SourceCritic

Disgaea Mayhem

66.6493SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 59.0513 · 39 reviews

The princess needs her pudding in this brand new take on the venerated Disgaea franchise. Take direct control of the action as N.A., a mercenary with a discerning sweet tooth, as you mow down monsters in the name of money. Equip weapons from seven different classes to play in seven different ways! Whether you want to use the tried-and-true sword or the ranged bow, you can always switch your weapon to switch up the way you play! The more things Magichange, the more they stay the same! Grind levels, improve your equipment, and pass new bills at the Dark Chocolate Assembly to make the numbers go up until you're dealing a million damage with every hit! You can even recruit classic demons like the Prinny to bring along with you! It's time to experience Disgaea in a whole new way!

2026 · Nintendo Switch 2, Nintendo Switch, PC

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

Capsule Computers65/100 → 65 · Z -1.7986Score 66.1049

Disgaea Mayhem’s humor lands but its shallow challenge, limited enemies, and easily breakable balance make the flan‑driven tale feel undercooked despite some solid combat mechanics.

Read original review

Cat with Monocle70/100 → 70 · Z -1.5577Score 68.5143

Disgaea Mayhem is an action RPG that introduces some new fun ideas and manages to include a few of the series’ signature mechanics, giving it that Disgaea charm for a goofy adventure. However, it feels like the game could use more time in the oven due to its short story campaign and repetitive, patchy presentation.

Read original review

CGMagazine65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5206Score 68.8849

Disgaea Mayhem is a spinoff title within the Disgaea series, while in Japan and some other regions, the game is called Makaism: Frenzy, referencing the Netherworld Battle Chronicle or Makai Senki subtitle of Disgaea.

Read original review

COGconnected65/100 → 65 · Z -1.7218Score 66.8727

Disgaea Mayhem is an excellent Musou game, no question. But as a Disgaea title, this game falls pretty flat.

Read original review

CrazyGameCommunity.it65/100 → 65 · Z -1.4538Score 69.5535

Disgaea Mayhem stands as an interesting experiment—albeit one with flaws—that nonetheless manages to capture the soul of the franchise while drastically changing the way it is experienced on the battlefield.

Read original review

Cubed350/100 → 50 · Z -1.7414Score 66.6775

Disgaea Mayhem is so close to being a decent game. It's held back by the most mindless and unimaginative battles ever conceived in a Dynasty Warriors clone. There are no generals to protect or outposts. No compelling winning or losing conditions. There aren't even that many foes to beat. The only thing N.A. has to do is slap around 100 cartoon monsters, and he's won. The core Disgaea elements work perfectly for character progression, and even the staple democratic features remain fun and make sense in Mayhem. However, the lacklustre presentation, barren gameplay, and lifeless combat keep it from meeting the standard of quality. At least it was over quickly.

Read original review

DualShockers65/100 → 65 · Z -1.5105Score 68.9858

Disgaea Mayhem is a solid entry into the action RPG genre for the franchise, successfully carrying over the nonsensical plot, core mechanics, and boundless progression that the series is celebrated for.

Read original review

Final Weapon70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7127Score 76.9643

Disgaea Mayhem is a fun new Disgaea action RPG spin-off with Musou-like gameplay qualities. Despite the change in genre from Disgaea's strategy RPG roots, Disgaea Mayhem retains many of the core features that Disgaea fans know and love, including the grindy Item World and leveling and gear systems. However, the short story runtime may leave gamers wanting more here.

Read original review

Game Lodge60/100 → 60 · Z -2.349Score 60.601

Disgaea Mayhem is ultimately just a mediocre game that gets elevated somewhat by being part of a series with enough charm to carry it. With its $60 launch price and disappointing performance, it's hard to imagine an optimistic future for a game that undermines itself just as much as it shows potential.

Read original review

Game862/100 → 62 · Z -1.9812Score 64.2796

Disgaea Mayhem is the kind of spin-off that has a lot of potential as a concept. The series, by its nature, routinely produces characters that lend themselves well to the action genre. Unfortunately, limiting the entire experience to a single playable character while carrying over progression systems designed for a full roster strips away much of what makes Disgaea satisfying in the first place. The result is a game that understands the appeal of the grind, but rarely gives you a reason to enjoy it.

Read original review

GameBlast45/100 → 45 · Z -3.0573Score 53.5178

Disgaea Mayhem delivers a merely mediocre result in what it proposes: it fails as a clone of Musou in terms of gameplay and fails to exude all the charisma of the brand it supposedly represents.

Read original review

Gamesource Italia65/100 → 65 · Z -1.3467Score 70.6244

Disgaea Mayhem is certainly an interesting experiment, which in itself is not something rare for the series; what is definitely more unusual though is it bearing the Disgaea name, usually reserved for mainline titles, a telltale sign of the importance Nippon Ichi Software places on what is essentially a pivot into a different genre. The experiment can't certainly be defined as a smashing success; Disgaea Mayhem is too much of an action-rpg to call itself a musou and too much of a musou to call itself an action-rpg. Its saving grace, ironically, is the elements more closely resembling its Disgaea roots, such as its exponential character progression and challenging post-game, despite both being severely watered down by having a single playable character.

Read original review

Gaming Boulevard50/100 → 50 · Z -2.5387Score 58.7046

Disgaea Mayhem is an attempt to create a Musou-style fighting game in the Disgaea universe. The story captures the whimsical DNA of the main series to the fullest, but the gameplay feels lackluster. Battles feel repetitive and button-mashy, especially because you have to play every map four times without any change to the gameplay. Since you can get strong quickly, you don’t really need to engage with the side modes. Truly a shame, because waging large-scale war as an Overlord with demon armies could be so awesome, dude!

Read original review

Gaming-Village75/100 → 75 · Z -0.3589Score 80.5024

Disgaea Mayhem is a brief action title that doesn't take itself too seriously. Its combat system is simple and accessible, with mission durations and story length just right to avoid exhaustion. Those who crave more beyond the story missions can endlessly grow stronger through the Item World, as long as motivation holds.

Read original review

GamingBolt70/100 → 70 · Z -1.0206Score 73.8856

Disgaea Mayhem is light, breezy, and charming, but that isn't enough to overcome the nagging feeling that it could have been a lot more than it currently is.

Read original review

Hardcore Gamer60/100 → 60 · Z -2.0228Score 63.8633

Disgaea Mayhem is an action-RPG that adapts the power grind of the strategy series into something more similar to the Dynasty Warriors games.

Read original review

MonsterVine70/100 → 70 · Z -0.883Score 75.2608

Disgaea Mayhem has its stumbles as it fuses Disgaea’s iconic systems with frantic hack-and-slash gameplay, but it’s a largely worthwhile venture for series fans. Jumping between the different weapon types and leveling yourself and your items to crazy heights make for a solid base, and the charm the series is known for is certainly intact, even with its short playtime. Essentially, if you like the Disgaea series and action RPGs, you’ll likely have a good time with Disgaea Mayhem – so long as you know it won’t be too long a time.

Read original review

Netto’s Game Room60/100 → 60 · Z -1.479Score 69.301

Disgaea Mayhem is a flawed and generic hack-and-slash that will not be for everyone. Those who enjoy grinding and watching their stats go up to insane heights might find themselves sucked into an extremely addictive gameplay loop, but for others, it will simply not be worth the time. The Carnage Dimension is where the game truly shines, but reaching it is a high bar to clear.

Read original review

Niche Gamer50/100 → 50 · Z -2.0334Score 63.7576

Disgaea Mayhem isn’t broken, and it’s fine for short play sessions. But it plays it incredibly safe, borrowing the series’ style and humor while stripping away most of what made the main games unique.

Read original review

Nintendo Life50/100 → 50 · Z -2.2602Score 61.4894

Playing Disgaea Mayhem almost feels like peeking into an alternate universe where NIS’ flagship series began life as an action RPG, rather than a tactical one. Plenty of the franchise’s iconic, over-the-top RPG systems are present and accounted for, and they graft surprisingly well onto Mayhem’s core hack-and-slash loop. The problem is that said loop isn’t fleshed out nearly enough, with shallow and repetitive combat that loses its lustre quickly. Couple that with a forgettable story and a bizarrely short runtime, and Disgaea Mayhem barely ends up making much of an impression at all. It’s an interesting novelty, but I’m fine staying in the timeline where Disgaea keeps tactical battles as its bread and butter.

Read original review

Nintendo News PL35/100 → 35 · Z -3.0373Score 53.7177

"There's an old joke. Two elderly women are at a Catskills mountain resort, and one of 'em says: "Boy, the food at this place is really terrible." The other one says, "Yeah, I know, and such ... small portions." Well, that's essentially how I feel about..." Disgaea Mayhem. A game lacking a clear identity. It features tedious combat and repetitive missions - plus, it ends too quickly.

Read original review

NintendoBoy60/100 → 60 · Z -1.9152Score 64.9393

At the end of the day, Tichelle and N.A.’s story ended up entertaining me in many ways, and the silly, somewhat "Zoomer" humor the series embraces really engaged me—I certainly didn't expect a Cory in the House reference, of all things. Unfortunately, a game can't survive on humor alone, and this one has aspects that make it hard to recommend—not just in a vacuum, but even to longtime Disgaea fans.

Read original review

NoobFeed67/100 → 67 · Z -1.2456Score 71.6356

Disgaea Mayhem is a good diversion into action for Disgaea fans. Charming characters, swift missions, and addictive number crunching make up for shallow fighting and lack of post-game material.

Read original review

OpenCritic Recommend %20/100 → 20 · Z -1.5055Score 69.036

20.0% of OpenCritic critics recommend this game (36 reviews).

Pixel Byte60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7713Score 66.3786

I was excited to see what Disgaea Mayhem would feel like. I understand NIS isn’t exactly the biggest or boldest studio out there, but they’ve rarely left me unimpressed. This was sadly one of the times I was. The concept on paper works well, but the story mode rarely gives the company a chance to shine. This is on top of having a lackluster, completely uninspired structure.

Read original review

PS4Blog.net75/100 → 75 · Z -0.8607Score 75.4838

You got your action RPG in my Disgaea!

Read original review

Pure Nintendo50/100 → 50 · Z -2.0539Score 63.5518

Disgaea Mayhem does a great job of presenting the loveable Disgaea vibe in an action RPG setting. But that setting is pretty thin and unrewarding, especially considering the limited content provided for the asking price.

Read original review

Raider King62/100 → 62 · Z -1.2444Score 71.6475

Disgaea Mayhem is a game which is next to impossible to recommend. While the game's combat fundamentals could have served as the foundation for a fun game, the complete lack of any stage design and incredibly short length make this experience feel very shallow and disappointing. Fans of both the Disgaea franchise and action games in general will find very little to enjoy in this title.

Read original review

Rectify Gaming50/100 → 50 · Z -3.0178Score 53.9135

Mayhem is a bold new step for the Disgaea series, and even though someone like me greatly enjoys the occasional different genre spin-off, there simply isn't much to be seen here. The game places a lot of emphasis on the Magichange mechanic, but the reality is that it rarely comes up during actual gameplay, as most enemies are pushovers and don't really require you to put in any effort. There's a lot of grinding to be done, something that fans of the series will probably enjoy, but while the stick is present, the carrot is unfortunately nowhere to be found.

Read original review

RPG Fan60/100 → 60 · Z -2.3151Score 60.94

Disgaea Mayhem feels more like a spin-off proof of concept than an evolution or new direction for the series, and a proverbial monkey’s paw that will make me careful what I wish for in the future.

Read original review

RPGamer70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7102Score 76.9894

Disgaea Mayhem, even with the large variety of side experiences, is a pretty short game, with a campaign that can easily be completed in under ten hours. There are certainly lots of systems that players can dive into to extend, especially for those to wish to reach the maximum possible level. There is no real post-game content, however, though there will be some downloadable content available after launch. That said, the game is still a pleasant experience. Battles are fun to blast through, and power-leveling a character before cranking up the difficulty can be a blast. Like the main series, it’s not something that everyone will enjoy, but fans of Disgaea will find it an enjoyable spin-off that stays true to the series’ fundamentals. It may not ultimately be as delicious as the dessert it revolves around, but it is a tasty experience while it lasts.

Read original review

Side Project50/100 → 50 · Z -2.7587Score 56.5038

Disgaea Mayhem is an insufficient game, even considering it's a Nippon Ichi Software title belonging to a glorious series like Disgaea. The gameplay is bland, the settings are repetitive, and the story, despite having all the series' classic elements, is so short it doesn't allow you to fully appreciate it

Read original review

Siliconera40/100 → 40 · Z -3.2368Score 51.7232

Everything about Disgaea Mayhem is disappointing, especially if you love Musou style beat’em ups. It is short. There’s no main character variety. There’s little enemy variety, and only small groups to cut through instead of hordes. The combat system feels clunky and doesn’t encourage smooth, satisfying combos. The story is bland. It’s all short. Fortunately, there’s a demo so you can at least test and see for yourself how far this spin-off has fallen.

Read original review

SmashPad50/100 → 50 · Z -2.0573Score 63.5182

I’m very disappointed in Disgaea Mayhem. I do very much enjoy the combat and the item worlds can be fun since they’re one of the only ways to fight actual hordes, but the game is far too short, the levels are far too simple, and the devs have simply added in a bunch of dull grinding in lieu of anything substantial.

Read original review

Starbit40/100 → 40 · Z -3.09Score 53.191

Disgaea Mayhem had a chance to bring the irreverence and originality of the Disgaea series to the Nintendo Switch 2. Unfortunately the result is a game that falls very short of expectations. While Disgaea Mayhem keeps loyal to the spirit of the series, its execution and performance are very disappointing, the new action RPG gameplay mechanics are excessively repetitive and uncreative, and the visual presentation is very outdated. It's a shame that such a quirky and fun series has been treated to such a subpar effort, more so when it's sold for a high retail price.

Read original review

The Outerhaven Productions80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3994Score 80.097

Disgaea Mayhem is a fun time and adds a new gameplay style to the mix of Disgaea. You still work on pumping up your numbers, but in a Musou-style engine. It is a load of fun, but it is not the Disgaea Warriors many Musou lovers might be wanting.

Read original review

TwoHitGames69/100 → 69 · Z -0.8745Score 75.3463

Disgaea Mayhem trades the series' signature turn-based strategy for direct action combat, delivering an entertaining if uneven first attempt at the genre. Its varied weapon classes, likable characters, and vibrant anime-inspired presentation make for a fun ride, though a lack of real challenge and repetitive post-game structure keep it from reaching its full potential.

Read original review

Video Chums63/100 → 63 · Z -1.823Score 65.8609

Disgaea Mayhem has plenty of nifty aspects going for it such as its cute and colourful visuals and familiar systems that are well incorporated in the new action formula. At the same time, the combat is just so simple and repetitive and I wish there was much more to it. 🐧

Read original review

WayTooManyGames70/100 → 70 · Z -0.7588Score 76.5031

Disgaea Mayhem ended up being far more entertaining than I expected, especially considering the initial wave of negative reviews it received. I even found myself enjoying its utterly idiotic premise and overlooking some of its gameplay shortcomings. It was quickly becoming one of those perfect “switch your brain off and have fun” kinds of games. Unfortunately, it just doesn’t have enough to offer in the long run.

Read original review