SourceCritic

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

86.2649SourceCritic scoreSimple mean 86.1094 · 64 reviews

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin includes the 3 previously released DLC packs - Crown of the Sunken King, Crown of the Old Iron King, and Crown of the ivory King - along with additional features. All versions of the game include the following features (Existing Dark Souls II owners will receive a patch to implement these elements): Additional NPCs added for an enhanced story experience. Parameter adjustments for improved game balance. Augmented item descriptions. Improved online matchmaking functionality.

2015 · PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PC, Playstation 3, Xbox 360

The published score is adjusted by each outlet's history. See how the score works.

Outlet reviews

4P.de88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5472Score 89.5636

It was and still is a grand, cruel and tormenting adventure that finally runs in a smooth framerate without tearing. But nonetheless technically you can see the age of the source material if you compare it to Bloodborne.

Read original review

Atomix95/100 → 95 · Z 0.8798Score 92.8892

Players with experience have a reason to visit Drangleic again, given that this adventure has design changes that truly refresh the journey. A definitive edition that without saying it, condenses and improves a trip of pain, huge challenges and even bigger rewards.

Read original review

Attack of the Fanboy90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5078Score 89.1687

Not quite content with improving the graphics and lumping in the downloadable content and calling it a day, Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin feels like From Software's definitive vision for the game.

Read original review

CGMagazine80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2979Score 81.1123

The game is a brilliant and complete version of Dark Souls 2, with enough fresh content and tweaks to encourage veterans.

Read original review

COGconnected90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7269Score 91.3606

Scholar of the First Sin is a fantastic upgrade and worth the purchase if you never had the chance to play Dark Souls 2 on PC or current gen consoles. Even if you did play through it before, the DLC alone is worth checking out.

Read original review

Critical Hit70/100 → 70 · Z -1.2657Score 71.4339

While it’s a hard sale for those that have already played the game to death, even with all the changes, but if you’ve never played it before, it’s an easy recommendation. Pick this game up as it’s chocked full of content that is still well worth your money. It’s no Bloodborne though.

Read original review

Cubed390/100 → 90 · Z 0.8259Score 92.3499

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is a phenomenal game, taking the spectacular original and giving it fresh lease of life. Creator Hidetaka Miyazaki's grim and beautiful world is truly a wonder to behold, and this new journey into that world is filled with fresh challenges that will test even the most experienced Souls players. You will die over and over and over again, but the key thing is that you will love every minute of it.

Read original review

Daily Mirror100/100 → 100 · Z 1.2607Score 96.6982

But if for some reason you missed Dark Souls 2 first time around, or need a great reason to go back, this superlative edition is a nightmare worth having.

Read original review

Dealspwn90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6813Score 90.9043

Dark Souls II: Scholar Of The First Sin is the definitive version of a masterpiece. Surprising for veterans yet deceptively welcoming to newcomers, this rebalanced remaster proves as deeply impressive as it is brutally compelling.

Read original review

Digital Chumps84/100 → 84 · Z -0.3529Score 80.5618

The best, most complete version of a great game that offers compelling reasons for current owners and newcomers to invest in. It's not for everyone, but if you can "get into it," you're likely going to be hooked on not only the game, but the franchise.

Read original review

Digital Spy100/100 → 100 · Z 1.029Score 94.3807

Between the new enemy placements, greater challenge, the improved visuals and all the additional bonus content, Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin is absolutely worth a first look if you're a newcomer to the series - and in the case of returning players, almost certainly worth a second.

Read original review

Digitally Downloaded90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4778Score 88.8688

Thematically, I find a lot more to appreciate about Dark Souls 2 than Bloodborne, it must be said.

Read original review

Edge Magazine90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8085Score 92.1758

Essential. [June 2015, p.114]

Eurogamer Italy80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3614Score 80.4768

With Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin, From Software and Bandai Namco have done a good job crafting an interesting remastered for both the veteran Souls fans and the newcomers. The different locations of the most of the enemies, the new content linked with the original lore, the new final boss and a bunch of extra challenges make Scholar of the First Sin the true incarnation of Dark Souls II.

Read original review

Examiner80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3822Score 80.2688

Is Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin worthy of a second purchase? If you loved the original release and want to experience the game with no major technical issues, a smooth frame-rate, enhanced graphics, and repositioned enemies, then it is well worth the price of admission. Those new to Dark Souls II will want Scholar of the First Sin to be their welcoming as it is the best way to play this glorious game.

Read original review

Game Informer90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3039Score 87.1297

Scholar of the First Sin is best suited for two types of player: Complete Souls newcomers that insist on playing with the latest hardware, and returning warriors who soaked up every bit of new game-plus content loaded into the original. While I don't think the encounters are quite up to the level of the original, it's hard to argue with more of one of 2014's best games.

Read original review

Game Revolution80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3974Score 80.1176

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin targets two audiences: newcomers and veterans. In both cases it succeeds.

Read original review

GameCritics90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7758Score 91.8494

While a large number of areas remain untouched and the remixed enemy placement isn't exactly an all-new quest, Scholar of the First Sin is the best version of this game, and it remains an exceptional experience. For those who have not yet played Dark Souls II, or for those who skipped the DLC chapters, I whole-heartedly recommend this edition.

Read original review

Gamefa95/100 → 95 · Z 0.9953Score 94.0441

The Scholar of the First Sin released as the final version for Dark Souls II and it is both an opportunity to play 3 amazing DLC's for people who haven't experienced them, as well as an opportunity for new players to dive in the depth of Dark Souls series.

Read original review

GameOver.gr100/100 → 100 · Z 1.297Score 97.0607

The changes have made this edition slightly more difficult, but the core of the game remains true to the superb game design of the original.

Read original review

Gamer.nl80/100 → 80 · Z -0.3134Score 80.9575

Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin is way more than just a re-release. The content is surprising and it has changed a lot, may be a bit too much. But this release offers a great opportunity to experience Dark Souls 2 once more on current-gen consoles.

Read original review

Games Master UK91/100 → 91 · Z 0.525Score 89.3414

It's the best version of one of last year's best games and runs beautifully on new-gen. Worth buying, especially if you've never played DS2 before.

Read original review

GameSpot90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5533Score 89.6242

The exultation of hard-earned victory here, of saying “What's next” with all the fear, fascination, and excitement of any good, bloody fight, has more joys than most, and even though the game is won, I find myself itching to go back...Dark Souls II, in its final form, is just my tempo.

Read original review

GamesVillage.it92/100 → 92 · Z 0.6578Score 90.6694

There's never been a better time to be a "Souls" fan. First Bloodborne, and now this new edition of Dark Souls 2, that benefits from a remarkable visual upgrade and from some new content.

Read original review

GameZone85/100 → 85 · Z -0.249Score 81.6014

Paradoxically, it's a version seemingly made for people that have already played through the original Dark Souls 2, rather than new players, who might actually have a harder time with the new, tougher enemy placements.

Read original review

Gaming Age91/100 → 91 · Z 0.2048Score 86.1389

If you’re coming from the PC version of the game, Scholar of the First Sin is a bit less enticing. But if you’ve only experienced the Xbox 360 or PS3 version, Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin certainly comes off as a definitive version worth checking out.

Read original review

Gaming Nexus90/100 → 90 · Z 0.3085Score 87.1761

Whether you're new to Dark Souls II or played it on older consoles, Scholar of the First Sin is worth revisiting. This PlayStation 4 collection features the original game, along with the three expansion packs.

Read original review

GamingBolt90/100 → 90 · Z 0.717Score 91.2607

Dark Souls 2on the PS4 is as close to perfect as any game I've played this year. The game is beautiful and the mechanics are easy. The only thing that ever got to me was when I'd end up wandering around, trying to find the way to move forward. But I'm pretty sure that was intentional on From Software's part.

Read original review

GamingTrend90/100 → 90 · Z 0.2904Score 86.9947

Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin improves upon Dark Souls 2 in nearly every category, and is the Souls game that current-gen console owners deserve.

Read original review

GearNuke88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4907Score 88.9981

It's hard not to recommend Scholar of the First Sin to newcomers and veterans alike. For newcomers, this latest version provides hours and hours of fantastic content for a great price. Meanwhile, the remixed encounters and items, the ramped up challenge, and the much-needed improvements to the multiplayer ensure that veterans also have plenty of reasons to pick this up.

Read original review

Hobby Consolas88/100 → 88 · Z 0.2837Score 86.9284

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is the perfect option for someone who's never played Dark Souls 2, or at least the 3 DLC's, but if you have already played it, the graphic improvements are not enough to make you play it again on the new consoles.

Read original review

IGN Italia88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5516Score 89.6071

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is a very good remaster for a great game. Visuals are a bit too old, today, especially if you come from Bloodborne, but gameplay is still unmissable.

Read original review

IGN Italy88/100 → 88 · Z 0.5806Score 89.8974

A great soulslike in a very valid edition, able to remix content in an interesting way even for those who know the original game very well.

Read original review

IGN Spain88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4909Score 89.0003

‎The best version of the ultra difficult game par excellence. It may not be as cutting edge as it was, or it may not contribute as much if you already crushed it, but if it is not your case and you have patience ...‎

Read original review

InsideGamer.nl85/100 → 85 · Z -0.037Score 83.7216

Scholar of the First Sin is a good re-release of Dark Souls 2. The higher frame rate works miracles and the even higher difficulty level together with the mixed content will surprise even Dark Souls 2-veterans.

Read original review

JeuxActu75/100 → 75 · Z -0.6909Score 77.182

Dark Souls 2's regular players will enjoy Scholar of the First Sin for having better graphics, better reactivity with the 60fps and a renewed challenge. For the others, it will be harsher than ever and maybe far too expensive.

Read original review

LaPS490/100 → 90 · Z 0.4589Score 88.6802

This is the ultimate edition of Dark Souls II, which is superb. It is not only the more than necessary visual enhancements, but the included downloadable contents and many fixes which make an even greater game. Even longer and challenging, and of course as deep as ever.

Read original review

LEVEL (Czech Republic)60/100 → 60 · Z -1.6263Score 67.8281

The “ultimate edition” adjustments could be a part of a larger patch. Dark Souls II changes dynamics and sweeps out some frustrating issues but still remains the weakest part of the series. [Issue#252]

Level7.nu90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4813Score 88.9039

Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the first sin is a package that includes far more than expected. Not only do we get one of the best game from last gen, it’s in all ways an improvement over the original version. A must-play for those who never have played Dark Souls 2 before.

Read original review

LevelUp85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0892Score 83.1996

‎Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin‎‎ is a recommended edition for those who do not know the title or for those veterans who want a little more‎.

Read original review

Meristation90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4624Score 88.7156

Dark Souls II is an ideal game for veteran players, but it's also a good opportunity for newcomers. From Software added some positive concessions while keeping the essence of the franchise. Action, exploration, replay value and great online experiences in another sweet nightmare. Prepare to die once again.

Read original review

Metro GameCentral80/100 → 80 · Z 0.1944Score 86.0349

Even if it’s only been a year, time has not been kind to Dark Souls’ sequel and this remaster does little to help the situation – even if it ‘s a hugely engrossing game in its own right.

Read original review

Multiplayer.it90/100 → 90 · Z 0.7455Score 91.5465

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is an enhanced edition of From Software's critically acclaimed title Dark Souls II. The overall experience is tense, seamless, engrossing, challenging, frustrating, but overwhelmingly rewarding and unique.

Read original review

Niche Gamer60/100 → 60 · Z -1.3629Score 70.4618

Dark Souls 2 has beautiful environments and interesting philosophical questions, followed by really mediocre gameplay and an ever-present feeling of being left unfinished.

Read original review

NZGamer85/100 → 85 · Z -0.0971Score 83.1206

If you’re returning to Dark Souls II, you’ll either come away pleased that you’re on the same page as the designers, or annoyed by the seemingly perfunctory remix of enemy and item placement. On the other hand, brand new players may find Scholar of the First Sin to be an ideal, more guided tour of the world of Drangleic.

Read original review

PC Aficionado78/100 → 78 · Z -0.6269Score 77.8223

I enjoyed every minute of it. I would have like to see the price drop a little bit over the course of the past two years but you are still getting a game that is a joy to play from start to finish here.

Read original review

PlaySense90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6049Score 90.1399

A deep, dark, extremely challenging and downright wonderful game that will keep you enthralled for weeks or months to come. New enemy placement justifies a purchase for even the most hardcore veterans of the last-gen edition.

Read original review

PlayStation LifeStyle85/100 → 85 · Z 0.1149Score 85.24

If you haven’t played the original or you were stopped a bit short the first time around, Scholar of the First Sin is the perfect excuse to come back and try your hand at the experience again. The new additions and visual upgrades make this the best version to play the game on.

Read original review

Playstation Official Magazine Australia90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5239Score 89.3304

Not to be underestimated. Runs like a dream, sucks you in with an addictive cycle of rage-reward like any real nightmare. [June 2015, p73]

Playstation Official Magazine UK90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6439Score 90.5301

Never played Dark Souls II? This is essential, even with Bloodborne out. [May 2015, p.92]

PlayStation Universe85/100 → 85 · Z 0.059Score 84.6811

Scholar of the First Sin is a noble attempt to right the perceived wrongs of Dark Souls II, but while some tweaks are welcome, others -such as certain enemy placements- are less so. Whatever way you cut it though, Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is still a great game.

Read original review

PPE.pl70/100 → 70 · Z -1.1842Score 72.2496

Dark Souls II on PS4 introduces some new features, but it has some trouble with new challenges. A large portion of the content is available in the PS3 update. Haven't played? You can buy. Otherwise forgive.

Read original review

Push Square90/100 → 90 · Z 0.8886Score 92.9771

While the industry's current love of rehashing games that are barely a year old is something that we should all be very suspicious of, Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is so much more than just a simple clean-up job.

Read original review

Readers Gambit60/100 → 60 · Z -1.7993Score 66.0984

From Software try to right their wrongs in this next gen port of Dark Souls 2 but fail to meaningfully address the issues that many players had with Dark Souls 2.

Read original review

Reno Gazette-Journal90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5636Score 89.7273

Overall, Scholar of First Sin can be a hard sell for folks who played the original Dark Souls 2 to death already (pun so totally intended). If you've never played its predecessor before, however, or are a rabid fan who wants to re-experience everything again on the newer consoles, this is one game you'll want to prepare to take a stab at.

Read original review

RPG Fan72/100 → 72 · Z -1.1956Score 72.1356

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin offers only minor tweaks to serious gameplay issues of the original game. Nonetheless, it still remains a wholly enjoyable online experience, just don't expect much from the singleplayer experience.

Read original review

SpazioGames80/100 → 80 · Z -0.228Score 81.811

Maybe it doesn't feature enough news to be a must have for those who already gnawed Dark Souls 2 to the bone, but with the new positioning of the enemies, the technical improvements and tweaks to the lore, Scholar of the First Sin undoubtedly deserves a place of prestige in the exclusive club of the "reissues made as they should be made".

Read original review

The Digital Fix90/100 → 90 · Z 0.5014Score 89.1051

Going backwards from Bloodborne feels almost archaic, and it takes some time to settle into that once familiar gameplay. However Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin offers the chance to revisit that still fantastic and familiar world with a slight twist to proceedings and a respectable face lift.

Read original review

USgamer100/100 → 100 · Z 1.3074Score 97.1651

From Software once raised the bar for game design; now, they've done the same for HD remakes. Rest assured, this isn't just a lazy repackaging of old content. Even if you know the Kingdom of Drangleic like the back of your hand, you're in for many new surprises. And if you've never played Dark Souls II before, your patience has paid off: This is simply the best version of it you'll ever play.

Read original review

Vandal92/100 → 92 · Z 0.7871Score 91.9617

This isn't just a visual upgrade, but a deeper remastering that also improves its gameplay. If you haven't played it yet, choosing the Scholar of the First Sin version is worth it.

Read original review

VideoGamer80/100 → 80 · Z -0.2198Score 81.8936

Whether or not you enjoy the technical tweaks brought forth by the upgrade, there’s no arguing that Scholar of the First Sin represents the best value prospect for players, with all DLC included, a bump to 1080p, and a solid framerate. Is it the best version of Dark Souls 2? Not necessarily, but it’s a good game.

Read original review

Xbox Achievements88/100 → 88 · Z 0.4726Score 88.8173

For newcomers Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is a superb package, with the wonderful DLC thrown in and the visuals at the best they have ever been. However, it's also tough going thanks to the remixed enemy placements and new random encounters. For veterans this is a welcome return to Drangleic but not one that is mandatory, as the changes feel all too insubstantial at times. So while Scholar of the First Sin is the definitive package, it isn't one that is required for repeat visitors.

Read original review

XGN90/100 → 90 · Z 0.6223Score 90.3139

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is the definitive version of Dark Souls II. The new enemy placement and lore give veterans a good reason to play through it again and for newcomers it is a great way to experience an already great game.

Read original review

ZTGD90/100 → 90 · Z 0.4856Score 88.9469

With the enemy placement changed, it really does offer a newer challenge to veteran players, and while the double weapon degradation is really, really annoying, it can be managed. It's just going to take a lot of backtracking.

Read original review