the finest game ever made in service of that creative vision was an ill-advised move.
Read original review
Digitec Magazine60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7539Score 66.5526Score 66.5526Z -1.7539Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad tells an engaging story that lets you experience the events of Aincrad from your own perspective, with emotional character moments and surprisingly dark themes. While the combat remains enjoyable, repetitive enemies and a highly linear quest structure quickly become monotonous. Its beautiful environments create the illusion of an open world, but exploration is largely superficial, making the adventure feel more like a single-player MMO without the benefits of actual multiplayer.
Read original review
DualShockers65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5105Score 68.9858Score 68.9858Z -1.5105Echoes of Aincrad is easily the most enjoyable Sword Art Online game I've played, largely because it finally understands what fans wanted from this series in the first place: letting you experience Aincrad as a custom avatar rather than someone constantly standing in Kirito's shadow.
Read original review
Echo Boomer75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7733Score 76.3578Score 76.3578Z -0.7733As expansive as its environments may be, as accessible as its narrative is, and as much as it draws on the popularity of genres such as soulslikes, Echoes of Aincrad is a collection of ideas that never rises above familiar territory, with not a hint of imagination. It can be enjoyable at times, but is also extremely limited when it should have been a breath of fresh air for fans of the series.
Read original review
ElderPlayers60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3672Score 60.4192Score 60.4192Z -2.3672Echoes of Aincrad initially seems like an ambitious adventure, especially with its story concept and its beautiful world, in addition, of course, to its relatively entertaining combat. However, the game quickly loses its luster, and a set of design decisions turns it into a mediocre experience.
Read original review
EmuGlx.org60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3595Score 60.4957Score 60.4957Z -2.3595Echoes of Aincrad feels like the long-awaited promise the Sword Art Online franchise has owed its fans for years - and it comes frustratingly close to fulfilling it, which somehow makes it even more disappointing than if it had never tried at all.
Read original review
Eternal Games50/100 → 50 · Z -3.0949Score 53.1426Score 53.1426Z -3.0949Artistic Style and Performance: Regarding the artistic style, it seems that Bandai has allocated a huge budget for this series; as the game features precise and dazzling details for a game that adopts the Japanese animation (Anime) style. Thanks to the beautiful lighting and visual effects, the game maintains a smooth and stable performance at a rate of 60 frames per second, despite the existence of some slight slowdowns or occasional stutters during battles.
Read original review
EvelonGames68/100 → 68 · Z -1.4223Score 69.8682Score 69.8682Z -1.4223Echoes of Aincrad has real heart in its soundtrack and world design, but empty, linear zones and constant enemy recycling drag it down. Combat is genuinely fun, just not enough to save the pace.
Read original review
Everyeye.it60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3298Score 60.7928Score 60.7928Z -2.3298In the 40 hours required to complete the adventure, the gameplay loop feels very redundant and not always adequately refined. As far as we're concerned, Echoes of Aincrad is only suitable for die-hard SAO fans.
Read original review
Everyeye.it60/100 → 60 · Z -2.295Score 61.1412Score 61.1412Z -2.295Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad aimed to present a darker side of the franchise compared to previous titles featuring Kirito and his allies. In a sense, it succeeds in this regard, boasting a grimmer art style, more detailed environments, and character models that are more polished and realistic—avoiding the overly glossy look of earlier games. Moreover, for a die-hard SAO fan, the experience is exhilarating: stepping into the game world, starting the epic journey from scratch, and engaging in combat that is more skill-based—and thus less automated—than in the past. However, this promising concept runs up against glaring technical and conceptual limitations, including level and game design that feel lazier than expected. Consequently, the forty hours required to complete the adventure are marked by a gameplay loop that feels highly repetitive and not always fully polished. Ultimately, we believe Echoes of Aincrad is a title suited only for die-hard SAO fans.
Read original review
Final Weapon40/100 → 40 · Z -2.7016Score 57.0751Score 57.0751Z -2.7016Echoes of Aincrad is a classic case of "sometimes less is more". It's a game that dilutes too much of its content in an attempt to look grander than it is. This can be a fun experience for those who value certain gameplay loops and new takes on established combat formulas, but it's frankly unacceptable for a AAA title. Only major SAO fans will likely get something out of this one.
Read original review
G4F.it | Gamers4FunChannel64/100 → 64 · Z -1.5627Score 68.464Score 68.464Z -1.5627Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad proves to be one of Bandai Namco’s strongest video game adaptations, although it still struggles with some of the common issues found in modern JRPGs.
Read original review
Game Lodge85/100 → 85 · Z -0.042Score 83.6716Score 83.6716Z -0.042Echoes of Aincrad is great because it lets us bring our own character into the Sword Art Online story. With a beautiful, vast map of Aincrad and smooth, well-paced gameplay, the game stands out not only as a great SAO game but also as an excellent action RPG. The problem is that this deep immersion sometimes comes at the cost of a very slow pace, which takes a while to pick up speed; furthermore, while the immense Aincrad is a feast for the eyes, its level design doesn’t always make exploration fun. This slightly dims the luster of the experience, though it doesn’t completely overshadow it.
Read original review
Game862/100 → 62 · Z -1.9812Score 64.2796Score 64.2796Z -1.9812Echoes of Aincrad is an incredibly frustrating game because so much of it works, yet doesn’t. Its core combat mechanics, progression, and story all show flashes of what made the original series so enjoyable, yet they’re all tied together by a genuinely frustrating exploration system that repeatedly and severely undercuts their strengths.
Read original review
GameBlast70/100 → 70 · Z -0.973Score 74.3607Score 74.3607Z -0.973Echoes of Aincrad draws in fans of the source material with an intriguing narrative, epic battles, and a wide variety of builds, though it lacks character development. However, limited exploration, uninteresting activities, and repetitive enemies make the duels tedious, rendering the project unappealing to new players.
Read original review
GameHall80/100 → 80 · Z -0.4171Score 79.9201Score 79.9201Z -0.4171Echoes of Aincrad is the Sword Art Online game I’ve been waiting for ever since I watched the anime's first arc and thought, 'Why has no game actually put me inside this world?' The decision to replace Kirito with a player-created character is the most important move the gaming franchise has made in its history, and it completely transforms the emotional equation of the experience.
Read original review
Gameliner60/100 → 60 · Z -1.2203Score 71.8881Score 71.8881Z -1.2203I had hoped Echoes of Aincrad would be more than just another licensed anime game, but it never really rises above that label despite its fun concept, enjoyable story moments, and solid action gameplay. The repetitive filler content and a few questionable design choices make it hard to keep playing for long stretches, which is a real shame. Beneath those flaws lies an engaging combat system and great visuals, making it a decent game if you're willing to overlook its shortcomings.
Read original review
GameOnly40/100 → 40 · Z -3.1277Score 52.8138Score 52.8138Z -3.1277Echoes of Aincrad is a bland, tedious attempt to cash in on the nostalgia of Sword Art Online fans, offering little more than a dozen hours of boredom.
Read original review
GamePro52/100 → 52 · Z -3.5128Score 48.9629Score 48.9629Z -3.5128"A beautiful but unsubstantial Sword Art Online spin-off that even hardcore fans of the anime should think carefully before buying."
Read original review
GamePro Germany52/100 → 52 · Z -3.4275Score 49.8163Score 49.8163Z -3.4275A beautiful but insubstantial Sword Art Online spin-off that even hardcore fans of the anime should think twice about buying.
Read original review
Gamer Guides82/100 → 82 · Z -0.1241Score 82.8505Score 82.8505Z -0.1241Despite being tied to Sword Art Online, Echoes of Aincrad is worth checking out for its own merits, as there is a polished and pristine sheen here that most anime-based RPG games don’t get. While it won’t surprise you, it will give you several dozen hours of exciting action and exploration.
Read original review
Gamer Point80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3291Score 80.8Score 80.8Z -0.3291Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad represents the franchise's most ambitious chapter. With engaging combat, rewarding exploration, good customization, and a story that works for both veterans and newcomers, the RPG delivers a solid experience.
Read original review
Gamer Social Club50/100 → 50 · Z -2.5858Score 58.2334Score 58.2334Z -2.5858Echoes of Aincrad feels designed to deliberately waste your time. It’s by no means a bad game, there’s a lot of interesting elements to enjoy including the story, the world, and the combat. However, it does itself a disservice by padding the game out excessively with repetitive missions and forced exploration. With strange restrictions on exploration and questionable design choices, it doesn’t respect the player, and suffers for it.
Read original review
Gamer.no60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5732Score 68.3588Score 68.3588Z -1.5732If you're a fan of Sword Art Online and like big games with highly variable challenges, Echoes of Aincrad is made for you. For my part, I feel like I've had enough, and I won't remember this game as anything other than a game that could have been a summer favorite if it had made a few very simple changes. Balance the difficulty, and fix the level design. Half the game could have been shredded, with good reason.
Read original review
Gamereactor UK60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5018Score 69.0728Score 69.0728Z -1.5018It's a shame, because the building blocks are actually there. The combat system isn't fantastic, but it's entertaining enough. The weapon system has some good ideas, the simulated MMO atmosphere is actually quite charming, and the whole "death" premise is still strong, even for a new player like me who doesn't have much prior familiarity with Sword Art Online. But Echoes of Aincrad just drags on for too long. It's not a game where I found myself thinking I couldn't wait to see what happened next, rather it became more of a battle between my patience and my stubbornness, where I eventually finished it simply because I'd already got that far.
Read original review
GamerFocus68/100 → 68 · Z -1.5956Score 68.135Score 68.135Z -1.5956Echoes of Aincrad faithfully recreates the visual universe of Sword Art Online and offers a functional combat system with extensive equipment optimization possibilities. Its smooth performance—using Unreal Engine 5—and the polished aesthetic of its main environments demonstrate a significant improvement in production compared to previous installments in the franchise. However, this new SAO is limited by a monotonous mission design, an exploration system restricted by invisible barriers, and a marked reuse of enemies and bosses. So, unless you're a die-hard fan of Reki Kawahara's work, it's difficult to overlook some of its shortcomings.
Read original review
GamersRD75/100 → 75 · Z -0.9758Score 74.333Score 74.333Z -0.9758Echoes of Aincrad is a much more entertaining and better-executed installment in the SAO franchise thanks to its gameplay improvements and new graphical treatment. Although it still has some aspects to polish, it offers a challenging and highly customizable experience that fans will love. Ultimately, it is a step forward that followers will appreciate.
Read original review
GAMES.CH73/100 → 73 · Z -1.2651Score 71.4401Score 71.4401Z -1.2651Echoes of Aincrad: Sword Art Online isn't a full-fledged open-world game, but some areas are quite expansive.
Read original review
GAMES.CH73/100 → 73 · Z -1.356Score 70.5309Score 70.5309Z -1.356At its core, Echoes of Aincrad: Sword Art Online is definitely a good action RPG. However, due to its repetitive game design and its reluctance to fully capitalize on the opportunities presented by this fresh perspective on the story of the hit anime, it never quite lives up to its full potential.
Read original review
Gamesource Italia79/100 → 79 · Z -0.2289Score 81.8023Score 81.8023Z -0.2289Echoes of Aincrad turned out to be a pleasant surprise. This time, the developers decided to go for a much freer, more 'MMORPG-like' approach, giving players a game that manages to pay tribute to the nature of the work while also being fun and satisfying. This is also thanks to a fast, technical, and entertaining combat system, even if, in the long run, it tends to get a bit repetitive. If I really wanted to nitpick, I’d say I didn’t enjoy the beginning much—it’s just too slow and boring, which could turn more than one player away from a game that actually knows how to entertain and excite.
Read original review
GameSpew70/100 → 70 · Z -0.9794Score 74.2972Score 74.2972Z -0.9794It doesn't excel in any particular area, or offer anything that's genuinely new, but Echoes of Aincrad is an enjoyable single-player action RPG experience once it really gets going.
Read original review
Gamesurf80/100 → 80 · Z -0.0963Score 83.1282Score 83.1282Z -0.0963Echoes of Aincrad is not a perfect game, but it has many strengths that allow Sword Art Online fans to experience Reki Kawahara’s work from a new perspective. The idea of letting us live the adventure of an ordinary SAO player is a winning one and gives us the chance to truly become the protagonists of a saga that many of us have loved and that others may come to discover, perhaps right through this game. The combat system is well designed in how it combines basic attacks, skills, and synergy with our companions, making the many battles we face engaging. Character progression is tied to crafting and, between missions, you find yourself managing weapons and materials to strengthen yourself and handle level growth in the most effective way possible, in a system that may not be innovative but is satisfying. The main flaw of Echoes of Aincrad is its inability to simulate the liveliness of an MMORPG, with too many silent NPCs and too few points of interest, which would have provided some variety to the many battles. Technically well made, Echoes of Aincrad has a story that struggles to truly take off and cannot be considered a masterpiece, but it remains a good title that takes home the crown as the best video game dedicated to Sword Art Online.
Read original review
Gaming Age65/100 → 65 · Z -1.6431Score 67.6603Score 67.6603Z -1.6431Echoes of Aincrad is by no means a bad game, it’s just not enough “game” I think. Combat could’ve used more fleshing out, the environments needed more to actually care about, and the story is just the story of Sword Art Online. If you’re a more casual gamer and want to experience SAO without watching any anime, it’s probably pretty solid for you, but it’s just not enough.
Read original review
Gaming Boulevard70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0491Score 73.6Score 73.6Z -1.0491Echoes of Aincrad is a flawed but fun (re)visit to the flying castle of Aincrad. The choice to make the main character of the game a random player in the world of Sword Art Online might be one of the best decisions in recent anime games. The action RPG combat is standard, with a large focus on the weapon you wield, offering the option to pull off some flashy attacks. However, the world and dungeon design have some odd choices built in, like the inability to venture outside a quest area in the open world or the lack of enemies for large chunks of dungeon and world map. But the moment you let go of the believability of this world, the fun starts to come in the monotony, making the experience oddly relaxing. After all, you’re playing a game within a game.
Read original review
Gaming-Village75/100 → 75 · Z -0.3589Score 80.5024Score 80.5024Z -0.3589I actually enjoyed the basics and found the story and characters entertaining. But the limited exploration, the sometimes chaotic combat and the unsatisfying ending detract from the experience.
Read original review
GamingBolt60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8893Score 65.198Score 65.198Z -1.8893Echoes of Aincrad gives you customisation tools to forge your own Sword Art Online story, but its repetitive design and lingering pace all but remove your sense of agency.
Read original review
Hardcore Gamer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1225Score 72.866Score 72.866Z -1.1225With Echoes of Aincrad, Bandai Namco tries to once again dive into the world of Sword Art Online, now from a perspective of different players.
Read original review
Hobby Consolas65/100 → 65 · Z -2.4291Score 59.7998Score 59.7998Z -2.4291It could have been a top-tier JRPG, but a host of issues leave Echoes of Aincrad: Sword Art Online as nothing more than a game that’s fine for killing time without thinking too much.
Read original review
IGN60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9316Score 64.7753Score 64.7753Z -1.9316Sword Art Online games have mostly been decent, although never truly exceptional. Echoes of Aincrad is a half-step in the right direction with a novel story starring an original cast of characters without heavily relying on Kirito to help it stand out. However, the open zones and world design are big stumbles due to its restricted exploration, along with the lack of variety in both the environments and enemies. The fiery combat and the smithy’s hot iron coals don’t bring enough heat to thaw out the story’s glacial pacing, either. Echoes of Aincrad may seem like a hardcore Sword Art Online fan’s dream game, but divorced from the anime’s branding, it’s just a passable action-RPG.
Read original review
IGN Benelux45/100 → 45 · Z -3.1823Score 52.2682Score 52.2682Z -3.1823The game starts off promising, but the remaining 95 percent of Echoes of Aincrad consists of repetition and waiting for a game that never actually begins. Even my love for Sword Art Online ultimately wasn't enough to push through it. Echoes of Aincrad isn't a game that's a complete failure. It's far more frustrating than that. It keeps showing you how great it could have been, only to disappoint you time and time again.
Read original review
IGN Deutschland60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8418Score 65.6732Score 65.6732Z -1.8418It’s a shame. In my opinion, Echoes of Aincrad provides the best foundation yet for a game set in the Sword Art Online universe. Both in terms of its concept and the fundamental implementation of game mechanics, it lays what appears to be an ideal groundwork—only to do so very little with it. That doesn't mean the title is a total failure; die-hard fans of the source material will likely still find plenty to enjoy. However, the significant gap between the core idea, the presentation, and the game design ultimately relegates Echoes of Aincrad to the ranks of the usual mediocre Sword Art Online titles. And that is a real pity.
Read original review
IGN France70/100 → 70 · Z -1.135Score 72.741Score 72.741Z -1.135Echoes of Aincrad stands out as an interesting yet imperfect reinterpretation of Sword Art Online’s original arc, offering a true story within the story.
Read original review
IGN Italia50/100 → 50 · Z -3.4049Score 50.0424Score 50.0424Z -3.4049Echoes of Aincrad manages the unenviable task of completely squandering the immense potential of its iconic setting. What could have been a thrilling alternate perspective on the classic death game instead devolves into a tedious and frustrating chore. The narrative is poorly paced and abruptly resolved, while exploration is actively discouraged by a disastrous map system and monotonously flat environments. Coupled with a repetitive, unfairly balanced combat system plagued by infinite enemy aggro and poorly designed boss fights, the gameplay loop quickly becomes an exercise in sheer endurance. Despite decent character models, the game is a massive misstep that will make you wish for a forced log-out long before the credits roll.
Read original review
IGN Italy50/100 → 50 · Z -3.1899Score 52.192Score 52.192Z -3.1899An unnecessarily frustrating action RPG with a story that lacks bite, despite the excellent source material.
Read original review
IGN Spain60/100 → 60 · Z -2.2512Score 61.5795Score 61.5795Z -2.2512Echoes of Aincrad isn't a bad game for the franchise; in fact, it has memorable moments that really stand out from the other entries. However, the ambition and fantasy it initially promised are too far removed from the actual gameplay experience, with issues related to pacing, quality of life, and content reuse that overshadow its many strengths.
Read original review
IGN Turkey75/100 → 75 · Z -0.5594Score 78.4968Score 78.4968Z -0.5594While the game starts off well as an original story set in the Sword Art Online universe and boasts a very enjoyable combat system, poor gameplay choices and a tedious "semi-open world" will make it difficult to satisfy players outside of the series' fans.
Read original review
Impulsegamer70/100 → 70 · Z -1.3101Score 70.9898Score 70.9898Z -1.3101Echoes of Aincrad is a solid albeit middling new entry that adds some enjoyable elements to the franchise. However, many of its gameplay mechanics make the game more frustrating and tedious, ultimately hindering the overall experience.
Read original review
Indigo GEEK75/100 → 75 · Z -1.0458Score 73.6334Score 73.6334Z -1.0458Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad introduces a few welcome ideas that help refresh the franchise's video game formula. Its Soulslike-inspired combat and maze-like level design make for an engaging experience at first, but the game quickly falls into repetitive patterns. Both its gameplay loop and narrative struggle to evolve over time, preventing its strongest ideas from reaching their full potential.
Read original review
Invision Community60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7311Score 66.7799Score 66.7799Z -1.7311In Summary, Echoes of Aincrad is what feels like a truly generational fumble by Bandai Namco and Game Studio Inc. They created a game world that simultaneously looks amazing but feels devoid of life. A world that encompasses so many great aspects of Sword Art Online itself but feels as if it’s actively choking you to death because of game mechanics that honestly feel like they belong in the dustbin of history.
Read original review
JsemGamer62/100 → 62 · Z -1.1951Score 72.1403Score 72.1403Z -1.1951Echoes of Aincrad offers an enjoyable action combat system, satisfying cooperation with companions, epic multi-phase boss fights, and a beautiful world. Unfortunately, repetitive enemies and quests, empty locations, uneven responsiveness, and a gradually stagnating story make the roughly fifty-hour adventure feel underdeveloped, especially at its premium price.
Read original review
Just Play it65/100 → 65 · Z -2.0409Score 63.6822Score 63.6822Z -2.0409Echoes of Aincrad delivers a promising story, engaging characters, and a solid combat system that offers a satisfying challenge. However, its empty world, weak level design, and excessive repetition of missions and enemies undermine the sense of exploration, causing the experience to gradually lose its charm over time.
Read original review
Life is Xbox78/100 → 78 · Z -0.436Score 79.7308Score 79.7308Z -0.436Echoes of Aincrad is an odd one for me; I do like it a lot, but I found myself getting just a little annoyed at the lack of variation in enemy types and the battles getting easier because of this. There is a lot to like about Echoes of Aincrad if you are new to the SAO universe, but fans of the anime might find themselves getting a little frustrated at themes they have seen before. I would recommend this to those of you who enjoy a good RPG and who want to invest in the lore of the SAO universe.
Read original review
Manual dos Games80/100 → 80 · Z -0.7053Score 77.0381Score 77.0381Z -0.7053Echoes of Aincrad ushers in a new era for Sword Art Online games, bringing long-requested elements such as a return to the series most famous arc with a brand-new story, while completely overhauling the series combat and exploration mechanics and establishing a solid foundation for the future of Sword Art Online in video games.
Read original review
Meristation70/100 → 70 · Z -1.6055Score 68.0359Score 68.0359Z -1.6055It was shaping up to be the definitive Sword Art Online game and while it marks an interesting step forward for the franchise, it still ultimately falls short.
Read original review
MKAU Gaming70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2885Score 71.2065Score 71.2065Z -1.2885Echoes of Aincrad is a good game with an interesting narrative, a beautiful world, and simple but effective combat. Despite some strange design choices and repetitive elements, there’s a lot to like here for both Sword Art Online fans and newcomers alike. It’s easily the best Sword Art Online game yet.
Read original review
MonsterVine60/100 → 60 · Z -1.5801Score 68.2897Score 68.2897Z -1.5801Echoes of Aincrad has the potential to be a stand-out Sword Art Online game, but it struggles to bear the weight of strangely archaic mechanics and monotonous missions. The story and visuals may be enough to get series fans into the game, but anyone else will likely be hard-pressed to get much out of the game.
Read original review
Multiplayer.it60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0833Score 63.258Score 63.258Z -2.0833Echoes of Aincrad is an action game heavily infused with RPG mechanics, but it fails to match the depth of previous Sword Art Online titles, nor does it fully deliver on the new features promised—and indeed clearly visible—at the core of its design. It’s a game aimed exclusively at longtime fans of the series, who will likely be willing to overlook its many rough edges in exchange for references to elements of the game’s lore that were never truly explored in the first season of SAO, such as the elves, the absence of magic, and certain important characters. Although its mechanics are easy to understand and, all things considered, it’s a game that is fairly enjoyable to play without too many issues, its shortcomings are glaring and, above all, difficult to justify. These include an open-map structure that never really allows you to explore the world in its entirety with complete freedom; an RPG system that fails to reward leveling up and prevents you from assigning skill points during missions; and companion AI that, despite its intended role, is hardly intelligent at all. Not to mention a rather unengaging narrative with outcomes that are easy to predict.
Read original review
Noisy Pixel60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9975Score 64.1166Score 64.1166Z -1.9975Echoes of Aincrad is the most refreshing Sword Art Online game in years, delivering an original story, immersive MMORPG progression, and meaningful character interactions that finally move beyond simply following Kirito. While repetitive dungeons, shallow crafting, and underdeveloped systems hold it back from reaching its full potential, its strong foundation makes it an encouraging first step for the series, but whether players will take those first steps remains to be seen.
Read original review
NoobFeed72/100 → 72 · Z -0.8389Score 75.7021Score 75.7021Z -0.8389Echoes of Aincrad has the bones of the SAO game longtime fans have wanted for years; it just needed more time in the oven to fill out everything surrounding that skeleton.
Read original review
OpenCritic Recommend %26.881720430107524/100 → 26.8817 · Z -1.2807Score 71.2844Score 71.2844Z -1.280726.9% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (93 reviews).
PCMag Middle East70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2425Score 71.666Score 71.666Z -1.2425Echoes of Aincrad is a well-realised RPG about the people behind the avatars. While repetitive exploration and awkward world design hold it back, its excellent characters, satisfying combat, and genuine love for MMORPG culture make it the strongest Sword Art Online game yet,and an enjoyable action RPG even for people who don't care for the anime.
Read original review
Pizza Fria81/100 → 81 · Z -0.2697Score 81.3939Score 81.3939Z -0.2697Echoes of Aincrad delivers one of the most fun experiences in the entire Sword Art Online franchise, featuring extremely responsive real-time combat, a good variety of mechanics, and the freedom to create your own character.
Read original review
PlayStation Universe60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0044Score 64.0469Score 64.0469Z -2.0044I wish Echoes of Aincrad were what it was advertised as. It tries to stand out as what fans expect from a game based on the Sword Art Online franchise, but it fails to capture what makes the franchise special. Instead of focusing on its unique setting and world-building, Bandai Namco instead focused on trends and what they think people want in an Action-RPG.
Read original review
PNN50/100 → 50 · Z -2.6669Score 57.4221Score 57.4221Z -2.6669'Echoes of Aincrad' was a title armed with ideas that fans would welcome. Viewing the original work through the eyes of a unique original protagonist offered a freshness distinct from spin-offs. However, compared to such an interesting story and setting, it was difficult to find any appealing aspects in the gameplay. In fact, setting aside its unique appeal, the level design—which should be considered the fundamentals—was so drawn out that it felt disappointing.
Read original review
PowerUp!65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5991Score 68.1003Score 68.1003Z -1.5991Like being trapped inside a virtual MMO, there’s a great adventure in here somewhere. You just have to grind through a few too many fetch quests before you find it.
Read original review
PPE.pl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3792Score 80.2992Score 80.2992Z -0.3792Fans of Sword Art Online can certainly thank Bandai Namco for rescuing their favourite game series from the dark ages, as for the first time ever we’ve been treated to modern, well-made and beautiful digital adventures featuring Kirito and his friends.
Read original review
Press Attack76/100 → 76 · Z -0.8834Score 75.2576Score 75.2576Z -0.8834Sword Art Online has always had a premise that seemed perfect for video games: living inside an MMORPG where every battle, level gained, and decision becomes part of a fight for survival. Echoes of Aincrad embraces that concept by placing players directly into the world of Aincrad, allowing them to create their own character and experience the early events of the series from a fresh perspective.
Unlike previous adaptations, the adventure is not centered solely on Kirito. Familiar characters such as Asuna, Argo, and Kirito himself remain part of the story, but players take on the role of another survivor trapped inside the game, struggling to grow stronger and find their own path through that world.
The opening hours, however, take a while to reveal the game's full potential. The prologue keeps players confined to enclosed environments for an extended period, functioning almost entirely as a lengthy tutorial while introducing the core mechanics. This approach fits the initial feeling of being trapped inside Aincrad, but it also delays the moment when the game begins to showcase its strongest qualities.
Once that introductory section is finally over and players begin exploring the open areas, towns, and landscapes, it becomes much easier to understand what Echoes of Aincrad is trying to accomplish: transforming one of anime's most iconic settings into a world where players can truly forge their own adventure.
Read original review
ProGamers.life65/100 → 65 · Z -1.6574Score 67.5171Score 67.5171Z -1.6574Echoes of Aincrad captures the thrill of survival within the floating castle through a highly dynamic real-time action combat system with Soulslike nuances, deep avatar customization, and a comprehensive alchemy and blacksmithing system—making it an unmissable RPG adventure for fans of the genre, despite suffering from some repetitiveness in its enemy roster.
Read original review
Push Square50/100 → 50 · Z -2.1701Score 62.3899Score 62.3899Z -2.1701Echoes of Aincrad understands the tone and appeal of Sword Art Online — and that counts for a lot — but it's let down by undercooked gameplay systems and disappointingly dull quest design. Those looking for a grindy action RPG might enjoy how progression is handled, and hardcore fans of the source material will probably push through for the sake of a mostly entertaining story, but you'll still need to stomach so many issues.
Read original review
ReGame It50/100 → 50 · Z -3.1524Score 52.567Score 52.567Z -3.1524Echoes of Aincrad is a disappointing entry from Bandai Namco. Despite its promising premise, the story falls flat, while repetitive content and a $70 price tag make it hard to recommend. Only dedicated Sword Art Online fans may enjoy it, as its biggest flaws are rooted in the game's core design.
Read original review
Region Free70/100 → 70 · Z -0.8792Score 75.2987Score 75.2987Z -0.8792Echoes of Aincrad wouldn't be my first recommendation for RPG or action game fans, but it certainly wouldn't be my last one, either. It's simply solid, and sometimes that's enough.
Read original review
República DG74/100 → 74 · Z -0.8603Score 75.4885Score 75.4885Z -0.8603Echoes of Aincrad delivers fun combat and pleasing visuals, making the journey through Aincrad quite engaging. However, the repetitive open world and some design decisions prevent the game from reaching its full potential. Even so, it is a competent action RPG that will certainly appeal to most players
Read original review
RPG Fan52/100 → 52 · Z -3.0615Score 53.4762Score 53.4762Z -3.0615The best thing I can say about Echoes of Aincrad is I no longer feel nostalgic for the PS3 generation. Whatever goodwill I had going in is completely drained. I came in thinking that era deserved another chance. I left reminded exactly why we moved on.
Read original review
Saudi Gamer60/100 → 60 · Z -1.8824Score 65.2669Score 65.2669Z -1.8824While its ideas and open world don't always come together into a cohesive experience, the enjoyable combat and memorable moments still make it a fun action RPG despite its uneven execution.
Read original review
Side Project56/100 → 56 · Z -2.2681Score 61.4097Score 61.4097Z -2.2681Echoes of Aincrad had a huge opportunity in its hands and squeezes almost every good idea into a shallow, disappointing execution.
Read original review
SpazioGames75/100 → 75 · Z -0.7501Score 76.5902Score 76.5902Z -0.7501Echoes of Aincrad works when it lets the swords do the talking: the combat system is varied, managing your companion adds a tactical layer the franchise has long been missing, and the crafting, derivative as it is, gives a concrete purpose to every run through dungeons and cities. The problem is everything else. A world that should pulse like a real MMORPG is instead full of mute background characters, a story that takes its time without ever really earning it, and a design choice, locking the Death Game Mode behind a premium purchase.
Read original review
STWGames Italia55/100 → 55 · Z -2.1991Score 62.1001Score 62.1001Z -2.1991Echoes of Aincrad is a prime example of an excellent conceptual vision ruined by a gameplay experience that is unnecessarily drawn out and lacks any real boldness in its design. Although the melee combat system offers genuine moments of fun and the smithy ensures considerable depth in weapon customization, the game collapses under the weight of outdated game design, recycled content, and a narrative progression that drowns its more mature themes in a slow pace. This is a game that may perhaps entertain the most die-hard fans of the universe created by Reki Kawahara for a few hours—those drawn in by the visual fidelity and the charm of an adventure experienced from the perspective of a beta tester—but for any other fan of action RPGs, it will prove to be a repetitive experience that hit the market before it was fully mature.
Read original review
TechStomper70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1416Score 72.675Score 72.675Z -1.1416Echoes of Aincrad delivers an enjoyable action RPG packed with meaningful progression, satisfying combat, and enough original storytelling to keep even the most die-hard Sword Art Online fans invested.
Read original review
TestingBuddies65/100 → 65 · Z -1.6806Score 67.2856Score 67.2856Z -1.6806Echoes of Aincrad is the best SAO game so far thanks to genuinely demanding combat, but its okay story and empty world leave it far from a masterpiece.
Read original review
The AU Review60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0212Score 63.879Score 63.879Z -2.0212Echoes of Aincrad is a serviceable entry point for most casual fans, complementing the main narrative without ever detracting from it.
Read original review
The Games Machine70/100 → 70 · Z -1.5537Score 68.554Score 68.554Z -1.5537Echoes of Aincrad offers a visually spectacular tribute that stays true to the original storyline, sure to thrill Sword Art Online fans. Unfortunately, its breathtaking world design is hampered by rigid invisible walls, repetitive quests, and clunky combat mechanics. It is a solid, high-quality action RPG, yet it ultimately lacks the polish needed to transcend the limitations of the license.
Read original review
The Outerhaven Productions80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3994Score 80.097Score 80.097Z -0.3994If you’re new to Sword Art Online, this may be a tougher sell. But if you’re already a fan of the series, Echoes of Aincrad is still worth playing, even with its shortcomings.
Read original review
TheSixthAxis40/100 → 40 · Z -2.9853Score 54.2384Score 54.2384Z -2.9853Echoes of Aincrad sadly fails as both a standalone RPG adventure or as a fan-pleasing experience for the Sword Art Online community. Its flaws hold it back a lot, and newcomers or seasoned fans alike would be better served playing any of the other games in the franchise instead of this one.
Read original review
TodoJuegos75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6164Score 77.9275Score 77.9275Z -0.6164Echoes of Aincrad offers a fresh look at Sword Art Online, moving away from Kirito to tell our own story inside Aincrad. Its direct combat, companions and setting work well, although the story feels a little short and the maps can become confusing.
Read original review
TrueGaming75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8515Score 75.5759Score 75.5759Z -0.8515Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad is ideal for those who are looking for a Dungeon Crawler Experience regardless of its shortcomings. However if you’re one looking for a more traditional Open World RPG with various exploration elements, this entry in the series won't be a suitable choice.
Read original review
Twisted Voxel60/100 → 60 · Z -2.6245Score 57.8461Score 57.8461Z -2.6245Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad successfully shakes up the formula with an engaging, flexible action-RPG combat system and rewarding partner mechanics. Unfortunately, severe pacing issues, a lifeless custom protagonist completely overshadowed by Kirito, restrictive invisible walls, and heavily recycled enemy designs relegate this barebones spin-off to a tedious, budget-strained slog.
Read original review
TwoHitGames75/100 → 75 · Z -0.4107Score 79.9839Score 79.9839Z -0.4107Echoes of Aincrad delivers one of the most immersive Sword Art Online experiences yet, thanks to its satisfying combat, meaningful progression, and fully customizable protagonist.
Read original review
Uagna68/100 → 68 · Z -1.4267Score 69.824Score 69.824Z -1.4267Echoes of Aincrad is a game with a noble concept, but its execution is too repetitive. While the game boasts a solid and engaging RPG system that highlights character stats and equipment customization, its lackluster gameplay ultimately dampens any enthusiasm. The bold decision to rewrite the narrative by sidelining Kirito stumbles due to a slow, poorly told story; a combat system that fails to impress because of the total lack of impact from attacks; exploration that offers no incentives whatsoever; and an overall repetitiveness that borders on the exhausting.
Read original review
Uagna.it68/100 → 68 · Z -1.5305Score 68.7863Score 68.7863Z -1.5305Echoes of Aincrad is noble in its concept, but far too repetitive in its execution. While the title boasts a solid and compelling RPG system capable of elevating stat management and equipment customization, a flat gameplay execution ultimately extinguishes any enthusiasm. The bold choice to rewrite the narrative by sidelining Kirito stumbles over a slow and poorly delivered pace, an unconvincing combat system hampered by a total lack of hit impact, completely unrewarding exploration, and an overall repetitiveness that borders on exhausting.
Read original review
Video Chums77/100 → 77 · Z -0.4639Score 79.4521Score 79.4521Z -0.4639Echoes of Aincrad is a charming game that has intuitive combat and rewarding character growth. Although its repetitiveness brings down the experience from time to time, I still couldn't help but want to keep playing so I could see where my chums would end up next.
Read original review
Virtualni Kutak75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8987Score 75.1044Score 75.1044Z -0.8987Despite its flaws, I enjoyed my over 50 hours with Echoes of Aincrad. It is an easy recommendation for fans of the franchise and a cautious recommendation for people who enjoy action JRPGs and are looking for an MMO feeling. Developer Game Studio Inc. created a solid foundation that they can hopefully build upon in the DLC or a sequel covering the higher floors of Aincrad.
Read original review
Voxel75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8054Score 76.0368Score 76.0368Z -0.8054I must confess I was somewhat surprised by the quality of Echoes of Aincrad. Although it still lacks the production value and scope the franchise deserves, it is the title that best recreates the atmosphere of the anime's first season—even without Kirito in the lead role. The chance to experience Sword Art Online from the perspective of an “ordinary” player is precisely what makes it so special, even if that choice comes at a cost.
Read original review
Xbox Achievements50/100 → 50 · Z -2.8184Score 55.9074Score 55.9074Z -2.8184Echoes of Aincrad's premise is a vaguely interesting one. You're a player in a Sword Art Online VRMMORPG experience, which requires the wearing of...
Read original review
Zoomg65/100 → 65 · Z -2.2149Score 61.9422Score 61.9422Z -2.2149Sometimes, the most disappointing thing about a game is realizing that its best moments prove the developers genuinely know what they're doing—only for its most repetitive and tedious stretches to reveal that they never figured out how to tie those great ideas together into a satisfying whole.
Sword Art Online: Echoes of Aincrad is exactly that kind of game. At its best, it has enough strengths to make it worth revisiting in the future, especially once its price comes down, and it could even introduce more players to the world of SAO. Until then, however, it remains little more than another decent release aimed primarily at those who are already dedicated fans of the franchise.
Read original review
ZTGD55/100 → 55 · Z -2.2879Score 61.212Score 61.212Z -2.2879In the end I was disappointed by Echoes of Aincrad, the pacing of the story combined with what felt to me like a dull world were the major reasons as to why.
Read original review